# Topological insulator metamaterials with tunable negative refractive index in the optical region

- Tun Cao
^{1}Email author and - Shuai Wang
^{1}

**8**:526

**DOI: **10.1186/1556-276X-8-526

© Cao and Wang; licensee Springer. 2013

**Received: **27 October 2013

**Accepted: **3 December 2013

**Published: **13 December 2013

## Abstract

A blueshift tunable metamaterial (MM) exhibiting a double-negative refractive index based on a topological insulator (bismuth selenide, Bi_{2}Se_{3}) has been demonstrated in the near-infrared (NIR) spectral region. The potential of Bi_{2}Se_{3} as a dielectric interlayer of the multilayer MM is explored. The optical response of elliptical nanohole arrays penetrating through Au/Bi_{2}Se_{3}/Au films is numerically investigated using the finite difference time domain (FDTD) method. The blueshift tuning range of the MM is as high as 370 nm (from 2,140 to 1,770 nm) after switching the Bi_{2}Se_{3} between its trigonal and orthorhombic states.

## Background

Metamaterials (MMs) are artificially engineered composites that attract considerable interests due to their exceptional electromagnetic properties, which are not typically found in nature, such as negative refractive index and cloaking[1–4]. These MMs with various subwavelength resonant elements have offered magnetic and/or electric resonant responses to incident electromagnetic radiation, scalable from the microwave frequencies up to the terahertz and optical ones[5–7]. Particularly, nanohole resonators embedded in metal-dielectric-metal (MDM) multilayers are frequently used as building blocks of negative-refractive-index MMs[8–11], owing to the coupling between surface plasmons counterpropagating on the two closely spaced interfaces which results in a closed loop of the electric currents. This gives rise to magnetic dipolar resonances between the two coupled metal layers, while the continuous metallic strip parts provide the electric resonance moments[12, 13]. All these features make the nanohole array perforating through MDM films become a strong candidate for developing three-dimensional negative-index MMs[14, 15].

One of the obstacles in this progress is the resonance responses of MMs to the impinge light which are usually fixed once the dimension of the structure is determined, thus making the MMs possess a limited bandwidth. However, for many applications (switching, modulation, filtering, etc.), it would be highly desirable to tune the MM resonances over a wide bandwidth. To this end, tunable photonic MMs, the spectral range of which can be controlled by changing the dielectric environment of the resonator with liquid crystals (LCs)[16–18]; phase transition materials[19, 20]; and optical pumping[21, 22] have been discussed recently. However, the challenge is to develop tunable MDM-MMs in the near-infrared (NIR) regime. It is due to the fact that frequency tunability of the MDM-MM mainly requires for the interlayer dielectric material to possess a tunable effective dielectric constant in the NIR region, hence limiting the choice of the active materials. Here, we take a different approach to actively tune the resonant frequency of the MDM-MMs in the NIR regions by using bismuth selenide (Bi_{2}Se_{3}) as the dielectric layer.

Recently, a rising Dirac material - topological insulators (TIs) - had been intensively researched in condensed matter physics[23, 24]. In analogy to the optoelectronic applications of graphene, a thin layer of TIs has been theoretically predicted to be a promising material for broadband and high-performance optoelectronic devices such as photodetectors, terahertz lasers, waveguides, and transparent electrodes[25]. Among these TIs, Bi_{2}Se_{3} is a particularly interesting compound due to its relatively large bulk band gap and a simple surface state consisting of a single Dirac cone-like structure[26, 27]. Study of the dielectric function reveals that the optical dielectric constant of Bi_{2}Se_{3} can be very different for the trigonal and orthorhombic phases in the NIR regime[28]. Bi_{2}Se_{3} exhibits a number of means through which their dielectric properties can be altered[28–33]. Herein, structural phase transition between trigonal and orthorhombic states, which is achieved by a high pressure and temperature, is proposed and studied as a means to change the intrinsic effective dielectric properties of the MDM-MMs[28].

Here, we numerically demonstrate a blueshift tunable nanometer-scale MM consisting of an elliptical nanohole array (ENA) embedded in the MDM multilayers where the dielectric core layer is a Bi_{2}Se_{3} composite. Under a high pressure of 2 to 4.3 Pa at 500°C, Bi_{2}Se_{3} occurring in trigonal phase undergoes a transition to orthorhombic phase and features a large change in the values of the effective dielectric constant[28]. Accordingly, a massive blueshift of the resonant response (from 2,140 to 1,770 nm) of a Bi_{2}Se_{3}-based MDM-ENA is achieved in the NIR region. Our proposed blueshift tunable negative-index MM provides greater flexibility in the practical application and has a potential of enabling efficient switches and modulators in the NIR region.

## Methods

_{2}Se

_{3}/Au. The thickness of each Au layer is 30 nm, and the thickness of the Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}layer is 60 nm. The metamaterial parameters are optimized for the maximum sensitivity of the resonance to a change in the refractive index of the Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}core dielectric layer in the NIR spectral range. The element resonator is shown in Figure 1b, where the pitch of the elliptical holes is

*L*= 400 nm, the diameters of the elliptical holes are

*d*

_{1}= 240 nm and

*d*

_{2}= 120 nm, and

*β*is a cross-sectional plane of the structure. The

*z*-axis is normal to the structure surface, and the

*x*-

*y*plane is parallel to the structure surface. This simulated structure is periodically extended along the

*x*and

*y*axes. The tunable optical properties of the structure are calculated using 3D EM Explorer Studio[34], a commercial finite difference time domain (FDTD) code. In the simulation, a simple Drude-type model for Au permittivity was used, which is a good approximation to experimental values in the NIR region. The dielectric properties of Au as given by Johnson and Christy are used[35]. A plane wave source is simulated at normal incidence to the structure. The computational domain (400 nm × 400 nm × 1,000 nm) has a perfectly matched layer (PML), absorbing boundaries in the

*z*direction and periodic boundaries in the

*x*-

*y*plane[36]. A uniform FDTD mesh size is adopted. The mesh size is the same along all Cartesian axes:

*∆x*=

*∆y*=

*∆z*= 2 nm, which is sufficient to minimize the numerical errors arising from the FDTD method.

_{2}Se

_{3}was selected due to its significantly different optical properties between the trigonal and orthorhombic phases. The real (

*ϵ*

_{1}) and imaginary (

*ϵ*

_{2}) parts of the dielectric function for the different structural phases of Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}were obtained from the published data in[28]; the NIR spectral region is shown in Figure 2. A large change in the dielectric function across the NIR is obtained after switching Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}from trigonal to its orthorhombic phase.

After the complex coefficients of transmission$t={T}_{a}{e}^{i{\phi}_{a}}$ and reflection$r={R}_{a}{e}^{i{\phi}_{\mathit{ra}}}$ are obtained by the 3D EM Explorer Studio, in which *T*_{
a
} is the amplitude and *φ*_{
a
} is the phase of the transmission coefficient, and *R*_{
a
} is the amplitude and *φ*_{
ra
} is the phase of the reflection coefficient, the effective optical parameters can be extracted using the Fresnel formula[37].

*h*surrounded by semi-infinite media with refractive index

*n*

_{1}and

*n*

_{3}under normal incidence, we have

*ϵ*

_{eff}and

*μ*

_{eff}of a single layer of a double-fishnet negative-index metamaterial are extracted using the well-known Nicholson-Ross-Weir (NRW) method[38–40]. Therefore, once

*n*

_{eff}and

*η*are evaluated, the effective permittivity and permeability are calculated using

where *n*_{eff} is the effective refractive index, *η* is the impedance, *h* is the thickness of the structure, *k* = *ω*/*c*, *c* is the speed of light, *m* is an arbitrary integer, and *n*_{1} = *n*_{3} = 1 since the structure is suspended in a vacuum. The signs of *n*_{eff} and *η* and the value of *m* are resolved by the passivity of the metamaterial that requires the signs of the real part of impedance *η* and imaginary part of effective index *n*_{eff} to be positive, i.e., Real(*η*) > 0, Imag(*n*_{eff}) > 0 which is consistent with the study described in[39, 40]. We then apply this extraction approach to determine the change in the optical response of the structure when the phase of Bi_{2}Se_{3} is switched between its trigonal and orthorhombic states.

## Results and discussion

*s*-polarized light due to the electric field's orientation with respect to the metallic stripe width[12]; hence, the polarization of the incident wave was set to be

*p*-polarized. As shown in Figure 1a,

*s*polarization means that the incident electric field vector is parallel to the long axis of the ENA, and the incident electric field vector perpendicular to the long axis of the ENA is then denoted by

*p*polarization. We first investigate the transmittance

*T*= |

*t*|

^{2}and reflectance

*R*= |

*r*|

^{2}of the structure for

*p*polarization in Figure 3. Structures with a different dielectric constant of Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}(shown in Figure 2) were modeled to investigate the effect of the phase change of Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}on the position and amplitude of the spectrums. It can be seen that the resonance wavelength blueshifts from 2,140 to 1,770 nm when the structural phase of Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}switches from trigonal to orthorhombic. The structure is impedance-matched, hence possessing a low reflectance corresponding to the dips in reflectance of Figure 3b for different forms of Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}.

*t*) and reflection(

*r*) phases are demonstrated. The transmission phase exhibits a dip around the resonance, indicating that the light is advanced in phase at the resonance, characteristic of a left-handed material[41]. Importantly, changing the structural phase of the Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}offers transmission and reflection phase tunability which implies tunable effective constitutive parameters in the structure.

*n*

_{eff}can be retrieved from the transmission and reflection coefficients shown in Figure 5. For the MM with the trigonal Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}dielectric layer, the negative-index band extends from 1,880 to 2,420 nm with a minimum value of the real part of the refractive index Real(

*n*

_{eff}) = -7. Regarding losses, the figure of merit (FOM) defined as$\text{FOM}=\frac{\text{Real}\left({n}_{\text{eff}}\right)}{\text{Imag}\left({n}_{\text{eff}}\right)}$ is taken to show the overall performance of the MM, where Imag(

*n*

_{eff}) is the imaginary part of the refractive index. As shown in Figure 5c, the FOM for the trigonal phase is 2.7 at the operating wavelength of 2,080 nm. The negative-index band of the orthorhombic Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}-based MM extends from 1,600 to 2,214 nm having a minimum value of Real(

*n*

_{eff}) = -3.2. The FOM is 1.2 at the resonant wavelength of 1,756 nm. Furthermore, the bandwidth of Real(

*n*

_{eff}) becomes wider for the orthorhombic Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}film in Figure 5a due to increased damping of the plasmon resonance but at the cost of an accompanied lower value of FOM in Figure 5c.

*μ*

_{eff}and permittivity

*ϵ*

_{eff}. However, the sign of the real part of the permeability

*μ*

_{eff}: Real(

*μ*

_{eff}) determines the relative magnitudes of the imaginary and real parts of the refractive index[41]. To achieve a negative index with a small loss, a negative Real(

*μ*

_{eff}) is required. Therefore, we have simulated

*μ*

_{eff}and

*ϵ*

_{eff}for the structure as shown in Figure 6. For the trigonal and orthorhombic phases of Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}, Real(

*μ*

_{eff}) has a Fano-type line shape and Im(

*μ*

_{eff}) has a Lorentzian line shape in the region of the negative index. Moreover, a double-negative MM can be achieved when Real(

*μ*

_{eff}) and Real(

*ϵ*

_{eff}) simultaneously reach negative values over a wide frequency range and thus a reduced loss. The maximum negative Real(

*μ*

_{eff}) decreases with the phase transition from the trigonal to orthorhombic, hence resulting in the smaller value of the maximum negative Real(

*n*

_{eff}) at the orthorhombic phase.

*β*plane shown in Figure 1. In the field maps of Figure 7, the arrows show the currents, whereas the color shows the intensity of the magnetic field. It clearly shows that the antiparallel currents are excited at opposite internal metallic interfaces, closed by an electric displacement current

*J*

_{D}. Therefore, these virtual current loops between two Au layers on the

*β*plane give rise to magnetic resonant responses of negative Re(

*μ*

_{eff}) that interact strongly with the incident magnetic field at which the total magnetic field intensity

*H*is strongly localized in the Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}dielectric layer between the top and bottom Au layers[42].

Specifically, *H* for the orthorhombic phase shown in Figure 7b is weaker than the trigonal phase shown in Figure 7a. It depicts that the MM based on orthorhombic phase has a smaller magnetic dipolar moment than the trigonal phase and thus smaller FOM.

_{2}Se

_{3}-Au sheets with the top Au film thickness

*t*

_{1}= 30 nm, middle Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}film thickness

*t*

_{2}= 60 nm, and bottom Au film thickness

*t*

_{3}= 30 nm. The transmittance spectrum of the multilayer metamaterials is also depicted together with the dispersion relation of the Au-Bi

_{2}Se

_{3}-Au films.

Recalling the coupling condition from light to SPP modes[42], it can be seen that the (1,1) internal resonance of the Au-Bi_{2}Se_{3}-Au trilayer is excited at 2,350 nm associated with the trigonal Bi_{2}Se_{3} in Figure 8a. This internal SPP resonance blueshifts to 2,010 nm when the trigonal state changes to the orthorhombic state as shown in Figure 8b. We also observe that the two internal (1,1) modes which appear at 2,350 and 2,010 nm in the simple MDM structure do not perfectly match the two absorbance peaks at the resonance wavelengths of 2,140 and 1,770 nm in the multilayer metamaterials for both the trigonal and orthorhombic phases, respectively. This difference is because the dispersion relation of the SPP modes used as matching condition does not include the resonant squares, which cause a resonance shift[42].

## Conclusions

In conclusion, this work numerically demonstrates the tunable optical properties of an ENA perforated through Au/Bi_{2}Se_{3}/Au trilayers. We present that the MDM-ENA can be improved to exhibit a substantial frequency tunability of the intrinsic resonance in the NIR spectral region by selecting Bi_{2}Se_{3} as the active dielectric material. Particularly, the resonant transmission, reflection, and the effective constitutive parameters of the Bi_{2}Se_{3}-coupled multilayer MM can be massively blueshifted by transiting the phase of the Bi_{2}Se_{3} film from the trigonal to orthorhombic. This may offer an innovative and practical paradigm for the development of tunable photonic devices. We expect that our results will facilitate further experimental studies of the tunable MMs and make this technique suitable for tuning of plasmon resonance in the optical regime.

## Declarations

### Acknowledgements

We acknowledge the financial support from National Natural Science Foundation of China (grant nos. 61172059, 51302026), PhD Programs Foundation of the Ministry of Education of China (grant no. 20110041120015), Postdoctoral Gathering Project of Liaoning Province (grant no. 2011921008), and The Fundamental Research for the Central University (grant no. DUT12JB01).

## Authors’ Affiliations

## References

- Pendry JB: Negative refraction makes a perfect lens.
*Phys Rev Lett*2000, 61: 3966–3969.View Article - Qiu CW, Gao L: Resonant light scattering by small coated nonmagnetic spheres: magnetic resonances, negative refraction and prediction.
*J Opt Soc Am B*2008, 25: 1728–1737.View Article - Shalaev VM: Optical negative-index metamaterials.
*Nat Photonics*2007, 1: 41–48. 10.1038/nphoton.2006.49View Article - Soukoulis CM, Wegener M: Past achievements and future challenges in the development of three-dimensional photonic metamaterials.
*Nat Photonics*2011, 5: 523–530. - Zheludev N: The road ahead for metamaterials.
*Science*2010, 328: 5582–5583.View Article - Zhou S, Huang X, Li Q, Xie YM: A study of shape optimization on the metallic nanoparticles for thin-film solar cells.
*Nanoscale Res Lett*2013, 8: 447. 10.1186/1556-276X-8-447View Article - Liaw JW, Chen HC, Kuo MK: Plasmonic Fano resonance and dip of Au-SiO
_{2}-Au nanomatryoshka.*Nanoscale Res Lett*2013, 8: 468. 10.1186/1556-276X-8-468View Article - Zhang S, Fan W, Panoiu NC, Malloy KJ, Osgood RM, Brueck SRJ: Experimental demonstration of near-infrared negative-index metamaterials.
*Phys Rev Lett*2005, 95: 137404.View Article - Li T, Li JQ, Wang FM, Wang QJ, Liu H, Zhu SN, Zhu YY: Exploring magnetic plasmon polaritons in optical transmission through hole arrays perforated in trilayer structures.
*Appl Phys Lett*2007, 90: 251112. 10.1063/1.2750394View Article - Valentine J, Zhang S, Zentgraf T, Ulin-Avila E, Genov DA, Bartal G, Zhang X: Three-dimensional optical metamaterial with a negative refractive index.
*Nature*2008, 455: 376–379. 10.1038/nature07247View Article - Minovich A, Neshev DN, Powell DA, Shadrivov IV, Lapine M, Hattori HT, Tan HH, Jagadish C, Kivshar YS: Tilted response of fishnet metamaterials at near-infrared optical wavelengths.
*Phys Rev B*2010, 81: 115109.View Article - Zhang S, Fan W, Panoiu NC, Malloy KJ, Osgood RM, Brueck SRJ: Demonstration of metal-dielectric negative-index metamaterials with improved performance at optical frequencies.
*J Opt Soc Am B*2006, 23: 434–438. 10.1364/JOSAB.23.000434View Article - Cao T, Cryan MJ: Study of incident angle dependence for dual-band double negative-index material using elliptical nanohole arrays.
*J Opt Soc Am A*2012, 29: 209–215.View Article - Pendry JB, Holden A, Robbins D, Stewart W: Magnetism from conductors and enhanced nonlinear phenomena.
*IEEE Trans Microw Theory Tech*1999, 47(11):2075–2084. 10.1109/22.798002View Article - Smith DR, Padilla WJ, Vier DC, Nemat-Nasser SC, Schultz S: Composite medium with simultaneously negative permeability and permittivity.
*Phys Rev Lett*2000, 84: 4184–4187. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.84.4184View Article - Zhao Q, Kang L, Du B, Li B, Zhou J, Tang H, Liang X, Zhang B: Electrically tunable negative permeability metamaterials based on nematic liquid crystals.
*Appl Phys Lett*2007, 90: 011112. 10.1063/1.2430485View Article - Wang X, Kwon DH, Werner DH, Khoo IC, Kildishev AV, Shalaev VM: Tunable optical negative-index metamaterials employing anisotropic liquid crystals.
*Appl Phys Lett*2007, 91: 143122. 10.1063/1.2795345View Article - Minovich A, Neshev DN, Powell DA, Shadrivov IV, Kivshar YS: Tunable fishnet metamaterials infiltrated by liquid crystals.
*Appl Phys Lett*2010, 96: 193103. 10.1063/1.3427429View Article - Dicken MJ, Aydin K, Pryce IM, Sweatlock LA, Boyd EM, Walavalkar S, Ma J, Atwater HA: Frequency tunable near-infrared metamaterials based on VO
_{2}phase transition.*Opt Express*2009, 17: 18330–18339. 10.1364/OE.17.018330View Article - Driscoll T, Kim HT, Chae BG, Kim BJ, Lee YW, Jokerst NM, Smith DR, Ventra MD, Basov DN: Memory metamaterials.
*Science*2009, 325: 1518–1521. 10.1126/science.1176580View Article - Chen HT, O'Hara JF, Azad AK, Taylor AJ, Averitt RD, Shrekenhamer DB, Padilla WJ: Experimental demonstration of frequency-agile terahertz metamaterials.
*Nat Photon*2008, 2: 295–298. 10.1038/nphoton.2008.52View Article - Hu XY, Zhang YB, Fu YL, Yang H, Gong QH: Low-power and ultrafast all-optical tunable nanometer-scale photonic metamaterials.
*Adv Mater*2011, 23: 4295–4300. 10.1002/adma.201101350View Article - Hasan MZ, Kane CL: Topological insulators.
*Rev Mod Phys*2010, 82: 3045. 10.1103/RevModPhys.82.3045View Article - Qi XY, Zhang SC: Topological insulators and superconductors.
*Rev Mod Phys*2011, 83: 1057. 10.1103/RevModPhys.83.1057View Article - Zhang X, Wang J, Zhang SC: Topological insulators for high-performance terahertz to infrared applications.
*Phys Rev B*2011, 82: 245107.View Article - Hsieh D, Xia Y, Qian D, Wray L, Dil JH, Meier F, Osterwalder J, Patthey L, Checkelsky JG, Ong NP, Fedorov AV, Lin H, Bansil A, Grauer D, Hor YS, Cava RJ, Hasan MZ: A tunable topological insulator in the spin helical Dirac transport regime.
*Nature*2009, 460: 1101. 10.1038/nature08234View Article - Pan ZH, Vescovo E, Fedorov AV, Gardner D, Lee YS, Chu S, Gu GD, Valla T: Electronic structure of the topological insulator Bi
_{2}Se_{3}using angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy: evidence for a nearly full surface spin polarization.*Phys Rev Lett*2011, 106: 257004.View Article - Sharma Y, Srivastava P: First-principles study of electronic and optical properties of Bi
_{2}Se_{3}in its trigonal and orthorhombic phases.*AIP Conf Proc*2009, 1249: 183–187. - Shao LH, Ruther M, Linden S, Essig S, Busch K, Weissmüller J, Wegener M: Electrochemical modulation of photonic metamaterials.
*Adv Mater*2010, 22: 5173–5177. 10.1002/adma.201002734View Article - Peng H, Dang W, Cao J, Chen Y, Wu D, Zheng W, Li H, Shen ZX, Liu Z: Topological insulator nanostructures for near-infrared transparent flexible electrodes.
*Nat Chem*2012, 4: 281–286. 10.1038/nchem.1277View Article - Dordevic SV, Wolf MS, Stojilovic N, Lei H, Petrovic C: Signatures of charge inhomogeneities in the infrared spectra of topological insulators Bi
_{2}Se_{3}, Bi_{2}Te_{3}and Sb_{2}Te_{3}.*J Phys Condens Matter*2013, 25: 075501. 10.1088/0953-8984/25/7/075501View Article - Hafiz MM, El-Shazly O, Kinawy N: Reversible phase change in Bi
_{x}Se_{100-x}chalcogenide thin films for using as optical recording medium.*Appl Surf Sci*2001, 171: 231–241. 10.1016/S0169-4332(00)00709-1View Article - Zhao J, Liu H, Ehm L, Dong D, Chen Z, Gu G: High-pressure phase transitions, amorphization, and crystallization behaviors in Bi
_{2}Se_{3}.*J Phys Condens Matter*2013, 25: 125602. 10.1088/0953-8984/25/12/125602View Article - EM Explorer http://www.emexplorer.net/
- Johnson PB, Christy RW: Optical constants of the noble metals.
*Phys Rev B*1972, 6: 4370–4379. 10.1103/PhysRevB.6.4370View Article - Berenger JP: Three-dimensional perfectly matched layer for the absorption of electromagnetic waves.
*J Comput Phys*1996, 127: 363–379. 10.1006/jcph.1996.0181View Article - Born M, Wolf E, Bhatia AB:
*Principles of Optics*. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1997:61–70. - Nicolson AM, Ross GF: Measurement of the intrinsic properties of materials by time-domain techniques.
*IEEE Trans Instrum Meas*1970, 19: 377–382.View Article - Smith DR, Schultz S, Markos P, Soukoulis CM: Determination of effective permittivity and permeability of metamaterials from reflection and transmission coefficients.
*Phys Rev B*2002, 65: 195104.View Article - Chen XD, Grzegorczyk TM, Wu B, Pacheco JJ, Kong JA: Robust method to retrieve the constitutive effective parameters of metamaterials.
*Phys Rev E*2004, 70: 016608.View Article - Zhang S, Fan W, Malloy KJ, Brueck SRJ: Near-infrared double negative metamaterials.
*Opt Express*2005, 13: 4922–4930. 10.1364/OPEX.13.004922View Article - Ortuño R, García-Meca C, Rodríguez-Fortuño FJ, Martí J, Martínez A: Role of surface plasmon polaritons on optical transmission through double layer metallic hole arrays.
*Phys Rev B*2009, 79: 075425.View Article

## Copyright

This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.