- Nano Express
- Open Access
- Published:

# Observation of anomalous linear photogalvanic effect and its dependence on wavelength in undoped InGaAs/AlGaAs multiple quantum well

*Nanoscale Research Letters*
**volume 9**, Article number: 493 (2014)

## Abstract

We observed an anomalous linear photogalvanic effect (ALPGE) in undoped InGaAs/AlGaAs multiple quantum well and studied its wavelength dependence in details. This effect is believed to originate from the optical momentum alignment effect and the inhomogeneity of light intensity. We find that the spot location with the maximum ALPGE current is wavelength independent. And the normalized ALPGE current decreasing at smaller wavelengths is attributed to the sharp decrease of the momentum and energy relaxation time. The electrical measurement of the spectra dependence of ALPGE is highly sensitive proving to be an effective method for detecting the momentum anisotropy of photoinduced carriers and band coupling.

## Background

Photocurrents induced by linearly polarized light in semiconductors have been intensively studied for decades [1–7]. Linearly polarized light can result in the linear photogalvanic effect (LPGE) [1], the photon drag effect [1], the pure spin current in a system with spin orbit interaction [2, 3], and the optical momentum alignment effect [4–6] (Figure 1). Recently, an anomalous linear photogalvanic effect (ALPGE) was firstly observed in a (001)-oriented GaN-based two-dimensional electron gas (2DEG) [7]. The ALPGE occurs in (001)-oriented 2DEG with *C*_{2v} symmetry for normal light incidence [7], while the ordinary LPGE is forbidden by symmetry in this situation [1] (but it is not always true for other situations, such as (110)-oriented quantum wells [8]).

In the following introduction, we take the *x*, *y*, and *z* directions to be parallel to the crystal’s [110], \left[\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}1\stackrel{\u0304}{1}0\right], and [001] directions, respectively. For the (001)-oriented 2DEG with *C*_{2v} symmetry, the ordinary LPGE current can be expressed as follows:

where the third-rank pseudotensor *χ*_{
yyz
} is a symmetry factor; *x*,*y*, and *z* are three orthogonal directions; *E*_{0},\phantom{\rule{0.5em}{0ex}}\xea, and *θ*_{0} are the electric field amplitudes of the light, the unit vector pointing in the direction of light propagation, and the angle between the plane of polarization defined by the electric field vector and the *x* direction, respectively [1]. For normal incidence,\phantom{\rule{0.5em}{0ex}}\xea is parallel to [001] crystallographic orientation and hence the current vanishes as {\xea}_{x}=0[1]. However, under normal incidence, a sizeable charge current induced by linearly polarized light is observed with the light spot moving away from the ‘O’ point and along the *x* direction (see the inset of Figure 2a). This current corresponds to the typical characteristics of LPGE which can be described by following formula:

where *j*_{0} is the amplitude of current, so it can be named as ALPGE current. Peng et al. [7] only revealed excitation by single wavelength, and there was not a regular transition corresponding to interband transition. While in this letter, we report the observation of ALPGE and its spectra dependence in an undoped (001)-oriented InGaAs/AlGaAs multiple quantum well (MQW) with *C*_{2v} symmetry, which is a good supplement to the in-depth investigation of the spectra dependence of momentum anisotropy of the photoinduced carriers in semiconductors.

## Methods

The sample studied here is an undoped In _{0.15}*Ga*_{0.85}As/Al _{0.3}*Ga*_{0.7}As quantum wells (QWs) grown by molecular beam epitaxy. A 200-nm buffer layer is initially deposited on (001) SI-GaAs substrate, followed by ten periods of 100-Å In _{0.15}*Ga*_{0.85}As/100-Å Al _{0.3}*Ga*_{0.7}As QWs. Then, a 500-Å Al _{0.3}*Ga*_{0.7}As layer and 100-Å GaAs cap layer are deposited. The sample is cleaved into a narrow strip along the GaAs \left[\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}1\stackrel{\u0304}{1}0\right] direction with a width of 4 mm and a length of 12 mm, respectively. The geometry has been shown in the inset of Figure 2a, where two ohmic electrodes with a distance of 3 mm were made along *y* direction by indium deposition and annealed at about 420°C in nitrogen atmosphere.

The experimental setup and method are described as follows: A 140-fs, 80-MHz Ti sapphire oscillator with a peak power of the optical pulses of 300 KW serves as the radiation source. As the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the laser pulse is about 7 nm, the step-length of the spectral scanning should not be too small. In this experiment, the excitation wavelength is tuned from 865 to 1,000 nm with a step-length of 5 nm, which covers both 1hh-1e (the first valence subband of heavy hole to the first conduction) transition and 1lh-1e (the first valence subband of light hole to the first conduction) transition [9]. The incident light goes through a polarizer and a photoelastic modulator (PEM), of which the peak retardation is set to be *λ*/4, to yield a modulated linearly polarized light with a fixed modulating frequency at 100 KHz. The angle between the polarization direction of the incident light and the optical fast axis of the PEM is set to be 45°. The Gaussian profile light beam irradiates vertically on the sample with a diameter of about 2 mm at the perpendicular bisector of the two circle electrodes (see the inset of Figure 2a). After the amplification by a preamplifier, the ALPGE current is collected by a lock-in amplifier through the two circle electrodes. At each light spot, one could get a spectrum dependence of ALPGE current. With the movement of the light spot along the perpendicular bisector of the two circle electrodes, one could get a two-dimentional graph of ALPGE currents as functions of wavelength and light spot, as shown in Figure 2b. As a comparison, the common photocurrent (*I*_{
PC
}) is also measured with reference frequency of 220 Hz provided by an optical chopper. The polarization independent light modulated by the optical chopper will induce photoinduced carriers on the plane of the QWs. When the electric field (100 V/cm in this letter) applies on the two circle electrodes, *I*_{
PC
} will be generated, which is collected by the lock-in amplifier, so one can see that *I*_{
PC
} is proportional to the density of the photoinduced carriers. All the experiments are carried out at room temperature.

## Theoretical model

Different from the ordinary LPGE due to asymmetry scattering on phonons, static defects, or other carriers in noncentrosymmetric media, the ALPGE is supposed to due to the optical momentum alignment effect [1, 7]. This ALPGE is similar to the so-called surface photogalvanic effect in [10–12] and the edge photogalvanic effect in [13], where the electrical detection of optical momentum alignment is carried out in metals as well as semiconductors. However, optical momentum alignment alone is not enough to induce a net electric current due to the symmetrical distribution of carriers with momenta ** k** and

**in optical excitation. It has been believed that the diffuse scattering of the surface or the edge breaks the symmetrical distribution of carriers with opposite**

*−k***. While in the MQW studied here, the optical absorption corresponds to the inner wells and the size of the sample is much larger than the diameter of the laser beam and can be considered edgeless, thus the surface as well as the edge photogalvanic effect can be neglected in our experiment. It is believed that in our experiments the inhomogeneity of light intensity plays the same role with the surface or the edge for generating a net electric current.**

*k*As shown in Figure 1c,d, the distribution of photoinduced carriers has a Gaussian profile due to the Gaussian light beam. During the momentum relaxation time, the carriers will have a very small displacement along their own momentum directions, which is on the scale of the mean free path. Because the carriers with momenta ** k** and

**will have opposite displacements, a small spatial separation of the two groups of carriers is generated, which results in a photocurrent proportional to the gradient of carrier density. Since the radius of light spot with about 2 mm is much bigger than the momentum diffusion length, the contribution of the current outside the light spot can be neglected. Therefore, the ALPGE current is decided by the distribution of the light intensity which can be expressed phenomenologically as**

*−k*where *ϕ* is a second-rank symmetric tensor relating to the optical momentum alignment effect, *I*(*r*) is the light intensity with a Gaussian distribution, and *r* is the radial direction in the *x*−*y* plane. The carrier distributions in QWs are highly influenced by *k*-linear terms in band structure and transition probabilities [14, 15]. For the sake of simplicity, we still use bulk equations of the optical momentum alignment effect in the following simulations. According to [7], *ϕ* can be expressed as

where *τ*^{∗} is the effective relaxation time, *α* is the optical absorption coefficient, *ω* is the photon frequency, *υ* is the velocity of carriers, *k*_{
ex
} is the magnitude of the wave vector at the exciting point, and *g*(*θ*,*θ*_{0}) is the momentum anisotropy factor. The *g*(*θ*,*θ*_{0}) factor describes the probability of an excited carrier’s momentum being along the *θ* direction given the light polarization plane along the *θ*_{0} direction. According to the optical momentum alignment effect theory [4], *g*(*θ*,*θ*_{0}) can be expressed as g(\theta ,{\theta}_{0})=\frac{3}{2}\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}{f}_{0}\mathit{\text{si}}{n}^{2}(\theta -{\theta}_{0}) for 1hh-1e transition and as g(\theta ,{\theta}_{0})=\frac{3}{2}\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}{f}_{0}\phantom{\rule{0.3em}{0ex}}\left[\mathit{\text{co}}{s}^{2}(\theta -{\theta}_{0})+1/3\right] for 1lh-1e transition, where *f*_{0} is the symmetric part of the the momentum anisotropy factor (see Figure 1a,b). As a result, an anisotropy electric current will be induced around the light spot, which will further generate an observed ALPGE current.

## Results and discussion

In the experiment, the ALPGE currents are measured as a function of the spot location at different wavelengths (near the transitions of 1hh-1e (955 nm) and 1lh-1e (905 nm)). As shown in Figure 2a, the ALPGE currents reverse the sign from the left to the right side, just like a sine curve, which is quiet similar to the anomalous circular photogalvanic effect (ACPGE) current (arising from the reciprocal spin Hall effect) where there is a current swirling over the center of the light spot [16]. However, different from the ACPGE, the ALPGE is derived from an anisotropic distribution of current due to the optical momentum alignment effect. The movement of the anisotropic current along *x* direction will change the amplitude of the ALPGE current. Taking the light spot as a simple geometric point, i.e., *I*(*r*)=*W* *δ*(*r*), the detected current between the two electrodes can be expressed as [7]

where *σ* is the conductivity which is considered to be the same at varied wavelengths with the same light intensity and *R* is the resistance between the two electrodes. As shown in Figure 2a, Equation (5) fits well with the experimental data. The small deviation of experimental data from the fitting line might be attributed to the nonuniformity of the sample. Since the momentum of hole is known to relax very fast, on a longer time scale, one can just take the electron contribution to the current into consideration. Under the effective mass approximation, the second-rank symmetric tensor *ϕ*_{
xy
} is expressed as [7]

where \beta \left({\theta}_{0}\right)=\int g(\theta ,{\theta}_{0})\mathrm{sin\theta cos\theta d\theta} is the momentum anisotropy factor in this experiment (where *θ*_{0} is fixed on 45°) and {\upsilon}_{e}=\frac{\hslash {k}_{\mathit{\text{ex}}}}{{m}^{\ast}} is the electron velocity. *β*(*θ*_{0}) is calculated as

for 1hh-1e transition and

for 1lh-1e transition.

As shown in Figure 2b, the extreme positions are all focused on the location of *x*=±0.87 mm, which indicates that the extreme position of ALPGE current is wavelength independent. When the wavelength is tuned from 895 to 980 nm, the changes of the size of the light spot can be neglected. In fact, the vary of wavelength only changes the density of photoinduced electrons which can be written as n=\int \frac{\mathrm{\alpha I}\left(r\right)}{\mathrm{\hslash \omega}}\mathit{\text{dr}}=\frac{\mathrm{\alpha W}}{\mathrm{\hslash \omega}} and the effective relaxation time *τ*^{∗}. Therefore, according to Equations (5) and (6), the vary of wavelength only affects the amplitude of the ALPGE current but does not change the extreme position.

Figure 3a shows the ALPGE current as a function of wavelength when the light spot is fixed on the position of *x*=+1 mm. From Equations (7) and (8), we can see that in both situations *β*(*θ*_{0}) are equal in size but different in signs. Therefore, one should observe that the ALPGE current reverses the sign when the optical interband transition changes between 1lh-1e and 1hh-1e. However, we do not observe obvious opposite in the sign, which is probably due to the strong band mixing [15], that is, the signal corresponding to 1lh-1e is contributed from not only the 1lh-1e transition but also the 1hh-1e transition. In other words, signal corresponding to 1lh-1e is small, and the current corresponding to the so-called 1lh-1e marked in Figures 2 and 3 is actually the combined action of 1lh-1e and 1hh-1e. As a comparison, the common photoinduced current is also measured under the same conditions, as shown in Figure 3b. According to Ohm’s law, the common photoinduced current can be written as

where {\mu}_{n}=\frac{e{\tau}_{p}}{{m}^{\ast}} is the mobility of electrons and *E* is the external electric field. One can surprisingly find that the two curve shapes in Figure 3a,b are quite different. To eliminate the difference of the nonequilibrium electron’s density at different wavelengths, we normalize the ALPGE current with the common photoinduced current, because the common photoinduced current is proportional to the density of photoinduced nonequilibrium electrons. And the normalized ALPGE current is shown in Figure 3c. According to Equations (5) and (9), the normalized *I*_{
ALPGE
} (see Figure 3c) can be simplified as

The contribution to *τ*^{∗} contains three parts: the momentum relaxation time *τ*_{
p
}, the energy relaxation time *τ*_{
ε
} which describes the inelastic processes due to the scattering of longitudinal optical phonon, and the carrier lifetime *τ*_{0} which describes the carrier recombination, i.e., {{\tau}^{\ast}}^{-1}={\tau}_{0}^{-1}+{\tau}_{\epsilon}^{-1}+{\tau}_{p}^{-1}. Given the average mobility of the photoinduced electrons to be 8,000 *c* *m*^{2}/(*V*·*s*) and the effective mass of electrons to be 0.06 *m*_{0} (where *m*_{0} is the mass of electron in a vacuum), the momentum relaxation time *τ*_{
p
} is estimated to be 0.27 ps, which would be smaller at higher excited states. Since *τ*_{0}∼1*ns*[17], *τ*_{
ε
}∼0.15−7*ps*[18], one can see that *τ*^{∗} is mainly determined by the momentum relaxation time *τ*_{
p
} and the energy relaxation time *τ*_{
ε
}. The decrease of the normalized *I*_{
ALPGE
} can be attributed to the faster momentum and energy relaxation at smaller excitation wavelengths. We have also testified that the ALPGE current still exist in undoped GaAs/AlGaAs QWs; however, we observed no obvious ALPGE current in undoped bulk GaAs. What is more, the ALPGE current in this strained InGaAs/AlGaAs QWs is much stronger than that in undoped GaAs/AlGaAs QWs. Thus, we believe that the ALPGE is a common phenomenon in low-dimensional semiconductors, and the ALPGE is probably stronger in strained semiconductors.

## Conclusions

The spectra dependence of ALPGE at normal incidence in undoped InGaAs/AlGaAs multiple quantum well has been studied. This effect is believed to originate from the optical momentum alignment effect and requires an inhomogeneous light illumination. We found that the spot location with the maximum ALPGE current is wavelength independent. We do not observe obvious opposite in the sign for 1hh-1e and 1lh-1e transitions, which is probably due to the fact that the detected current is mainly derived from 1hh-1e transition. And the normalized ALPGE current decreases at smaller wavelengths, which can be attributed to the sharp decrease of the momentum and energy relaxation time. This high sensitivity of electrical measurements proves to be an effective method for detecting the momentum anisotropy of photoinduced carriers and band coupling.

## References

Ganichev SD, Prettl W: Spin photocurrents in quantum wells.

*J Phys Condens Matter*2003, 15(20):935. 10.1088/0953-8984/15/20/204Ganichev SD, Belkov VV, Tarasenko SA, Danilov SN, Giglberger S, Hoffmann C, Ivchenko EL, Weiss D, Wegscheider W, Gerl C, Schuh D, Stahl J, Boeck JD, Borghs G, Prettl W: Zero-bias spin separation.

*Nat Phys*2006, 2(9):609–613. 10.1038/nphys390Zhao H, Loren EJ, Van Driel H, Smirl AL: Coherence control of hall charge and spin currents.

*Phys Rev Lett*2006, 96(24):246601.Zakharchenya BP, Mirlin DN, Perel’ VI, Reshina I: Spectrum and polarization of hot-electron photoluminescence in semiconductors.

*Soviet Physics Uspekhi*1982, 25(3):143. 10.1070/PU1982v025n03ABEH004519Meier F, Zakharchenya BP:

*Optical Orientation*. Amsterdam: North-Holland Physics Publishing; 1984.Sapega V: Optical momentum alignment and spin orientation of hot electrons in GaAs/AlAs superlattices.

*Semicond Sci Tech*2008, 23(11):114016. 10.1088/0268-1242/23/11/114016Peng X, Zhang Q, Shen B, Shi J, Yin C, He X, Xu F, Wang X, Tang N, Jiang C, Chen Y, Chang K: Anomalous linear photogalvanic effect observed in a GaN-based two-dimensional electron gas.

*Phys Rev B*2011, 84(7):075341.Bieler M, Pierz K, Siegner U, Dawson P: Shift currents from symmetry reduction and coulomb effects in (110)-orientated GaAs/Al

_{0.3}Ga_{0.7}As quantum wells.*Phys Rev B*2007, 76(16):161304.Yu J, Chen Y, Jiang C, Liu Y, Ma H, Zhu L: Observation of the photoinduced anomalous hall effect spectra in insulating InGaAs/AlGaAs quantum wells at room temperature.

*Appl Phys Lett*2012, 100(14):142109. 10.1063/1.3701281Al’perovich V, Belinicher V, Novikov V, Terekhov A: Surface photovoltaic effect in solids. Theory and experiment for interband transitions in gallium arsenide.

*Zh Eksp Teor Fiz*1981, 80: 2298–2312.Gurevich V, Laiho R: Photomagnetism of metals: microscopic theory of the photoinduced surface current.

*Phys Rev B*1993, 48(11):8307. 10.1103/PhysRevB.48.8307Gurevich V, Laiho R: Photomagnetism of metals. First observation of dependence on polarization of light.

*Phys Solid State*2000, 42(10):1807–1812. 10.1134/1.1318868Karch J, Olbrich P, Schmalzbauer M, Brinsteiner C, Wurstbauer U, Glazov M, Tarasenko S, Ivchenko E, Weiss D, Eroms J, Ganichev S: Photon helicity driven electric currents in graphene. 2010. arXiv preprint arXiv:1002.1047. doi:10.1109/ICIMW.2010.5612541

Ivchenko E, Tarasenko S: Pure spin photocurrents.

*Semicond Sci Tech*2008, 23(11):114007. 10.1088/0268-1242/23/11/114007Duc HT, Förstner J, Meier T: Microscopic analysis of charge and spin photocurrents injected by circularly polarized one-color laser pulses in gaas quantum wells.

*Phys Rev B*2010, 82(11):115316.Zhu L, Liu Y, Jiang C, Qin X, Li Y, Gao H, Chen Y: Excitation wavelength dependence of the anomalous circular photogalvanic effect in undoped InGaAs/AlGaAs quantum wells.

*J Appl Phys*2014, 115(8):083509. 10.1063/1.4867039Gurioli M, Vinattieri A, Colocci M, Deparis C, Massies J, Neu G, Bosacchi A, Franchi S: Temperature dependence of the radiative and nonradiative recombination time in GaAs-Ga

_{1−x}Al_{ x }As quantum-well structures.*Phys Rev B*1991, 44: 3115–3124. 10.1103/PhysRevB.44.3115Yang C, Carlson-Swindle JM, Lyon S, Worlock J: Hot-electron relaxation in GaAs quantum wells.

*Phys Rev Lett*1985, 55(21):2359. 10.1103/PhysRevLett.55.2359

## Acknowledgements

The work was supported by the 973 Program (2012CB921304, 2013CB632805, and 2012CB619306) and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (61474114 and 60990313).

## Author information

### Authors and Affiliations

### Corresponding author

## Additional information

### Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

### Authors’ contributions

LZ conducted the experiments and wrote the paper. LZ and YC designed the experiments and performed the sample fabrications. All authors contributed through scientific discussions and read and approved the final manuscript.

## Authors’ original submitted files for images

Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.

## Rights and permissions

**Open Access** This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made.

The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder.

To view a copy of this licence, visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

## About this article

### Cite this article

Zhu, L., Liu, Y., Gao, H. *et al.* Observation of anomalous linear photogalvanic effect and its dependence on wavelength in undoped InGaAs/AlGaAs multiple quantum well.
*Nanoscale Res Lett* **9, **493 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1186/1556-276X-9-493

Received:

Accepted:

Published:

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/1556-276X-9-493

### Keywords

- Spectra
- Anomalous linear photogalvanic effect
- Optical momentum alignment effect
- Momentum relaxation time