- Nano Express
- Open Access
Improvement in the breakdown endurance of high-κ dielectric by utilizing stacking technology and adding sufficient interfacial layer
Nanoscale Research Letters volume 9, Article number: 464 (2014)
Improvement in the time-zero dielectric breakdown (TZDB) endurance of metal-oxide-semiconductor (MOS) capacitor with stacking structure of Al/HfO2/SiO2/Si is demonstrated in this work. The misalignment of the conduction paths between two stacking layers is believed to be effective to increase the breakdown field of the devices. Meanwhile, the resistance of the dielectric after breakdown for device with stacking structure would be less than that of without stacking structure due to a higher breakdown field and larger breakdown power. In addition, the role of interfacial layer (IL) in the control of the interface trap density (Dit) and device reliability is also analyzed. Device with a thicker IL introduces a higher breakdown field and also a lower Dit. High-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) of the samples with different IL thicknesses is provided to confirm that IL is needed for good interfacial property.
As the shrinking of devices continues, conventional metal-oxide-semiconductor field-effect transistor (MOSFET) will reach the dimension limitation because of excessive gate leakage current, which would result in an increase in static power consumption and error read in logic device . In addition, since the distance needed to obtain full bandgap SiO2 at each interface is about 3.5 ~ 4 Å, thickness of 8 Å is required for a perfect dielectric [2, 3]. Under the situation, it is expected that the physical limited thickness for SiO2 is about 8 Å. Moreover, because the dimension of device decreases more rapidly in comparison with operating voltage, electric field applied upon the gate dielectric would increase more quickly. Therefore, severe phonon scattering and downgraded channel mobility would happen since channel carriers would be attracted towards the dielectric interface. The study of Timp et al.  revealed that the drive current of device would decrease while SiO2 thickness is less than 13 Å.
An obvious solution to the above problem is achieved by applying material with higher permittivity (high-κ) than SiO2, since it could not only suppress the gate leakage current but also maintain the same oxide capacitance. Numerous studies of high-κ materials such as HfO2, HfSiON, Al2O3, ZrO2, Ta2O5, TiO2, Y2O3, SrTiO3 (STO), and BaSrTiO3 (BST) were proposed as potential candidates for replacing SiO2. However, materials with merely medium permittivity of κ < 10 [5, 6] would not achieve significant advantage over SiO2 when the dielectric becomes thinner. In addition, high-κ materials such as Ta2O5 and TiO2 would result in thermal instability while contact directly to Si. While for the STO and BST, some reports revealed that the high dielectric constant would result in fringing field-induced barrier-lowering effect and would cause a short channel effect .
HfO2 is a very promising high-κ material and owns several advantages in the formation of gate dielectric layer. It owns high dielectric constant (κ ~ 20), relatively large bandgap (5.7 eV) , and high heat of formation (271 kcal/mol) . Great numbers of research in the fabrication of high-κ dielectric films had been reported [9–16]. Atomic layer deposition (ALD) is generally reported as a good method to form HfO2. However, there still exist some technique concerns about the degradation of metal-oxide-semiconductor (MOS) device reliability [17, 18].
The method of nitric acid oxidation (NAO) was adopted in this work . Noticeably, this method is not only cost-effective but could also be carried out in a low temperature (below 323 K in the whole process). The process is proceeded by the reaction of Hf with atomic oxygen which is produced by the decomposition of HNO3 according to the reaction 2HNO3 → 2NO + H2O + 3O. The high-κ HfO2 dielectric layer can be formed by NAO towards sputtered Hf metal layer due to the high reactivity of atomic oxygen. The method of NAO is also available in forming Al2O3 from Al metal . Some research focused on the enhancement of illumination and temperature sensitivity by using NAO process to form HfO2 on interfacial layer (IL) [21, 22]. Furthermore, since NAO is carried out at room temperature, multi-stacking structures could be achieved without the consideration of thermal budget, and each stacking layer could also be fully oxidized in order to reach optimal quality of dielectric structure. Several studies on the trapping characteristics of stacking structure Al2O3 and HfO2 had been proposed [23, 24]. The research of tunneling current characteristics in dark and illumination was also explored on stacking structure . It is believed that the process control of stacking technology for devices with better performance and reliability is still of interest.
The importance of IL is also examined in this work. Numerous reports demonstrated that an intentionally grown ultrathin oxide IL is indeed necessary to maintain stability between HfO2 and Si [25, 26]. HfO2 film is believed to have poor interface property with Si which may be caused by the undercoordinated hafnium atom, so the electrical properties of dielectrics would not be optimized [27–29]. Additionally, nonuniformity and poor morphology for HfO2 film growing on hydrofluoric (HF)-last Si were found according to high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) and MEIS analyses. Since it is difficult to form a high-κ dielectric that having perfect interface with Si in comparison with SiO2, the use of SiO2 as IL is crucial and needed [30, 31]. Moreover, the IL could not only help to reduce the thermodynamic instability between high-κ materials and Si, but it could also accommodate the difference in lattice constants between Si and another material.
In this work, we first manufactured two batches of MOS capacitors with the first batch having one-time forming HfO2 with SiO2 as gate dielectric layers and the second batch of HfO2 stacking layer with SiO2 as gate dielectric layers. The time-zero dielectric breakdown (TZDB) tests are investigated, and the current–voltage (I-V) characteristics are discussed. It is found that stacking structure owns a higher breakdown field, which would lead to lower resistance after breakdown. Then, in order to corroborate the results, samples with different IL thicknesses are manufactured and investigated. The stacking structures still own a higher breakdown field. Nevertheless, with the decreasing thickness of IL, higher density of interfacial states and lower breakdown field are observed. The mechanism for the observation is proposed, and HRTEM is given in this work.
Two different MOS capacitors studied in the first experiment denoted by SH/O and H/O (S stands for stacking structure, H stands for HfO2, and O stands for SiO2) were manufactured on the substrate of p-type (100) Si wafer with a resistivity of 1 ~ 10 Ω cm. The wafers were undergone the process of standard Radio Corporation of America (RCA) cleaning in order to remove impurities. Then, SiO2 as ultrathin IL was grown onto the wafers using the technique of anodization (ANO) after removing native oxides by HF. The oxidation method of ANO could be carried out in room temperature and could provide a promising option for the preparation of low-temperature IL [32, 33]. It was reported that the anodic oxide grown in room temperature has few pinholes and owns a good dielectric quality [34, 35]. The samples after anodization were followed by 950°C annealing in N2 for 15 s. Then, sample H/O was undergone the deposition of Hf onto a wafer by sputtering with the power of 60 W for 210 s, followed by NAO process to form HfO2 dielectric. Then, postoxidation annealing (POA) was carried out in a furnace at 380°C for 10 min in order to improve the quality of dielectric layer. The combined procedures from the deposition of Hf to the following annealing are defined as one cycle. Under the circumstance, the sample SH/O would undergo the sputtering time of 90 s as the first cycle and that of 60 s as other two cycles. Then, 250-nm aluminum metal was evaporated onto the top of all samples. The process of photolithography was carried out to pattern the devices with square area of 2.25 × 104 μm2. Finally, the back contact was formed by the evaporation of 250-nm aluminum.
In order to corroborate our investigation, another two different MOS capacitors with various IL thicknesses denoted by SH/Ox and H/Ox were manufactured. Ox represents the SiO2 that was formed with various thicknesses from ANO process. There are two main differences of the experiments for SH/Ox and H/Ox in comparison with SH/O and H/O. First, the platinum was tilted while using the ANO in order to form IL with different thicknesses, as shown in Figure 1. Second, H/Ox was undergone one cycle of Hf sputtering with 150 s instead of 210 s for H/O while SH/Ox was carried out Hf sputtering of 90/30/30 s separately instead of 90/60/60 s for SH/O.
Results and discussion
TZDB characteristics between one-time forming HfO2 and stacking structure
We first take the capacitance-voltage (C-V) and I-V measurements of H/O and SH/O. C-V measurements with gate voltage (V G ) from -3 to 3 V are shown in Figure 2. Effective oxide thickness (EOT) of both samples is calculated as 52 Ǻ. The I-V curves of both devices are shown in the insets. In the following work, the TZDB characteristics are investigated. V G is swept from 0 to -15 V in recording the leakage current density. It is observed that SH/O shows a higher breakdown voltage than the one without stacking structure as presented in Figure 3. Figure 3a presents the median breakdown field (E50%BD) of 14.8 (MV/cm) for SH/O, while merely 11.3 (MV/cm) for H/O. It is believed that the grain boundaries (GBs) exist in dielectric layer are responsible for current conduction . It is supposed that the stacking structure would result in the misalignment of GBs between separate dielectric layers. With the discontinuous paths for current leakage as schematically illustrated in Figure 3b, the higher breakdown field (EBD) would be expected for stacking structure.
Characteristics after dielectric breakdown
The I-V characteristics after breakdown of these two samples are shown in Figure 4. Resistance after breakdown is defined as
where V and I represent gate voltage and current. The cumulative data of R (absolute value) after breakdown are shown in Figure 4a. R is extracted with V1 and V2 of -13 and -12 V and the corresponding I1 and I2, respectively. It indicates that sample H/O shows higher R value than SH/O after breakdown. In the case, due to the finding that stacking structures have higher EBD, the power per unit area in the initiation of breakdown would be larger for stacking structures. The power per unit area of breakdown could be defined as
where J and V are current density and corresponding gate voltage at the initiation of breakdown. The cumulative data of P'BD are presented in Figure 4b. It indicates that the stacking structures would suffer from higher breakdown power per unit area than that of without stacking. It would lead to more serious damage in dielectric and result in lower resistance after breakdown.
The important role of IL in reliability
In corroborating that stacking structure owns the higher breakdown field than the one without stacking structure, devices of SH/Ox and H/Ox were fabricated. Since the platinum was tilted while forming the IL with different thicknesses by ANO, as schematically illustrated in Figure 1, devices with different EOTs were obtained. The C-V curves of SH/Ox are shown in Figure 5a, with the overall EOTs ranging from 27 to 22 Ǻ, and the inset shows the corresponding I-V curves. For another sample of H/Ox, the C-V curves are presented in Figure 5b, with the overall EOTs ranging from 31 to 25 Ǻ, and the I-V curves are presented in the inset. Although both samples have different ranges of EOT, which may result from the longer oxidation time by nitric acid, it does not influence our conclusion since we are comparing the EBD instead of breakdown voltage. After the TZDB test, the EBD versus different EOTs of SH/Ox and H/Ox are shown in Figure 6. The result that stacking structure owns larger EBD is consistent with our investigation for SH/O and H/O.
Interestingly, it is noticed that through the minimization of EOT in both samples, the EBD would all be deteriorated. It is believed that the thin IL is responsible for the phenomenon. SiO2 as IL is helpful in relieving the strain due to different lattice constants between high-κ dielectric and Si. Furthermore, it helps to reduce the thermodynamic instability between high-κ materials and Si. Once the IL becomes thinner, much more HfO2 may contact directly to Si, as schematically illustrated in Figure 7a,b for thicker and thinner SiO2, respectively. It is believed that thin IL would lead to higher density of interfacial states. The results of HRTEM for H/Ox with the thickest and thinnest IL are shown in Figure 8a,b, respectively. The phenomenon that HfO2 may directly contact to Si is observed for sample with thin IL, as presented in Figure 8b (red circles). It is consistent with our assumption as described in Figure 7b. Figure 9a,b,c,d shows the C-V curves measured at various frequencies for H/Ox with various EOTs (SH/Ox not shown for brevity). It is observed that the interface trap density (Dit) is increasing with the decreasing IL thickness. The Dit could be calculated by using high-low frequency method
where Cox is the gate oxide capacitance per unit area, C H is the measured capacitance per unit area under frequency 1 MHz, and C L is the measured capacitance per unit area under frequency 1 kHz. The cumulative data of Dit at midgap (E t = E i ) of samples H/Ox are presented in Figure 10 (SH/Ox not shown for brevity). Higher Dit and wider Weibull distribution for samples with thin IL are observed. Nonuniform interfacial property becomes serious when IL thickness is reduced.
In this study, we demonstrated that structure with stacking dielectric layer would own the higher breakdown field from TZDB test. While higher breakdown power at the initiation of breakdown and lower resistance after breakdown are observed for stacking structure. In addition, the importance of IL is discussed in this work. Thinner IL would result in the increase of Dit and the degradation of breakdown field. The explanation of the phenomenon is proposed and is confirmed by HRTEM.
Effective oxide thickness
Nitric acid oxidation
Time-zero dielectric breakdown.
Kim NS, Austin T, Baauw D, Mudge T, Flautner K, Hu JS, Irwin MJ, Kandemir M, Narayanan V: Leakage current: Moore’s law meets static power. IEEE computer 2003, 36: 68–74.
Tang S, Wallance RM, Seabaugh A, King-Smith D: Evaluating the minimum thickness of gate oxide on silicon using first-principles method. Appl Surf Sci 1998, 135: 137–142. 10.1016/S0169-4332(98)00286-4
Muller DA, Sorsch T, Moccio S, Baumann FH, Evans-Lutterodt K, Timp G: The electronic structure at the atomic scale of ultrathin gate oxides. Nature 1999, 399: 758–761. 10.1038/21602
Timp G, Agarwal A, Baumann FH, Boone T, Buonanno M, Cirelli R, Donnelly V, Foad M, Grant D, Green M, Gossmann H, Hillenius S, Jackson J, Jacobson D, Kleiman R, Komblit A, Klemens F, Lee JT-C, Mansfield W, Moccio S, Murrell A, O'Malley M, Rosamilia J, Sapjeta J, Silverman P, Sorsch T, Tai WW, Tennant D, Vuong H, Weir B: Low leakage, ultra-thin gate oxides for extremely high performance sub-100 nm nMOSFETs. IEEE Int Electron Devices Meeting 1997, 930. doi:10.1109/IEDM.1997.650534 doi:10.1109/IEDM.1997.650534
Cho MH, Ko DH, Choi YG, Lyo IW, Jeong K, Whang CN: YSi2-x formation in the presence of interfacial SiO2 layer. J Appl Phys 2002, 92: 5555–5559. 10.1063/1.1512323
Klein TM, Niu D, Epling WS, Li W, Maher DM, Hobbs CC, Hegde RI, Baumvol IJR, Parsons GN: Evidence of aluminum silicate formation during chemical vapor deposition of amorphous Al2O3 thin films on Si(100). Appl Phys Lett 1999, 75: 4001–4003. 10.1063/1.125519
Hubbard KJ, Schlom DG: Thermodynamic stability of binary oxides in contact with silicon. J Mater Res 1996, 11: 2757–2776. 10.1557/JMR.1996.0350
Cheng B, Min C, Rao R, Inani A, Vande Voorde P, Greene WM, Stork JMC, Zhiping Y, Zeitzoff PM, Woo JCS: The impact of high-κ gate dielectrics and metal gate electrodes on sub-100 nm MOSFETs. IEEE Trans Electron Devices 1999, 46: 1537–1544. 10.1109/16.772508
Balog M, Schieber M, Michiman M, Patai S: Chemical vapor deposition and characterization of HfO2 films from organo-hafnium compounds. Thin Solid Films 1977, 41: 247–259. 10.1016/0040-6090(77)90312-1
Wilk GD, Wallace RM, Anthony JM: High-κ gate dielectrics: current status and materials properties considerations. J Appl Phys 2001, 89: 5243–5276. 10.1063/1.1361065
Balog M, Schrieber M, Patai S, Michman M: Thin films of metal oxides on silicon by chemical vapor deposition with organometallic compounds. I. J Cryst Growth 1972, 17: 298–301.
Cameron MA, George SM: ZrO2 film growth by chemical vapor deposition using zirconium tetra-tert-butoxide. Thin Solid Films 1999, 348: 90–98. 10.1016/S0040-6090(99)00022-X
Zhu J, Li TL, Pan B, Zhou L, Liu ZG: Enhanced dielectric properties of ZrO2 thin films prepared in nitrogen ambient by pulsed laser deposition. J Phys D : Appl Phys 2003, 36: 389–393. 10.1088/0022-3727/36/4/310
Manory RR, Mori T, Shimizu I, Miyake S, Kimmel G: Growth and structure control of HfO2-x films with cubic and tetragonal structures obtained by ion beam assisted deposition. J Vac Sci Technol A 2002, 20: 549–554. 10.1116/1.1453453
Kukli K, Ritala M, Leskelae M, Sajavaara T, Keinonen J, Jones AC, Roberts JL: Atomic layer deposition of hafnium dioxide films using hafnium bis(2-butanolate)bis(1-methoxy-2-methyl-2-propanolate) and water. Chem Vap Deposition 2003, 9: 315–320. 10.1002/cvde.200306263
Endo K, Tatsumi T: Metal organic atomic layer deposition of high-k gate dielectrics using plasma oxidation. Jpn J Appl Phys 2003, 42: L685-L687. 10.1143/JJAP.42.L685
Kukli K, Ritala M, Sajavaara T, Kemonen J, Leskla M: Comparison of hafnium oxide films grown by atomic layer deposition from iodide and chloride precursors. Thin Solid Films 2002, 416: 72–79. 10.1016/S0040-6090(02)00612-0
Lysaght PS, Foran B, Bersuker G, Chen PL, Murto RW, Huff HR: Physicochemical properties of HfO2 in response to rapid thermal anneal. Appl Phys Lett 2003, 82: 1266–1268. 10.1063/1.1553998
Asuha HK, Maida O, Takahashi M, Iwasa H: Nitric acid oxidation of Si to form ultrathin silicon dioxide layers with a low leakage current density. J Appl Phys 2003, 94: 7328–7335. 10.1063/1.1621720
Chen CH, Hwu JG: Stack engineering of low-temperature-processing Al2O3 dielectrics prepared by nitric acid oxidation for MOS structure. Microelectronic Engineering 2010, 87: 686–689. 10.1016/j.mee.2009.09.013
Pang CS, Hwu JG: Photo-induced tunneling currents in MOS structures with various HfO2/SiO2 stacking dielectrics. AIP Advances 2014, 4: 047112–1-047112–10.
Wang TM, Chang CH, Hwu JG: Enhancement of temperature sensitivity for metal–oxide–semiconductor (MOS) tunneling temperature sensors by utilizing hafnium oxide (HfO2) film added on silicon dioxide (SiO2). IEEE Sensors Journal 2006, 6: 1468–1472.
Yang CY, Hwu JG: Low temperature tandem aluminum oxides prepared by DAC-ANO compensation in nitric acid. J The Electrochemical Soc 2009, 156: G184-G189. 10.1149/1.3211800
Chang CH, Hwu JG: Trapping characteristics of Al2O3 /HfO2 /SiO2 stack structure prepared by low temperature in situ oxidation in dc sputtering. J Appl Phys 2009, 105: 094103–1-094103–6.
Hobbs C, Tseng H, Reid K, Taylor B, Dip L, Hebert L, Garcia R, Hegde R, Grant J, Gilmer D, Franke A, Dhandapani V, Azrak M, Prabhu L, Rai R, Bagchi S, Conner J, Backer S, Dumbuya F, Nguyen B, Tobin P: 80 nm poly-Si gate CMOS with HfO2 gate dielectric. IEEE Int Electron Devices Meeting 2001, 30.1.1. doi:10.1109/IEDM.2001.979592 doi:10.1109/ IEDM.2001.979592
Gusev EP, Buchanan DA, Cartier E, Kumar A, DiMaria D, Guha S, Callegari A, Zafar S, Jamison PC, Neumayer DA, Copel M, Gribelyuk MA, Okorn-Schmidt H, D'Emic C, Kozlowski P, Chan K, Bojarczuk N, Ragnarsson L-A, Ronsheim P, Rim K, Fleming RJ, Mocuta A, Ajmera A: Ultrathin high-K gate stacks for advanced CMOS devices. IEEE Int Electron Devices Meeting 2001, 20.1.1. doi:10.1109/IEDM.2001.979537 doi:10.1109/IEDM.2001.979537
Puthenkovilakam R, Sawkar M, Chang JP: Electrical characteristics of postdeposition annealed HfO2 on silicon. Appl Phys Lett 2005, 86: 202902–1-202902–3.
Gusev EP, Cabral C Jr, Copel M, D’Emic C, Gribelyuk M: Ultrathin HfO2 films grown on silicon by atomic layer deposition for advanced gate dielectrics applications. Microelectronic Engineering 2003, 69: 145–151. 10.1016/S0167-9317(03)00291-0
Green ML, Ho MY, Busch B, Wilk GD, Sorsch T, Conard T, Brijs B, Vandervorst W, Räisänen PI, Muller D, Bude M, Grazul J: Nucleation and growth of atomic layer deposited HfO2 gate dielectric layers on chemical oxide (Si–O–H) and thermal oxide (SiO2 or Si–O–N) underlayers. J Appl Phys 2002, 92: 7168–7174. 10.1063/1.1522811
Roy PK, Kizilyalli IC: Stacked high-ϵ gate dielectric for gigascale integration of metal–oxide–semiconductor technologies. Appl Phys Lett 1998, 72: 2835. 10.1063/1.121473
Kizilyalli IC, Huang RYS, Roy PK: MOS transistors with stacked SiO2-Ta2O5-SiO2 gate dielectrics for giga-scale integration of CMOS technologies. IEEE Electron Device Lett 1998, 19: 423–425.
Chen YC, Lee CY, Hwu JG: Ultra-thin gate oxides prepared by alternating current anodization of silicon followed by rapid thermal anneal. Solid State Electronics 2001, 45: 1531–1536. 10.1016/S0038-1101(01)00182-4
Ting CC, Shih YH, Hwu JG: Ultralow leakage characteristics of ultrathin gate oxides (~3 nm) prepared by anodization followed by high-temperature annealing. IEEE Trans Electron Devices 2002, 49: 179–181. 10.1109/16.974766
Paily R, DasGupta A, DasGupta N: Improvement in electrical characteristics of ultrathin thermally grown SiO2 by selective anodic oxidation. IEEE Electron Device Lett 2002, 23: 707–709.
Jeng MJ, Hwu JG: Thin-gate oxides prepared by pure water anodization followed by rapid thermal densification. IEEE Electron Device Lett 1996, 17: 575–577.
Gilmer DC, Hegde R, Cotton R, Garcia R, Dhandapani V, Triyoso D, Roan D, Franke A, Rai R, Prabhu L, Hobbs C, Grant JM, La L, Samavedam S, Taylor B, Tseng H, Tobin P: Compatibility of polycrystalline silicon gate deposition with HfO2 and Al2O3/HfO2 gate dielectrics. Appl Phys Lett 2002, 81: 1288–1290. 10.1063/1.1499514
This work is supported by the National Science Council of Taiwan, Republic of China, under Contract No. NSC 102-2221-E-002-183-MY3.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
C-SP carried out the experiments and the measurements. J-GH provided thoughts and revised the manuscript. C-SP completed the manuscript. Both authors discussed the results. Both authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Pang, C., Hwu, J. Improvement in the breakdown endurance of high-κ dielectric by utilizing stacking technology and adding sufficient interfacial layer. Nanoscale Res Lett 9, 464 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1186/1556-276X-9-464
- Stacking structure
- Time-zero dielectric breakdown
- Interfacial layer
- Interface trap density
- Nitric acid oxidation