 Nano Express
 Open Access
 Published:
Thermodynamic Complexing of Monocyclopentadienylferrum (II) Intercalates with DoubleWalled Carbon Nanotubes
Nanoscale Research Letters volume 11, Article number: 128 (2016)
Abstract
By employing the methods of molecular mechanics, semiempirical quantumchemical РМ3 and MonteCarlo, the positioning of monocyclopentadienylferrum (II) molecules in doublewalled (5,5)@(10,10) carbon nanotubes (CNT) depending on their concentration and temperature has been studied. The molecules have been found out to form stable bonds with CNT walls, with a tendency between intercalate stability and the CNT structure. The temperature growth (over ~500 K) causes gradual bond ruining followed by extrusion of interwall intercalate. Further temperature increase up to 600–700 K is characterised with intercalate external surface desorption, stabilising the whole system and keeping the interwall intercalate only. The CNT’s UVspectrum (5,5)@(10,10) depending on the intercalate concentration and association constant of the “doublewalled CNT–intercalate” system have been calculated. A combination of unique optical, electrical and magnetic behaviour of cyclopentadienyl complexes with their ability to form highstable intercalate with CNT opens a prospect of their applying in nanotechnology.
Background
Unique physical properties of multiwalled nanosystems (especially of graphenebased ones) have been the subject of keen interest lately. Their specific energyband structure with a zero band gap and linear dependency of electron and hole energy spectrum from the wavevector cause the electric charges to behave like relativist particles with zero effective mass [1–3]. Anomalous transportation and field effects open a wide prospect of their applying in nanoelectronics [4–7]. Such nanostructures are assumed to be promising spintronics materials due to the long electronfree path, weak spinorbital interaction and the long spin scattering [8, 9]. What is more, the chemical or physical modification of multiwalled nanosystems enables to reveal their new extraordinary features. Thus, intercalation with atoms (molecules) allows to change the Fermi level position, relative electron and hole concentration, without considerable changes in energyband structure of source nanomaterials [10–12].
On the other hand, unique optical, electrical and magnetic, and also biological behaviour of cyclopentadienyl complexes [13] stimulate creation on their base of intercalates with multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNT), since the ability of these complexes to coordinate with MWCNT [6, 10] allows to obtain new materials (including catalytic methods with cyclopentadienyl catalysts [14]) as effective elements for photo and magnetosensitive devices.
As identification of structuretoproperty relations is an important task of chemistry and material physics, the aim of this work was to study the structure of intercalated monocyclopentadienylferrum (II) doublewalled CNT (DWCNT) under heating by the methods of molecular mechanics ММ+, semiempirical quantumchemical РМ3 and MonteCarlo, to calculate the UVspectrum of a DWCNT depending on intercalate concentration as well as to determine the association constant of the “DWCNTintercalate” system.
Methods
The initial structure was a (5,5)@(10,10) DWCNT having 270 carbon atoms. Intercalation of this DWCNT assumes placing the intercalate inside the (5,5) CNT, into intertubular space, and its differently oriented sorption on the outer surface of a (10,10) CNT.
The intercalate is the monocyclopentadienylferrum (II) molecule (Fig. 1).
It is their relative position, orientation relatively the CNT walls, behaviour in the intertubular space and the system as a whole, as well as the quantity characteristics of bonding with the DWCNT at temperature change that is the subject of this calculation.
In the model considered the interaction potential between Fe^{2+} ions (see Eq. (1)) and a cyclopentadienyl anion directly mated the pair potential of high energy of atomic excitation [15], and it was described by the BornMayer equation within 0–0.2815 nm of effective interaction radius (see Eq. (2)).
where r is the distance between particle centres, ε is the depth of potential pit and σ is the distance at which the interaction energy is equal to zero (parameters ε and σ characterise atoms of corresponding substances);
where m is the mass of a particle.
To describe the atom interaction at a distance smaller than 0.2 nm, there was a use of the TersoffBrenner potential of interatomic interaction [16]. Total potential energy of system U is expressed as a sum of bonding energies for all pairs of atoms forming this system.
where r _{ ij } is the distance between i and j atoms; V _{ A }(r) and V _{ R }(r) are the exponential functions of the Morse potential type which corresponds to the energies of attraction and repulsion between the atoms; and B _{ ij } ^{*} is the function expressing the dependence of binding energy of the і and j atoms from the angles θ _{ ijk } between the bond ij and close bonds ik and jk.
To describe the atom interaction at a distance greater than 0.21 nm, the TersoffBrenner potential of interatomic interaction was employed [16] along with the ZieglerBiersackLitmark pair potential [15]. The length of С–С bonds in a CNT was 0.139 nm, the Fe–C interaction was described by the LennardJones pair potential [17] with potential interaction energy 0.12 eV. The modelled period of one excitation cascade was 2 ps, and the energy conservation law in every calculation cycle was correlated within 0.15 %. The initial coordinates of the intercalate were selected in conformity with the law of random numbers.
To do the task above, the following numerical modelling scheme was used [10, 11]:

(1)
The first calculation stage was based on the ММ+ molecular mechanics method;

(2)
The second stage was based on the semiempirical РМ3 method. It should be noted that the main distinction of this method from the others is their different parameterisation. In our case, РМ3 method was parameterised to the best match of calculated and experimental molecule formation heats;

(3)
The third stage was based on the MonteCarlo method.
To calculate the association constant of the “DWCNTintercalate” complex formed, the modified BenesHilderbrand method [18] that accounts the data on the maximum DWCNT absorption values at various intercalate concentrations in the UVspectrum was employed.
Results and Discussion
Modelling the “DWCNT–intercalate” system resulted in such statements. First, the four intercalate molecules in the intertubular space form a hightemperature resistant system—up to ~475 K, being completely and quickly extruded at higher temperatures. Second, two of the four monocyclopentadienylferrum (II) molecules placed beside the outer side surface of the (10,10) CNT are desorbed at the temperature ~600 K. The other two intercalate molecules are within the effective interaction radius, remaining sorbed up to the temperature ~750 K. Third, all the monocyclopentadienylferrum (II) molecules being in the inner (5,5) CNT are stable regardless of the temperature factor. Last, the two sorbed intercalate molecules which were not desorbed from the outer side surface of the (10,10) CNT were oriented at the latter one by the cyclopentadienyl ring, but not by Fe^{2+}.
The studied system (see Fig. 2) proved to be rather heatresistant in a wide temperature range (up to ~900 K). At that, the deformation vibrations of the DWCNT’s crystal grate do not exceed 0.015 nm, and the vibrations of the intercalate molecules do not exceed 0.025 nm that provides for configuration and conformation stability of the system.
Temperature dependence of the model system energy is shown in Fig. 3. As it is seen, when initially heated from 273 to ~425 K, the system energy grows gradually and then rises sharply between 425–475 K and 725–750 K, then, with temperature growth, it reaches the plateau that proves its high stability up to ~900 K.
The modelling performed allows to determine the following dynamics of the intercalated DWCNT structure under heating: when being initially heated to ~425 K, the system remains rather stable; there is no extrusion of the intercalate molecules. There are observed vibrational and rotational (along the quintic axis) capabilities of bonds and angles of a DWCNT and monocyclopentadienylferrum (II) molecules. When the system temperature is increased to ~500 K, the rapid intercalate extrusion out of the intertube space of the system appears. At the temperature of ~600 K, the desorption from the outer surface of only two intercalate molecules being ferrumoriented to the DWCNT wall is observed. At the temperature of over ~800 K, the full external desorption appears while the inner (5,5) CNT remains completely filled (Fig. 4 shows the screenshot of configurational change of the “DWCNTintercalate” system under heating).
It should be noted that this variant of the model suggested allows to observe thermodynamic selectivity of physical and chemical sorptiondesorption. At the temperature range 273–425 K, the physical sorption whose natural feature is most likely to overlap the nonhybrisized orbital 3d _{ xy } of the Fe^{2+} ion with the πsystem of the DWCNT side surface appears while chemisorption is observed at higher temperature values (~600 K), that is peculiar or ππ interactions of aromatic and quasiaromatic cyclic and heterocyclic systems.
Moreover, simultaneous presence of donor/acceptor feature of the DWCNT’s intertube space as a result of positive and negative Gaussian curvature makes it possible to regulate orientation of intercalate’s donor and acceptor edges, which allows to view it as a potential molecular switch.
Finally, theoretical calculations of UVabsorption spectra of the (5,5)@(10,10) DWCNT depending on the intercalate concentration in terms of the modified BenesHilderbrand method (Fig. 5) show that the association constant of the system studied is 6.745 l · mol^{−1}.
Conclusions
The type of monocyclopentadienylferrum (II) molecule arrangement on the outer side surface and on the inner surface as well as in the intertube space of the (5,5)@(10,10) DWCNT has been found. The calculations made allow to prove discover that the “DWCNTintercalate” system is rather stable at high temperature (up to ~425 K) that provides reliability and stability of the process of intercalate synthesis under conditions regular for this procedure. However, at further heating (over ~500 K), the gradual intercalate extrusion out of the intertube space and intercalate’s outer surface desorption (at the temperature 600–700 К) as well as thermodynamic stabilisation of the system containing the intertube intercalate only are observed. The association constant of the “DWCNTintercalate” system has been theoretically calculated, and it is equal to 6.745 l · mol^{−1}.
References
 1.
Novoselov KS, Jiang D, Schedin F, Booth TJ, Khotkevich VV, Morozov SV, Geim AK (2005) Twodimensional atomic crystals. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 102:10451–10453
 2.
Son YW, Cohen ML, Louie SG (2006) Halfmetallic graphene nanoribbons. Nature 444:347–349
 3.
Geim AK, Novoselov KS (2007) The structure of suspended graphene sheets. Nature 346:60–63
 4.
Matsui DV, Prylutskyy Yu I, Matzuy LY, Normand F, Le RU, Scharff P (2008) Transverse and longitudinal magnetoresistance in graphite intercalated by Co. Physica E 40(7):2630–2634
 5.
Matsui D, Ovsiyenko I, Lazarenko O, Prylutskyy Y, Matsui V (2011) Abnormal electron transport in graphite intercalation compounds with iron. Mol Cryst Liq Cryst 535(1):64–73
 6.
Ritter U, Scharff P, Grechnev GE, Desnenko VA, Fedorchenko AV, Panfilov AS, Prylutskyy Yu I, Kolesnichenko Yu A (2011) Structure and magnetic properties of multiwalled carbon nanotubes modified with cobalt. Carbon 49(13):4443–4448
 7.
Ritter U, Tsierkezos NG, Prylutskyy Yu I, Matzui LY, Gubanov VO, Bilyi MM, Davydenko MO (2012) Structureelectrical resistivity relationship of Ndoped multiwalled carbon nanotubes. J Mater Sci 47(5):2390–2395
 8.
Durkop T, Kim BM, Fuhrer MS (2004) Properties and applications of highmobility semiconducting nanotubes. J Phys Condens Matter 16:553–580
 9.
Kane CL, Mele EJ (2005) Quantum spin hall effect in graphene. Phys Rev Lett 95:226801–226805
 10.
Мykhailenko O, Matsui D, Prylutskyy Y, Normand F, Le EP, Scharff P (2007) Monte Carlo simulation of intercalated carbon nanotubes. J Mol Model 13(1):283–287
 11.
Mykhailenko OV, Prylutskyy Yu I, Matsuy DV, Strzhemechny YM, Normand F, Le RU, Scharff P (2010) Structure and thermal stability of Co and Feintercalated double graphene layers. J Comput Theor Nanosci 7(6):996–999
 12.
Grechnev GE, Lyogenkaya AA, Kolesnichenko YA, Prylutskyy YI, Hayn R (2014) Electronic structure and magnetic properties of graphite intercalated with 3dmetals. Low Temp Phys 40(5):580–584
 13.
Liu Z, Habtemariam A, Pizarro A, Clarkson G, Sadler P (2011) Organometallic iridium (III) cyclopentadienyl anticancer complexes containing C,Nchelating ligands. Organometallics 30(17):4702–4710
 14.
Ionescu MI, Zhang Y, Li R, Sun X, AbouRachid H, Lussier LS (2011) Hydrogenfree spray pyrolysis chemical vapor deposition method for the carbon nanotube growth: parametric studies. Appl Surf Sci 257(15):6843–6849
 15.
Rapaport DC (1995) The art of molecular dynamics simulation. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, p 237
 16.
Tersoff J (1989) Modelling solid–state chemistry: interatomic potentials for multicomponent systems. Phys Rev 39:5566–5568
 17.
Dorfman S, Mundim KC, Fuks D, Berner A, Ellis DE, Van Humbeeck J (2001) Snapshot of an electron orbital. Mat Sci and Eng 15:191–201
 18.
Mukhopadhyay M, Banerjee D, Koll A, Mandal A, Filarowski A, Fitzmaurice D, Das R, Mukherjee S (2005) Excited state intermolecular proton transfer and caging of salicylidine3,4,7methylamine in cyclodexrins. J Photochem Photobiol A 175(2–3):94–99
Author information
Additional information
Competing Interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Authors' Contributions
All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
About this article
Cite this article
Мykhailenko, О.V., Prylutskyy, Y.I., Кomarov, І.V. et al. Thermodynamic Complexing of Monocyclopentadienylferrum (II) Intercalates with DoubleWalled Carbon Nanotubes. Nanoscale Res Lett 11, 128 (2016) doi:10.1186/s1167101613517
Received
Accepted
Published
DOI
Keywords
 Association Constant
 Outer Side Surface
 Model System Energy
 Intercalate Molecule
 Intertubular Space