Weak and strong confinements in prismatic and cylindrical nanostructures
© Vorobiev et al.; licensee Springer. 2012
Received: 16 April 2012
Accepted: 19 June 2012
Published: 5 July 2012
Skip to main content
© Vorobiev et al.; licensee Springer. 2012
Received: 16 April 2012
Accepted: 19 June 2012
Published: 5 July 2012
Cylindrical nanostructures, namely, nanowires and pores, with rectangular and circular cross section are examined using mirror boundary conditions to solve the Schrödinger equation, within the effective mass approximation. The boundary conditions are stated as magnitude equivalence of electron's Ψ function in an arbitrary point inside a three-dimensional quantum well and image point formed by mirror reflection in the walls defining the nanostructure. Thus, two types of boundary conditions - even and odd ones - can be applied, when Ψ functions in a point, and its image, are equated with the same and the opposite signs, correspondingly. In the former case, the Ψ function is non-zero at the boundary, which is the case of a weak confinement. In the latter case, the Ψ function vanishes at the boundary, corresponding to strong quantum confinement. The analytical expressions for energy spectra of electron confined within a nanostructure obtained in the paper show a reasonable agreement with the experimental data without using any fitting parameters.
Nanostructures (NS) of different kinds have been actively studied during the last two decades, both theoretically and experimentally. A special interest was focused on quasi-one-dimensional NS such as nanowires, nanorods, and elongated pores that not only modify the main material's parameters, but are also capable of introducing totally new characteristics such as optical and electrical anisotropy, birefringence, etc. In particular, the existence of nanoscale formations on the surface (or embedded into semiconductor) result in quantum confinement effects. As the motion of the carriers (or excitons) becomes restrained, their energy spectra change, moving the permitted energy levels towards higher energies as a consequence of confinement. In the experimental measurements, such modification would be noticed as a blueshift of energy-related characteristics, such as, for example, the edge of absorption. This paper is dedicated to the theoretical investigation of confined particle problem, aiming to explain the available experimental data basing on geometry of corresponding nanoparticles present in the particular material. Here, we focus on elongated NS that can be approximated as prisms or cylinders with different shapes of cross section.
The theoretical treatment of NS is based on the solution of the Schrödinger equation, usually within the effective mass approximation [1–4], although for small NS, such approach can be questioned because the symmetry describing a nanoparticle may not inherit its shape symmetry but would rather depend on atomistic symmetry . In addition, at small scale, it becomes necessary to take into account atomic relaxation and piezoelectric phenomena  that may strongly influence the energy states of confined particles and split their energy levels. The detailed consideration of these phenomena can be accounted using the pseudopotential method  introduced by Zunger's group that, after a decade, became a standard energy level model for detailed description of quantum dots. However, in cases when dimensions of nano-objects are large enough to validate the effective mass approximation, it is possible to obtain analytical solution to the problem of a particle confined within a quantum dot.
An important element of the quantum mechanical description is the boundary conditions; the traditional impenetrable wall conditions (1) are not always realistic and, (2) in many cases (depending on the shape of NS), could not be written in simple analytical form, thus complicating the further analysis. To overcome these problems, we proposed to use a mirrorlike boundary condition [8–10] assuming that the electron confined in an NS is specularly reflected by its walls acting as mirrors. In addition to a significant simplification of problem solution, this method favors the effective mass approximation.
Within the same framework, one can study pores as ‘inverted’ nanostructures (i.e., a void surrounded by semiconductor material) considering the ‘reflection’ of the particle's wave function from the surfaces limiting a pore. Thus, one will obtain essentially the same solution of the Schrödinger equation (and the energy spectrum) for both the pore and NS of the same geometry and size. A previous attempt to treat walls of a quantum system as mirrors in quantum billiard problem  yielded quite a complicated analytical form of the boundary conditions that made the solution of Schrödinger equation considerably more difficult.
In our treatment of the NS boundary as a mirror, the boundary condition equalizes absolute values of the particle's Ψ function in an arbitrary point inside the NS and the corresponding image point with respect to a mirror-reflective wall. Thus, depending on the sign of the equated Ψ values, one will obtain even and odd mirror boundary conditions. For the case of odd mirror boundary conditions (OMBC), Ψ functions in real point and its images should have the opposite sign, which means that the incident and reflected de Broglie waves cancel each other at the boundary. This case is equivalent to the impenetrable walls with vanishing Ψ function at the boundary, representing a ‘strong’ confinement case. However, some experimental data (see, e.g., ) show the evidence that a particle may penetrate the barrier, later returning into the confined volume. Thus, the wave function will not vanish at the boundary, and the system should be considered as a ‘weak’ confinement case as long as the particle flux through the boundary is absent. This case corresponds to even mirror boundary conditions (EMBC), when Ψ function in real point and its images are the same. Below, we analyze solutions of the Schrödinger equation for several cylindrical structures, using mirror boundary conditions of both types and making comparison of the energy spectra obtained with experimental data found in the literature.
The wave vector components will be the same as that presented in Equation 4, yielding the same energy spectrum (Equation 5). Using the traditional impenetrable wall boundaries, one will also obtain the solution in the form (Equation 6) that coincides with the OMBC solution that has a vanishing Ψ function at the boundary. Therefore, the energy spectrum is the same for both types of mirror boundary conditions and impenetrable wall boundary, although the solutions themselves are not equal. In , we demonstrated that for NS of spherical shape, the energy spectrum found with EMBC (weak confinement) is different from that corresponding to impenetrable walls conditions.
From Equation 5, it is evident that the energy spectrum of prismatic (cylindrical) NS is a sum of the spectra corresponding to the two-dimensional cross-section NS (a square with side length a) and the one-dimensional wire of length c. In a similar manner, the spectrum for cylinders with other cross-section shapes can be constructed using the solutions for two-dimensional triangular or hexagonal structures analyzed previously [8, 9]. Below, we present the analysis of cylindrical NS.
Strong confinement (OMBC) gives B = −C, which introduces sinkz instead of coskz in Equation 7A.
It is Bessel's differential equation regarding the variables kr, the solution of which is given by the cylindrical Bessel function of integer order |p|: J|p|(kr); with, k = ħ−1(2mE n )1/2. Here, m is the effective mass of the particle, and E n is the quantized kinetic energy corresponding to the motion in two-dimensional circular quantum well. The total energy consists of energy contribution for the motion within cross-section plane and along the vertical axis z: E = E n + Ez.
Argument values at nodes and extremes of cylindrical Bessel function
If the EMBC are used, the situation becomes different since the function values in the points approaching the boundary of the nanostructure should match those in the image points, making the boundary to correspond to the extremes of the Bessel function (which was strictly proved for the spherical quantum dots (QDs) ).
Table 1 gives several values of the Bessel function argument kr corresponding to the function nodes (q|p|i) and extremes (t|p|i) calculated for function orders 0, 1, 2, and 3.
Here, the parameter s|p|i takes the values of q|p|i for OMBC (strong confinement) and t|p|i for EMBC (weak confinement).
Equations 10, 11, and 11A can be used for the analysis of optical processes in the NS discussed. In particular, blueshift in exciton ground state can be found from Equations 11 and 11A if one substitutes a reduced exciton mass in place of particle mass m. Using Equation 10, it is possible to obtain in a similar way the energies corresponding to the higher excited states.
The choice of OMBC or EMBC has to be made taking into account the probability of electron tunneling through the walls forming the nanostructure. One can expect that in the case of isolated NS strong confinement (OMBC), approximation will be more appropriate, whereas for NS surrounded by other solid or liquid media (core-shell QDs  and pores in semiconductor media), weak confinement with EMBC should be used.
Considerable scientific interest has been attracted to semiconductor nanorods (nanowires) and cylindrical pores. Let us mention here publications dealing with arrays of cylindrical pores in sapphire , ZnO nanorods grown within these pores , as well as CuS and In2O3 nanowires. Usually, the experiments report on relatively large structures measuring 30 nm or more in diameter. As one can see from Equations 11 and 11A, in these cases, the expected blueshift will be about 0.01 eV or less for both the weak and strong confinements. Nevertheless, there exists literature data referring to nanorods of sufficiently small diameter for a pronounced confinement effect.
A paper  reports on CdS nanorods with a diameter of 5 nm and a length of 40 nm embedded into a liquid crystal. The authors study the optical anisotropy caused by the alignment of the nanorods. To determine it, they measure polarization of photoluminescence due to electron–hole recombination, reporting that the spectral maximum of luminescence is located at 485 nm (2.56 eV), which exceeds the bandgap of the bulk CdS by 0.14 eV. Taking the electron effective mass in CdS  as 0.16 m0 and hole effective mass 0.53 m0, one can find the reduced mass μ = 0.134 m0 and the blueshift 0.12 eV using Equation 11, which agrees reasonably with the experiment. As CdS nanostructure is surrounded by liquid crystal media, we were using the EMBC or weak confinement approximation.
Another study  is focused on the optical properties of CuS nanorods measuring 6 to 8 nm in diameter and 40 to 60 nm in length; the authors report definite blueshift of fundamental absorption edge. Alas, we found no data on the effective masses for CuS, so it was not possible to make numerical comparison with the theory.
Another paper  presents the experimental data concerning the optical properties of coronene molecules in tetrahydrofuran (THF) solution. Since the molecules are submerged into media, we expect that weak confinement/EMBC will be most appropriate for solution of the problem. Strong absorption lines were registered at photon energies of 4.1 to 4.3 eV, with weaker absorption down to 3.5 eV. To use our methodology, one should first determine the diameter a of a circle embracing the molecule with its 12 atoms of carbon (Figure 3).
The C-C bond length in coronene is d = 1.4 AǺ, which corresponds to the side of a hexagon. Thus, one would have a = = 0.741 nm. Taking in (Equation 11) m as free electron mass and using only the first term, we obtain the ground state energy EGS = 0.73 eV. The higher energy states (Equation 10) will be defined by the values of s|p|i = t|p|i equal to 2.92, 3.713, 4.30 etc. The corresponding energies are 2.353, 3.805, and 5.1 eV that result in transition energies 1.62, 3.1, and 4.37 eV. The first value is out of the spectral range investigated in ; the other two could reasonably fit the absorption observed.
If we attempt to treat the case on the basis of strong confinement approximation (OMBC), one should use the q|p|i values in the formulas (Equations 10 and 11A), yielding the ground state of 1.591 eV and excited states at 3.78, 7.21, and 8.35 eV. Therefore, the transition energies would be 2.19, 5.62, and 6.76 eV which have nothing in common with the experimental values, proving that the previous conclusion to use EMBC based on the fact that coronene molecules are embedded into THF medium was the right one.
The lowest transition energies in coronene-like molecules
Theoretical description of prismatic and cylindrical nanostructures (including pores in semiconductor) is made using two types of mirror boundary conditions for solution of the Schrödinger equation, resulting in simple analytical procedure to obtain wave functions that offer reasonably good description of optical properties of nanostructures of various shapes. The expressions for energy spectra are defined by the geometry and dimensions of the nanostructures. The even mirror boundary conditions correspond to weak confinement that is applicable for the cases when the nanostructure is embedded into another media (which is especially true for a case of a pore) that enables tunneling through the boundary of the nanostructure. In contrast, odd mirror boundary conditions are more appropriate in the treatment of isolated nanostructures where strong confinement exists. Both cases are illustrated with experimental data, proving good applicability of the corresponding type of boundary conditions.
The authors thank the FCT Projeto Estratégico PEst-OE/FIS/UI0091/2011 (Portugal) and CONACYT Basic Science Project 129269 (Mexico).
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.