- Nano Express
- Open Access
High performance surface-enhanced Raman scattering substrates of Si-based Au film developed by focused ion beam nanofabrication
Nanoscale Research Letters volume 7, Article number: 399 (2012)
A novel method with high flexibility and efficiency for developing SERS substrates is proposed by patterning nanostructures on Si substrates using focused ion beam direct writing (FIBDW) technology following with precise thermal evaporation of gold film on the substrate. The effect of SERS on the substrate was systematically investigated by optimizing the processing parameters and the gold film thickness. The results proved that small dwell time could improve the machining accuracy and obtain smaller nanogap. The Raman-enhanced performance of the substrate was investigated with 10−6mol/L Rhodamine 6 G solution. It was indicated that the elliptic nanostructures with 15-nm spacing on Si substrates, coated with approximately 15-nm thick gold film, have exhibited a high-enhanced performance, but dramatic performance degradation was found as the gold film thickness further increased, which most probably resulted from changes of the nanostructures’ morphology such as elliptical tip and spacing. To avoid the morphological changes effectively after depositing gold film, optimization design of the nanostructures for FIBDW on Si substrates was proposed. Besides, a similar phenomenon was found when the gold film was less than 15nm because there was little gold remaining on the substrate. The method proposed in this paper shows a great potential for the higher performance SERS substrates development, which can further reduce the spacing between hot spots.
Surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) is one of the most powerful tools for trace detections and biochemical applications because of its ultrasensitivity, low-cost, and real-time characteristics[1–6]. In 1928, Raman and Krishnan first observed a special phenomenon that monochromatic light incident on molecules resulted in normal Rayleigh scattering as well as modified scattered radiation of different frequencies. This ‘feeble’ phenomenon is known as Raman scattering, which is attributable to the excitation (or relaxation) of vibration modes of a molecule. Therefore, the Raman spectrum could be used to identify the target molecules up to single molecule in chemical and biological systems because every molecule has its unique Raman spectrum, and different functional groups have different characteristic vibration energies. But in a long time after the Raman scattering was discovered, the applications in biosensing had been limited by its inherent much weak signal until 1977, when Jeanmaire and Van Duyne indicated that the magnitude of Raman scattering signal can be largely enhanced by roughened noble metal surface[7, 8]. Later, this phenomenon was defined as SERS. The main underlying enhancement mechanism was attributed to the localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) that electronic collective oscillation contributes to the electromagnetic enhancement, occurring when the nanostructure is much smaller than the excitation wavelength. The chemical mechanism would also play a role in SERS enhancement with less contribution than LSPR.
The most critical aspect of SERS is the research of efficient SERS-active substrates, such as nanostructured surface or nanoparticles of noble metals with suitable physical parameters such as their material, size, shape, and spacing[12, 13]. Generally, Ag and Au nanoparticles are regarded as one of the best candidates for SERS substrate studies. During its development, many methods were put forward to fabricate SERS-active substrates, such as roughened electrodes, noble metal colloidal nanoparticles, silver island films, metal films over nanostructured surfaces, acid-etched metal foils, and lithographically produced nanoparticle arrays[15–17]. Nevertheless, fabrication of SERS substrates with both high sensitivity and high stableness remains difficult, and it is costly for routine SERS detection.
Recently, focused ion beam direct writing (FIBDW) technology has been an increasingly important nano-fabrication technique, which has been used in the SERS substrate’s development[4, 10]. However, thin gold film which is coated on the Si substrate or quartz glass is soft, so it has unstable properties during the FIB processing. It is difficult to obtain nanostructures with spacing less than 20nm. Owning to this, we report a simple method for fabricating Au elliptical nanostructures on Si substrates with spacing less than 15nm. The fabrication procedure of the patterned Au nano-ellipse is illustrated in Figure 1. Firstly, we etch nanostructures on Si substrates due to its better fabrication accuracy than that of Au. Secondly, Si substrates were coated with gold film through thermal evaporation with precise film thickness. From Figure 1, we could find that the spacing of the nanostructure became smaller after thermal evaporation. The micrographs of the nanostructures were characterized by scanning electron microscopy (SEM); the thickness of gold film was measured by white light interferometry; and the SERS properties were detected using low concentration Rhodamine 6 G as probe molecules. The result indicates that this nanostructure showed high Raman enhancement with the gold film of approximately 15nm. Moreover, it can be concluded that the edge and spacing are truly the dominant factors for electric enhancement.
Materials and instruments
In this work, Si wafers were cut into squares, cleaned in an ultrasonic bath with methanol for 20min, and dried in the air. Rhodamine 6 G was diluted to 10−6mol/L with deionized water. The adsorption peak of R6G molecule in deionized water was 557nm, and fluorescence wavelength was 610nm. Therefore, in the experiment, a laser wavelength of 785nm was chosen so as to avoid fluorescence.
FIB system (Nova 200, NanoLab, MA, USA) was used to fabricate patterning nanostructures. It combines ultra-high resolution field emission SEM and precise focused ion beam etch, and could be used for nanoscale prototyping, machining, and on-line high resolution SEM measurements. The thickness of gold film was measured by white light interferometry (NT 9300, Veeco Instruments Inc., Shanghai, China). Raman spectra were obtained with an inVia Raman microscope (Renishaw plc, Gloucestershire, UK) with a CCD detector and a × 50 objective measuring the probe molecules. The nanostructure SERS substrate, which was placed into the R6G solution for 2h and dried in the air, was irradiated by 785nm wavelength with a laser power of approximately 70mW and integration time of 10s. The Raman shift ranges from 550 to 2,000cm−1. All tests were carried out on three different places from the substrate, and the final spectra were averaged by those measurements.
Nanostructures developed on Si substrates by FIB
Firstly, ellipse patterns of BMP files with 24-bit format used for the FIB fabrication were compiled with Matlab. In the experiment, the FIB etching size and depth were 9.5 × 9.6μm2 and approximately 30 to 40nm, respectively. By adjusting the FIBDW key fabrication parameters, such as dwell time and etching time, micro/nanostructure arrays with high form accuracy were fabricated on Si substrates. Table 1 shows the FIBDW relevant parameters for different substrates, where the average dimensions of the ellipses were 300nm in long axis and 100nm in short axis. Figure 2 shows the SEM images of nanostructures on the Si substrate. The nanostructure spacing can be down to 15nm on Si substrates.
Preparation of SERS-active substrates via thermal evaporation
The SERS-active substrates were made by depositing Au with thermal evaporation. Figure 3 shows the SERS-active substrate with different gold film thickness, and all the substrates were fabricated with a dwell time of 1μs and total time of 8min. In order to estimate the influence of gold film, the thicknesses of the film varied from 10 to 70nm, which were calculated by white light interferometry, as shown in Figure 4. We should note that all the measured thicknesses have a deviation of ± 2nm due to the inaccuracy of the measuring instrument.
Results and discussion
Effect of FIB fabrication conditions on SERS
By optimizing the FIBDW parameters, the nanostructure’s dimension and form accuracy on Si substrates can be well controlled, and the nanostructure’s spacing can be reduced to 15nm, as shown in Table 1 and Figure 2. However, bigger dwell time and longer FIB etching time result in apparent changes of the nanostructure’s profile. For example, compared to A_1, the nanostructure’s spacings of A_2 and A_3 increased by 20% and 46.7%, respectively, and the curvature of the elliptical tip becomes bigger. It can be clearly seen in Figure 2. This phenomenon could be attributed to the ion beam etching. Longer FIB fabrication time can induce large-depth structures, but it would also degrade the nanostructures accuracy accordingly.
In order to test the FIB fabrication accuracy on the SERS enhancement results, the FIB parameter-dependent Si-based substrate with approximately 15-nm thick gold film and neat gold film without nanostructures was characterized by 10−6mol/L R6G solution. The substrate was placed into the R6G solution for 2h and dried in the air, then measured by SERS detections. Figure 5 clearly shows the SERS spectra and the related micrographs of the nanostructures after coated with 15-nm thick gold film. The Raman spectrum shows the intense peaks of R6G ’s main vibrational features at 611, 775, 1187, 1307, 1367, 1504, 1573, 1596, and 1650cm−1. It is noted that A_1 substrate shows higher Raman signal enhancement than the one for A_2. With increasing dwell and etching times, the Raman signal decreased as shown in Figure 5. It is implied that dwell and etching times were the vital factors for the nanoscale fabrication controlled by FIB. It is worth noting that it was difficult to distinguish any Raman signal from the naked Au surface, which indicated the gold film surface was smooth and homogeneous enough. The high SERS activity in A_1 was mainly attributed to the availability of much smaller structure’s spacing. It is reasonable that the tip gathered amount of charge so that strong electromagnetic field (EM) coupling would be induced by adjacent metal nanostructures when the spacing between two micro/nanostructures decreased[2, 21]. The EM effect increases rapidly, which would enhance the signal intensity of SERS.
Therefore, in order to obtain high performance and high electromagnetic field enhancement Si-based gold film SERS substrates, FIB fabrication parameters should be optimized.
Effect of Au film thickness on SERS
For the evaluation of the different film thickness on the quality of SERS spectra, R6G was also chosen as the probe molecule (detection method is the same as the previous work). Obviously, Figure 6 shows the values of Raman signal intensity which almost exponentially decreased with an increasing thickness of the Au film. The elliptical nanostructures coated with approximately 15-nm Au have exhibited very strong SERS effect. The thinner the Au films were, the higher the signal occurred. However, we could not detect any R6G signal when the gold film was 10nm because there was little Au remaining on the surface of the substrate as well as on the sidewall and bottom of the trench. It should also be mentioned that there were no Raman peaks on the bare Au film, noting that the gold film surface was smooth and homogeneous enough. According to Figure 3, we know that when the thickness of Au film is 15nm, the structure form keeps very well, but the FIBDW nanostructures deformed with the thickness increasing to 20 or 70nm, such as the curvature of the elliptical tip and dimension becomes bigger, because the deposition of Au may cover this region. According to the lighting rod effect, geometries with a small curvature lead to charge oscillation and induce a higher EM effect[19, 22]. Therefore, the decreased intensities from 15 to 70nm are most probably related to the decreased number of hot spots[23, 24] due to the longtime deposition of Au. Since the spacing becomes smaller with the gold film increasing (Figure 1), why was there no Raman signal? It is found that nanostructure tip almost disappeared during deposition progress which obstructed the electromagnetic field enhancement. It can be concluded that, for the geometrical factors of micro/nanostructures, small curvatures and small spacing, which played a key role in promoting cooperative plasmon mode, were equally significant for the creation of a higher electromagnetic field enhanced effect and lead to higher SERS.
Optimization of the nanostructures
In order to avoid the performance degradation which was induced by Au film thermal evaporation process, an optimization design method for FIB nanofabrication was proposed. Firstly, the size of nanostructures was minimized during FIB manufacturing process. Secondly, the nanostructures with a smaller curvature should be produced. The bitmap files for FIB fabrication were modified as follows (Figure 7a): the pink area represents the revised structure, where the curvature and size of the elliptical tip become smaller. With an optimized geometry and dimensions, the relative surface area coated with a gold film of 18nm exhibits evident R6G Raman signal (Figure 7b) compared to the original area. The black line represents the original structure; red line, the optimized structure; and blue, the bare Au film. The picture on the right was the optimized structure and the original structure (inset). It is further confirmed that the edge and spacing are the main enhancement factors for SERS. The improvement in the variability of the SERS signal from these optimization substrates indicates that this fabrication process has a great potential for fabricating SERS substrates.
This paper presents a high enhancement SERS substrate development method with FIB nanofabrication in advance and subsequently with gold film thermal evaporation. It is found that acceleration current, dwell time, and etching time play a major role in precisely controlling nanostructures during the FIB nanofabrication on Si substrates. SERS spectra study revealed the relativities between Raman enhancement and thickness of gold film. As the gold film increased from 15 to 70nm, the Raman signal decreased and disappeared finally because thermal evaporation has covered many hot spots. It is concluded that the spacing and curvature of structures are the key factors for the electromagnetic field enhancement and SERS performance. The method integrated the advantages of high sensitivity and repeatability, and would significantly facilitate practical SERS substrate preparation.
FF is a professor working in Tianjin University from 2005. His main research interests are micro/nano manufacturing and freeform optics. He is the president of the International Society for Nanomanufacturing (ISNM). He is also a Fellow of CIRP - International Academy for Production Engineering, and an Editor-in-Chief of the International Journal of Nanomanufacturing (IJNM).
Whitney AV: Silver island films as substrate for surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS): a methodological study on their application to artists’ red dyestuffs. SPIE 2005, 5993: 59930K-10.
Huang Z, Meng G, Huang Q, Yang Y, Zhu C, Tang C: Improved SERS performance from Au nanopillar arrays by abridging the pillar tip spacing by Ag sputtering. Adv Mater 2010, 22: 4136–4139. 10.1002/adma.201001179
Yang Y, Meng G: Ag dendritic nanostructures for rapid detection of polychlorinated biphenyls based on surface-enhanced Raman scattering effect. J Appl Phys 2010, 107: 044315. 10.1063/1.3298473
Min Q, Santos MJL, Girotto EM, Brolo AG, Gordon R: Localized Raman enhancement from a double-hole nanostructure in a metal film. Phys Chem Lett 2008, 112: 15098–15101. 10.1021/jp806785u
Grand J, Kostcheev S, Bijeon JL, Lamy CM, Adam PM, Rumyantseva A, Lerondel G, Royer P: Optimization of SERS-active substrates for near-field Raman spectroscopy. Synth Met 2003, 139: 621–624. 10.1016/S0379-6779(03)00276-5
Lal S, Link S, Halas Naomi J: Nano-optics from sensing to waveguiding. Nature Photonics 2007, 1: 641–648. 10.1038/nphoton.2007.223
Liu L, Shao M, Cheng L, Zhuo S, Que R, Lee ST: Edge-enhanced Raman scattering effect from Au deposited nanoedge array. Appl Phys Lett 2011, 98: 073114. 10.1063/1.3556649
De Angelis F, Das G, Patrini M, Candeloro P, Liberale C, Cojoc G, Mecarini F, Fabrizio ED: Novel plasmonic nanodevices for few/single molecule detection. SPIE 2008, 7032: T320-T320.
Laura B, Sagle , Ruvuna LK, Ruemmele JA, Duyne RPV: Advances in localized surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy biosensing. Nanomedicine 2011, 6: 1447–1462. 10.2217/nnm.11.117
Bahns JT, Imre A, Vlasko-Vlasov VK, Pearson J, Hiller JM, Chen LH, Welp U: Enhanced Raman scattering from focused surface plasmons. Appl Phys Lett 2007, 91: 081104. 10.1063/1.2759985
Chursanova MV, Dzhagan VM, Yukhymchuk VO, Lytvyn OS, Valakh MY, Khodasevich IA, Lehmann D, Zahn DR, Waurisch C, Hickey SG: Nanostructured silver substrates with stable and universal SERS properties: application to organic molecules and semiconductor nanoparticles. Nanoscale Res Lett 2009, 5: 403–409.
Wang C, Fang J, Jin Y, Cheng M: Fabrication and surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) of Ag/Au bimetallic films on Si substrates. Appl Surf Sci 2011, 258: 1144–1148. 10.1016/j.apsusc.2011.09.052
Rao Y, Chen Q, Kong F, Dong J, Qian W: 3D ordered gold nanoshell composite array as sensitive SERS nanosensor for detecting l-DOPA and tyrosinase activity. Anal Methods 1969, 2011: 3.
Cheng HW, Li Y: IEEE International Nanoelectronics Conference - INEC: June 21–24 2011. In Local field enhancement dependence on nanoparticle’s geometry in Au/TiO2/Ti/Si SERS active substrate for biochemical sensors. Taoyuan City, Taiwan; 2011:1–2.
Wang J, Huang L, Yuan L, Zhao L, Feng X, Zhang W, Zhai L, Zhu J: Silver nanostructure arrays abundant in sub-5 nm gaps as highly Raman-enhancing substrates. Appl Surf Sci 2011, 258: 3519–3523.
Zvatora P, Rezanka P, Prokopec V, Siegel J, Svorcik V, Kral V: Polytetrafluorethylene-Au as a substrate for surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy. Nanoscale Res Lett 2011, 6: 366. 10.1186/1556-276X-6-366
Hao J, Han MJ, Xu Z, Li J, Meng X: Fabrication and evolution of multilayer silver nanofilms for surface-enhanced Raman scattering sensing of arsenate. Nanoscale Res Lett 2011, 6: 263. 10.1186/1556-276X-6-263
Naik JP, Prewett PD, Das K, Raychaudhuri AK: Instabilities in focused ion beam-patterned Au nanowires. Microelectron Eng 2011, 88: 2840–2843. 10.1016/j.mee.2011.04.050
Lin YY, Liao JD, Ju YH, Chang CW, Shiau AL: Focused ion beam-fabricated Au micro/nanostructures used as a surface enhanced Raman scattering-active substrate for trace detection of molecules and influenza virus. Nanotechnology 2011, 22: 185308. 10.1088/0957-4484/22/18/185308
Xu ZW, Fang FZ, Fu YQ, Zhang SJ, Han T, Li JM: Fabrication of micro/nano-structures using focused ion beam implantation and XeF2 gas-assisted etching. J Micromech Microeng 2009, 19: 054003. 10.1088/0960-1317/19/5/054003
Yokota Y, Ueno K, Misawa H: Essential nanogap effects on surface-enhanced Raman scattering signals from closely spaced gold nanoparticles. Chem Commun (Camb) 2011, 47: 3505–3507. 10.1039/c0cc05320a
Wu LY, Ross BM, Lee LP: Optical Properties of the crescent-shaped nanohole antenna. Nano Letters 2009, 9: 1956–1961. 10.1021/nl9001553
Tan Y, Zang X, Gu J, Liu D, Zhu S, Su H, Feng C, Liu Q, Lau W, Moon W, Zhang D: Morphological effects on surface-enhanced Raman scattering from silver butterfly wing scales synthesized via photoreduction. Langmuir: ACS J Surf Colloids 2011, 27: 11742–11746. 10.1021/la202445p
Yi Z, Chen S, Chen Y, Luo J, Wu W, Yi Y, Tang Y: Preparation of dendritic Ag/Au bimetallic nanostructures and their application in surface-enhanced Raman scattering. Thin Solid Films 2011, 520: 2701–2707.
The authors appreciate the supports of the National Basic Research Program of China (973 Program, grant no.: 2011CB706703) and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (grant nos.: 90923038 and 50905126), Tianjin Natural Science Foundation (grant no.: 10JCYBJC06400). The authors would like to thank Mr. B. Tang for the assistance in coating the Au thin films and valuable discussions with Prof. Yongqi Fu from University of Electronic Science and Technology of China.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
TG conceived of the study and carried out the fabrication of nanostructures and optimization design. QZ participated in the thermal evaporation of gold films. XX participated in the measurement of gold film. TG and WG participated in the SERS spectra analysis and discussion. ZX and FZF are the advisors of the project, participating in the design of the study, revising the manuscript, and conducting coordination. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.