Impacts of Post-metallisation Processes on the Electrical and Photovoltaic Properties of Si Quantum Dot Solar Cells

  • Dawei Di1Email author,

    Affiliated with

    • Ivan Perez-Wurfl1,

      Affiliated with

      • Angus Gentle1,

        Affiliated with

        • Dong-Ho Kim1,

          Affiliated with

          • Xiaojing Hao1,

            Affiliated with

            • Lei Shi1,

              Affiliated with

              • Gavin Conibeer1 and

                Affiliated with

                • Martin A. Green1

                  Affiliated with

                  Nanoscale Research Letters20105:1762

                  DOI: 10.1007/s11671-010-9707-x

                  Received: 14 June 2010

                  Accepted: 15 July 2010

                  Published: 1 August 2010


                  As an important step towards the realisation of silicon-based tandem solar cells using silicon quantum dots embedded in a silicon dioxide (SiO2) matrix, single-junction silicon quantum dot (Si QD) solar cells on quartz substrates have been fabricated. The total thickness of the solar cell material is 420 nm. The cells contain 4 nm diameter Si quantum dots. The impacts of post-metallisation treatments such as phosphoric acid (H3PO4) etching, nitrogen (N2) gas anneal and forming gas (Ar: H2) anneal on the cells’ electrical and photovoltaic properties are investigated. The Si QD solar cells studied in this work have achieved an open circuit voltage of 410 mV after various processes. Parameters extracted from dark IV, light IV and circular transfer length measurement (CTLM) suggest limiting mechanism in the Si QD solar cell operation and possible approaches for further improvement.


                  Silicon Quantum dots Solar cells Third generation Electrical characterisation


                  The concept of a tandem solar cell has been well developed as a method of improving solar cell efficiency. In a tandem cell, solar cells of different band gaps are stacked on top of one another. The cell with the highest band gap is placed on the top, while the cell with the lowest band gap is positioned at the bottom of the tandem stack. Each cell absorbs the light it can most effectively convert, with the rest passing through to the underlying cells [1]. The highest efficiency cells to date are tandem cells made using single crystal III-V materials. These materials are grown by very expensive epitaxial techniques.

                  An ‘all-Si’ tandem solar cell makes use of inexpensive silicon thin-film technology in combination with a high-efficiency multi-band gap approach. It takes the advantage of quantum confinement effects in silicon. When silicon is made very thin (of the order of a few nanometers) in one or more dimensions, quantum confinement causes its effective bandgap to increase. The strongest effect is obtained when silicon is confined in 3D (i.e., quantum dots). If the quantum dots are close to each other, carriers can tunnel between them to form quantum dot superlattices which can be used as the higher bandgap cells in a tandem stack (Fig. 1) [2].
                  Figure 1

                  Schematic diagram of an all-Si quantum dot super lattice tandem solar cell [2]

                  A simple approach to make Si quantum dot super lattices has been described by Zacharias et al. [3]. Similar multi-layer structure was also suggested for the formation of InGaAs quantum dots [4]. The effective bandgap of silicon thin films made this way can be varied by varying the size of the quantum dots. This effect has been supported by photoluminescence (PL) measurements (Fig. 2) [1, 5].
                  Figure 2

                  Normalised photoluminescence for Si QDs of various sizes in SiO2 matrix [1]

                  As an encouraging step towards the realisation of silicon-based tandem solar cells using silicon quantum dots embedded in a silicon dioxide (SiO2) matrix, single-junction silicon quantum dot (Si QD) solar cells on quartz substrates have been fabricated.

                  We also demonstrate that post-metallisation treatments such as phosphoric acid (H3PO4) etching and forming gas (Ar: H2) anneal significantly impact solar cell performance. So far, our best single-junction Si QD solar cell has achieved 490 mV Voc[6, 7] (In this paper, samples with Voc up to 410 mV are studied). Our medium-term goal is to demonstrate Voc over 700 mV on single-junction Si QD solar cells. As this would be close to the V oc record [8] of single-junction mono-crystalline silicon solar cells, in a thin film solar cell it would be a clear demonstration that the electronic band gap of the nanostructured material is enhanced due to the quantum confinement effect. At present, the emphasis is on increasing Voc and the devices are very unoptimised for absorption and collection. Hence, the very low currents currently obtained are not a concern.

                  Fabrication of Single-Junction Silicon Quantum Dot Solar Cell on Quartz Substrate

                  Alternating layers of a 2-nm silicon dioxide (SiO2) followed by a 4-nm silicon-rich oxide (SRO) are deposited on a quartz substrate using magnetron co-sputtering of Si and quartz (SiO2) targets [9]. Either a phosphorous pentoxide for n-type doping or boron for p-type doping is incorporated into the Si-rich material during sputtering of appropriate layers, to obtain a p–n junction after annealing. The sample is then annealed at ~1100°C to form Si QDs and to activate these dopants. Hydrogenation was then performed in a cold-wall vacuum system featuring an inductively coupled remote plasma source (Advanced Energy), using a glass substrate temperature of 600–625°C for 15 min [10, 11].

                  Formation of metal contacts (metallisation) is done by: (1) thermal evaporation of aluminium, (2) photo-lithography to define mesa areas, (3) CF4:O2 reactive ion etching (RIE) to etch the unmasked silicon areas until the underlying n-layer is reached, (4) Al evaporation for self-aligned contacts in the trenches, (5) second photo-lithography to define metal contacts pads, (6) thermal evaporation of Al, (7) Liftoff. The resultant structure is shown in Fig. 3. The cells investigated in this work have areas in the range 2–10 mm2.
                  Figure 3

                  Schematic diagram of a single-junction Si QD solar cell on quartz substrate. The total thickness of the p–n junction diode is 420 nm. The thickness of the quartz substrate is 1 mm

                  Removal of localised Aluminium shunts

                  It was found that one cell was severely shunted after the self-aligned metallisation process. The reason for the shunt is attributed to the localised Al shunting routes between p-type and n-type layers (Fig. 4a) due to the imperfect self-alignment. A forming gas anneal (H2: Ar, 400°C, 20 min) was performed on the sample after the shunting problem was identified. Dark IV measurements have shown that the situation of the shunt gets worse with the annealing process (Fig. 4b). This suggests the existence of localised Al shunts lying across the p-type and n-type regions as the annealing improves the contact of the Al shunts to both p- and n-regions of the cell thus shorting the cell more effectively.
                  Figure 4

                  a Schematic diagram of a Si QD cell with localised Al shunts. b The corresponding dark IV curves measured on the shunted cell before and after the forming gas anneal

                  To overcome this problem, the cell was immersed in 42.5% H3PO4 acid etch (25°–40°C) for 6 min. It has been reported earlier that such a phosphoric acid etch can be used to recover shunted polycrystalline thin-film solar cells [12]. This mild chemical etch gradually removes the shunting paths due to the reaction between Al and H3PO4 acid. Measurement shows that the solar cell is no longer shunted after the etching (Fig. 5b).
                  Figure 5

                  a Schematic diagram of the same cell as in Fig. 4 after H3PO4 etching. Local Al shunts are removed. b The corresponding dark IV curve showing rectifying behaviour and a large shunt resistance (Rsh = 2 × 105 Ω)

                  Effects of Nitrogen Gas Anneal and Forming Gas Anneal

                  Dark and Illuminated IV Characteristics

                  Another sample metallised with the aligned photo-lithography method was subjected to an initial N2 anneal at 250°C followed by three consecutive forming gas anneals (250, 300 and 350°C). The duration of each annealing step was 20 min. Dark and illuminated (1-sun) IV data were measured before and after each annealing step.

                  The dark currents in Figs. 5b and 6a are very different due to the fact that these two devices are metallised in different ways and have different contact geometry. The contacts in the former (sample in Fig. 5b) are made by self-aligned lithography technique which makes the lateral distance between the base and emitter electrodes very small (<5 μm) but easier to be shunted. On the other hand, the latter aligned lithography approach (sample in Fig. 6a) utilises two separate lithography masks, creating a larger separation (~50 μm) between the base and emitter metal contacts. Given that the resistance of the semiconductor material is very high (as shown in Fig. 8), a larger lateral contact separation makes the overall resistance of the device substantially larger, resulting in a current decrease of two orders of magnitude.
                  Figure 6

                  a Evolution of the dark IV characteristics of the measured cell following initial nitrogen (250°C) and consecutive forming gas anneals (250–350°C). b Rs and Rsh extracted from the dark IV curves as a function of annealing steps

                  It has been noted that a N2 gas anneal at 250°C has a very limited influence on the IV characteristics, while a forming gas anneal at the same temperature is able to alter the electrical properties (Fig. 6). With increasing forming gas annealing temperature, there is a clear change in both dark and light IV curves. Information about the parasitic resistances (Rs and Rsh) is extracted from the dark IV curve. Voc and Isc are obtained from the light IV data. Details about the calculation of Rs are discussed in later sections.

                  The test solar cell with an initial open circuit voltage of 350 mV produces a Voc of 410 mV after the 350°C forming gas anneal step (Fig. 7). The performance of the cell is heavily limited by the series resistance, although the magnitude of the series resistance has been reduced by more than three times after annealing. The shunt resistance has also decreased which might have a detrimental effect. However, this effect is very small as Rsh of the cell is in the order of 1 MΩ.cm2. The short circuit current increases by a factor of three due to the decrease of Rs.
                  Figure 7

                  a The 1-sun light IV characteristics of the cell. b Voc and Isc extracted from the light IV curves as a function of annealing conditions

                  Contact and Sheet Resistances

                  To identify the origin of the large series resistance, a circular transfer length measurement (CTLM) [13] contact was applied photolithographically to the n-type material and measurements were carried out before and after each annealing step. The measurement is able to extract contact (Rc) resistance of the bottom electrode and sheet (Rsheet) resistance of the n-type layer (Fig. 8).
                  Figure 8

                  Contact (Rc) and sheet (Rsheet) resistances measured by CTLM

                  It can be seen from the data that the 250°C N2 gas anneal has a negative impact on the cell’s contact resistance, while the forming gas anneals improve the contact. The change of sheet resistance is negligibly small when annealed in N2 ambient. However, annealing in forming gas is able to reduce Rsheet by approximately three times. The contact resistance is small in comparison with the semiconductor sheet resistance, as shown in Fig. 8. Therefore, the reduction of series resistance is largely due to the reduction of the material’s resistivity.

                  The implication of the results is that the H2 in the forming gas is responsible for the improvement of the cell material. Hydrogen atoms are able to passivate the interfaces of the Si nanocrystals [14] and hence to reduce trap density and facilitate better carrier transport.

                  Extraction of Series Resistance and Apparent Ideality Factor (n)

                  Special attention has been paid to the analysis of the series resistance (Rs) of the cell. Instead of simply calculating the slope of the dark IV curve at the high voltage region, Rs is obtained according to the following.

                  In a general solar cell circuit model, the total voltage across the terminals (V) equals the voltage across the diode (VD) plus the voltage across the series resistance (VRs).
                  By rearranging the ideal diode equation [15]:
                  and for VD >>nkT/q, it can be shown that
                  Substituting Eq. (3) into Eq. (1), yields
                  Differentiating V with respect to I,

                  To obtain Rs from the dark I V data, it is convenient to plot dV/ dI against 1/I (See Eq. (5)). The plot appears to be a linear relationship. The intercept of the line with the y-axis gives Rs (Rs results are shown in Fig. 6b), while the slope of the line equals to nkT/q. Thus, the ideality factor n = slope/VT, where VT = kT/q is the thermal voltage.

                  The ideality factor (n) extracted for the cells investigated in this work is found to be in the range 2–4 (Fig. 9), with no obvious explanation as to why n should be greater than 2. This may be because the conventional circuit model for a solar cell, which accounts for current flow in only one dimension, is insufficient for modelling a thin-film diode with high base or emitter resistance. An improved circuit model incorporating current crowding effects should be used to describe this behaviour [6].
                  Figure 9

                  Ideality factor n calculated from the IV curves


                  In this work, we have fabricated single-junction Si QD solar cells on quartz substrates, as an important step to realise an ‘all-silicon’ tandem solar cell.

                  The impacts of post-metallisation treatments such as phosphoric acid (H3PO4) etching, nitrogen (N2) gas anneal and forming gas (Ar: H2) anneal on the cells’ electrical and photovoltaic properties have been studied. The Si QD solar cells investigated in this work have achieved an open circuit voltage of 410 mV after various processes.

                  Parameters extracted from dark IV, light IV and circular transfer length measurement (CTLM) suggest that the performance of the solar cell is strongly limited by poor carrier transport. This limiting factor can be partly eliminated by forming gas annealing.

                  Other possible solutions include reduction of the barrier height and thickness of the quantum mechanical tunnelling barrier, modification of the composition of the cell’s absorber material, improved Si QD growth, an improved device structure such asusing a transparent conducting contact (e.g. ITO) or a conductive substrate to avoid current crowding.



                  The authors gratefully thank all members of the Third Generation Group at the ARC Photovoltaics Centre of Excellence for their contributions to this project. This work is supported by the Australian Research Council (ARC) via its Centers of Excellence Scheme. The authors also acknowledge the support of the Global Climate and Energy Project (GCEP), administered by Stanford University, for helping to fund this work.

                  Open Access

                  This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Noncommercial License which permits any noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and source are credited.

                  Authors’ Affiliations

                  ARC Photovoltaics Centre of Excellence, University of New South Wales


                  1. Green MA, Conibeer G, Cho E-C, Konig D, Huang SJ, Song D, Scardera G, Cho Y-H, Hao XJ, Fangsuwannarak T, Park SW, Perez-Wurfl I, Huang Y, Cheng S, Pink E, Bellet D, Bellet-Amalric E, Puzzer T: Progress with silicon-based tandem cells using silicon quantum dots in a dielectric matrix. In in Proceedings 22nd EU PVSEC. Milan, Italy; 2007. Sept Sept
                  2. Green MA, Conibeer G, Konig D, Cho EC, Song D, Cho Y, Fangsuwannarak T, Huang Y, Scardera G, Pink E, Huang S, Jiang C, Trupke T, Corkish R, Puzzer T: Progress with all-silicon tandem cells based on silicon quantum dots in a dielectric matrix. In Proceedings 21st EU PVSEC. Dresden; 2006. Sept Sept
                  3. Zacharias M, Heitmann J, Scholz R, Kahler U, Schmidt M, Blasing J: Appl. Phys. Lett.. 2002, 80: 661. COI number [1:CAS:528:DC%2BD38XnsFGjuw%3D%3D]; Bibcode number [2002ApPhL..80..661Z] 10.1063/1.1433906View Article
                  4. Xie YZ, Kunets VP, Wang ZM, Dorogan V, Mazur YI, Wu J, Salamo GJ: Nano-Micro Lett.. 2009, 1: 1–3. COI number [1:CAS:528:DC%2BC3cXjvFemtrk%3D]View Article
                  5. Cho EC, Park S, Hao X, Song D, Conibeer G, Park S-C, Green MA: Nanotechnology. 2008, 19: 245201. Bibcode number [2008Nanot..19x5201C] 10.1088/0957-4484/19/24/245201View Article
                  6. Perez-Wurfl I, Hao X, Gentle A, Kim D-H, Conibeer G, Green MA: Appl. Phys. Lett.. 2009, 95: 153506. Bibcode number [2009ApPhL..95o3506P] 10.1063/1.3240882View Article
                  7. Hao X, Perez-Wurfl I, Conibeer G, Green MA: in Proceedings PVSEC 19. Korea; 2009. Nov
                  8. Green MA, Emery K, Hishikawa Y, Warta W: Prog. Photovolt: Res. Appl.. 2009, 17: 320. COI number [1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1MXpvFeis7Y%3D] 10.1002/pip.911View Article
                  9. Cho EC, Hao XJ, Park SW, Song D, Huang S, Cho Y-H, Conibeer G, Green MA: Toward silicon quantum dot junction to realize all-silicon tandem solar cells. In Proceedings 22nd EU PVSEC. Milan, Italy; 2007. Sept
                  10. Hao XJ, Cho E-C, Flynn C, Shen YS, Conibeer G, Green MA: Nanotechnology. 2008, 19: 424019. Bibcode number [2008Nanot..19P4019H] 10.1088/0957-4484/19/42/424019View Article
                  11. Hao XJ, Cho E-C, Scardera G, Shen YS, Bellet-Amalric E, Bellet D, Conibeer G, Green MA: Sol. Energy Mater. Sol. Cells. 2009, 93: 1524. COI number [1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1MXotFWlsro%3D] 10.1016/j.solmat.2009.04.002View Article
                  12. Song D, Walsh TM, Aberle AG: Monolithically integrated polycrystalline silicon thin-film mini-modules on glass. in Proceedings 4th world conference on photovoltaic energy conversion 2006, 2094–2097. May
                  13. Reeves GK: Solid State Electron.. 1980, 23: 487. COI number [1:CAS:528:DyaL3cXktFOmsb8%3D]; Bibcode number [1980SSEle..23..487R] 10.1016/0038-1101(80)90086-6View Article
                  14. Godefroo S, Hayne M, Jivanescu M, Stesmans A, Zacharias M, Lebedev OI, Van Tendeloo G, Moshchalkov VV: Nat. Nanotech.. 2008, 3: 174. COI number [1:CAS:528:DC%2BD1cXivFKgsLw%3D]; Bibcode number [2008NatNa...3..174G] 10.1038/nnano.2008.7View Article
                  15. Green MA: Solar Cells: Operating Principles, Technology and System Applications. UNSW, Sydney; 1992.


                  © The Author(s) 2010