- Nano Express
- Open Access
Carbon Nanotube-Silicon Nanowire Heterojunction Solar Cells with Gas-Dependent Photovoltaic Performances and Their Application in Self-Powered NO2 Detecting
Nanoscale Research Letters volume 11, Article number: 299 (2016)
A multifunctional device combining photovoltaic conversion and toxic gas sensitivity is reported. In this device, carbon nanotube (CNT) membranes are used to cover onto silicon nanowire (SiNW) arrays to form heterojunction. The porous structure and large specific surface area in the heterojunction structure are both benefits for gas adsorption. In virtue of these merits, gas doping is a feasible method to improve cell’s performance and the device can also work as a self-powered gas sensor beyond a solar cell. It shows a significant improvement in cell efficiency (more than 200 times) after NO2 molecules doping (device working as a solar cell) and a fast, reversible response property for NO2 detection (device working as a gas sensor). Such multifunctional CNT-SiNW structure can be expected to open a new avenue for developing self-powered, efficient toxic gas-sensing devices in the future.
There is a growing requirement of lightweight, energy-saving, integrated devices for various wearable and portable electronic applications. In particular, multifunctional devices combining energy generation and other specific function are highly desired in many applications. To this end, functionalized piezotronic generators and solar cells with additional properties, such as wind speed , UV  and pressure  detecting, have been developed accordingly. In recent years, carbon nanotube (CNT)-silicon heterojunction structure has been considered as one of facile and promising designs for many applications [4–6]. In this structure, CNT films are assembled with silicon wafer to form heterojunction, in which the built-in electric field is generated and driving charge carriers to electrodes. Particularly, owing to its potential prospect for developing high-efficiency and low-cost solar cells, the heterojunction structure has attracted great research interest in both elucidating its working mechanism [7, 8] and improving its power conversion efficiency (η) [9–15]. Some key points in this structure are crucial to the junctions’ performance, including properties of carbon materials (sheet resistance, light transmissivity, etc.), substrate wafer (resistance, energy band gap, light transmissivity, etc.), and their interface (contact state, thickness). To improve the cell efficiency, different strategies focusing on those points have been proposed accordingly. Firstly, chemical doping with volatile oxidants [9–11, 14] was applied to CNT membranes to adjust their Fermi level and carrier concentration. Secondly, an insulator layer (SiOx) with a suitable thickness was introduced at the interface of CNT membrane and silicon wafer to form a metal-insulator-semiconductor (MIS) junction [11, 15]. The existence of this insulator layer significantly suppressed carrier recombination and improved the diode ideality factor of CNT-Si junction. Moreover, surface anti-reflection treatments (PDMS , TiO2 , and MoOx  coating) were also efficient to enhance the light absorption of CNT-Si devices. In addition, silicon nanowire (SiNW) arrays with their unique one-dimensional aligned structure and outstanding electrical properties have exhibited excellent light trapping and carrier-transporting performances . In our previous work, SiNW arrays have been used to assembly heterojunction solar cells with CNT membranes. Electrolyte was also used to fill into the pores between SiNW arrays and CNT membranes to provide additional channels for charge transport . Thus, the cell efficiency increased from 0.092 to 1.29 % after electrolyte infiltration. However, without extra-encapsulation, cell stability was poor due to the gradual evaporation of electrolyte.
In this work, we utilize SiNW arrays to fabricate heterojunction with CNT membranes for reducing light reflection, followed by NO2 gas doping to increase cell performances. In this structure, the large specific surface area of both SiNW arrays and CNT membranes, together with additional channels built by their point-to-line contact, can greatly facilitate gas adsorption and desorption, which will further improve cell performances. To take full advantages of this structure, we also demonstrate the gas-sensitive properties of CNT-SiNW heterojunction structure. Compared with traditional metallic oxide gas sensors working at relatively high temperatures, this CNT-SiNW gas sensor works at room temperature. Particularly, it combines the functions of solar cell and gas sensor, as a result, this CNT-SiNW gas sensor is self-powered (by light), which is more energy-efficient and safer, especially for explosive gases detecting.
Chemical Etching for SiNW Arrays
SiNW arrays used in this study were prepared by a Ag-assisted etching method. n-type (100) silicon wafers with the electrical resistivity of 2~4 Ω cm were cleaned with acetone, ethanol, and piranha solution (H2O2 and H2SO4), followed immersing into HF and AgNO3 mixture solution for 15 min to fabricate SiNW arrays. After that, the as-prepared SiNW arrays were rinsed in deionized water and treated with HF and HNO3 to remove dendrite silver films covered onto SiNW arrays. The height of SiNWs was 300 nm. Then a Ti/Au layer (50 nm) was deposited on the back side of SiNW arrays.
Synthesis of CNT Membranes
High-quality CNT membranes were synthesized by a chemical vapor deposition (CVD) method using xylene as carbon source, ferrocene, and sulfur as catalyst precursor, respectively. The reaction temperature was set at 1160 °C, and CNT membranes were collected onto a piece of nickel foil at the downstream of quartz tube reactor.
Assembly and Test of CNT-SiNW Solar Cells
The as-prepared spiderweb-like CNT membranes were directly lifted up and transferred onto SiNW arrays to construct CNT-SiNW heterojuction devices. The active area for each solar cell was 0.24 cm2. In order to investigate the effects of NO2 modification on cell performances, CNT-SiNW solar cells were sealed into a quartz chamber with a window for light illumination from a solar simulator. The light intensity in the quartz chamber was 80 mW/cm2, which was calibrated by a silicon solar cell. The temperature in the quartz chamber was kept at room temperature. The flow rates of NO2 and N2 in the quartz chamber were adjusted by two mass flow controllers, respectively. Thus, the NO2 concentration could be finely controlled from 0 to 1000 ppm. The I-V data of CNT-SiNW solar cells were recorded by a Keithley 2601 digital source-meter.
Test of CNT-SiNW Gas-Sensing Properties
To test gas-sensing properties, CNT-SiNW solar cells were sealed into the same quartz chamber with some appropriate changes in the devices and equipment. First, a cold light source (LED) was used here to replace the solar simulator. Thus, the thermal effect of solar light source on cell performance could be eliminated. Second, SiNW arrays used to fabricate solar cell here had been stored in air for more than half a year to form a stable interfacial oxide layer. In this case, the non-reversible interfacial oxide layer effect could be avoided during gas-sensitive testing process. Third, the exhaust gas of the quartz chamber was evacuated by a vacuum pump. The V-t data of CNT-SiNW gas sensors were also recorded by the Keithley 2601 digital source-meter.
Results and Discussion
Figure 1a shows that the heterojunction consists of an n-type SiNW array wafer coated by a semi-transparent CNT membrane. Incident photons are absorbed by vertical SiNWs and converted into photon-generated carriers. Those charge carriers are directly separated by the built-in field at the CNT-Si junction and then driven to CNT membranes (for hole) and SiNW array wafer (for electrons) at the same time. NO2 molecules with controlled concentration are injected and adsorbed onto the heterojunction surfaces to improve cell performances. SEM image in Fig. 1b reveals that CNT membranes are uniformly coated onto SiNW arrays to form a heterojunction for the separation and transport of charge carriers. It also shows thousands of traps in SiNW arrays; thus, light reflection at their surface is remarkably suppressed. The optical reflection spectra of SiNW arrays and polished silicon wafer are shown in Fig. 1c. The polished silicon wafer shows a lager reflectance about 40~80 % from near-infrared to ultraviolet region. After chemical etching, the reflectance of SiNW array surface sharply decreases to nearly 0 %. Accordingly, in the photograph of Fig. 1d, the mirror-like silicon wafer converts to ultra-black SiNW arrays after chemical etching.
The porous structures of both CNT membranes and SiNW arrays can greatly facilitate gas adsorption and desorption, which can influence cell performances. In Fig. 2a, the current density versus voltage (J-V) curves are shown for pristine and NO2-doped CNT-SiNW solar cells under light illumination. The pristine CNT-SiNW solar cell (with a thin native oxide layer) shows a V oc = 0.45 V, J sc = 12.1 mA/cm2, FF = 17 %, and a cell efficiency (ƞ) of 1.2 %. After NO2 doping, those performances increase to V oc = 0.55 V, J sc = 22.2 mA/cm2, FF = 54.4 %, and ƞ = 8.4 %. Corresponding dark J-V curves in Fig. 2b reveal that the series resistance (R s) drops from 61 to 7.3 Ω cm2 and the rectification ration at ±0.75 V increases from 3000 to 50,000. Those results from dark J-V curves indicate an improvement in diode characteristics for CNT-SiNW solar cell after NO2 modification. Next, the influences of different NO2 concentration and treating time on cell performance were studied. Figure 2c shows a series of dramatic shifts in J-V curves when a solar cell was exposed in different NO2 conditions (the characteristics are summarized in Table 1. The fresh cell (cell surface was rinsed by dilute HF solution and deionized water) shows a V oc = 0.28 V, J sc = 0.66 mA/cm2, a poor FF = 12.5 %, and a power conversion efficiency of 0.03 %. With a small amounts of NO2 treatment (10 ppm, 30 min), there are significant improvements in V oc (0.42 V) and J sc (7.4 mA/cm2). After 1000 ppm NO2 treatment for 60 min, the cell performances reached a V oc = 0.48 V, J sc = 20.7 mA/cm2, FF = 54.3 %, and ƞ = 6.74 %. The final cell efficiency is more than 200 times of the initial ƞ. Previous studies have demonstrated that a thin oxide layer at the CNT-Si cell could result in significant ƞ enhancement [8, 11, 15]. Obviously, the oxidation ability of NO2 is much stronger than that of air. Thus, the formation of interface oxide layer (Additional file 1: Figure S1) could be one reason for cell performance improvement. Besides that, NO2 treatment not only affected on the interface state of CNT-Si heterojunction but also can remarkably decrease the resistance of the device. The inset in Fig. 2d shows that CNT membrane sheet resistance reduces from 79.7 to 40.5 Ω/□ after keeping in NO2 atmosphere for 60 min. The reduction of the sheet resistance further leads to the change of series resistance (R s) for solar cells. The R s of solar cell in N2 and NO2 treatment states have been calculated from corresponding dark J-V curves. Consistent with the CNT membrane sheet resistance reduction, after 1000 ppm NO2 doping for 60 min, the solar cell’s series resistances decreases from 7.8 to 7.0 Ω cm2, as shown in Fig. 2d.
Based on previous reports, the CNT-Si structure can be considered as a Schottky junction, in which CNT membrane serves as metallic materials while silicon wafer serves as a semiconductor [8, 11, 15]. Figure 3 is the corresponding energy band diagram for CNT-SiNW junction. In this diagram, the barrier height (Φ B) is equal to the work function difference between CNT membranes and silicon nanowire; the equation for the barrier height  is
where q is the electron charge, Φ B is the barrier height, W CNT is the work function of CNT membrane (4.8 eV), W doping is the additional doping work function of CNT membrane, and χ is electron affinity of silicon (4.05 eV). For CNT-SiNW heterojunction junction in Fig. 3, when NO2 molecules modified onto CNT membranes surface, the work function of CNT membranes was up-shifted, leading to the increases of Φ B in Eq. (1) and energy diagram.
According to theories for Schottky junction solar cells, the V oc can be expressed as :
where n is the diode ideality factor, k is the Boltzmann constant, T is the working temperature, I s is the diode saturation current, and A e and A * are the contact area of the diode and the Richardson constant, respectively. In Eq. (2), V oc is positively correlated with Φ B. After NO2 molecules doping, the up-shift of CNT work function and increase of Φ B led to the improvements of V oc for solar cells, as shown in Fig. 2.
The results above have demonstrated that NO2 gas can modify both CNT membranes and heterojunction interface to improve cell performance. On the other hand, from the energy band diagram in Fig. 3, it also means that the cell performance is sensitive to the ambient environment. Moreover, the adsorption site for NO2 molecules onto CNTs is the top of a carbon atom and the charge transfer is −0.06~−0.09 electron per molecule, resulting in a weak binding (0.4~0.8 eV) between them . The non-covalent combination leads to a reversible behavior in cell performance by switching NO2 molecule adsorption and desorption states. Starting from this point, we used a quartz chamber to test CNT-SiNW junctions’ gas-sensing properties. Figure 4 is the real-time NO2 detection by CNT-SiNW heterojunction. In vacuum condition, the V oc of the device is 0.24 V. When the device is exposed in small amounts of NO2 gas (e.g., 10 ppm), a fast response of V oc can be achieved in 4~6 s, the V oc sharply increases to 0.35 V, which is improved more than 40 % compared with that of the initial untreated devices. After switching the NO2 concentration from 0 to 10 ppm for six times, the maximum response remains unchanged, indicating a good repeatability of this CNT-SiNW heterojunction sensor. Further increasing the concentration to 100 ppm and 1000 ppm, the V oc will increase to 0.39 and 0.44 V, respectively.
To study the effect of CNT-SiNW structure on gas detection, a control sample of CNT-planar silicon was tested under repeated exposures of 1000 ppm NO2 at room temperature. The result in Fig. 5a shows that it needs more than 40 min for 1000 ppm NO2 desorption from CNT-planar silicon sample, which is much longer than the recovery time in CNT-SiNWs (less than 5 min). Moreover, Fig. 5b also shows that the normalized voltage responses of CNT-SiNW structure (~1.8) are much larger than the responses of CNT-planar silicon (~1.1) under repeated exposures of 1000 ppm NO2. All the results above indicate that CNT-SiNW structure plays an important role in improving device’s response speed and amplitude.
In summary, we directly assembled CNT membranes with SiNW wafer to form heterojunction for solar cells and gas sensors. The CNT-SiNW heterojunction showed a gas-dependent photovoltaic effect. Thus, the power conversion efficiencies of CNT-SiNW solar cells are up to 8.4 % after NO2 gas doping. The CNT-SiNW heterojunction also demonstrated a self-powered gas detection sensitivity at room temperature. This CNT-SiNW heterojunction-based gas sensor will lead to much more sensitive and simple carbon-based gas sensors in the future.
Fan GF, Fan LL, Li Z, Bai X, Mulligan S, Jia Y, Wang KL, Wei JQ, Cao AY, Wu DH, Wei BQ, Zhu HW (2012) Hybrid effect of gas flow and light excitation in carbon/silicon Schottky solar cells. J Mater Chem 22:3330–3334
Zheng YB, Cheng L, Yuan MM, Wang Z, Zhang L, Qin Y, Jing T (2014) An electrospun nanowire-based triboelectric nanogenerator and its application in a fully selfpowered UV detector. Nanoscale 6:7842–7846
Somani PR (2010) Pressure sensitive multifunctional solar cells using carbon nanotubes. Appl Phys Lett 96:173504
Wei JQ, Jia Y, Shu QK, Gu ZY, Wang KL, Zhuang DM, Zhang G, Wang ZC, Luo JB, Cao AY, Wu DH (2007) Double-walled carbon nanotube solar cells. Nano Lett 7:2317–2321
Li XM, Lv Z, Zhu HW (2015) Carbon/silicon heterojunction solar cells: state of the art and prospects. Adv Mater 27:6549–6574
Jia Y, Li X, Li PX, Wang KL, Cao AY, Wei JQ, Zhu HW, Wu DH (2012) Strong, conductive carbon nanotube fibers as efficient hole collectors. Nanoscale Res Lett 7:137
Pintossi C, Pagliara S, Drera G, De Nicola F, Castrucci P, De Crescenzi M, Crivellari M, Boscardin M, Sangaetti L (2015) Steering the efficiency of carbon nanotube-silicon photovoltaic cells by acid vapor exposure: a real-time spectroscopic tracking. ACS Appl Mater Inter 7:9436–9444
Tune DD, Hennrich F, Dehm S, Klein MFG, Glaser K, Colsmann A, Shapter JG, Lemmer U, Kappes MM, Krupke R, Flavel BS (2013) The role of nanotubes in carbon nanotube-silicon solar cells. Adv Energy Mater 3:1091–1097
Li Z, Kunets VP, Saini V, Xu Y, Dervishi E, Salamo GJ, Biris AR, Biris AS (2009) Light-harvesting using high density p-type single wall carbon nanotube/n-type silicon heterojunctions. ACS Nano 3:1407–1414
Jia Y, Cao AY, Bai X, Li Z, Zhang LH, Guo N, Wei JQ, Wang KL, Zhu HW, Wu DH, Ajayan PM (2011) Achieving high efficiency silicon-carbon nanotube heterojunction solar cells by acid doping. Nano Lett 11:1901–1905
Jia Y, Li PX, Gui XC, Wei JQ, Wang KL, Zhu HW, Wu DH, Zhang LH, Cao AY, Xu Y (2011) Encapsulated carbon nanotube-oxide-silicon solar cells with stable 10 % efficiency. Appl Phys Lett 98:133115
Shi EZ, Zhang LH, Li Z, Li PX, Shang YY, Jia Y, Wei JQ, Wang KL, Zhu HW, Wu DH, Zhang S, Cao AY (2012) TiO2-coated carbon nanotube-silicon solar cells with efficiency of 15 %. Sci Rep 2:884
Wang F, Kozawa D, Miyauchi Y, Hiraoka K, Mouri S, Ohno Y, Matsuda K (2015) Considerably improved photovoltaic performance of carbon nanotube-based solar cells using metal oxide layers. Nat Commun 6:6305
Li Z, Kunets VP, Saini V, Xu Y, Dervishi E, Salamo GJ, Biris AR, Biris AS (2008) SOCl2 enhanced photovoltaic conversion of single wall carbon nanotube/n-silicon heterojunctions. Appl Phys Lett 93:243117
Jia Y, Cao AY, Kang FY, Li PX, Gui XC, Zhang LH, Shi EZ, Wei JQ, Wang KL, Zhu HW, Wu DH (2012) Strong and reversible modulation of carbon nanotube-silicon heterojunction solar cells by an interfacial oxide layer. Phys Chem Chem Phys 14:8391–8396
Peng KQ, Huang ZP, Zhu J (2004) Fabrication of large-area silicon nanowire p-n junction diode arrays. Adv Mater 16:73–76
Shu QK, Wei JQ, Wang KL, Zhu HW, Li Z, Jia Y, Gui XC, Guo N, Li X, Ma CR, Wu DH (2009) Hybrid heterojunction and photoelectrochemistry solar cell based on silicon nanowires and double-walled carbon nanotubes. Nano Lett 9:4338–4342
Shi YM, Kim KK, Reina A, Hofmann M, Li LJ, Kong J (2010) Work function engineering of graphene electrode via chemical doping. ACS Nano 4:2689–2694
Zhao JJ, Buldum A, Han J, Lu JP (2002) Gas molecule adsorption in carbon nanotubes and nanotube bundles. Nanotechnology 13:195–200
This work is supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 51202119 and 51472019) and Tsinghua University Initiative Scientific Research Program.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
YJ carried out the experiment and wrote the manuscript. ZZ and LX participated in the data analysis. YJ and RL checked and revised the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.