- Nano Express
- Open Access
MoS2/C Multilayer Nanospheres as an Electrode Base for Lithium Power Sources
Nanoscale Research Letters volume 11, Article number: 243 (2016)
Multilayer nanospheres with alternating 2H-MoS2 and C layers were studied as a cathode base for lithium power sources. Interesting hierarchical structure, synergetic effect, and the presence of defects as supplementary active sites, introduced by the additional annealing at 773 K in Ar atmosphere, have determined the conductivity, referred to symmetric hopping or random barrier model, and led to achieve the high values of specific capacity of 3700, 1390, and 790 A h kg−1 at currents 0.1, 0.3, and 0.5 C. Such unusual result was never reported before and could be explained by combining of the faradaic and non-faradaic accumulation processes within electrode material.
Since the batteries were introduced in 1980s as new high-energy density power sources, one of the most promising materials used as electrode materials for further commercialization was MoS2. Being a layered transition metal dichalcogenide compound, it possesses the ability to accommodate Li ions within interlayer spaces that are due to the noncovalent Van der Waals forces between S-Mo-S packages. Taking into account its low cost, owing to the natural abundance, the first MoS2-based commercial batteries were developed by Moli Energy Ltd., (British Columbia, Canada) in 1989 and have the specific energy values 100 W h kg−1 [1, 2]. In spite of few failures in operating such systems, the study of MoS2 as an electrode material still is continuing.
Theoretically, the capacity of MoS2 is about 167 A h kg−1, when in conversion reaction, only one mole of Li+ takes part per mole of MoS2, but reported typical capacity value even for bulk material is more than 600 A h kg−1 and became a reason to consider at least four Li+ ions intercalated per MoS2 unit. According to , it takes around six lithium ions during the first discharge cycle. However, the first discharge process capacity of the MoS2 quickly decreases by several times. Most of the intercalated Li+ ions remain localized in the crystal structure within the interlayer space between S-Mo-S packages after the first discharge in nanostructures despite that the Li+ diffusion path is significantly shortened in comparison to bulk material. Both bulk and exfoliated materials exhibit capacity reduction upon cycling; moreover, for exfoliated MoS2, this decrease can be more sharp [4, 5]. The initial discharge capacity of exfoliated MoS2 is typically more than 1000 A h kg−1, and capacity gain is caused by the Li2S formation and Mo metal reduction. MoS2 can be additionally exfoliated via lithium intercalation with a metastable phase formation: electron transfer from lithium during the intercalation causes the change in the electron density and the additional deformation of crystal structure, in particular, in Mo symmetry—from trigonal prismatic (2H) to octahedral. The increasing of MoS2 structural disorder leads to the possibility for more Li+ ions to reversibly penetrate into the expanded interlayer spaces. But still, the capacity of exfoliated MoS2 dramatically decreases with the increasing of cycle number.
The electrochemical performance of MoS2 as an electrode for lithium batteries was believed to be significantly influenced by morphology, structure, and particle size. In order to shorten the Li+ diffusion path for improving the performance, many research efforts have been directed to prepare nanostructured MoS2 for application as electrode material. The most popular approach to increase the capacity is to enlarge the interlayer distance and lower the barrier for Li+ intercalation. A good example is MoS2 nanoplates , consisting of disordered graphene-like layers, with a thickness of ∼30 nm and interlayer distance of 0.69 nm (for bulk, it is 0.62 nm), that showed reversible capacity of 700 A h kg−1 even at 50 C. Another way is to play on morphology effect; 3D MoS2 nanospheres  and flower-like structures  have been demonstrated with the reversible capacity of >850 A h kg−1 however at low current rates. In the same time, 1D nanoribbons and nanotubes possess 776 A h kg−1 [9, 10].
But the latest tendency is a combination of MoS2 with carbon materials (as nanotubes, carbon coating, and graphene). Being a good conductor and chemically stable substance, it contributes to the overall conductivity of the composite, facilitating the charge transfer within the material, and prevents the volume expansion and restacking of MoS2. The synergetic effect between these two materials improves the electrochemical performance of the composite in Li batteries. Indeed, a MoS2/GNS (graphene nanosheets) composite with a Mo to C mole ratio of 1:2 that delivered the highest specific capacity (1300 A·h·kg-1), although the specific capacity of samples with mole ratios of 1:1 and 1:4 (i.e., 1001 A·h·kg-1and 1132 A·h·kg-1, respectively) still exhibited high specific capacity and better cycling stability than pure MoS2 and GNS. One of the largest reported value of specific capacity is 1549 A·h·kg-1 for 2D MoS2 grown on the surface of 1D multiwall carbon nanotubes . At the same time, it should be taken into account the possibility of pseudocapacitive mechanism of charge storage with electron transfer and oxidation/reduction of Mo4+ . In some cases, the contribution of pseudocapacity is dominant and has significant impact on the electrochemical performance .
Here, we present hierarchically structured nanospheres with alternating layers of MoS2 and carbon as an electrode base for lithium power sources. Studied nanocomposite showed the very high specific capacity during Li+ intercalation and interesting conductivity features.
The synthesis procedure was based on the hydrothermal method described in . XRD study confirmed the formation of 2H-MoS2 (P63/mmc) (Fig. 1); TEM, SEM, and EDS investigations (FEI Technai G2 X-TWIN and VEGA 3 TESCAN microscopes) showed that the obtained nanocomposite consists of mostly spherical particles with a size of near 40–70 nm composed of alternating layers of 2H-MoS2 and carbon (Fig. 2a, Fig. 3). Additional annealing led to partial rupture of the spherical particles due to gas releasing during the surfactant decomposition (Fig. 2b), but the relative contents of Mo, S, and C atoms, received from EDS analysis, remain unchanged (Table 1).
Electrical conductivity σ as a function of frequency (0.01–100 kHz range) and temperature were measured by the method of impedance spectroscopy (Autolab, PGSTAT12, FRA-2 software). All samples were made in pellet form with the diameter of 1.7 × 10−2 m and thickness of 0.6 × 10−3 m under pressure of 34 MPa. Taking into account the nature of ultrafine material to avoid, the probable oxidation of the air at it was chosen to conduct the conductivity evaluation is in the narrow temperature range of 293–333 K with precision of ±1 K.
The galvanostatic and potentiodynamic measurements were conducted in two electrode cells with Li as a counter electrode and 1М LiPF6 in a 50:50 (w/w) mixture of ethylene carbonate and diethyl carbonate as an electrolyte. The working electrode consists of a test material (MoS2/C multilayered nanospheres), carbon black, and polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF) in a weight ratio of 8:1:1 coated on Cu foil.
Results and Discussion
Frequency dependence of the real part of the conductivity of the MoS2/C nanosphere samples dried at 353 K (Fig. 4a) has the typical look of condensed disordered dielectrics and semiconductors: asymptotic approximation to a certain value at constant current and constant power dependence at high frequencies. Meanwhile, as it is seen in Fig. 4b, the frequency dependence of conductivity of MoS2/C annealed in Ar atmosphere at 773 K differs. TEM confirmed that heat treatment led to partial destruction of multilayer nanospheres; however, the XRD patterns are similar indicating on the rigidity of 2H-MoS2 structure of the material. The morphology changes dramatically affect the electrical properties of the material and the value of conductivity, being increased from 0.4 × 10−4 to 1.95 × 10−4 Sm−1. The typical conductivity of MoS2 is in the range of 10–6–10–8 Sm–1 [16, 17], and the achieved conductivity growth in our case should have an influence on the overall electrochemical performance. The conductivity of the annealed samples increases by an order at high frequencies with the next saturation. With the increase of the annealing temperature, the equilibrium conductivity characteristic value decreases and its saturation is achieved at relatively lower frequencies. According to Dyre and Schrøder , the dependences σ(ω) of such type are characteristic for the case of materials disordered at the microscopic level.
where σ dc is a conductivity at constant current; ω h is a charge carrier hopping frequency; and s is an exponent, which characterizes the system deflection of the properties provided by Debye model, and is a measure of interparticle interactions, 0 < s < 1. From the received data, we have plotted the temperature dependences of σ dc, ω h and s. It is found that in the case of as-prepared nanocomposite, MoS2/C parameter s varies nonlinearly with increasing temperature, getting the minimum value at 313 K and determining the change of carrier hopping frequency (Fig. 5a). The observed temperature dependence of s parameter even for such a narrow range of T change indicates the conduction mechanisms other than quantum tunneling of electrons and is a typical for good crystalline samples of MoS2 . Apparently, the observed features are the result of the carbon presence. Probably, the temperature in the vicinity of 313 K activates the electron transition from the impurity levels in the forbidden zone. The results allowed to build the Arrhenius plot and determine the activation energy for the conduction of the material in the given temperature range, which is evaluated as 0.192 ± 0.010 еV and is in good agreement with published data for МоS2. Conductivity of bulk MoS2 is typically nonlinear dependent on temperature, in particular, the conductivity activation energy at the temperatures lower than room temperature lies in the range of 0.03–0.15 eV and above 760 K—0.4–0.9 еV . Usually, such behavior is a characteristic of doped semiconductors with impurity conductivity below and intrinsic above 773 K.
where p = 1/(d + 1), and d is the dimensionality of the system; thus, in our case, p = 1/4 . The resulting calculated value of the characteristic temperature T 0 is 3.05 × 106 K, which is several times higher than for atomically thin layers of MoS2  and defines the effective density of the states near the Fermi level of the material, herewith the observed inverse dependence of these parameters.
In the case of materials obtained after annealing at 773 K in a stream of argon, the σ(ω) dependences (Fig. 4b) were approximated just partially to the zone of inflection. It was found that parameter s for this material is weakly dependent on the annealing temperature, varying within the approximation error within 0.33–0.37. Thus, we can assume that in this case, we observe the displays of quantum mechanical tunneling of charge carriers . As it was already mentioned, the curves σ(ω) have a distinctive look, indicating a higher level of disorder. In this case, it becomes possible to use the symmetric hopping model (or random barrier model), whereby the charge transfer is a jump between close equilibrium positions in non-periodic potential . In this model, the probability of hopping between individual positions is considered as the same with the normal distribution of potential barrier height, which provides no explicit value of activation energy. Reducing the equilibrium conductivity with increasing frequency and temperature is explained as follows: energy comes into the system as a result of both thermal excitation and application of the external periodic potential. At lower temperatures, the hops occur at higher frequencies, and thermal excitation effect is small. Thus, the frequency growth causes an increase of hop probability over the barriers, the heights of whose are distributed by the Gauss function, which explains the smooth curve growth progress—a sharp increase (area corresponded to the vicinity of mode value of the barrier height)—a saturation. With increasing temperature, this situation persists on providing the probability growth of carrier scattering on phonons and saturation at relatively lower frequencies.
For next study of electrochemical properties, we decided to take the MoS2/C multilayer nanospheres after thermal treatment, based on results described above. Galvanostatic measurements for this material as an electrode base for lithium power sources at currents 0.1, 0.3, and 0.5 C gave the specific capacity values at 3700, 1390, and 790 A h kg−1, respectively (Fig. 6). The calculated specific energy values are 5380, 1370, and 702 W h kg−1. Coulumbic efficiencies for the first and fifth discharge-charge cycles are 21.3 and 63.1 % at 0.3 C (Fig. 6b) and 46.6 and 63.4 % at 0.5 C (Fig. 6c). Such high values of specific capacity were not achieved before for any MoS2-based system presented in the literature.
In turn, cyclic voltammograms (Fig. 7) in the 0–3.0 V potential window at different scanning rates (0.5, 0.4, and 0.3 mV s−1) correspond to quasi-reversible system and are very similar to CVs obtained for single-layered ultrasmall nanoplates MoS2 embedded in carbon nanowires . Two cathodic peaks in the vicinity of 1 and 0.6 V can be attributed to the intercalation of Li+ into the interlayer spacing of MoS2 to form LixMoS2, accompanied by phase transformation from the 2H (trigonal prismatic) to 1T (octahedral molybdenum coordination) MoS2 structure [27–29]. Electron transfer from lithium during intercalation changed the electron density causing the deformation of crystal structure. A peak at ~0.6 V is attributed to the following conversion reaction (3):
anodic peak at approximately 1.7 V is due to the removal of Li+ ions and incomplete oxidation of Mo. The peak 2.3 V, which in the literature data corresponds to the formation of MoS2, is absent, signifying on the partial reversibility of the processes that occurred in the studied system. Moreover, Wang et al. [7, 27] assumed that Li2S is likely to be oxidized into S during the anodic scans. Thus, the possible reaction describes the Li storage mechanism as
The Randles-Ševcik Eq. (5) for such quasi-reversible system at 298 K defines the diffusion coefficient D as a slope of linear dependence of peak current I p on the square root of scan rate V (Fig. 8) 
where n is the electron transfer number in the electrode reaction, A is the cathode surface, and C is the bulk concentration of electroactive particles. It is calculated in such manner that D = 1.65 × 10−10 cm2 s−1; however, it should be noted that the intercept of the resulted line does not equal zero, which signifies the complex rate-limiting processes, i.e., a mixture of diffusion and surface processes . The studied redox species are partially adsorbed on the electrode surface or confined in a film matrix. This assumption could also explain the overall cyclic voltammograms look: the Li+ accumulation at the interfaces results in broadening and nearly rectangular shape between 0 and 1.4 V, which is a characteristic of supercapacitors . According to , the intercalation and the pseudocapacity contributions can coexist. Thus, the high capacity value of MoS2/C multilayered nanospheres is a result of faradaic charge transfer processes and non-faradaic charge species storage at the interfaces or possibly at the inner surfaces of hollow multilayered nanospheres. The annealing caused numerous breaches, increasing the edges sites that have higher Li binding energies than the inner sites, implying a remarkable edge effect [9, 32, 33]. In particular, the S edge of the MoS2 is more favorable to bind Li than the Mo edge and favors the active material to achieve a high specific capacity due to the increasing number of intercalated Li atoms. In addition, the hollow spherical structure could effectively tolerate the volume change caused by the discharge-charge processes, reduce the diffusion distance of lithium ions, and facilitate the charge diffusion due to carbon presence. But still, there is not good cycling performance and capacity loss due to the electrolyte decomposition and inevitable formation of solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) and/or some lithium trapping inside the lattice .
Spherical nanoparticles with alternating MoS2 and C layers synthesized by hydrothermal method were studied as an electrode base for Li power sources. It was determined that the obtained values of specific capacity (3700, 1390, and 790 A h kg−1 at currents 0.1, 0.3, and 0.5 C, respectively) are caused by synergetic effect of the following factors: (i) deformation, expanding, and breaches of MoS2 crystal structure as a result of carbon layers’ presence and thermal treatment; (ii) conductivity growth for MoS2/C nanocomposite comparatively to bulk materials; and (iii) combination both faradaic and pseudocapacitive non-faradaic mechanisms of charge accumulation. The conductivity character of the obtained MoS2/C composite is being changed after thermal treatment from typical for crystalline MoS2 to symmetric hopping or random barrier model. The conductivity saturation point, observed in the annealed material, is balancing between temperature and frequency of applied field and decreasing at higher temperatures. Without modifying the 2H structure of MoS2, the annealing has introduced a number of defects—the supplementary active sites—where the redox reactions occur. This together with spherical hollow structure of MoS2/C nanoparticles affected the results of galvanostatic and potentiodynamic studies.
Haering RR, Stiles JAR, Brandt K. Lithium molybdenum disulfide battery cathode. US Patent 4224390. 1980
Levy SC, Bro P (1994) Rechargeable lithium systems. In: Levy SC, Bro P (eds) Battery hazards and accident prevention. Springer, New York, pp 257–272
Julien C, Samaras I, Saikh S, Balkanski M (1988) Lithium electrochemical investigations of crystalline layered compounds. MRS Proc 135:467–472
Kumar Sen U, Sarkar S, Srinivas Veluri P, Singh S, Mitra S (2013) Nano dimensionality: a way towards better Li-ion storage. Nanosci Nanotechnol Asia 3(1):21–35
Xiao J, Choi D, Cosimbescu L, Koech P, Liu J, Lemmon JP (2010) Exfoliated MoS2 nanocomposite as an anode material for lithium ion batteries. Chem Mater 22(16):4522–4524
Hwang H, Kim H, Cho J (2011) MoS2 nanoplates consisting of disordered graphene-like layers for high rate lithium battery anode materials. Nano Lett 11(11):4826–4830
Meng W, Guangda L, Huayun X, Yitai Q, Jian Y (2013) Enhanced lithium storage performances of hierarchical hollow MoS2 nanoparticles assembled from nanosheets. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces 5:1003–1008
Yutao L, Xiayin Y, Jingyun Y, Gang P, Ping C, Xiaoxiong X (2015) MoS2 nanoflowers consisting of nanosheets with a controllable interlayer distance as high performance lithium ion battery anodes. RSC Adv 5:7938–7943
Li Y, Wu D, Zhou Z, Cabrera CR, Chen Z (2012) Enhanced li adsorption and diffusion on MoS2 zigzag nanoribbons by edge effects: a computational study. J Phys Chem Lett 3(16):2221–2227
Zhang C, Wang Z, Guo Z, Lou XW (2012) Synthesis of MoS2-C one-dimensional nanostructures with improved lithium storage properties. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces 4(7):3765–3768
Chang K, Chen W (2011) In situ synthesis of MoS2/graphene nanosheet composites with extraordinarily high electrochemical performance for lithium ion batteries. Chem Commun 47:4252–4254
Shi Y, Wang Y, Wong JI, Tan AYS, Hsu CL, Li LJ, Lu YC, Yang HY (2013) Self-assembly of hierarchical MoSx/CNT nanocomposites (2 < x < 3): towards high performance anode materials for lithium ion batteries. Sci Rep 3:2169
Bissett MA, Kinloch IA, Dryfe RA (2015) Characterization of MoS2-graphene composites for high-performance coin cell supercapacitors. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces 7(31):17388–17398
Hu Z, Wang L, Zhang K, Wang J, Cheng F, Tao Z, Chen J (2014) MoS2 nanoflowers with expanded interlayers as high‐performance anodes for sodium‐ion batteries. Angew Chem 126(47):13008–13012
Shyyko LO, Kotsyubynsky VO, Budzulyak IM, Rawski M, Kulyk YO, Lisovski RP (2015) Synthesis and double‐hierarchical structure of MoS2/C nanospheres. Phys Status Solidi A 212(10):2309–2314
Ahmad M, Rafiq M, Imran Z, Rasool K, Shahid R, Javed Y, Hasan M (2013) Charge conduction and relaxation in MoS2 nanoflakes synthesized by simple solid state reaction. J Appl Phys 114(4):043710
Benavente E, Santa Ana M, Gonzalez G (2004) Electrical conductivity of MoS2 based organic-inorganic nanocomposites. Phys Status Solidi B 241(10):2444–2447
Dyre JC, Schrøder TB (2000) Universality of ac conduction in disordered solids. Rev Mod Phys 72:873–892
Jonscher AK (1996) Universal relaxation law. Chelsea Dielectric Press, London
Lee JK, Park HW, Choi HW, Kim JE, Kim SJ, Yang YS (2005) Dielectric properties of BaTi2O5 glass. J Korean Phys Soc 47:S267–S270
Ghosh S, Najmaei S, Kar S, Vajtai R, Lou J, Pradhan NR, Balicas L, Ajayan PM, Talapatra S (2014) Universal ac conduction in large area atomic layers of CVD-grown MoS2. Phys Rev B 89(12):125422
Belougne P, Giuntini JC, Zanchetta JV (1986) A.c. conductivity in molybdenum sulphides. Philos Mag B 53(3):233–246
El-Mahblawy SH, Evans BL (1977) Temperature dependence of the electrical conductivity and hall coefficient in 2H-MoS2, MoSe2, WSe2, and MoTe2. Phys Status Solidi B 79:713–722
Mott NF, Davis EA (1971) Electronic processes in non-crystalline materials. Clarendon Press, Oxford
Ghatak S, Pal AN, Ghosh A (2011) Nature of electronic states in atomically thin MoS2 field-effect transistors. ACS Nano 5(10):7707–7712
Zhu C, Mu X, Van Aken PA, Yu Y, Maier J (2014) Single‐layered ultrasmall nanoplates of MoS2 embedded in carbon nanofibers with excellent electrochemical performance for lithium and sodium storage. Angew Chem Int Ed 53(8):2152–2156
Fang X, Guo X, Mao Y, Hua C, Shen L, Hu Y, Wang Z, Wu F, Chen L (2012) Mechanism of lithium storage in MoS2 and the feasibility of using Li2S/Mo nanocomposites as cathode materials for lithium-sulfur batteries. Chem Asian J 7:1013–1017
Liu H, Su D, Zhou R, Sun B, Wang G, Qiao SZ (2012) Highly ordered mesoporous MoS2 with expanded spacing of the (002) crystal plane for ultrafast lithium ion storage. Adv Energy Mater 2:970–975
Hu L, Ren Y, Yang H, Xu Q (2014) Fabrication of 3D hierarchical MoS2/polyaniline and MoS2/C architectures for lithium-ion battery applications. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces 6:14644–14652
Brownson DAC, Banks CE (2014) The handbook of graphene electrochemistry. Springer-Verlag, London
Zhu N, Han S, Gan S, Ulstrup J, Chi Q (2013) Graphene paper doped with chemically compatible Prussian blue nanoparticles as nanohybrid electrocatalyst. Adv Funct Mater 23:5297–5306
Lu J, Lu JH, Liu H, Liu B, Chan KX, Lin J, Chen W, Loh KP, Sow CH (2014) Improved photoelectrical properties of MoS2 films after laser micromachining. ACS Nano 8(6):6334–6343
Lu J, Lu JH, Liu H, Liu B, Gong L, Tok ES, Loh KP, Sow CH (2015) Microlandscaping of Au nanoparticles on few-layer MoS2 films for chemical sensing. Small 11:1792–1800
The authors are very thankful to Michal Rawski, the specialist at the Analytical Laboratory of the Faculty of Chemistry, Maria Curie-Skłodowska University (Lublin, Poland), for the TEM and EDS investigation of the studied material and for invaluable support and help.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
VOK offered the general concept of obtaining and studying MoS2/C nanocomposite and was also involved in drafting the manuscript and the interpretation of data. IMB gave the idea of such nanocomposite to be created and participated in the analysis of the data. PS provided some structural investigations and interpretation of the received results. LOS carried out the experimental procedures and interpretation of the obtained results and drafted the manuscript, and is also the corresponding author. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
VOK is a doctor of physics and mathematics and professor at the Department of Materials Science and New Technology, Physical and Technical Faculty at Vasyl Stefanyk Precarpathian National University. IBM is a doctor of physics and mathematics; professor at the Department of Materials Science and New Technology, Physical and Technical Faculty at Vasyl Stefanyk Precarpathian National University; director of the Science and Educational Center “Nanomaterials in energy generation and storage devices” supported by the CRDF/USAID. PS has a PhD in chemistry and is a researcher at the Centre for Innovation and Transfer of Natural Sciences and Engineering Knowledge at University of Rzeszow. LOS is a PhD student at the Department of Materials Science and New Technology, Physical and Technical Faculty at Vasyl Stefanyk Precarpathian National University.