- Nano Express
- Open Access
Raman scattering of InAs/AlAs quantum dot superlattices grown on (001) and (311)B GaAs surfaces
Nanoscale Research Lettersvolume 7, Article number: 476 (2012)
We present a comparative analysis of Raman scattering by acoustic and optical phonons in InAs/AlAs quantum dot superlattices grown on (001) and (311)B GaAs surfaces. Doublets of folded longitudinal acoustic phonons up to the fifth order were observed in the Raman spectra of (001)- and (311)B-oriented quantum dot superlattices measured in polarized scattering geometries. The energy positions of the folded acoustic phonons are well described by the elastic continuum model. Besides the acoustic phonons, the spectra display features related to confined transverse and longitudinal optical as well as interface phonons in quantum dots and spacer layers. Their frequency positions are discussed in terms of phonon confinement, elastic stress, and atomic intermixing.
Semiconductor nanostructures such as quantum dot superlattices (QD SLs) grown by molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) in the Stranski-Krastanov growth mode offer unique opportunity of engineering their electron and phonon spectra with the most appropriate properties for nanodevices. Among optical techniques, Raman spectroscopy is considered as the most informative method for determining phonon spectra of semiconductor nanostructures including QD SLs consisting of a variety of materials (Ge/Si, (In,Ga,Al)Sb/GaAs, In(As,Sb)/InP, InAs/(Al,Ga)As) [1–8].
The phonon spectrum of QD SLs presents a fundamental interest because of new physical phenomena (such as localization of optical phonons, interference of acoustic phonons, and spectrum renormalization of interface phonons in QD SLs). It also provides valuable information on structural parameters of QDs such as QD size and shape as well as strain and atomic intermixing in QD structures. Most of the published data related to phonons in QD SLs were obtained by Raman scattering experiments and refer mainly to the study of resonance effects on acoustic and optical phonons in Ge/Si QD SLs [1, 2], to establishing the phonon spectra in novel QD SLs [3, 4], and to investigation of the topology effects as well as strain and intermixing on the optical and interface phonons in InAs/AlGaAs QD SLs [5–7]. InAs/AlAs QDs are of special interest because they have electronic bandgap transitions in the visible spectral range (600 to 700 nm) making resonant Raman scattering experiments possible .
The majority of the reported Raman experiments were carried out for QD SLs grown along the principal crystallographic axis . For these structures, according to the Raman selection rules, only longitudinal optical (LO) phonons can be observed in backscattering from the planar surfaces of the SLs while rather sophisticated scattering geometries should be used for probing the transverse optical (TO) phonons . The QD SLs grown on high-index surfaces present significant interest for optoelectronic applications because they reveal intensive narrow linewidth bandgap photoluminescence. These structures are much less investigated by Raman spectroscopy despite Raman selection rules allow simultaneous observation of both LO and TO phonons in backscattering experiments from the planar surface. Here, we report the comparison of Raman spectra by acoustic and optical phonons in InAs/AlAs QD SL fabricated on (001) and (311)B GaAs surfaces in the same growth process.
InAs/AlAs QD SLs were grown by molecular beam epitaxy in a Riber 32P system simultaneously on (001)- and (113)B-oriented GaAs substrates utilizing Stranski-Krastanov growth mode. Samples are composed of 20 periods of InAs QD layers with a nominal thickness of 2.4 monolayers separated by AlAs spacer layers with thicknesses of 6, 8, 10, and 13 nm (samples A n , B n , C n , and D n , respectively). Here, the indexes n = 001 and 113 note the sample growth direction. The substrate temperature was 460°C during the growth of InAs QDs at an arsenic pressure of 8 × 10−6Torr. After the deposition of the nominal amount of island material, the growth was interrupted for 10 s for InAs QDs. The growth was monitored by reflection high-energy electron diffraction (RHEED). According to RHEED data, the transition from a two-dimensional to a three-dimensional growth mode (beginning of island formation) for all the samples occurs after the deposition of 1.8 monolayers of the QD material. After the dot formation, the first 5 nm of AlAs spacers were grown at the same temperature as the QDs (460°C). Then the temperature was increased to 610°C, and the rest of the AlAs spacer was deposited.
Raman spectra in acoustic and optical phonons were recorded at T = 20 and 300 K using a Dilor XY800 triple spectrometer (HORIBA JobinYvon Inc., Edison, NJ, USA). Different lines of Ar+ and Kr+ lasers (457.9 to 676.4 nm) were used for excitation. The spectra were measured in backscattering geometries parallel to the growth axes in both polarized (z(xx) − z, z′(x′x′) − z′) and depolarized configurations (z(yx) − z, and z′(y′x′) − z′) with x, y, z, x′, y′, z′ parallel to the , , , [−110], [33–2], and  directions, respectively. The spectral resolution was 2 cm−1 over the entire spectral range.
Results and discussion
The structures under investigation were characterized by high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM). Cross-sectional TEM images of samples B001 and B113 are shown in Figure 1 and reveal highly ordered periodic structures with randomly distributed InAs QDs in the layers. InAs QDs have pyramid-like shape with a base length about 10 to 15 nm and a height of about 1.5 to 2 nm for both substrate orientations. HRTEM images of InAs QD structures demonstrate the presence of an InAs wetting layer. These data are in good agreement with the previously reported ones .
Figure 2a shows the Raman spectra of samples B001 and B113 measured in the acoustical spectral range in polarized (z(xx) − z and z′(x′x′) − z′) scattering geometries. In depolarized (z(yx) − z and z′(y′x′) − z′) scattering geometries, Raman spectra are featureless in the acoustic spectral range; therefore, they are not shown in Figure 2. According to the selection rules, Raman spectra of samples B001 and B113 measured in the polarized geometry should reveal doublets of longitudinal acoustic (LA) and quasi-longitudinal acoustic (QLA) folded phonons. Indeed, doublets of folded acoustic phonons are clearly observed up to the fifth order (Figure 2a). In the case of QD SLs grown in (113)B direction, acoustic phonons propagating along (113) direction have mixed LA-TA character . The sound velocities of QLA and quasi-TA modes were calculated in . Using the elastic continuum model , the dispersions of folded LA and QLA phonons were calculated (Figure 2b). The frequency positions of folded LA phonons were determined at the scattering wave vector , where λL = 514.5 nm is the laser line, and n is the refractive index of QD SL at 514.5 nm. The best agreement of calculated and experimental data was obtained for parameters taken from . The period of structure derived from the calculation coincides with the nominal thickness set during the MBE process. An excellent agreement of the experimental and calculated frequency position of the folded LA phonons was also obtained for samples A001, C001, and D001. Dispersion of folded QLA phonons was calculated for samples A113, C113, and D113 taking sound velocities calculated for QLA phonons propagating along the  direction  into account. The comparison of the frequency positions of the folded acoustic phonons observed in the experiment and calculation using the nominal thickness of QD SLs as a parameter is shown in Figure 3. One can see from Figure 3 that the model of elastic continuum which is usually used for the description of the acoustic spectrum of planar semiconductor SL is well applicable to InAs/AlAs QD SLs grown on (001)- and (113)B-oriented surfaces.
Raman spectra of samples grown on (001)- and (113)B-oriented GaAs were also studied in the spectral range of optical phonons. Figure 4 shows typical Raman spectra (for samples B001 and B113) measured in the spectral range of InAs and AlAs optical phonons. In the case of sample B001, LO phonons in InAs QDs are observed in the polarized geometry. One can see that the feature assigned to LO phonons localized in InAs/AlAs QDs shifts from 255 to 242 cm−1 with decrease in the excitation wavelength from 676.4 to 457.9 nm (from 1.83 to 2.71 eV) while the frequency position of TO optical phonons from GaAs (268 cm−1) remains unchanged. This behavior of LO phonons in InAs QDs was already explained by QD size distribution and phonon confinement in small-size dots [12, 13]. In large QDs, phonon confinement effects are negligible, and the optical phonon energies are affected by strain only. These QDs have lower energies of electronic interband transitions (below 1.8 eV). The contribution of these QDs to the Raman spectra is stronger for excitation lines in the red spectral range that are closer to the resonance with electronic transitions. Therefore, the position of the LO phonon lines of InAs QDs in the Raman spectra excited with 1.83 eV (255 cm−1) is determined predominantly by the strain distribution, while the influence of the phonon confinement can be neglected. The smaller QDs have higher energies of interband transitions. Therefore, the relative contribution of small dots to the Raman spectra increases at higher excitation energies. In smaller-size dots, the phonon confinement effect becomes more significant and causes a noticeable decrease in the phonon frequencies (up to 242 cm−1).
According to , the In/Al atomic intermixing is relatively small for this growth temperature, and the Al content in InAs QDs is below 15%. As one can see from Figure 3, the behavior of LO phonons as a function of excitation energy in InAs QDs grown on (113)B-oriented GaAs surfaces (sample B113) is similar to that observed for InAs QDs on (001) GaAs (sample B001). However, the frequency position of the LO phonon in sample B113 is regularly lower (on 2 to 5 cm−1) than that for sample B001. This indicates enhanced In/Al atomic intermixing that leads to increasing Al content in InAs QDs on (113)B GaAs (up to 20%). Raman spectra of InAs QDs grown on (113)B-oriented GaAs measured in depolarized geometry reveal additional features near 230 cm−1 attributed TO phonons localized in InAs QDs. These frequency positions of features remain unchanged due to negligible dispersion of TO phonons in InAs [11, 13].
Raman spectra of InAs QDs measured in the polarized geometry with different excitation wavelengths show interesting behavior of interface phonons (Figure 4b). In this geometry, AlAs-like interface (IF) phonons localized in the vicinity of InAs QDs are observed. Their frequency positions are located between LO and TO mode frequencies and are shifted from 380 to 395 cm−1 with decreasing the excitation wavelength (increasing excitation energy) from 676.4 to 457.9 nm (from 1.83 to 2.71 eV). This behavior can be explained by Raman scattering of InAs QD array having not only different size but also different QD aspect ratio (QD height/base size). It was already shown  that the IF phonon frequencies depend on the aspect ratio in InAs/AlAs QDs having oblate shape. In the case of spherical QDs, InAs-like IF phonons have frequencies located in the middle between the frequencies of LO and TO phonons. With decreasing the aspect ratio, the IF phonon frequencies aspire to frequencies of LO phonons in InAs QDs. One can see from Figure 3b that IF phonons in sample B113 have higher frequencies at higher excitation energies than that in sample B001, thus, indicating lower QD aspect ratio for sample B001.
Thus, with increasing excitation energy, InAs QDs having smaller height and larger base size are selectively excited in the Raman process. This is accomplished by the decreasing frequencies of InAs phonons localized in InAs/AlAs QDs and increasing frequencies of IF AlAs-like phonons localized in the vicinity of InAs QDs having lower aspect ratio.
InAs/AlAs QD SLs were grown on (001)- and (113)B-oriented GaAs with excellent optical and crystalline quality confirmed by high-resolution transmission electron microscopy and Raman scattering by folded acoustical phonons observed up to the fifth order. The Raman spectra were interpreted within the elastic continuum model, and excellent agreement between the measured and calculated data was obtained. The dependences of optical and interface modes in the QD structure on the excitation energies were explained in terms of size and shape selective Raman scattering.
AM is a senior researcher and Dr. of Science, NY is a senior researcher and Ph.D. student, AT is a doctor and senior researcher, and DD is a researcher at the Institute of Semiconductor Physics, Novosibirsk, Russia. ES is a Ph.D. student and DRTZ is a professor at the Semiconductor Physics, Chemnitz University of Technology, Chemnitz, Germany.
Mlayah A, Groenen J: Light Scattering in Solids IX. In Resonant Raman scattering by acoustic phonons in quantum dots. Edited by: Cardona M, Merlin R. Springer, Heidelberg; 2007:237–314.
Milekhin AG, Nikiforov AI, Pchelyakov OP, Schulze S, Zahn DRT: Size-selective Raman scattering in self-assembled Ge/Si quantum dot superlattices. Nanotechnology 2002, 13: 55–58. 10.1088/0957-4484/13/1/312
Tenne DA, Haisler VA, Toropov AI, Bakarov AK, Gutakovsky AK, Zahn DRT, Shebanin AP: Raman study of self-assembled GaAs and AlAs islands embedded in InAs. Phys Rev B 2000, 61: 13785–13790. 10.1103/PhysRevB.61.13785
Armelles G, Utzmeier T, Postigo PA, Briones F, Ferrer JC, Peiro P, Cornet A: Raman scattering of InSb quantum dots grown on InP substrate. J Appl Phys 1997, 81: 6339–6342. 10.1063/1.365169
Yu LM, Milekhin AG, Toropov AI, Bakarov AK, Gutakovskii AK, Tenne DA, Schulze S, Zahn DRT: Interface phonons in semiconductor nanostructures with quantum dots. JETP 2005, 101: 554–561. 10.1134/1.2103225
Milekhin AG, Toropov AI, Bakarov AK, Tenne DA, Zanelatto G, Galzerani JC, Schulze S, Zahn DRT: Interface phonons in InAs and AlAs quantum dot structures. Phys Rev B 2004, 70: 085313–1-5.
Ibanez J, Cusco R, Artus L, Henini M, Patane A, Eaves L: Raman scattering in InAs/(AlGa)As self-assembled quantum dots: evidence of Al intermixing. Appl Phys Lett 2006, 88: 141905–1-3.
Milekhin AG, Toropov AI, Bakarov AK, Schulze S, Zahn DRT: Resonant Raman scattering in nanostructures with InGaAs/AlAs quantum dots. JETP Letters 2006, 83: 505–508. 10.1134/S0021364006110087
Popovic ZV, Spitzer J, Ruf T, Cardona M, Notzel R, Ploog K: Folded acoustic phonons in GaAs/AlAs corrugated superlattices grown along the 311 direction. Phys Rev B 1993, 48: 1659–1654. 10.1103/PhysRevB.48.1659
Rytov M: Acoustical properties of a thinly laminated medium. Sov Phys Acoust 1956, 2: 68–80.
Madelung O, Schulz H New Series. In Landolt–Bornstein Tables. Springer, Berlin; 1987. vol 17a vol 17a
Tenne DA, Bakarov AK, Toropov AI, Zahn DRT: Raman study of self -assembled InAs quantum dots embedded in AlAs: influence ofgrowth temperature. Physica E 2002, 13: 199–202. 10.1016/S1386-9477(01)00519-7
Milekhin A, Toropov A, Kalagin A, Zahn DRT: Raman study of atomic intermixing in InAs/AlAs quantum dots. Chinise Journal of Physics 2011, 49: 71–76.
The work was supported by the following projects: DFG project ZA146/22-1, RFBR-DFG 11-02-91348, RFBR 11-02-90427-Ukr_at, the Program of the Presidium of the Russian Academy of Sciences (project 24.27), and IRTG (grant GRK 1215).
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
All authors read and approved the final manuscript.