Skip to main content

Use of thulium-sensitized rare earth-doped low phonon energy crystalline hosts for IR sources


Crystalline hosts with low phonon energies enable novel energy transfer processes when doped with rare earth ions. Two applications of energy transfer for rare earth ions in thulium-sensitized low phonon energy crystals that result in infrared luminescence are discussed. One application is an endothermic, phonon-assisted cross-relaxation process in thulium-doped yttrium chloride that converts lattice phonons to infrared emission, which raises the possibility of a fundamentally new method for achieving solid-state optical cooling. The other application is an optically pumped mid-IR phosphor using thulium-praseodymium-doped potassium lead chloride that converts 805-nm diode light to broadband emission from 4,000 to 5,500 nm. These two applications in chloride crystals are discussed in terms of critical radii calculated from Forster-Dexter energy transfer theory. It is found that the critical radii for electric dipole-dipole interactions in low phonon energy chloride crystals are comparable to those in conventional oxide and fluoride crystals. It is the reduction in multi-phonon relaxation rates in chloride crystals that enable these additional energy transfer processes and infrared luminescence.


Rare earth-doped crystals are widely used in many applications that require sources of visible and near-infrared radiation. However, when doped into conventional commercially available crystals such as YAG or YLF, rare earth ions do not radiate efficiently at wavelengths much longer than 3 μm. The mid-infrared range (3 to 10 μm) is not directly accessible using host crystals that have tightly bound oxygen or fluorine ions. The reasons are the relatively high energies for lattice phonons in these crystals and the fact that the rates for non-radiative multi-phonon relaxation increase exponentially as the energies of the electronic transitions are reduced and fewer phonons are required to bridge the gap. The demand for mid-infrared sources and applications in gas detection, remote sensing, IR spectroscopy, and infrared countermeasures has motivated research on alternative methods for generating mid-infrared. Quantum cascade lasers [1], thermal tungsten filaments, small bandgap III-V or II-VI optically pumped semi-conductors [2, 3], rare earth-doped chalcogenide glasses [4], oxide glasses [5], and rare earth-doped fluoride crystals [6] have all been used as sources of mid-infrared. This paper discusses an approach to generating mid-infrared that uses rare earth-doped crystals with reduced phonon energies. It focuses specifically on crystals sensitized for diode pumping with the trivalent rare earth ion thulium (Tm3+). This ion is interesting because it has a strong absorption near 800 nm that is readily accessible using low-cost laser diodes, and it has cross-relaxation mechanisms between the pumped state and the ground state that produce two infrared-emitting Tm3+ ions for every ion activated by the pump.

Figure 1 illustrates the lower energy levels of Tm3+ that become populated when the 3H4 level is pumped near 800 nm. Populations of the first three excited states can be monitored by observing infrared fluorescence near 1,400 nm from the 3H4, near 1,200 nm from the 3H5, and near 1,800 nm from the 3 F4. Two non-resonant phonon-assisted cross-relaxation mechanisms involving the pumped 3H4 state and the ground 3H6 state are also illustrated in Figure 1.

Figure 1
figure 1

Tm3+energy levels. Transitions for pumping, cross-relaxation, and fluorescence within the lower energy levels of Tm3+.

The 'two for one’ cross-relaxation process labelled C1 that feeds the 3F4 state is well known for Tm3+ and has been used in YAG [7] and YLF [8] host crystals to sensitize 2-μm sources for diode pumping. Diode-pumped lasers near 2 μm using singly doped Tm3+:YAG and co-doped Tm3+-Ho3+:YAG are in wide use. However, incorporating Tm3+ into a host crystal with reduced multi-phonon relaxation rates enables emission from the 3H5 state that is fed by the cross-relaxation process labelled C2. In contrast, for conventional Tm3+, 2-μm laser material multi-phonon quenching of the 3H5 leads to strong heat generation and distortions. Reduced multi-phonon quenching in low phonon energy materials also results in additional energy transfer processes when Tm3+ is co-doped with other species of rare earth ions.

This paper discusses two results that arise from Tm3+ cross-relaxation in low phonon energy host crystals: (1) In singly doped crystals with Tm3+, the C2 process is a phonon-assisted cross-relaxation channel that is endothermic and converts lattice phonons into infrared emission. This raises the possibility of a fundamentally new way of achieving solid-state optical cooling. (2) In crystals co-doped with Tm3+ and Pr3+, cross-relaxation results in efficient energy transfer to the lower energy levels of the Pr3+ ions that fluoresce in the mid-infrared. The result is an optically pumped phosphor that converts 800-nm diode light into mid-IR emission between 4 and 5.5 μm.

While these two results have different motivations, the underlying physical mechanisms are the same. Both results involve sensitized luminescence using diode-pumped Tm3+ ions in host crystals with reduced multi-phonon relaxation rates. The purpose of this paper is to show how crystals with low phonon energies enable these novel energy transfer processes.


Sensitized luminescence

In an insulator, excited-state ions can transfer energy non-radiatively to ions of the same species or of a different species through a distance-dependent electric dipole-dipole interaction [9]. The energy transfer rate between sensitizers and acceptors Wsa for two ions separated by a distance R can be written in the form

W sa = W s R cr / R 6 ,

where Ws is the rate at which the sensitizer ions radiate and Rcr, the critical interaction distance, is the distance between the sensitizers and acceptors for which the energy transfer rate Wsa is equal to Ws. In other words, for two ions separated by the critical distance Rcr, the probability of a sensitizer ion radiating is equal to the probability of its energy transfer to an acceptor ion. Therefore, crystals in which sensitizers and acceptors are on average closer than the critical radius, Wsa > Ws, which results in non-radiative energy transfer being favoured over radiation.

The critical interaction distance Rcr is given by Dexter's formula [10]:

R cr 6 = 3 / 4 π ħ c / π n 4 Q a 1 E 4 f s ems E f a abs E dE .

In this expression, n is the index of refraction, Qa is the integrated absorption cross section of the acceptor ion ∫σ(E)dE, and fsems and faabs are the normalized (∫f(E)dE = 1) emission and absorption spectra with E the photon energy equal to ħc/λ. This means that the greater the overlap between the sensitizer ion's emission spectrum and the acceptor ion's absorption spectrum, the greater the critical distance. A large critical distance allows a relatively dilute distribution of sensitizer and acceptor ions within the lattice to interact and exchange energy at rates faster than their radiative rates.

The practical consequence of Dexter’s formula is that the energy transfer is much more likely in a system in which there is significant overlap between the excited-state transitions of the sensitizing ions and the ground-state absorptions of the acceptor ions. Even in a singly doped system, in which the acceptors and sensitizers are of the same species, the pump will only interact with a small fraction of the total ions available. This means that the average distance between an excited-state ion and a ground-state ion is essentially equal to the average distance Rav between the ions in the crystal, assuming a random distribution is given by

R av = 1 / N 1 / 3 ,

where N is the density of ions in the lattice. If Rav is less than or equal to Rcr for an interaction involving a ground-state absorption by an acceptor ion, energy transfer can occur. Interactions involving excited-state acceptor ions can usually be neglected because at pump powers of a few Watts, the average separation between these excited-state ions is usually much larger than Rcr.

It is for these reasons that the cross-relaxation pathways illustrated in Figure 1 for a singly doped Tm3+ system are the only ones that are significant. Both C1 and C2 involve interactions between sensitizer ions excited by the pump and acceptor ions in the ground state. However, there will be no energy transfer or radiation if multi-phonon relaxation is too rapid, which is the case in many crystals that have relatively high lattice phonon energies.

Low phonon energy crystals

Reducing the multi-phonon relaxation rates in crystalline hosts is accomplished by incorporating heavier halides, such as chlorine or bromine, which has the effect of reducing the maximum phonon energies in the crystal. As a result, electronic states with small energy gaps, corresponding to mid-IR transitions, that are normally quenched in conventional oxide and fluoride hosts will radiate in a chloride host. This effect has been used to build mid-IR rare earth-based solid-state lasers. For example, Pr3+:LaCl3 lasers have produced 5.2-μm [11] and 7.2-μm [12] emission. The LaCl3 host is extremely hygroscopic and offers poor mechanical stability. However, lead salts offer better mechanical stability and moisture resistance and, when created with chlorine or bromine as the halide, also have low phonon energies. For example, a room temperature 4.6-μm erbium laser using KPb2Cl5 as the crystalline host and no environmental precautions to limit exposure to moisture has been demonstrated [13]. The KPb2Cl5 host has also been used to demonstrate a Dy3+ 2.43-μm laser [1416]. The success of infrared lasers using KPb2Cl5 as a host material has motivated further spectroscopic studies of Er3+:KPb2Cl5[17, 18] in addition to other rare earth ions such as Pr3+[19, 20] and Nd3+[2124]. Activation of mid-infrared transitions of rare earth ions by reducing the phonon energies has been pushed further using KPb2Br5 as a host crystal [25, 26]. This material has even lower phonon energies than KPb2Cl5 because of the substitution of Cl with the heavier Br.

Crystal growth

Crystals with heavy halides such as chlorine have low melting points. For LaCl3, the melting point is 858°C; for KPb2Cl5, the melting point is 434°C; and for YCl3, a host crystal used in a study of cross-relaxation of singly doped thulium crystals, the melting point is 721°C. The low melting point of all these crystals allows them to be grown in fused silica ampoules in a furnace constructed of fused silica with nickel-chromium resistance wire for heating. A self-seeded vertical Bridgman can be used to grow chloride crystals from melts of anhydrous-powered starting materials under a low-pressure (approximately 100 Torr) Cl2 atmosphere, which is necessary to prevent the chloride compounds from disassociating. Methods for producing crystalline KPb2Cl5 and a documentation of its basic properties were reported in 1995 by Nitsch et al. [27]. Interest in incorporating rare earth ions into KPb2Cl5 has lead to further refinements of material preparation and crystal growth techniques [2831].

Data discussed in this paper are from rare earth ions doped into two different low phonon energy crystalline hosts. YCl3 was chosen as a host to study Tm3+ cross-relaxation because TmCl3 and YCl3 share the same monoclinic crystal structure. As a result, Tm3+ ions incorporate at any concentration and occupy a single, highly symmetric site, which enables long excited-state lifetimes and a Stark structure that is partially resolvable even at room temperature. The KPb2Cl5 host was chosen to study singly doped crystals with Tm3+ or Pr3+ and a co-doped crystal with Tm3+ and Pr3+ because the crystal is stable under normal atmospheric conditions. In contrast, YCl3 crystals will dissolve in a matter of minutes when exposed to normal atmospheric humidity. For the crystal growth of KPb2Cl5, stoichiometric mixtures were prepared from anhydrous, high-purity KCl and PbCl2 powders mixed with small amounts of anhydrous, high-purity powders of PrCl3 or TmCl3, or both. To grow YCl3, anhydrous, high-purity powdered YCl3 and TmCl3 were mixed. In all cases, the powdered mixtures were melted and allowed to sit molten under approximately 100 Torr of Cl2 for several hours to reduce oxide impurities. The melt, contained in a 10-mm inner diameter fused silica ampoule with a tapered tip, was cooled over a period of 5 days while remaining under the Cl2 atmosphere. The finished samples were polycrystalline with large grains and were un-oriented.


Unpolarized fluorescence spectra between 1,600 and 5,500 nm were collected with a 0.20-m monochrometer. Fluorescence was induced with laser diodes gated to produce 50-ms pulses. The diode pump powers were between 0.25 and 2.0 W. A pulse repetition rate of 10 Hz was used to synchronize a lock-in amplifier that received its input from a photo-detector mounted at the exit slits of the monochrometer. Spectra were collected using three passes - one for the 1,100- to 1,700-nm range, one for the 1,550- to 3,000-nm range, and one for the 3,000- to 5,500-nm range. An InGaAs photo-detector was used for the 1,100- to 1,700-nm range. For the other two spectral ranges that covered 1,550 to 5,500 nm, a liquid nitrogen-cooled InSb was used for photo-detection. For the 3,000- to 5,500-nm range, a long pass filter that blocked wavelengths less than 2,500 nm was in place to eliminate the short wavelength features from appearing in higher order. Also, for spectral acquisition at wavelengths greater than 2,500 nm, the monochrometer was purged with dry nitrogen gas in order to reduce a strong absorption feature at 4,300 nm resulting from atmospheric CO2. Emission was measured with the Tm3+:YCl3 remaining sealed in the fused silica ampoules to prevent degradation from exposure to atmospheric moisture. Fused silica is transparent for the range of emission wavelengths studied. For Tm3+:KPb2Cl5, no environmental precautions were used. In each case, the wavelength dependence of the complete light collection and detection system was calibrated using a blackbody source. Spectra were corrected using the system response function obtained from the blackbody calibration. To observe fluorescent decays, the laser diodes were operated in pulsed mode to pump the 3H4 level of Tm3+, and a digitizing oscilloscope recorded the transient response from the photo-detectors. During fluorescent decay measurements, the monochrometer acted as a filter to isolate emission at wavelengths associated with specific energy levels.

Results and discussion

Spectroscopy of singly doped Tm3+ crystals

Figure 2 shows a fluorescence spectrum at 300 K between 1,100 and 2,000 nm of Tm3+:KPb2Cl5 that results from pumping with a 1.5-W, 805-nm laser diode [32]. The spectrum has three features that are typical of Tm3+ spectra in low phonon energy hosts. The emissions originate from the first three excited states and arise from the following transitions: 3H4 → 3 F4 (centred at 1,450 nm), 3H5 → 3H6, (centred at 1,250 nm), and 3 F4 → 3H6 (centred at 1,850 nm). The emissions at 1,450 and 1,250 nm are a characteristic of Tm3+ in a low phonon energy host crystal. For Tm3+ in YAG or YLF, these emissions are quenched by multi-phonon relaxation, and the only IR emission observed is the broadband centred at 1,850 nm arising from the 3F4 level.

Figure 2
figure 2

Fluorescence from Tm3+:KPb 2 Cl 5 . Fluorescence spectrum at 300 K between 1,100 and 2,000 nm of Tm3+:KPb2Cl5 that results from pumping with an 805-nm laser diode.

For the same 1,100- to 2,000-nm spectral range, a fluorescence spectrum from Tm3+:YCl3 at 300 K arising from pumping with a 0.35-W, 811-nm laser diode is shown in Figure 3[33]. Because YCl3 is also a low phonon energy host, the same three spectral features appear. In YCl3, the Tm3+ ions are at sites with higher symmetry than in KPb2Cl5. As a result, more of the Stark multiplet structure is resolvable in the emission lines in Figure 3 than in Figure 2. Also shown in Figure 3 is an overlap of a fluorescence spectrum at 400 K from the same crystal under the same pump conditions. As the temperature is increased, there is a small reduction in emission at 1,850 nm from the 3F4 level, but a doubling in 1,250-nm emission from the 3H5 level. The increase in emission from the 3H5 as the temperature is raised is an interesting and counterintuitive result. The effect of a temperature increase on this emission is illustrated more graphically in Figure 4[33]. It shows the normalized fluorescence intensity at three specific wavelengths as a function of temperature between 300 and 500 K. The wavelengths chosen reflect the populations of the first three excited states for Tm3+. The data show that the population of 3H5 state increases relative to the other states as the temperature rises.

Figure 3
figure 3

Fluorescence from Tm3+:YCl 3 . Comparison of fluorescence spectrum at 300 and 400 K between 1,100 and 2,000 nm of Tm3+:YCl3 that results from pumping with an 811-nm laser diode.

Figure 4
figure 4

Temperature dependence of infrared fluorescence from Tm3+:YCl 3 . Normalized fluorescence intensity versus temperature between 300 and 500 K for Tm3+:YCl3. The fluorescence intensity of the 3 F4 level at 300 K is normalized to 1. The sample has a Tm3+ concentration of 0.7 × 1020 ions/cm3.

Cross-relaxation in singly doped Tm3+ crystals

The anomalous behaviour of the 1,200-nm fluorescence from the 3H5 state can be explained as arising from phonon-assisted cross-relaxation [34]. The processes illustrated in Figure 1 labelled C1 and C2 are both non-resonant and require phonon assistance to complete. C1 is the process already known in Tm3+-doped YAG and YLF that involves an interaction between a 3H4 ion activated by the pump and a 3H6 ion in the ground state to produce two 3F4 ions. The C1 process results in an excess of energy that must be converted to phonons. The energy gap for this cross-relaxation is 698 cm-1, which corresponds to the creation of about three phonons in the YCl3 lattice that has a maximum phonon energy of 260 cm-1.

For the process C2 that feeds both the 3F4 and 3H5 levels, the energy gap is a deficit of -641 cm-1. This process must absorb three phonons from the lattice to complete. However, phonon absorption processes have much stronger temperature dependence than phonon-emitting processes. At low temperatures, any relaxation process that emits phonons, such as cross-relaxation or multi-phonon relaxation, can proceed through spontaneous emission. At high temperatures, stimulated emission will occur as phonon occupation increases, which increases the relaxation rate. Therefore, the temperature dependence of the rate for a phonon emission process We is given by

W e T = W e T = 0 1 + n N e ,

where Ne is the number of phonons (ΔE/ħω) emitted to fill the energy gap ΔE that have energy ħω and n is the phonon occupation number [35].

However, phonon absorption processes must have occupied phonon states in order to proceed. The temperature dependence of the rate Wa for a phonon absorption process is given by

W a T = W a T = 0 n N a ,

where Na is the number of phonons absorbed. The temperature dependencies of Equations 4 and 5 arise because the phonon occupation number n follows a Bose-Einstein distribution given by

n = exp ħ ω / kT - 1 - 1 ,

where ħω is the maximum phonon energy (260 cm-1 for YCl3) [36]. Therefore, the maximum phonon energy is the most important parameter in controlling the temperature and energy gap dependence of all phonon-assisted relaxation processes, including cross-relaxation and multi-phonon relaxation.

Excited state populations and lifetimes for Tm3+, which ensue after pumping the 3H4 state at 800 nm, depend on the competition between spontaneous emissions of radiation, cross-relaxation, multi-phonon relaxation, and up-conversion. At temperatures greater than 500 K, multi-phonon relaxation is the dominant process, which results in quenching of the fluorescence from all levels. At room temperature, near 300 K, multi-phonon relaxation is reduced and cross-relaxation can proceed. However, at 300 K, the occupation of phonon states is still substantial, which allows the endothermic process C2 to compete with the exothermic process C1.

A macroscopic model of the populations of the four lowest levels of Tm3+ was constructed using coupled time-dependent rate equations [33]. Rate constants for spontaneous emission, cross-relaxation, and up-conversion were determined by fitting the model to fluorescence lifetime data at 300 K, a temperature at which multi-phonon relaxation can be neglected. Rate constants for multi-phonon relaxation were determined by fitting the model to lifetime data above 400 K, temperatures at which multi-phonon relaxation is significant [33].

After the determination of the rate constants, the relative populations of the three lower levels of Tm3+ as a function of temperature were determined using the rate model and the temperature dependencies of Equations 4 and 5 for cross-relaxation processes C1 and C2, respectively. Figure 5 shows an overlay of the temperature-dependent rate modelling with the temperature-dependent intensity data from Figure 4[33]. The model predicts the observed increase in emission from the 3H5 level as the temperature is raised. The model shows that the branching ratio for the 3H4 to 3H5 transition is less than 1%, and as a result, the population of the 3H5 arises almost entirely from the C2 cross-relaxation process [33]. Between 300 and 400 K the model also predicts the observation that the emission from the 3F4 and 3H4 levels is unchanged as the temperature rises because multi-phonon relaxation has not increased to a level that it competes with radiation and cross-relaxation.

Figure 5
figure 5

Temperature dependence of infrared fluorescence from Tm3+:YCl 3 . Overlay of temperature-dependent rate model for the relative population of the three lower levels for Tm3+:YCl3 with the temperature-dependent intensity data from Figure 4. The solid lines are the model, and the markers are the data. The population of the 3F4 level at 300 K is normalized to 1. The sample has a Tm3+ concentration of 0.7 × 1020 ions/cm3.

This result is significant because it implies that the process C2 converts lattice phonons into 1,200-nm radiation, which is a cooling effect. In contrast to previous demonstrations of solid-state optical cooling from anti-Stokes emission [3743], cooling from cross-relaxation will not lose efficiency at low temperatures because the -641 cm-1 energy gap for the process is temperature independent. At low-temperatures, cooling from anti-Stokes emission loses efficiency because of thermal depopulation of the upper Stark levels.

Also of interest for Tm3+:YCl3 is that additional study of the concentration dependence of the cross-relaxation rates determined that the critical radius Rcr at room temperature for the energy transfer is about 15 Å. That distance is comparable to Rcr for Tm3+ cross-relaxation in conventional oxide and fluoride hosts [7, 8]. This implies that the endothermic cross-relaxation process C2 is enabled by the reduction in multi-phonon quenching and not because interaction rates between neighbouring Tm3+ ions are changed significantly by a chloride host. These spectroscopic results suggest that a heat generation study should be conducted for the near-IR-pumped Tm3+ in a low phonon energy host.

Energy transfer in Tm3+-Pr3+ co-doped crystals

In addition to its own IR-emitting properties, the Tm3+ ion has been used to sensitize other rare earth ions for diode pumping. Most notable is the Ho3+ ion, which has a useful IR laser transition at 2.1 μm from its first excited state to its ground state but lacks a level that absorbs at 800 nm. Energy transfer from Tm3+ to Ho3+ has been used to create diode-pumped 2.1-μm lasers using YLF [7] and YAG [8] host crystals. Tm3+ sensitization has also been used in low phonon energy crystals. For example, Nd3+ has absorption near 800 nm. However, for co-doped Tm3+-Nd3+:KPb2Cl5, the presence of the Tm3+ is known to increase the absorption of the pump and enhance the IR emission from the Nd3+ ions [44]. An additional example is co-doped Tm3+-Pr3+:CsCdBr3, in which pumping the 3H4 level of Tm3+ results in energy transfer and up-conversion to emitting states in the visible [45].

Energy transfer from the 3H4 state of Tm3+ to the IR-emitting states of Pr3+ in a low phonon energy host crystal is also an interesting phenomenon. Like Ho3+, the Pr3+ ion also lacks absorption at 800 nm. However, transitions out of the first three excited states of Tm3+ that populate through cross-relaxation are resonant with absorption transitions out of the Pr3+ ground state to excited states of Pr3+ that radiate in the mid-IR. Figure 6 compares the lower energy levels of Tm3+ to the lower levels of Pr3+ and illustrates three possible pathways for resonant energy transfer that involve excited-state Tm3+-sensitizing ions interacting with ground-state Pr3+ acceptor ions.

Figure 6
figure 6

Energy transfer processes for co-doped Tm3+-Pr3+:KPb 2 Cl 5 . The first three excited states of Tm3+-sensitizing ions are all resonant with ground-state transitions of Pr3+ acceptor ions.

In contrast to Pr3+:YAG or Pr3+:YLF, Pr3+ ions in a chloride host crystal will radiate at mid-IR wavelengths because the lower energy levels are no longer quenched by multi-phonon relaxation. This effect was exploited to make 5.2- and 7.2-μm lasers using Pr3+:LCl3[11, 12]. For Pr3+ doped into KPb2Cl5, the lower energy levels will also radiate in the mid-IR. The mid-IR fluorescence can be observed in singly doped Pr3+:KPb2Cl5 when the 3F4 level is pumped directly with a 1.5-W, 1,483-nm laser diode. For Pr3+:KPb2Cl5 under this pump, the room temperature fluorescence that results from 1,600 to 2,800 nm is shown in Figure 7 and from 3,000 to 5,500 nm is shown in Figure 8[32]. Each feature in the spectra is labelled with the associated Pr3+ energy level transition.

Figure 7
figure 7

Fluorescence from 1,600 to 2,800 nm resulting from 1,483-nm pumping of Pr3+:KPb 2 Cl 5 . The sample has a Pr3+ concentration of 1.5 × 1020 ions/cm3.

Figure 8
figure 8

Fluorescence from 3,000 to 5,500 nm resulting from 1,483-nm pumping of Pr3+:KPb 2 Cl 5 . The sample has a Pr3+ concentration of 1.5 × 1020 ions/cm3.

The Tm3+ sensitization of Pr3+:KPb2Cl5 allows for more convenient 800-nm diode pumping. For a co-doped Tm3+-Pr3+:KPb2Cl5 crystal using a 1.5-W, 805-nm laser diode as a pump source, the same broadband mid-IR emission between 4,000 and 5,500 nm from the Pr3+ ions is observed. The room temperature fluorescence that results from 805-nm pumping of the co-doped crystal overlapped with the fluorescence that results from the 1,483-nm pumping of the same co-doped crystal from 1,600 to 2,800 nm is shown in Figure 9 and from 3,000 to 5,500 nm is shown in Figure 10[32]. The overlap of the two spectra in Figure 10 show that the broadband emission between 4,000 and 5,500 nm from the Pr3+ ions is essentially the same for the two crystals, even though the pump sources are at different wavelengths. As expected, Figure 9 shows less emission at 2,400 nm out of the 3F4 state of Pr3+ in the co-doped crystal compared to 1,483-nm pumping of the singly doped crystal, because the 3F4 state of Pr3+ is no longer being pumped directly.

Figure 9
figure 9

Fluorescence from 1,600 to 2,800 nm from Tm3+-Pr3+:KPb 2 Cl 5 . Fluorescence resulting from 1,483-nm pumping of Tm3+-Pr3+:KPb2Cl5 compared to fluorescence resulting from 805-nm pumping. The sample has a Pr3+ concentration of 1.5 × 1020 ions/cm3 and a Tm3+ concentration of 3.0 × 1020 ions/cm3.

Figure 10
figure 10

Fluorescence from 3,000 to 5,500 nm from Tm3+-Pr3+:KPb 2 Cl 5 . Fluorescence resulting from 1,483-nm pumping of Tm3+-Pr3+:KPb2Cl5 compared to fluorescence resulting from 805-nm pumping. The sample has a Pr3+ concentration of 1.5 × 1020 ions/cm3 and a Tm3+ concentration of 3.0 × 1020 ions/cm3.

Figure 11 shows lifetime data for the 1,450-nm emission from the 3H4 level of Tm3+ resulting from 805-nm pumping for the singly doped and co-doped samples [32]. Comparison of the 1,450-nm emission from Tm3+:KPb2Cl5 to 1,450-nm emission from Tm3+-Pr3+:KPb2Cl5 shows the rapid quenching of emission from the Tm3+ because of energy transfer to the Pr3+. Analyses of the Tm3+ lifetime data for the co-doped crystal show that the energy transfer processes from the Tm3+ sensitizers to the Pr3+ acceptors have high quantum efficiencies. For the energy transfer process labelled T1 in Figure 6, the quantum efficiency η1 is estimated at 94%, and for the process labelled T2 in Figure 6, the estimated quantum efficiency η2 is 83% [32]. The process labelled T3 can be neglected because the 3H5 level of Tm3+ never obtains significant population. Further analysis of the decay transients provides estimates of 11 and 12 Å, respectively, for the critical radii of energy transfer from the 3H4 and 3F4 states of Tm3+. The critical radii for this co-doped system are comparable to the critical radii of electric dipole-dipole interactions involving rare earth ions in other host crystals, such as the cross relaxation of Tm3+ in YCl3 discussed in the earlier part of this paper.

Figure 11
figure 11

Transient decays from the 3H 4 level of Tm3+. Room temperature normalized fluorescence decays from the 3H4 level of Tm3+ arising from 805-nm diode pumping. Comparison is made of 1,450-nm emission from Tm3+:KPb2Cl5 to 1,450-nm emission from Tm3+-Pr3+:KPb2Cl5.

The usefulness of this system is that it functions as an optically pumped mid-IR phosphor that converts light from 805-nm diodes to broadband mid-IR from 4 to 5.5 μm. The 805-nm diode sources are low in cost compared to 1.5- or 2-μm sources that would activate the Pr3+ mid-IR emission directly. This material could be used as a low-cost method for detecting gases with absorptions in the 4- to 5.5-μm range. For example, the small dip at 4,300 nm in the fluorescence spectra shown in Figure 10 is an artefact of a less than perfect purge of the optical path with dry nitrogen. Without the purge, the 4,300-nm fluorescence emitted by the diode-pumped crystal is completely absorbed by atmospheric CO2. In effect, the experimental setup functioned as a very sensitive atmospheric CO2 detector.


This paper discussed two applications of Tm3+ sensitization of rare earth-doped low phonon energy host crystals, in which the resulting reduction in multi-phonon relaxation rates enables useful energy transfer processes to occur that are quenched in conventional oxide and fluoride crystals. One application is the enabling of an endothermic cross-relaxation process for Tm3+ that converts lattice phonons to infrared emission near 1,200 nm. The existence of this process suggests that endothermic phonon-assisted energy transfer could be a fundamentally new way of achieving optical cooling in a solid. The other application is a novel optically pumped mid-IR phosphor that converts 805-nm light from readily available low-cost diodes into broadband emission from 4 to 5.5 μm. The phosphor is efficient, low-cost, and scalable.

Application of theories for electric dipole-dipole sensitizer-acceptor interactions shows that the critical radii for energy transfer processes between rare earth ions do not change significantly between various host crystals. The novel energy transfer processes observed in low phonon energy host crystals occur because the multi-phonon relaxation rates for the levels involved are reduced and no longer compete with the radiative and non-radiative energy transfer rates. In imagining new kinds of applications for low phonon energy crystals, circumstances in which the multi-phonon relaxation rates can be reduced to much less than the known rates for electric dipole interactions should be investigated.


  1. Kosterev A, Wysocki G, Bakhirkin Y, So S, Lewicki R, Fraser M, Tittel F, Curl RF: Application of quantum cascade lasers to trace gas analysis. App Phys B 2008, 90: 165–176. 10.1007/s00340-007-2846-9

    Article  Google Scholar 

  2. Aidaraliev M, Zotova NV, Karandashev SA, Matveev BA, Remennyi MA, Stus NM, Talalakin GN: Optically pumped “immersion-lens” infrared light emitting diodes based on narrow-gap III–V semiconductors. Semiconductors 2002, 36: 828–831. 10.1134/1.1493757

    Article  Google Scholar 

  3. Fedorov VV, Galliana A, Moskalev I, Mirov SB: En route to electrically pumped broadly tunable middle infrared lasers based on transition metal doped II–VI semiconductors. J Lumin 2007, 125: 184–195. 10.1016/j.jlumin.2006.08.010

    Article  Google Scholar 

  4. Shaw LB, Cole B, Schaafsma DT, Harbison BB, Sanghera JS, Aggarwal ID: Rare-earth-doped selenide glass optical sources. CLEO 98 Technical Digest: Summaries of Papers Presented at the Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics: May 3–8 1998; San Francisco 1998, 420–421.

    Google Scholar 

  5. Richards BDO, Teddy-Fernandez T, Jose G, Binks D, Jha A: Mid-IR (3–4 μm) fluorescence and ASE studies in Dy3+ doped tellurite and germinate glasses and a fs laser inscribed waveguide. Laser Phys Lett 2013, 10: 085802. 10.1088/1612-2011/10/8/085802

    Article  Google Scholar 

  6. Wang P, Xia H, Peng J, Hu H, Tang L, Dong Y, Fu L, Jiang H, Chen B: Growth and spectral properties of Er3+/Tm3+ co-doped LiYF4 single crystal. Cryst Res Technol 2013, 48: 446–453. 10.1002/crat.201300104

    Article  Google Scholar 

  7. Payne SA, Smith LK, Kway WL, Tassano JB, Krupke WF: The mechanism of Tm → Ho energy transfer in LiYF4. J Phys Condens Matter 1992, 4: 8525–8542. 10.1088/0953-8984/4/44/014

    Article  Google Scholar 

  8. French VA, Petrin RR, Powell RC, Kokta M: Energy-transfer processes in Y3Al5O12:Tm,Ho. Phys Rev B 1992, 46: 8018–8026. 10.1103/PhysRevB.46.8018

    Article  Google Scholar 

  9. Forster T: Experimentelle und theoretische Untersuchung des zwischenmolecularen Uebergangs von Electronenanregungsenergie. Z Naturforsch 1949, 49: 321–327.

    Google Scholar 

  10. Dexter DL: A theory of sensitized luminescence in solids. J Chem Phys 1953, 21: 836–851. 10.1063/1.1699044

    Article  Google Scholar 

  11. Bowman SR, Feldman BJ, Ganem J, Kueny AW: Infrared laser characteristics of praseodymium-doped lanthanum trichloride. IEEE J Quantum Electron 1994, 30: 2925–2928. 10.1109/3.362716

    Article  Google Scholar 

  12. Bowman SR, Shaw LB, Feldman BJ, Ganem J: A 7-μm praseodymium-based solid-state laser. IEEE J Quantum Electron 1996, 32: 646–649. 10.1109/3.488838

    Article  Google Scholar 

  13. Bowman SR, Searles SK, Jenkins NW, Qadri SB, Skelton EF, Ganem J: Diode pumped room temperature 4.6 μm erbium laser. In Advanced Solid State Lasers, Vol. 50 of OSA TOPS Proceeding Series. Edited by: Marshall C. Washington DC: Optical Society of America; 2001:154–156.

    Google Scholar 

  14. Nostrand MC, Page RH, Payne SA, Krupke WF, Schunemann PG, Isaenko LI: Room temperature CaGa2S4: Dy3+ laser action at 2.43 μm and 4.31 μm and KPb2Cl5 laser action at 2.43 μm. In Advanced Solid State Lasers, Vol. 26 of OSA TOPS Proceeding Series. Edited by: Fejer MM, Injeyan H, Keller U. Washington, DC: Optical Society of America; 1999:441–449.

    Google Scholar 

  15. Nostrand MC, Payne SA, Schunemann PG, Isaenko LI: Laser demonstration of rare-earth ions in low-phonon chloride and sulfide crystals. In Advanced Solid State Lasers Vol. 34 of OSA TOPS Proceeding Series. Edited by: Injeyan H, Keller U, Marshall C. Washington, DC: Optical Society of America; 2000:459–463.

    Google Scholar 

  16. Isaenko L, Yelisseyev A, Tkachuk A, Ivanova S, Vatnik S, Merkulov A, Payne S, Page R, Nostrand M: New laser crystal based on KPb2Cl5 for IR region. Mat Sci EnginB 2001, 81: 188–190. 10.1016/S0921-5107(00)00735-2

    Article  Google Scholar 

  17. Jenkins NW, Bowman SR, O’Conner S, Searles SK, Ganem J: Spectroscopic characterization of Er-doped KPb2Cl5 laser crystals. Opt Mater 2003, 22: 311–320. 10.1016/S0925-3467(02)00290-2

    Article  Google Scholar 

  18. Tkachuk AM, Ivanova SE, Joubert M–F, Guyot Y, Isaenko LI, Gapontsev VP: Upconversion processes in Er3+:KPb2Cl5 laser crystals. J Lumin 2007, 125: 271–278. 10.1016/j.jlumin.2006.08.040

    Article  Google Scholar 

  19. Amedzake P, Brown E, Hommerich U, Trivedi SB, Zavada JM: Crystal growth and spectroscopic characterization of Pr-doped KPb2Cl5 for mid-infrared laser applications. J Cryst Growth 2008, 310: 2015–2019. 10.1016/j.jcrysgro.2007.10.042

    Article  Google Scholar 

  20. Ferrier A, Velazquez M, Doualan J-L, Moncorge R: Mid-infrared luminescence properties and laser potentials of Pr3+ doped KPb2Cl5 and CsCdBr3. J Appl Phys 2008, 104: 123513. 10.1063/1.3033492

    Article  Google Scholar 

  21. Jenkins NW, Bowman SR, Shaw LB, Lindle JR: Spectroscopic analysis laser modeling of neodymium-doped potassium lead chloride. J Lumin 2002, 97: 127–134. 10.1016/S0022-2313(01)00411-2

    Article  Google Scholar 

  22. Mendioroz A, Balda R, Voda M, Al-Saleh M, Fernadez J: Infrared to visible and ultraviolet upconversion processes in Nd3+-doped potassium lead chloride crystal. Opt Mater 2004, 95: 351–357.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  23. Nostrand MC, Page RH, Payne SA, Isaenko LI, Yelisseyev AP: Optical properties of Dy3+ and Nd3+-doped KPb2Cl5. JOSA B-Opt Phys 2001, 18: 264–276. 10.1364/JOSAB.18.000264

    Article  Google Scholar 

  24. Brown E, Hömmerich U, Bluiett AG, Trivedi SB, Zavada JM: Synthesis and spectroscopic properties of neodymium doped lead chloride. J Appl Phys 2007, 101(113103):1–7.

    Google Scholar 

  25. Hömmerich U, Nyein EE, Trivedi SB: Crystal growth, upconversion, and infrared emission properties of Er3+-doped KPb2Br5. J Lumin 2005, 113: 100–108. 10.1016/j.jlumin.2004.09.111

    Article  Google Scholar 

  26. Hömmerich U, Brown E, Amedzake P, Trivedi SM, Zavada JM: Mid-infrared (4.6 μm) emission properties of Pr3+ doped KPb2Br5. J Appl Phys 2006, 100: 113507. 10.1063/1.2399888

    Article  Google Scholar 

  27. Nitsch K, Dusek M, Nikl M, Polak K, Rodova M: Ternary alkali lead chlorides: crystal growth, crystal structure, absorption and emission properties. Progr Cryst Growth Char 1995, 30: 1–22. 10.1016/0960-8974(95)00012-V

    Article  Google Scholar 

  28. Voda M, Al-Saleh M, Lobera G, Balda R, Fernadez J: Crystal growth of rare-earth-doped ternary potassium lead chloride single crystals by the Bridgman method. Opt Mater 2004, 25: 359–363. 10.1016/j.optmat.2003.08.002

    Article  Google Scholar 

  29. Roy UN, Cui Y, Guo M, Groza M, Burger A, Wagner GJ, Carrig TJ, Payne SA: Growth and characterization of Er-doped KPb2Cl5 as laser host crystal. J Cryst Growth 2003, 258: 331–336. 10.1016/S0022-0248(03)01541-0

    Article  Google Scholar 

  30. Condon NJ, O’Connor S, Bowman SR: Growth and characterization of single-crystal Er3+:KPb2Cl5 as a mid-infrared laser material. J Cryst Growth 2006, 291: 472–478. 10.1016/j.jcrysgro.2006.03.037

    Article  Google Scholar 

  31. Kichkova NV, Zagorodnev VN, Butvina LN, Okhrimchuk AG, Shestakov AV: Preparation and optical properties of rare-earth-activated alkali metal lead chlorides. Inorg Mater 2006, 42: 81–88. 10.1134/S002016850601016X

    Article  Google Scholar 

  32. Howse D, Logie M, Bluiett AG, O'Connor S, Condon NJ, Ganem J, Bowman SR: Optically-pumped mid-IR phosphor using Tm3+-sensitized Pr3+-doped KPb2Cl5. J Opt Soc Am B 2010, 27: 2384–2392. 10.1364/JOSAB.27.002384

    Article  Google Scholar 

  33. Ganem J, Crawford J, Schmidt P, Jenkins NW, Bowman SR: Thulium cross-relaxation in a low phonon energy crystalline host. Phys Rev B 2002, 66(245101):1–14.

    Google Scholar 

  34. Miyakawa T, Dexter DL: Phonon sidebands, multiphonon relaxation of excited states, and phonon-assisted energy transfer between ions in solids. Phys Rev B 1970, 1: 2961–2969. 10.1103/PhysRevB.1.2961

    Article  Google Scholar 

  35. Riseberg LA, Moos HW: Multiphonon orbit-lattice relaxation of excited states of rare-earth ions in crystals. Phys Rev 1968, 174: 429–438. 10.1103/PhysRev.174.429

    Article  Google Scholar 

  36. Auzel F: Multiphonon-assisted anti-Stokes and Stokes fluorescence of triply ionized rare-earth ions. Phys Rev B 1976, 13: 2809–2817. 10.1103/PhysRevB.13.2809

    Article  Google Scholar 

  37. Epstein RI, Buchwald MI, Edwards BC, Gosnell TR, Mungan CE: Observation of laser-induced cooling of a solid. Nature 1995, 377: 500. 10.1038/377500a0

    Article  Google Scholar 

  38. Seletskiy DV, Melgaard SD, Bigotta S, Di Lieto A, Tonelli M, Sheik-Bahae M: Laser cooling of solids to cryogenic temperatures. Nat Photonics Lett 2010, 4: 161–164. 10.1038/nphoton.2009.269

    Article  Google Scholar 

  39. Thiede J, Distel J, Greenfield SR, Epstein RI: Cooling to 208 K by optical refrigeration. Appl Phys Lett 2005, 86: 154107. 10.1063/1.1900951

    Article  Google Scholar 

  40. Bowman SR, O'Connor SP, Biswal S, Condon NJ, Rosenberg A: Minimizing heat generation in solid-state lasers. IEEE J Quantum Electron 2010, 46: 1076–1085.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  41. Condon NJ, Bowman SR, O'Connor SP, Quimby RS, Mungan CE: Optical cooling in Er3+:KPb2Cl5. Opt Express 2009, 17: 5466–5472. 10.1364/OE.17.005466

    Article  Google Scholar 

  42. Hoyt CW, Hasselbeck MP, Sheik-Bahae M, Epstein RI, Greenfield S, Thiede J, Distel J, Valencia J: Advances in laser cooling of thulium-doped glass. J Opt Soc Am B 2003, 20: 1066–1074. 10.1364/JOSAB.20.001066

    Article  Google Scholar 

  43. Fernandez J, Mendioroz A, Gareia AJ, Balda R, Adam JL: Anti-Stokes laser-induced internal cooling of Yb3+-doped glasses. Phys Rev B 2000, 62: 3213–3217. 10.1103/PhysRevB.62.3213

    Article  Google Scholar 

  44. Bluiett AG, Condon NJ, O'Connor S, Bowman SR, Logie M, Ganem J: Thulium-sensitized neodymium in KPb2Cl5 for mid-infrared laser development. J Opt Soc Am B 2005, 22: 2250–2256. 10.1364/JOSAB.22.002250

    Article  Google Scholar 

  45. Murdoch KM, Cockroft NJ: Energy-transfer processes between Tm3+ and Pr3+ ions in CsCdBr3. Phys Rev B 1996, 54: 4589–4603. 10.1103/PhysRevB.54.4589

    Article  Google Scholar 

Download references


Work at Loyola University Maryland was supported by the National Science Foundation Division of Electrical and Communication Systems under grants ECS-9970055 and ECS-0245455. The Office of Naval Research supported this work at the Naval Research Laboratory.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations


Corresponding author

Correspondence to Joseph Ganem.

Additional information

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Authors’ contributions

JG drafted the manuscript, prepared the samples, and participated in acquiring, analyzing and interpreting the data and in conceiving and designing these experiments. SRB participated in acquiring, analyzing, and interpreting the data, in conceiving and designing these experiments, and in revising the manuscript. Both authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Authors’ original submitted files for images

Rights and permissions

Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 International License (, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Reprints and Permissions

About this article

Cite this article

Ganem, J., Bowman, S.R. Use of thulium-sensitized rare earth-doped low phonon energy crystalline hosts for IR sources. Nanoscale Res Lett 8, 455 (2013).

Download citation

  • Received:

  • Accepted:

  • Published:

  • DOI:

  • Rare earth-doped crystals
  • Thulium cross-relaxation
  • Solid-state optical cooling
  • Mid-infrared sources
  • Optically pumped mid-infrared phosphors
  • Potassium lead chloride
  • 42.72.Ai
  • 78.60.Lc
  • 63.20.kd