 Nano Express
 Open Access
 Published:
Simultaneous Generation of Multiple ThreeDimensional Tractor Curve Beams
Nanoscale Research Lettersvolume 14, Article number: 82 (2019)
Abstract
A tractor beam, which has the ability to attract objects, is a class of special optical beams. Currently, people are using the holographic technology to shape complex optical tractor beams for both fundamental research and practical applications. However, most of the work reported is focusing on generating twodimensional (2D) tractor beams and simple threedimensional (3D) tractor beams, which has limitations in the further development on mechanism and application of beam shaping. In the present work, we are introducing our study in designing multiple 3D tractor beams with spatial location regulated independently. Meanwhile, each individual beam could be prescribed along arbitrary geometric curve and twisted at arbitrary angles as desired. In our method, the computergenerated hologram (CGH) of each curve is calculated, and all the CGHs are multiplexed and encoded into one phaseonly hologram by adding respective linear phase grating such that different 3D curves appeared in the different positions of the focal regions. We experimentally prove that the generation of optical tractor beams at 3D configuration can be readily achieved. The generated beams in the present study are especially useful for applications such as multiple micromachining optical trapping and complex 3D manipulation.
Introduction
Long ago, people have demonstrated the ability of light to exert forces. The idea of attracting objects with optical beams has also arrested our attention for a long time. Due to the phase singularity and unique orbital angular momentum, optical vortex has important research value in the fields of optical micromanipulation, quantum communication, optical imaging, and optical measurement [1,2,3,4,5,6]. Although the technology for generating optical vortices has been developed and may be valuable in various applications, the efficiency of a single optical vortex is still low. In order to capture multiple particles at the same time and operate different particles separately, the generation of optical vortex arrays has become a hot topic [7, 8].
Recent theoretical studies [9,10,11,12,13] have shown that a tractor beam is a traveling wave that can transport illuminated material along its length back to its source. New advances in laser beam control have led to the experimental realization of tractor beams [14, 15]. One important type of 3D vortex trap is the socalled solenoid beam that exhibits a fixed spiral shape around the optical axis [16], in which the phase gradient can be prescribed along this curve to obtain a tractor beam. It was achieved by imposing helical phases to a collinear superposition of Bessel beams. Ruffner and Grier [17] experimentally demonstrated and analyzed the properties of a class of tractor beam obtained by the interference of two coaxial Bessel Beams that differ in their axial wave numbers. In 2013, Rodrigo et al. present a method for efficient generation of tractor beams by loading designed phaseonly holograms into the spatial light modulator (SLM) and meanwhile irradiating the SLM with lasers. They used the technique to allow the generation of highintensity gradient (HIG) beams whose phase and intensity are prescribed based on the computergenerated hologram (CGH) [18]. They experimentally proved that the beams in distinct 3D geometries could be shaped. The HIGs and phase gradient forces are crucial for the construction of 3D laser traps that are able to move multiple particles even against light radiation pressure [19]. Rodrigo also showed that a freestyle laser trap, including HIG and phase gradient forces, was able to confine multiple particles and drive their motion [20]. However, most of the work reported is focusing on generating simple 3D tractor beams, which has limitations in the further development of applications of beam shaping. Based on the above analysis, advanced beamshaping technology for the generation of multiple 3D tractor beams is urgently needed.
In this paper, we demonstrate the method for generation of multiple 3D tractor beams using the modified holographic beam shaping technique, where all the CGHs are multiplexed and encoded into one phaseonly hologram by adding respective linear phase grating. We design multiple 3D tractor beams that are twisted at different angles. Such >new tractor beams are expected to expand the application field of optical vortices and are potentially useful in the realization of superperformance multiple optical applications.
Methods
Figure 1a shows the scheme of a holographic 3D beam shaping technique in [18] that allows designing complex beams whose intensity and phase distribution follow a prescribed 3D curve. Encoding the complex amplitude field into phase holographic gratings is a method to calculate CGH. Specifically, in order to generate a desired focal beam, the complex amplitude of the incident plane is given by the expression:
The terms ψ(x, y, t) and φ(x, y, t) in Eq. (1) are determined by
[x_{0}(t), y_{0}(t), z_{0}(t)] represents the prescribed 3D curve in the Cartesian coordinate with t∈[0,2π]. f_{0} and λ refer to the focal length of the Fourier lens and the wavelength, respectively.
Eq. (1) allows calculating the incident complex field (namely, complex CGH) that can shape a structurally stable focal beam with special intensity distribution and phase gradient (helical phase along the curve). We first consider a 2D ring curve x_{0}(t) = Rcos(t), y_{0}(t) = Rsin(t). The intensity distribution of the resulting beam is displayed in Fig. 1b. The phase distribution of the ring is well defined along curves under the topological charge of m = 1 [see Fig. 1c]. We consider a tilted ring in Fig. 1d. The plane of the ring curve inclined to a certain angle on the basis of the plane z = 0. In this case, the beam is focused appearing on the top and bottom points [seen in Fig. 1e].
In order to multiplex various tractor curve beams partially separated in the focal field, each complex CGH calculated by Eq. (1) must be encoded with a unique carrier frequency. This can be achieved by adding a linear phase grating to the hologram of each beam. Linear gratings in combination with spatial filters are commonly used to isolate the first diffraction order from undesired zero and higher diffraction orders. The transfer function of a linear phase grating is given as
u_{i} and v_{i} are the spatial coordinates of the generated beam in the far field, achieved with a Fourier lens of focal length f_{0}. k = 2π/λ is the wave number, and z_{i} is the axial shifted displacement away from the focal plane (Fourier plane). In order to generate tractor curve beams simultaneously, the expressions of the final complex CGH need to be added together by
Results and Discussion
Light field regulation at 3D configuration is very meaningful in practical applications, such as 3D manipulation of particles in a fluid environment. Therefore, we study the generation of HIG beams whose intensity and phase are prescribed along 3D curves of different shapes. Specifically, we consider a tilted ring Fig. 2a–e, an Archimedean spiral Fig. 2f–j, a trefoilknotted curve Fig. 2k–o, and a square curve Fig. 2p–t. The corresponding curve expressions are provided in Table 1. These 3D structures are revealed along the beam propagation in the focal region. The beam intensity distributions measured in the focal plane (z = 0) are shown in the third column of Fig. 2. The Z coordinates corresponding to other columns of Fig. 2 are marked in the simulation diagrams.
In optical micromanipulation fields, tractor beams with different degrees of 3D distortion can play a greater role in applications. However, for higher efficiency, it is highly desired to synchronously carry out differentiated manipulations at different locations. Therefore, we design multiple tractor beams of four patterns simultaneously, each of which may be used to confine given particles in any prescribed geometric curve with a certain degree of 3D distortion. The relative position of the tractor beams can be designed. In order to show that multiple tractor beams are focused on the 3D region, we have selected six 2D planes to observe. The tractor beams are focused on different 2D planes, seen in Fig. 3. These 3D structures are revealed along the beam propagation in the focal region.
In order to observe the interaction of multiple manipulated particles, we designed copperlike nested graphic tractor beams. The 3D distortion and shapes of the inner and outer beams can be separately designed. The ring curve is focused on the plane (z = 0), and the square curve has a certain degree of 3D distortion [seen in Fig. 4a–e]. The square curve is focused on the plane (z = 0), and the ring curve has a certain degree of 3D distortion [seen in Fig. 4f–j]. The beam intensity distributions measured in the focal plane (z = 0) are shown in the third column of Fig. 4. The z coordinates corresponding to other columns of Fig. 4 are marked in the simulation diagrams. The shape of the tractor beams can be flexibly adjusted to control the particles at different positions.
Optical experiments have been performed to verify that the method introduced above can be used to achieve the purpose of focusing multiple 3D tractor beams in tunable focusing regions. As shown in Fig. 5, the optical setup for generating the 3D tractor beam is composed of a liquid crystal spatial light modulator (SLM), a 4f filtering system, and a Fourier transform (focusing) lens. A solidstate laser with a wavelength of 532 nm is collimated to plane wave illumination. The SLM (Holoeye Pluto, 8 pixel pitch, 1920 × 1080 resolution) is utilized to address a phaseonly CGH. We use the doublephase method [18, 20] to encode the complex CGH H(x,y) calculated by Eq. (4) into a phaseonly CGH. It consists in the encoding of the complex function as a hologram into the SLM. The beam modulated by SLM is then projected to the backaperture of the Fourier transform lens (f = 400 mm) through a 4f optical filtering configuration. A chargecoupled device (CCD) camera is placed at the Fourier plane of the focusing lens to record the generated intensity patterns. The results of the 3D tractor beams are shown in Fig. 6. Although the resulting beams have errors after passing through the 4f optical system, they are in good agreement with the simulation results.
The results of the multiple 3D tractor beams are shown in Fig. 7. We have selected six 2D planes to observe, which is convenient for comparison with simulation. The simulation results are in good agreement with the experimental results. It is verified that this method can generate multiple 3D tractor beams flexibly and efficiently. Different beams with a certain degree of 3D distortion can confine particles.
The results of copperlike nested graphic tractor beams are shown in the Fig. 8. The simulation results are in good agreement with the experimental results. Thus, the two nested beams hardly interact with each other. The tractor beams can be used for multiparticle manipulation on different curves.
Conclusion
We design multiple 3D tractor beams with spatial location regulated independently. Meanwhile, each individual beam could be prescribed along arbitrary geometric curves and twisted at arbitrary angles as desired. We theoretically and experimentally prove that the generation of optical tractor beams at 3D configuration can be readily achieved. Highintensity gradients and phase gradients have the ability to capture particles. At present, experiments have been carried out and the optical vortex beams damage the particles to a minimum extent. Our work broadens the types of tractor beams. It is believed meaningful and useful for further development of tractor beams for multiple optical applications.
Abbreviations
 2D:

Twodimensional
 3D:

Threedimensional
 CGH:

Computergenerated hologram
 HIG:

High intensity gradient
 SLM:

Spatial light modulator
References
 1.
Shvedov VG, Desyatnikov AS, Rode AV, Izdebskaya YV, Krolikowski WZ, Kivshar YS (2010) Optical vortex beams for trapping and transport of particles in air. Applied Physics A 100(2):327–331
 2.
Liu C, Guo Z, Li Y, Wang X, Qu S (2015) Manipulating ellipsoidal microparticles by femtosecond vortex tweezers. J Opt, 17(3):035402.
 3.
Marsal N, Wolfersberger D, Sciamanna M (2012) Optical patterns using vortex beams. Proc SPIE 8434(2):46
 4.
Li XZ, Tai YP, Nie ZG (2012) Digital speckle correlation method based on phase vortices. Opt Eng 51(51):7004
 5.
Chen D, Zhao SH, Shi L, Liu Y (2016) Measurementdeviceindependent quantum key distribution with pairs of vector vortex beams. Physical Review A, 93(3):032320
 6.
Rodrigo JA, Alieva T (2016) Freestyle laser traps: applications and future outlook. The workshop on Information Optics. IEEE. Barcelona, SPAIN
 7.
Deng D, Li Y, Han Y, Su X, Ye J, Gao J et al (2016) Perfect vortex in threedimensional multifocal array. Opt Express 24(25):28270–28278
 8.
Rosalesguzmán C, Bhebhe N, Mahonisi N, Forbes A (2017) Multiplexing 200 spatial modes with a single hologram. J Optics, 19(11):113501
 9.
Chen J, Ng J, Lin Z, Chan CT (2011) Optical pulling force. Nat Photonics 5(9):531–534
 10.
Novitsky A, Qiu CW, Wang H (2011) Single gradientless light beam drags particles as tractor beams. Phys Rev Lett 107(20):203601
 11.
Sukhov S, Dogariu A (2011) Negative nonconservative forces: optical “tractor beams” for arbitrary objects. Phys Rev Lett 107(20):203602
 12.
Carretero L, Acebal P, Blaya S (2014) Threedimensional analysis of optical forces generated by an active tractor beam using radial polarization. Opt Express 22(3):3284–3295
 13.
Garcia C, Carretero L, Acebal P, Blaya S (2015) Helical tractor beam: analytical solution of rayleigh particle dynamics. Opt Express 23(16):20529–20539
 14.
Brzobohatý O, Karásek V, Šiler M, Chvátal L, Čižmár T, Zemánek P (2013) Experimental demonstration of optical transport, sorting and selfarrangement using a 'tractor beam. Nat Photonics 7(2):123–127
 15.
Kajorndejnukul V, Ding W, Sukhov S, Qiu CW, Dogariu A (2013) Linear momentum increase and negative optical forces at dielectric interface. Nat Photonics 7(10):787–790
 16.
Grier DG, Lee SH, Roichman Y (2010) Optical solenoid beams. Opt Express 18(7):6988–6993
 17.
Ruffner DB, Grier DG (2012) Optical conveyors: a class of active tractor beams. Phys Rev Lett 109(16):163903
 18.
Rodrigo JA, Alieva T, Abramochkin E, Castro I (2013) Shaping of light beams along curves in three dimensions. Opt Express 21(18):20544–20555
 19.
Sukhov S, Dogariu A (2010) On the concept of “tractor beams”. Opt Lett 35(22):3847–3849
 20.
Rodrigo JA, Alieva T (2015) Freestyle 3d laser traps: tools for studying lightdriven particle dynamics and beyond. Optica 2:812–815
Funding
This work was supported by National key R&D Program of China (2017YFB1002900), National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) (61775035, 61805037, 61875241, 11734005), and Natural Science Foundation of Jiangsu Province (BK20181268).
Availability of Data and Materials
Authors did not acquire any data or materials from any other party. Authors also declared that materials described in the manuscript, including all relevant raw data, will be freely available to any scientist wishing to use them for noncommercial purposes, without breaching participant confidentiality.
Author information
Affiliations
Contributions
All the authors listed are from the Joint International Research Laboratory of Information Display and Visualization, School of Electronic Science and Engineering, Southeast University, Nanjing 210096, China. WJ designed the experimental content and prepared the manuscript. TXQ performed the modeling and experimental investigation and analyzed the data. XJ revised the paper. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Correspondence to Jun Xia.
Ethics declarations
Competing Interests
No conflict of interest exits in the submission of this manuscript, and the manuscript is approved by all authors for publication. The work described was original research that has not been published previously, and not under consideration for publication elsewhere, in whole or in part. All the authors listed have approved the manuscript that is enclosed.
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
About this article
Received
Accepted
Published
DOI
Keywords
 Beam shaping
 3D tractor beam
 Computer holography