- Nano Express
- Open Access
Patterned growth of carbon nanotubes over vertically aligned silicon nanowire bundles for achieving uniform field emission
Nanoscale Research Letters volume 9, Article number: 540 (2014)
A fabrication strategy is proposed to enable precise coverage of as-grown carbon nanotube (CNT) mats atop vertically aligned silicon nanowire (VA-SiNW) bundles in order to realize a uniform bundle array of CNT-SiNW heterojunctions over a large sample area. No obvious electrical degradation of as-fabricated SiNWs is observed according to the measured current-voltage characteristic of a two-terminal single-nanowire device. Bundle arrangement of CNT-SiNW heterojunctions is optimized to relax the electrostatic screening effect and to maximize the field enhancement factor. As a result, superior field emission performance and relatively stable emission current over 12 h is obtained. A bright and uniform fluorescent radiation is observed from CNT-SiNW-based field emitters regardless of its bundle periodicity, verifying the existence of high-density and efficient field emitters on the proposed CNT-SiNW bundle arrays.
One-dimensional nanomaterials have attracted a tremendous amount of attention in recent years due to their interesting electronic and optical properties and a diverse array of potential for nanoscale device applications [1, 2]. Among the promising nanoelectronic applications, field emission and related devices have become the subject of intense fundamental and technological investigations because of their great potential for industrial applications, in particular as flat panel displays and electron guns [3–10]. Reports had shown that carbon nanotube (CNT)-based field emitter exhibits excellent field emission properties due to its superior thermal and electrical characteristic . However, the wire number density of as-grown CNTs is usually as high as 1010 CNTs/cm2. Such a dense CNT structure would suffer from the so-called electrostatic screening effect provoked by the proximity of neighboring wires which results in limited field emission performance. Alternatively, a pillar array of aligned CNT bundles had shown better field emission performance due to the release of the electrostatic screening effect . However, it is difficult to maintain the verticality of CNT bundles as the bundle periodicity becomes submicron scale to maximize the number of effective field emitters. Therefore, instead of using CNTs as both field emitter material and the supporting structure to obtain certain aspect ratio in conventional CNT bundle arrays, this work proposes to use vertically aligned silicon nanowires (VA-SiNWs) as the supporting template structures, while CNTs only serve as the emitter material. Recent results also focused on the synthesis of hybrid CNT-SiNW heterojunction array in order to take the advantages from both material systems for breakthrough findings in not only high performance electron field emitters but also many other emerging technologies [14–16]. We had previously demonstrated that VA-SiNWs could be realized with top-down wet chemical etching using a thin silver film as the catalyst . We also developed several fabrication processes to realize an array of VA-SiNW bundles using thin chemical oxide or thick photoresist (PR) as the mask to define the arrayed structure [18, 19]. In this work, mesa-type arrays of VA-SiNW bundles are realized to serve as an arrayed template for the growth of coarse CNT mats atop their surfaces. The proposed hybrid device leverages from the metallic-like property of CNTs and mature and flexible processing technologies available in silicon. The bundle arrangement of SiNW templates is optimized in order to release the electrostatic screening effect and to maximize the field enhancement factor. The material and electrical characterization of as-realized CNT-SiNW field emitter array as well as its emission uniformity and stability tests are conducted and discussed.
Synthesis of CNT-SiNW heterojunction bundle array
The fabrication procedure to realize the CNT-SiNW heterojunction bundle array is shown in Figure 1. The synthesis of VA-SiNW arrays is carried out on front-side polished, boron-doped (100) crystalline silicon wafers with an improved metal-induced chemical etching method which utilizes a thin silver film as catalysts to avoid the agglomeration issue of nanowires. As the facts that the motion of silver particles is preferentially along the silicon (100) crystallographic orientation , the entire etching process is optimized for obtaining VA-SiNWs without the use of additional nanopatterning processes. The process condition for SiNW formation is set as the concentrations of HF, H2O2, and H2O in oxidizing hydrofluoric acid solution being 6.72, 0.79, and 48 M, respectively, initial silver thickness of 20 nm, and etchant temperature of 25°C. The control of silver thickness is crucial to the success of VA-SiNW formation since the morphology of thin silver film changes with the thickness . The SiNW formation rate is about 1.2 μm/min. The control of wire length of SiNWs could be done by tuning the etching time. Residual silver catalysts are removed by nitric acid solution. In order to achieve the best alignment between SiNW and CNT patterns, a Fe/Al multilayer catalyst is deposited atop planar SiNWs by electron beam evaporation prior to the patterning process conducted by standard photolithography process using thick AZ-5214E PR to protect the catalysts and SiNWs at selective areas. The periodicity of the bundle array is controlled by the use of a photomask and at exposure/development conditions. Unmasked catalysts and SiNWs are then removed with hydrochloric acid and HNO3/HF/H2O etchants, respectively. The sample is then immersed in acetone for PR removal. Subsequent annealing is carried out at 750°C for 1 h at a pressure of about 0.1 Pa to form catalyst nanoparticles atop SiNW bundles. Thermal chemical vapor deposition (CVD) is then carried out with a growth temperature of 750°C and under a pressure of about 533 Pa maintained by flowing acetylene (C2H2) to grow CNT mats atop SiNW surface where the Fe/Al nanoparticles exist.
Material and electrical characterization
All materials are characterized by using a field emission scanning electron microscope (SEM), an atomic force microscope (AFM), a Raman spectrometer, and a transmission electron microscope (TEM). The field emission characteristics and long-term stability tests of all samples are measured in a stainless chamber in which the samples serve as the cathode electrode. The current-voltage characteristic is determined by manipulating an electrometer under a chamber pressure of around 1.33 × 10−5 Pa. Accordingly, the current density to electric field characteristic of the sample is derived from the measured current-voltage curve, the inter-electrode distance (150 μm), and the sample area (10 × 10 mm2). The field emission performance is analyzed according to the Fowler-Nordheim (F-N) equation: J = A(β2E2/Φ)exp(−BΦ3/2/βE), where J is the field emission current density, β is the overall field enhancement factor, E is the applied electric field (V/μm), A (1.54 × 10−6 AeV/V2) and B (6.8 × 103 eV−3/2 V/μm) are constants, and Φ is the work function (Φ is 4.8 and 4.15 eV for CNTs and SiNWs, respectively). The field enhancement factor is determined by the slope of the F-N plot.
For the electrical resistivity characterization of single SiNW, individual SiNWs are dispersed on the insulating Si3N4/n-Si template with pre-patterned Ti/Au microelectrodes. Electrical contacts of the two-terminal single-nanowire devices are fabricated by focused ion beam deposition using platinum as the metal electrode. Electrical measurements are carried out on an ultralow-current leakage cryogenic probe station. A semiconductor characterization system is utilized to source dc bias and measure current.
Fluorescent tests are conducted to verify the uniformity of field emission from the CNT-SiNW heterojunction bundle array. In this experiment, the metal anode is replaced with a fluorescent screen in which the phosphor powder is uniformly smeared on the graphene electrode to collect emission electrons, as indicated in Figure 2. The inter-electrode distance is fixed by a 150-μm-thick glass spacer, and the chamber pressure is 6.6 × 10−5 Pa.
Results and discussion
CNT-SiNW heterojunctions take the benefits of superior thermal and electrical characteristics from CNTs. Though the electric field on the SiNWs is shielded by the CNTs such that the SiNWs may not be able to contribute to the emission current, the wire number density of as-grown CNTs atop SiNWs is found to be lower than the density of the underlying SiNWs which is at least 1 order of magnitude lower than the density of CNTs grown on flat silicon surface. The generated emission current from coarse CNTs as the emitters atop VA-SiNWs would be enhanced due to the release of electrostatic screening effect that typically limits the emission performance in dense CNTs. Nevertheless, the density of SiNWs is still high on the order of 109 wires/cm2. The realization of an array of VA-SiNW bundles with a proper periodicity could further release the electrostatic screening effect and improve the field enhancement factor. This patterning approach had been verified by using an array of CNT bundles . Previous report discovered that the emission strength in the edge of CNT bundles is 3.5 times higher than that in the center of the bundles . The total edge area of the CNT-SiNW bundle array is then inversely proportional to the periodicity of the bundle array, indicating that smaller bundle periodicity would lead to better field emission performance. Prior to the patterning process shown in Figure 1, planar VA-SiNWs are prepared to have a nanowire length of around 2.44 μm, which is close to the optimal wire length of 2 μm according to the theoretical calculation taking both wire diameter and spacing into account. Figure 3a shows the SEM images of as-realized SiNW bundle array prior to the final PR removal step. The results indicate that thick PR could serve as the protecting mask to protect the SiNWs at selective areas from the chemical etching process, thus leads to the realization of a uniform SiNW bundle array. Figure 3b shows the cross-sectional SEM views of multi-walled CNT mats grown atop VA-SiNW bundle. The results verify the formation of CNTs only on top of SiNW bundles. According to the AFM results, the root mean square (rms) roughness of SiNW/catalyst removed areas is below 40 nm. The morphology of VA-SiNWs remains unchanged after the growth of CNTs. The bundle array of CNT-SiNW heterojunctions is fabricated with a hexagonal lattice and three periodicities (P = 20, 40, and 60 μm). Figure 4 shows the SEM image of the CNT-SiNW bundle array with an inter-bundle distance of 20 μm. The CNT mats cover the entire top surfaces of VA-SiNW bundles with precise alignment such that uniform bundle arrays of CNT-SiNW heterojunctions could be realized over a large sample area. We notice that the diameter of as-realized CNT-SiNW bundles shrinks by around 5 μm for all samples, which leads to a bundle diameter of 5, 15, and 25 μm for the corresponding CNT-SiNW bundle array with a periodicity of 20, 40, and 60 μm, respectively. The shrinkage may be due to the sinusoidal profile of the PR patterns such that the PR on the edge of the bundles cannot well protect the SiNWs during the wet chemical etching process.
Figure 5a shows the TEM image of individual CNT-SiNW heterojunction. As-grown CNTs are multi-walled with around 25 layers. The average diameters of as-realized SiNWs and CNTs are 90 and 30 nm, respectively. Their corresponding electron diffraction images reveal that SiNW retains the single-crystalline property whereas the CNT is polycrystalline. Raman spectra comparisons of SiNW and CNT-SiNW bundle array are shown in Figure 5b. The VA-SiNW bundle array shows characteristic Raman peaks at around 520, 960, and 300 cm−1, corresponding to the first-order transverse optical phonon mode (TO), the second-order transverse optical phonon mode (2TO), and the second-order transverse acoustic phonon mode (2TA), respectively . The downshift and decreased intensity of the characteristic peak at 520 cm−1 for the cases of patterned CNT-SiNW heterojunctions indicate that there is a direct interaction between the SiNWs and CNTs . After the patterned growth of CNTs, additional peaks appear in the Raman spectrum. The graphitic peak (G band) at 1,582 cm−1 is a peculiar characteristic of CNTs, which confirms that CNTs have grown on the surface of SiNWs . The peak at 1,350 cm−1 (D band) indicates the defective layers on the surfaces of CVD-grown CNTs . A relative determination of CNT quality can be found by comparing the ratio of the D band intensity (ID) over the G band intensity (IG). The ID/IG ratio of multi-walled CNTs varies from 0.47 (with best quality) to 1.58 (highly defective) depending on the growth method and catalyst/barrier combinations . The ID/IG ratio of as-grown CNTs in this work is about 0.83, indicating a slightly higher defect density in CNTs. Nevertheless, a previous study found no clear correlation between CNT quality as determined by Raman spectroscopy and CNT field emission due to the effects CNT areal density has on field emission , indicating that it is electrostatic screening effect that dominates the performance of a field emitter. The cause of higher defect density in CNTs grown atop SiNWs and the influence of defect density in CNTs to the field emission performance of the CNT-SiNW bundle array require further investigations.
For field emission applications, the use of CNTs as the emitter material would benefit from its metallic-like property and high thermal conductivity, while the advantages of using SiNWs would be the availability of mature and flexible processing technologies for silicon. Since the emission current flows through not only the CNTs but also the underlying SiNWs, the preservation of low bulk electrical resistivity in SiNWs is crucial to the success of this hybrid device. Figure 6a shows the top SEM view of a two-terminal single-nanowire device. This device is utilized to characterize the electrical resistivity of single SiNW. The diameter of the nanowire used in this experiment is 190 nm. The measured current-voltage characteristic of single SiNW is shown in Figure 6b. This experiment is conducted at room temperature in air ambience. The results reveal a linear relationship, indicating the ohmic contact condition of the nanowire device. Taking the nanowire length and diameter into account, the resistivity RSiNW of single nanowire is estimated at around 2.14 Ω cm, which is close to the resistivity of original silicon substrate RSi_sub. Similar current-voltage characteristic and electrical resistivity is also obtained from a single-nanowire device with a wire diameter of 700 nm fabricated with the same process procedure. The results indicate that the electrical property of SiNWs comes from its bulk silicon material. The total electrical resistivity of individual CNT-SiNW heterojunction is mainly determined by the resistivity of SiNWs and silicon substrate, as indicated in the inset of Figure 6b. To further reduce the series resistance of the field emitter, heavily doped silicon wafer could be used as the starting substrate for SiNW formation.
According to the measured electron field emission characteristics shown in Figure 7a, planar and patterned CNT-SiNW heterojunctions enable a turn-on electric field of 1.73 and 0.9 V/μm, respectively, while their emission current densities could reach 1.7 and 5.86 mA/cm2, respectively. Linear F-N plots derived from the measured field emission characteristics confirm that the emission detected originates from barrier tunneling quantum mechanical process. Therefore, the field enhancement factors of planar and patterned CNT-SiNW heterojunctions are calculated to be 1,915 and 3,380, respectively. Figure 7b shows the long-term field emission stability of planar and patterned CNT-SiNW heterojunctions. For comparison, different electric fields are applied to the respective devices in order to generate the same emission current density. Results indicate that the bundle array of CNT-SiNW heterojunctions exhibits relatively stable emission performance with a current fluctuation of about 10% over a 12-h period. Almost two times higher electric field is required for planar CNT-SiNW heterojunctions, thus leads to gradual emission degradation. The observed current-dependent degradation mechanism could be attributed to the interaction and energy dissipation during the solid-state transport of a high current density at the CNT apex, through the CNTs and SiNWs, or at the interface of CNT-SiNW and SiNW-substrate.Fluorescent tests are conducted to verify the uniformity of field emission from the CNT-SiNW bundle array. Figure 8 reveals the photographs of the fluorescent screens of the CNT-SiNW bundle array with an inter-bundle distance of 20, 40, and 60 μm, respectively, under an applied electric field of 2.66, 3, and 3.33 V/μm, respectively. Since a larger total edge area, thus better field emission performance, exists in the CNT-SiNW bundle array with a smaller periodicity, a higher electric field for samples with larger inter-bundle distances is applied in order to obtain similar emission current. Nevertheless, a uniform and bright fluorescent radiation is observed from all samples. The results indicate the existence of high-density and efficient field emitters on the proposed CNT-SiNW bundle arrays.
The realization of field emitters based on arrayed CNT-SiNW heterojunctions would benefit from the superior thermal and electrical properties of CNTs while taking the advantages of flexible patterning technologies available for SiNWs. The proposed field emitter is capable of generating >5 mA/cm2 emission current density with a turn-on electric field of 0.9 V/μm. With the proposed fabrication strategy, it is possible to further scale down the periodicity of the CNT-SiNW bundle array while maintaining the verticality of the supporting structure. To investigate the electrical conductivity of as-realized SiNWs, a two-terminal single-nanowire device is fabricated and characterized. The results indicate similar electrical resistivity between individual SiNW and original bulk silicon substrate, meaning that no obvious electrical degradation after SiNW fabrication is observed. Therefore, further reducing the series resistance of the field emitters could be achieved by simply using low-resistivity silicon wafer as the starting substrate. Raman spectra of CNT-SiNW bundle arrays also reveal direct interactions between CNTs and SiNWs. The bundle array of CNT-SiNW heterojunctions exhibits relatively stable emission performance with a current fluctuation of about 10% over a 12-h period, as compared to planar CNT-SiNW counterparts. Finally, a bright and uniform radiation from the fluorescent screens of CNT-SiNW bundle arrays is observed regardless of its bundle periodicity. The results indicate the existence of high-density and efficient field emitters on the proposed CNT-SiNW bundle arrays.
Y-JrH is the assistant professor at the Department of Photonics, National Sun Yat-sen University, Kaohsiung, Taiwan. His research interests include the realization of silicon-based nanostructures for applications in various emerging fields. Y-JH and H-CC are graduate students at the Department of Electronic Engineering, National Taiwan University of Science and Technology, Taipei, Taiwan, under the supervision of professor Kuei-Yi Lee. Their researches focus on carbon nanotube- and graphene-based materials and devices. S-LL is the distinguished professor at the Department of Electronic Engineering, National Taiwan University of Science and Technology. His research interests include semiconductor optoelectronic devices and optical networking.
Tzeng Y-F, Wu H-C, Sheng P-S, Tai N-H, Chiu HT, Lee CY, Lin I-N: Stacked silicon nanowires with improved field enhancement factor. ACS Appl Mater Inter 2010, 2: 331–334. 10.1021/am900490m
Xia Y, Yang P, Sun Y, Wu Y, Mayers B, Gates B, Yin Y, Kim F, Yan H: One-dimensional nanostructures: synthesis, characterization, and applications. Adv Mater 2003, 15: 353–389. 10.1002/adma.200390087
Lin ZD, Young SJ, Hsiao CH, Chang SJ, Huang CS: Improved field emission properties of Ag-decorated multi-walled carbon nanotubes. IEEE Photon Technol Lett 2013, 25: 1017–1019.
Lin CM, Chang SJ, Yokoyama M, Chuang FY, Tsai CH, Wang WC, Lin IN: Electron field emission characteristics of planar field emission array with diamondlike carbon electron emitters. Jpn J Appl Phys 1999, 38: 890–893. 10.1143/JJAP.38.890
Huang YJ, Chang HY, Chang HC, Shih YT, Su WJ, Ciou CH, Chen YL, Honda S, Huang YS, Lee KY: Field emission characteristics of vertically aligned carbon nanotubes with honeycomb configuration grown onto glass substrate with titanium coating. Mater Sci Eng B 2014, 182: 14–20.
de Heer WA, Chatelain A, Ugarte D: A carbon nanotube field-emission electron source. Science 1995, 270: 1179–1180. 10.1126/science.270.5239.1179
Tristan-Lopez F, Morelos-Gomez A, Vega-Diaz SM, Garcia-Betancourt ML, Perea-Lopez N, Elias AL, Muramatsu H, Cruz-Silva R, Tsuruoka S, Kim YA, Hayahsi T, Kaneko K, Endo M, Terrones M: Large area films of alternating graphene-carbon nanotube layers processed in water. ACS NANO 2013, 7: 10788–10798. 10.1021/nn404022m
Rai P, Mohapatra DR, Hazra KS, Misra DS, Tiwari SP: Nanotip formation on a carbon nanotube pillar array for field emission application. Appl Phys Lett 2008, 93: 131921. 10.1063/1.2996283
Zanin H, May PW, Hamanaka MHMO, Corat EJ: Field emission from hybrid diamond-like carbon and carbon nanotube composite structures. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces 2013, 5: 12238–12243. 10.1021/am403386a
Wang YY, Gupta S, Liang M, Nemanich RJ: Increased field emission site density from regrown carbon nanotube films. J Appl Phys 2005, 97: 104309. 10.1063/1.1897836
Kale VS, Sathe BR, Kushwaha A, Aslam M, Shelke MV: A novel catalyst-free synthesis of vertically aligned silicon nanowire-carbon nanotube heterojunction arrays for high performance electron field emitters. Chem Commun 2011, 47: 7785–7787. 10.1039/c1cc12243f
Komukai T, Aoki K, Furuta H, Furuta M, Oura K, Hirao T: Density control of carbon nanotubes through the thickness of Fe/Al multilayer catalyst. Jpn J Appl Phys 2006, 45: 6043–6045. 10.1143/JJAP.45.6043
Katayama M, Lee K-Y, Honda S, Hirao T, Oura K: Ultra-low-threshold field electron emission from pillar array of aligned carbon nanotube bundles. Jpn J Appl Phys 2004, 43: L774-L776. 10.1143/JJAP.43.L774
Lu M, Li MK, Zhang ZJ, Li HL: Synthesis of carbon nanotubes/Si nanowires core-sheath structure arrays and their field emission properties. Appl Surf Sci 2003, 218: 195–201.
Li X, Cho JH, Li N, Zhang Y, Williams D, Dayeh SA, Picraux ST: Carbon nanotube-enhanced growth of silicon nanowires as an anode for high-performance lithium-ion batteries. Adv Eng Mater 2012, 2: 87–93. 10.1002/aenm.201100519
Liu Y, Fan S: Field emission properties of carbon nanotubes grown on silicon nanowire arrays. Solid State Commun 2005, 133: 131–134. 10.1016/j.ssc.2004.09.058
Hung Y-J, Lee S-L, Wu K-C, Pan Y-T: Antireflective silicon surface with vertical-aligned silicon nanowires realized by simple wet chemical etching processes. Opt Express 2011, 19: 15792–15802. 10.1364/OE.19.015792
Hung Y-J, Lee S-L, Looi CB: Formation of mesa-type vertically-aligned silicon nanowire bundle arrays by selective-area chemical oxidation and etching processes. J Vac Sci Technol B 2012, 30: 030604. 10.1116/1.4711000
Hung Y-J, Lee S-L, Wu K-C, Pan Y-T: Realization and characterization of aligned silicon nanowire array with thin silver film. IEEE Photonics J 2011, 3: 617–626.
Peng K, Lu A, Zhang R, Lee S-T: Motility of metal nanoparticles in silicon and induced anisotropic silicon etching. Adv Funct Mater 2008, 18: 3026–3035. 10.1002/adfm.200800371
Koch R: The intrinsic stress of polycrystalline and epitaxial thin metal films. J Phys Condens Matter 1994, 6: 9519–9550. 10.1088/0953-8984/6/45/005
Fujii S, Honda S-I, Machida H, Kawai H, Ishida K, Katayama M, Furuta H, Hirao T, Oura K: Effiecient field emission from an individual aligned carbon nanotube bundle enhancement by edge effect. Appl Phys Lett 2007, 90: 153108. 10.1063/1.2721876
Temple PA, Hathaway CE: Multiphonon Raman spectrum of silicon. Phys Rev B 1973, 7: 3685–3697. 10.1103/PhysRevB.7.3685
Dresselhaus MS, Dresselhaus G, Saito R, Jorio A: Raman spectroscopy of carbon nanotubes. Phys Rep 2005, 409: 47–99. 10.1016/j.physrep.2004.10.006
Talapatra S, Kar S, Pal SK, Vajtai R, Cl L, Victor P, Shaijumon MM, Kaur S, Nalamasu O, Ajayan PM: Direct growth of aligned carbon nanotubes on bulk metals. Nat Nanotechnol 2006, 1: 112–116. 10.1038/nnano.2006.56
Matthews MJ, Pimenta MA, Dresselhaus G, Dresselhaus MS, Endo M: Origin of dispersive effects of the Raman D band in carbon materials. Phys Rev B 1999, 59: R6585. 10.1103/PhysRevB.59.R6585
Crossley BL, Glauvitz NE, Quinton BT, Coutu RA Jr, Collins PJ: Carbon nanotubes applications on electron devices: characterizing multi-walled carbon nanotube synthesis for field emission applications. In Tech Edited by: Marulanda JM. 2011, 105–126.
This work was supported in part by the National Science Council, Taiwan, under grant NSC 102-2218-E-110-010 and NSC 102-2218-E-011-002.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Y-JrH made substantial contributions to the conception, design, and implementation of the whole study. Y-JH contributed to the fluorescent test of CNT-SiNW field emitters. H-CC carried out the TEM characterization of CNT-SiNW heterjunction. K-YL and S-LL contributed to the data analysis as well as provided valuable advices to this study. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Hung, Y., Huang, Y., Chang, H. et al. Patterned growth of carbon nanotubes over vertically aligned silicon nanowire bundles for achieving uniform field emission. Nanoscale Res Lett 9, 540 (2014) doi:10.1186/1556-276X-9-540
- Silicon nanowire
- Carbon nanotube
- Metal-induced chemical etching
- Field emission
- Electrostatic screening effect