Molecular beam epitaxy and properties of GaAsBi/GaAs quantum wells grown by molecular beam epitaxy: effect of thermal annealing

  • Hajer Makhloufi1, 2, 6,

    Affiliated with

    • Poonyasiri Boonpeng1, 2, 6,

      Affiliated with

      • Simone Mazzucato3, 6,

        Affiliated with

        • Julien Nicolai4, 6,

          Affiliated with

          • Alexandre Arnoult1, 6,

            Affiliated with

            • Teresa Hungria5, 6,

              Affiliated with

              • Guy Lacoste1, 6,

                Affiliated with

                • Christophe Gatel4, 6,

                  Affiliated with

                  • Anne Ponchet4, 6,

                    Affiliated with

                    • Hélène Carrère3, 6,

                      Affiliated with

                      • Xavier Marie3, 6 and

                        Affiliated with

                        • Chantal Fontaine1, 6Email author

                          Affiliated with

                          Nanoscale Research Letters20149:123

                          DOI: 10.1186/1556-276X-9-123

                          Received: 18 November 2013

                          Accepted: 31 January 2014

                          Published: 17 March 2014


                          We have grown GaAsBi quantum wells by molecular beam epitaxy. We have studied the properties of a 7% Bi GaAsBi quantum well and their variation with thermal annealing. High-resolution X-ray diffraction, secondary ion mass spectrometry, and transmission electron microscopy have been employed to get some insight into its structural properties. Stationary and time-resolved photoluminescence shows that the quantum well emission, peaking at 1.23 μm at room temperature, can be improved by a rapid annealing at 650°C, while the use of a higher annealing temperature leads to emission degradation and blue-shifting due to the activation of non-radiative centers and bismuth diffusion from the quantum well.


                          Dilute bismides Molecular beam epitaxy Heteroepitaxy X-ray diffraction Transmission electron microscopy Photoluminescence


                          Dilute bismuth alloys grown on GaAs attract more and more attention because of their peculiar electronic properties. Adding bismuth to GaAs efficiently decreases the gap energy of this semiconductor [1] through a change in its valence band properties and increases the spin-orbit interaction [2]. GaAsBi/GaAs quantum wells (QWs) are of interest with a view to fabricate laser diodes which could benefit from these properties, in particular from the higher spin-orbit splitting expected to lower the non-radiative carrier recombination due to Auger mechanisms [3]. Moreover, their emitting wavelength range could meet the requirements for infrared GaAs-based laser diodes as an alternative to low-temperature GaInAs/GaAs [4] and GaInAsN/GaAs [5] QWs. Besides, the properties of these III-V alloys are also very promising for photovoltaics [6]. Up to now, literature on GaAsBi has mainly been devoted to thick layers (see [7] and ref. herein), and only a few papers on the growth of quantum well structures have been published [8]. Here, we present the structural and optical properties of a GaAsBi/GaAs QW grown by molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) and discuss their change after rapid thermal annealing (RTA).


                          GaAsBi quantum well structures were grown using a 32P RIBER (Bezons, France) MBE system. Substrates were pieces of a semi-insulating GaAs substrate soldered with indium on a silicon wafer mounted on the substrate holder to be loaded in the MBE system. The substrate thermocouple temperature for the molybdenum substrate holder was first calibrated by using a band edge thermometry system (BandIT). The control of the growing material was performed by reflection high-energy electron diffraction (RHEED). Our MBE system is designed to grow in the RIBER ‘optimal cell/sample oven’ geometry which leads to high thickness uniformity on 2-in. samples even though the 32P Riber MBE system is not normally designed to get high uniformity on these large surface areas. In such a geometry, substrate rotation is required to be used continuously during the growth, since the fluxes are not converging towards the substrate holder center.

                          QWs with different Bi contents and widths were grown, and the results presented here come from the QW emitting at the longer wavelength. They were grown after careful calibration of the growth conditions, the GaAs growth rate, i.e., the V/III ratio, the substrate temperature, and the Bi content, on thick GaAsBi layers. Note that we do not have any flux gauge in our MBE system, so the Bi control was carried out via the cell temperature.

                          The investigated QW sample consists of a 500-nm-thick buffer GaAs layer, the GaAsBi/GaAs QW, and finally a 100-nm-thick cap layer. After the growth of the buffer layer at 580°C, the temperature is lowered to 365°C, the value selected for the QW growth. The As cell valve opening is reduced in order to yield the As4 flux corresponding to a V/III atomic ratio close to unity, as needed for GaAsBi growth [9]; the As cell is a RIBER VCAS700 cracker (Bezons, France) one whose nose temperature is set to 650°C, thus mostly ejecting As4 species. At the same time, the Ga cell temperature is decreased to a value which leads to a low growth rate for GaAs, of the order of 0.25 ml/s. After substrate temperature cooling, care is taken to get temperature stabilization since this parameter plays a major role in Bi incorporation [7]. At this step, the Ga and Bi cell shutters are opened simultaneously. For the first period of growth, bismuth plays the role of a surfactant for the low-temperature-grown GaAs [9], until a (2 × 1) reconstruction of a bismuth-rich GaAs surface [10] is observed, the required condition for efficient incorporation of this element into GaAs [11]. Then, the bismuth element contributes to the formation of a GaAsBi QW. At the end of the QW growth, the Bi cell shutter is closed first. The Ga shutter is only closed once a 5-nm layer of GaAs has been grown; we have observed that the GaAs RHEED pattern deteriorates for a GaAs layer thickness higher than 5 to 10 nm, after the floating bismuth was incorporated in GaAs or desorbed [7]. The growth is then interrupted to heat the structure temperature to 520°C. Finally, a 30-nm-thick GaAs layer is grown at 0.7 ml/s at this temperature, and the 100-nm-thick barrier growth is completed while the temperature is raised to 580°C.

                          Once grown, the GaAsBi/GaAs QW structures were analyzed by stationary photoluminescence using the 514-nm line of an argon laser and a GaInAs photodetector. The quantum well emitting at 300 K at the longer wavelength, 1.23 μm, was selected. The sample was cleaved into pieces, which were subjected to ex situ RTA in an AnnealSys AS-One system (West Newbury, MA, USA). RTA was carried out in a nitrogen atmosphere during 30 s at annealing temperatures of 650°C, 700°C, 750°C, and 800°C. Samples were covered with a GaAs substrate during annealing in order to prevent surface degradation by arsenic desorption.

                          High-resolution X-ray diffraction (HR-XRD) was performed on the as-grown sample using a D8 Discover Bruker (Karlsruhe, Germany) equipment in order to determine its thickness and strain, from which we deduce its bismuth content. It was also used on the annealed samples to get insight into the evolution of their structural properties upon annealing. Secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) with a CAMECA IMS-6f (Gennevilliers, France) was employed to measure the profile of the bismuth element within the structure for the as-grown and annealed samples. Primary Cs+ ions were accelerated at 3 kV, while the positive secondary ions were collected at 2 kV. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) in conventional and high-resolution (HR) modes was carried out on the as-grown QW sample. A <110 > -oriented cross-sectional sample was thinned by mechanical polishing and ion milling. HR-TEM observations were performed at 200 kV on a TECNAI F-20 (E.A. Fischione Instruments, Inc., Export, PA, USA), equipped with a spherical aberration corrector tuned to avoid the delocalization effect at the interface and to achieve a 0.12-nm resolution.

                          Time-resolved photoluminescence (PL) spectroscopy was performed at room temperature on the as-grown and annealed samples. Optical excitation was provided by focusing 1.5-ps pulses generated by a mode-locked Ti-sapphire laser with 80-MHz repetition frequency. The laser wavelength was set to λexc = 795 nm with 20-mW incident power, focused to a 50-μm diameter spot at the sample surface. The signal was recorded using a S1 photocathode Hamamatsu streak camera (Hamamatsu, Shizuoka, Japan) with an overall time resolution of 8 ps. The signal was recorded in the high-energy side (1,120 to 1,220 nm) of the PL spectrum.

                          Results and discussion

                          As-grown quantum well structure

                          SIMS analysis was carried out on the as-grown sample in order to image the bismuth profile through the structure. Indeed, it is worth to recall that we opened bismuth with Ga and As for a longer duration compared to the one which should be applied for growth of a 7-nm QW. We postulated that the incorporation of the bismuth occurs when the right content of the element saturates the surface, giving rise to the (2 × 1) surface which promotes its incorporation as explained in [10]. The use of this method allows us to optimize the lower QW interface. We actually observe in Figure 1a for this QW that the bismuth content actually exhibits a step shape within the structure. We only observe a small Bi shoulder close to the lower interface which we associate to a slight incorporation of Bi before the quantum well. Moreover, no bismuth is observed to be incorporated in the subsequent 5-nm GaAs grown at low temperature while a As/Ga stoechiometric ratio was still being used. This supports our hypothesis that this element plays the role of a surfactant during the first stage of low-temperature GaAs:Bi growth and, once the bismuth cell was closed, during the low-temperature GaAs growth. Note that, contrary to the case of thick layers, the bismuth content cannot be directly inferred from the SIMS profile as the QW is too thin for SIMS to provide a direct correspondence with the absolute Bi content.
                          Figure 1

                          SIMS profiles and X-ray diffraction scans. SIMS profiles of the different elements (Ga, As, Bi) within the QW structure (a); (004) X-ray diffraction ω/2θ transverse scans measured (black) and simulated (orange) for the QW structure (b).

                          In order to determine the Bi content and QW thickness, HR-XRD analysis is used. As it can be observed in Figure 1b, the presence of thickness fringes and a narrow diffraction peak in the resulting 2θ transverse scan indicates that the grown material is of high quality. It allows us to accurately evaluate the thickness, content, and strain of the QW. The X-ray diffractogram was simulated. This calculation was done using the software provided by Bruker, with GaAs and GaBi lattice parameters taken equal to 0.56353 and 0.633 nm, respectively [12], and with the elastic constants of GaAs (C11 = 118.81 GPa and C12 = 53.8 GPa) for a structure under complete elastic tetragonal strain. For a thickness of 7.5 nm and a Bi content of 7%, we observe perfect agreement of the experimental rocking curve with the simulated one, further highlighting that the as-grown QW structure exhibits good quality structural properties.

                          This is also supported by the TEM analysis. The abruptness and flatness of the lower and upper interfaces are confirmed. First, conventional TEM experiments reveal the absence of extended defects and insignificant roughness (Figure 2a). HR-TEM performed on various areas confirms on a more local scale the absence of dislocations (Figure 2b), indicating a full accommodation of the lattice misfit by elastic deformation. The strain related to a reference zone chosen in the GaAs buffer was determined with a spatial resolution better than 1 nm, by means of geometrical phase analysis of the HR-TEM images [13, 14]. As shown by the profile along the growth direction (Figure 2b, inset), the out-of-plane strain ϵ can be considered as homogeneous in the quantum well. Following the linear elasticity and taking into account the fact that ϵ is measured related to a GaAs reference zone, ϵ is related to the misfit f through ϵ = (1 + 2C12/C11)f.
                          Figure 2

                          TEM observation of a cross section of the QW structure. Conventional (a) and high-resolution modes (inset: strain profile measured along the growth direction) (b).

                          The average strain measured from HR-TEM is 0.016, but this value has to be corrected for surface relaxation effects: the strain before thinning is numerically estimated to be 10% to 20% larger [14].

                          Thus, after this correction, the estimated misfit is in the range of 0.0095 to 0.0105. Applying the Vegard’s law, this corresponds to a Bi amount of 7.8% to 8.8%, close to the content provided by HR-XRD. Different analyzed zones have given comparable values of strain. In addition, the measured QW thickness in Figure 2b is measured to be 7 nm, again close to the value estimated through HR-XRD.

                          Taking into account the values measured by HR-XRD and TEM, the assumption of late incorporation of the bismuth is valid. The thickness of the QW is thinner than the one which would have been obtained had the Bi atoms been directly incorporated as soon as the Bi cell was opened.

                          Annealed QW samples

                          Figure 3a shows that the RTA of the QW structure leads to a drastic change in its X-ray 2θ transverse scan. The diffractogram is similar to the as-grown one except for the 650°C annealing temperature. At 700°C, a slight difference is observed, while for the two highest annealing temperatures, the background is observed to drastically evolve, which can be accounted for by a modification of the bismuth profile within the structure. Figure 3b shows how the SIMS Bi signal broadens with annealing. This analysis confirms that the Bi profile has become more distributed within the structure, as a result of its diffusion into the GaAs surrounding barriers for the two higher annealing temperatures. This Bi diffusion at high temperature is certainly supported by strain for this QW with a high Bi content. Indeed, Mohmad et al. [15] have shown that the optimal annealing temperature is affected by the local strain supported by the GaAsBi alloys due to the high atomic size of the Bi atom.
                          Figure 3

                          X-ray diffraction scans and Bi SIMS profiles. (004) X-ray diffraction ω/2θ transverse scans (a) and Bi SIMS profiles for the differently annealed samples (b).

                          As a consequence, the QW optical properties are greatly affected by the RTA treatment. Figure 4a shows the evolution of the 20-K PL spectra for different annealing temperature conditions. The QW emission wavelength is unchanged for the 650°C and 700°C RTA, but it strongly blue-shifts at higher RTA temperatures, due to the Bi diffusion out of the annealed QW. Moreover, only the 650°C RTA improves the emission intensity compared to the as-grown sample. For higher temperatures, a rapid reduction of the PL intensity is found. Additionally, at room temperature, the PL emission of the 650°C RTA QW is found to be better than the one of the as-grown QW, while no PL emission is visible for the annealed samples at the 750°C and 800°C. RTA is known to improve structural properties of materials. In the case of GaAsBi thin layers, a decrease of the density of localized defects, due to bismuth aggregates or alloy disorder, has been claimed to occur during annealing by Mohmad et al. [15] and Mazzucato et al. [16].
                          Figure 4

                          Annealing effect on QW PL. The 20-K PL spectra of the as-grown and annealed QW samples (a); room temperature time-resolved PL carrier decay time for the as-grown QW and those annealed at 650°C and 700°C (b).

                          The increase of the carrier decay time in the time-resolved luminescence analysis measured for the 650°C annealed sample, in Figure 4b, also supports its better crystallinity, in agreement with the improved emission recorded under CW photoluminescence analysis. On the contrary, for annealing treatment at temperatures higher than 700°C, the room temperature carrier decay time like the other properties of this annealed QW degrades with respect to the as-grown QW, showing again that a too high annealing temperature leads to the activation of additional non-radiative centers.


                          We have shown that a 7% Bi GaAsBi quantum well grown by molecular beam epitaxy, emitting at 1.23 μm at room temperature is completely elastically strained and exhibits good structural properties, with a uniform thickness, sharp interfaces, and the absence of extended defects. Annealing this QW leads to bismuth out-diffusion as soon as the applied annealing temperature is higher than 650°C. At the latter annealing temperature, the photoluminescence emission and decay time at room temperature are all improved.

                          Authors’ information

                          Hajer Makhloufi is a PhD student at LAAS. Poonyasiri Boonpeng is a TECHNO Tempus Erasmus Post-doctorate at LAAS. Simone Mazzucato is a visitor researcher at LPCNO. Hélène Carrère holds an assistant professor position at INSA and is a researcher at LPCNO. Julien Nicolai is a CNRS post-doctorant at CEMES. Alexandre Arnoult and Guy Lacoste are CNRS engineers at LAAS. Teresa Hungria is an engineer at INSA. Christophe Gatel (assistant professor at Université Paul Sabatier) and Anne Ponchet (Research Director at CNRS) are researchers at CEMES. Xavier Marie is a professor at INSA and is a researcher at LPCNO. Chantal Fontaine (Research Director at CNRS) is a CNRS researcher at LAAS.



                          This work was supported by the Paul Sabatier University (AO1 programme), the LAAS-CNRS technology platform (RENATECH), and the LPCNO laboratory. We acknowledge the TECHNO Erasmus Mundus Programme for its support through the post-doctoral grant of Poonyasiri Boonpeng. Part of this work has been supported by the NAIADE project (ANR-11-BS10-017). We would also like to thank the cooperation of COST Action MP0805 and Stephane Calvez for the fruitful discussions.

                          Authors’ Affiliations

                          CNRS, LAAS
                          Université Paul Sabatier
                          Université de Toulouse, LPCNO, INSA-UPS-CNRS
                          Service Analyseur ionique, INSA
                          Université de Toulouse


                          1. Francoeur S, Seong MJ, Mascarenhas A, Tixier S, Adamcyk M, Tiedje T: Band gap of GaAs1-x Bix, 0<x<3.6%. Appl Phys Lett 2003, 82: 3874. 10.1063/1.1581983View Article
                          2. Broderick CA, Usman M, Sweeney SJ, O’Reilly EP: Band engineering in dilute nitride and bismide semiconductor lasers. Semicond Sci Technol 2012, 27: 094011. 10.1088/0268-1242/27/9/094011View Article
                          3. Batool Z, Hild K, Hosea TJC, Lu X, Tiedje T, Sweeney SJ: The electronic band structure of GaBiAs/GaAs layers: influence of strain and band anti-crossing. J Appl Phys 2012, 111: 113108. 10.1063/1.4728028View Article
                          4. Mogg S, Chitica N, Schatz R, Hammar M: Properties of highly strained InGaAs/GaAs quantum wells for 1.2-μm laser diodes. Appl Phys Lett 2002, 81: 2334. 10.1063/1.1509478View Article
                          5. Shan W, Walukiewicz W, Ager JW III, Haller EE, Geisz JF, Friedman DJ, Olson JM, Kurtz SR: Band anticrossing in GaInNAs alloys. Phys Rev Lett 1999, 82: 1221. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.82.1221View Article
                          6. Ptak AJ, France R, Jiang CS, Reedy RC: Effects of bismuth on wide-depletion-width GaInNAs solar cells. J Vac Sci Technol B 2008, 26: 1053. 10.1116/1.2837848View Article
                          7. Lewis RB, Masnadi-Shirazi M, Tiedje T: Growth of high Bi concentration GaAs1-xBix by molecular beam epitaxy. Appl Phys Lett 2012, 101: 082112. 10.1063/1.4748172View Article
                          8. Tominaga Y, Kinoshita Y, Oe K, Yoshimoto M: Structural investigation of GaAs1-xBix/GaAs multiquantum wells. Appl Phys Lett 2008, 93: 131915. 10.1063/1.2993343View Article
                          9. Ye H, Song X, Gu Y, Wang S: Light emission from InGaAs:Bi/GaAs quantum wells at 1.3 μm. AIP Adv 2012, 2: 042158. 10.1063/1.4769102View Article
                          10. Laukkanen P, Punkkinen MPJ, Kosma HP, Ahola-Tuomi M, Kokko K, Kuzumin M, Adell J, Sadowski J, Perälä RE, Ropo M, Rantala TT, Väyrynen IJ, Pessa M, Vitos L, Kollár J, Mirbt S, Johansson B: Anomalous bismuth-stabilized (2 × 1) reconstructions on GaAs(100) and InP(100) surfaces. Phys Rev Lett 2008, 100: 086101.View Article
                          11. Masnadi-Shirazi M, Beton DA, Lewis RB, Lu X, Tiedje T: Surface reconstructions during growth of GaAs1-xBix alloys by molecular beam epitaxy. J Cryst Growth 2012, 338: 80. 10.1016/j.jcrysgro.2011.09.055View Article
                          12. Tixier S, Adamcyk M, Tiedje T, Francoeur S, Mascarenhas A, Wei P, Schiettekatte F: Molecular beam epitaxy growth of GaAs1-xBix. Appl Phys Lett 2003, 82: 2245. 10.1063/1.1565499View Article
                          13. Hytch MJ, Snoeck E, Kilaas R: Quantitative measurement of displacement and strain fields from HREM micrographs. Ultramicroscopy 1998, 74: 131. 10.1016/S0304-3991(98)00035-7View Article
                          14. Gatel C, Tang H, Crestou C, Ponchet A, Bertru N, Doré F, Folliot H: Analysis by high-resolution electron microscopy of elastic strain in thick InAs layers embedded in Ga0.47In0.53As buffers on InP(0 0 1) substrate. Acta Mater 2010, 58: 3238. 10.1016/j.actamat.2010.01.047View Article
                          15. Mohmad AR, Bastiman F, Hunter CJ, Richards R, Sweeney SJ, Ng JS, David JPR: Effects of rapid thermal annealing on GaAs1-xBix alloys. Appl Phys Lett 2012, 101: 012106. 10.1063/1.4731784View Article
                          16. Mazzucato S, Boonpeng P, Carrère H, Lagarde D, Arnoult A, Lacoste G, Zhang T, Balocchi A, Amand T, Marie X, Fontaine C: Reduction of defect density by rapid thermal annealing in GaAsBi studied by time-resolved photoluminescence. Semicond Sci Technol 2013, 28: 022001. 10.1088/0268-1242/28/2/022001View Article


                          © Makhloufi et al.; licensee Springer. 2014

                          This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://​creativecommons.​org/​licenses/​by/​2.​0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly credited.