In these days, the development of positioning technology for realizing ubiquitous environments has become one of the most important issues. The Global Positioning System (GPS) is a well-known positioning scheme, but it is not suitable for positioning in in-door/building environments because it is difficult to maintain line-of-sight condition between satellites and a GPS receiver. To such problem, various positioning methods such as RFID, WLAN, ZigBee, and Bluetooth have been developed for indoor positioning scheme. However, the majority of positioning schemes are focused on the two-dimension positioning even though three-dimension (3D) positioning information is more useful especially in indoor applications, such as smart space, U-health service, context aware service, etc. In this paper, a 3D positioning system based on mutually orthogonal nano-scale impulse radio ultra-wideband (IR-UWB) signals and cross array antenna is proposed. The proposed scheme uses nano-scale IR-UWB signals providing fine time resolution and high-resolution multiple signal specification algorithm for the time-of-arrival and the angle-of-arrival estimation. The performance is evaluated over various IEEE 802.15.4a channel models, and simulation results show the effectiveness of proposed scheme.

Keywords

3D positioningnano-scale pulseUWBorthogonalityimpulse radio

Introduction

The extraction of interesting features or positioning information from target objectives has become increasingly popular and required for realizing intelligent environment services such as smart space, U-health service, context aware service, etc [1–3]. It is well known that the outdoor positioning system has shown a lot of progress with Global Positioning System (GPS), which is a navigation system based on satellite signals. However, this method is useful only in the line-of-sight condition between satellites and GPS receivers, i.e., outdoor environments. It is hard to get the positioning information by using the GPS in in-door/building environments, where most urban peoples are active and reside. Recently, the importance of indoor positioning technology has been gradually increased because of rescue operations and disaster prevention in underground shopping centers, factories, logistics centers, and so on. As indoor positioning method, various systems such as RFID, WLAN, ZigBee, and Bluetooth have been considered, but their positioning errors are several meters to tens of meters. Moreover, most positioning researches have been focused on two-dimension (2D) positioning even though three-dimension (3D) positioning information is more useful in indoor applications. In indoor environments, the time-of-arrival (TOA) and the angle-of-arrival (AOA) approaches are well-known scheme for a high-precision ranging purpose.

The former estimates the distance between a mobile system (MS) and a base station (BS) by estimating the time-of-flight of signal and it requires minimum three BSs for the 2D positioning, while the latter estimates the receiving angle of the signal and it requires minimum two BSs. Various super-resolution techniques, like multiple signal specification (MUSIC) [4], minimum norm [5], and total least square estimation of signal parameter via rotational invariance techniques [6], have been researched for achieving precise ranging and angle information against severe multipath fading channels. Among them, MUSIC is the most widely used algorithm based on eigenvalue decomposition of an array input correlation matrix due to its high-resolution capability, simplicity, and low computational complexity. In the mean time, the impulse radio ultra-wideband (IR-UWB) signal is based on the radiation of a train of extremely short pulses, typically in the range of nanoseconds and sub-nanoseconds, which results in fine time resolution for high-precision ranging performance. However, the different positioning performance is caused by what type of pulse shape. For instance, the interference problem between the pulses transmitted at the same time can be resolved by using the orthogonal pulses, and thereby the diversity gain can be achieved with multiple orthogonal pulses.

Since a hybrid TOA/AOA scheme can estimate the 2D position with only one BS, the 3D positioning system based on the hybrid TOA/AOA scheme is considered in this paper. Based on the hybrid scheme, the 3D positioning system with mutually orthogonal nano-scale IR-UWB signals and cross array antenna is proposed. Specifically, the proposed scheme uses nano-scale IR-UWB signals providing fine time resolution and the 2D MUSIC algorithm for estimating the TOA and the AOA simultaneously [7]. In the proposed scheme, elevation angle (ø), azimuth angle (θ), and distance (d) between MS and BS are estimated through cross array antennas and positioning algorithm. Figure 1 shows a simplified schematic of 3D positioning scheme. It is shown in the figure that the elevation and azimuth angles are respectively estimated with vertical array and horizontal array while the distance is estimated with centered antenna. The performance of proposed scheme is evaluated through the computer simulations over the IEEE 802.15.4a channel models (CMs) [8].

The rest of this paper is organized as follows. The proposed system description is addressed in "Background." In "Result," the effectiveness of the proposed approach is demonstrated with simulation results. The conclusion is made in "Conclusions."

Background

Orthogonal pulse

There have been many different types of the UWB pulses, e.g., Gaussian pulse, prolate spheroidal pulse, root raised cosine pulse, and modified Hermite polynomial (MHP) pulse. The cross-correlation property between orthogonal pulses is close to zero, and thus the orthogonal pulse is not only effective to prevent interference between uniform linear arrays (ULA) but also to achieve optimum performance based on channel characteristics. The orthogonal pulse can be used to improve performance of 3D positioning system. In this regard, we employ the MHP pulse, the most representative orthogonal pulse. The fourth-order and the fifth-order derivative MHP pulses, which are shown in Figure 2, satisfy the Federal Communication Commission (FCC) indoor spectral mask and have orthogonal characteristic. The MHP pulse is expressed as follows [9]:

where n is order of the pulse and α is duration factor and its value is 1/128e17.

System model

In the positioning system, the BS consists of two ULA with multiple antennas where the distance between two consecutive antennas is d = c/2f_{
c
}, where f_{
c
} represents the center frequency. Figure 3 shows a simplified proposed system structure for positioning where the ULA receives the signal from an MS and the phase difference among antennas is used to estimate the AOA. The arriving signal at each antenna is sampled into L samples, where the sampling interval is Δf in frequency domain for TOA estimation. At the receiver side, the received signal over the multipath fading channel can be expressed as follows [10]:

where K is the total number of multipath channels, α_{
k
} is the amplitude, β_{
u
}(θ_{
k
}) is the response of the u th antenna to the k th path arriving from angle θ_{
k
}, τ_{
k
}is the propagation delay of the k th path, S(·) is the transmitted signal shape, and w(t) is the additive white Gaussian noise with mean zero and variance. By applying the harmonic signal model, Equation 2 can be rewritten in frequency domain as follow:

where m = 0, 1,..., M - 1. Since we use harmonic model for transmitted signal in L frequency samples, the N samples are divided into M consecutive segments of length L, where M = N - L + 1. Thus, the transmitted signal S is formed into an M × L matrix and the sampled signal of Equation 4 can be rewritten as follows [4]:

The signal model in Equation 5 can be used to minimum mean square error (MMSE) for channel estimation and jointly estimate θ_{
k
} and τ_{
k
} in the 2D MUSIC algorithm. The detection with different pulse shapes is evaluated with correlators, and the estimation performance of angle and distance is compared at the receiver. Based on the performance comparison for angle and distance estimations, position estimation can be performed by selecting the pulse shape providing enhanced performance.

Channel estimation

The channel impulse response (CIR) can be estimated by channel estimation methods such as zero forcing and MMSE. In this paper, MMSE is applied to the CIR. The CIR can be estimated by applying the inversion or pseudo-inversion of the known signal matrix. By multiplying both sides of Equation 5 by the inverse of the signal shape matrix S^{+}, where ${S}^{+}={S}^{H}{\left\{S\cdot {S}^{H}+\left({\sigma}_{w}^{2}\right)\cdot I\right\}}^{-1}$, Equation 5 can be rewritten as follows:

AOA and TOA are jointly estimated by the MUSIC algorithm which has become a popular high-resolution method since it was pioneered by Schmidt. The algorithm is based on eigenvalue decomposition of correlation matrix, R_{
XX
}. By finding the largest eigenvalues and eigenvectors (EVs), the signal can be distinguished from noise. For example, if the number of multipath signals is K, the number of eigenvalues and eigenvectors is K. The signal correlation matrix R_{
XX
} can be expressed as follows:

where A = E {αα^{
H
}}. The correlation matrix R_{
XX
} has the UL-dimensional subspace including two orthogonal subspaces of signal and noise. When the matrix SAS^{
H
}, which corresponds to signal subspace, has the rank K, the eigenvectors corresponding to K largest eigenvalues of R_{
XX
} are called the signal EVs. On the other hand, the EVs corresponding to (UL-K) smallest eigenvalues of R_{
XX
} are called the noise EVs. The signal and noise subspaces are spanned by the signal and noise eigenvectors, respectively. Because of the orthogonal condition between the signal and noise subspaces, the following pseudo-spectrum can estimate θ_{
k
} and τ_{
k
} for k = 1,..., K:

where E_{
i
} is the i th column vector of the noise eigenvectors and s = (θ, τ) is the column vector of S having arbitrary direction θ and delay, τ. For the special case that θ = θ_{
k
} and τ = τ_{
k
}, the corresponding signal vector is orthogonal to E_{
i
}. Therefore, we can estimate the desired values by detecting the maximum value of the pseudo-spectrum on the AOA-TOA plane.

Result

In this section, the performance of proposed scheme is evaluated through the computer simulations over the IEEE 802.15.4a CMs. For each ULA, the number of antennas is three. The pulse duration of IR-UWB signals is 2 ns. As channel models, the CM1, the CM3, and the CM5 of IEEE802.15.4a standard are employed for computer simulations. The parameters for simulations are set to L = 120, K = 57. It is assumed that the azimuth angle has a Laplacian distribution and the elevation angle has a Gaussian distribution. Variance of each angle is one and angle range is from -60 to 60 [11]. The characteristic of the channel model is shown Table 1.

Table 1

Characteristic of 802.15.4a channel models

Channel model

Center frequency (GHz)

Environment

MS and BS distance (m)

1

6

LOS residential

7 to 20

3

4.5

LOS office

3 to 28

5

4.5

LOS outdoor

5 to 17

Figure 4 shows the ranging and angle estimation errors of TOA and AOAs from azimuth and elevation ULAs in CM1. As shown in the figure, the fifth MHP outperforms the fourth MHP over all signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) with respect to ranging and angle errors. Figure 5 presents the ranging and angle estimation errors under same conditions in CM3. From this figure, the fifth MHP outperforms the fourth MHP in SNR from around 5 to 20 dB or so. On the other hand, the ranging performance of the fourth MHP outperforms that of the fifth MHP at other SNR levels. In case of angle error, the fifth MHP is superior to the fourth MHP in less than 25 dB, but two pulses show similar accuracy in more than 25 dB. Figure 6 depicts the ranging and angle estimation error of TOA and AOA of azimuth ULA and elevation ULA in CM5. As shown in the figure, the fourth MHP shows good ranging performance than fifth MHP in less than about 5 dB and in more than about 25 dB. In other part of the SNR, fifth MHP ranging performance is better than fourth MHP in both Azimuth and elevation. The fifth MHP outperform than fourth MHP in less than about 25 dB. In more than 25 dB, the performances of the two pulses are similar.

Conclusions

In this paper, we evaluated performance of 3D positioning system with nano-scale IR-UWB pulses. In the CM1, fifth MHP confirmed that the performance is good than fourth MHP in all SNR. In the CM3 and the CM5, the fourth MHP showed good ranging performance in less than about 5 dB and in more than about 25 dB. The fifth MHP showed an excellent performance in angle estimation than fourth MHP in less than about 25 dB. However, the performances of the two pulses are similar in more than about 25 dB. The simulation results showed the different performance according to pulse shape and CMs. With consideration of SNR and channel environments, therefore, the use of different pulse shape can enhance estimation performance compared to that of the system using only one pulse.

Declarations

Acknowledgements

This research was supported by Basic Science Research Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Education, Science and Technology (no. 2011-0004197). The present research has been conducted by the research grant of Kwangwoon University in 2011.

Authors’ Affiliations

(1)

Kwangwoon University

References

Pahlavan K, Krishnamurthy P: Principles of Wireless Networks: A Unified Approach. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall; 2002.

Hahn M, Barrois B, Kruger L, Wohler C, Sagerer G, Kummert F: 3D pose estimation and motion analysis of the articulated human hand-forearm limb in an industrial production environment. 3D Research 2010, 3(3):1–23.

Shahjahan M, Ahmed SU, Imran Hassan HM, Murase K: Extraction of interesting features from human motion. 3D Research 2010, 2(3):1–8.

Li X, Pahlavan K: Super-resolution TOA estimation with diversity for indoor geolocation. IEEE Trans Wireless Commun 2004, 3: 224–234. 10.1109/TWC.2003.819035View Article

Pallas M, Jourdain G: Active high resolution time delay estimation for large BT signals. IEEE Trans Signal Process 1991, 3: 781–788.View Article

Saarnisaari H: TLS-ESPRIT in a time delay estimation. IEEE VTC 1997, 1619–1623.

Jung S, Kim S, Kim N, Kang J, Kim Y: Low-complexity joint DOA/TOA estimation algorithm for mobile location. IEEE WCNC 2011, 581–586.

IEEE 802.15 WPAN Low Rate Alternative PHY Task Group 4a: PART 15.4: Wireless MAC and PHY Specifications for LR-WPANs. 2007. Draft P802.15.4a/D7 Draft P802.15.4a/D7

Michael LB, Ghavami M, Kohno R: Multiple pulse generator for ultra wideband communication using Hermite polynomial based orthogonal pulses. IEEE UWST 2002, 47–51.

Vanderveen MC, Papadias CB, Paulraj A: Joint angle and delay estimation (JADE) for multipath signal arriving at an antenna array. IEEE Commun Lett 1997, 12–14.

Yongwei Z, Brown AK, Malik WQ, Edwards DJ: High resolution 3-D angle of arrival determination for indoor UWB multipath propagation. IEEE Trans Wireless Commun 2008, 3047–3055.

This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.