 Nano Express
 Open Access
 Published:
Modeling and Optimizing the Composite Prepreg Tape Winding Process Based on Grey Relational Analysis Coupled with BP Neural Network and Bat Algorithm
Nanoscale Research Letters volume 14, Article number: 296 (2019)
Abstract
As a significant way to manufacture revolving body composite, the composite prepreg tape winding technology is widely applied to the domain of aerospace motor manufacture. Processing parameters, including heating temperature, tape tension, roller pressure, and winding velocity, have considerable effects on the void content and tensile strength of winding products. This paper was devoted to studying the influence of process parameters on the performances of winding products including both void content and tensile strength and trying to provide the optimal parameters combination for the objectives of lower void content and higher tensile strength. In the experiments, tensile strength and void content were selected as the mechanical property and physical performance of winding products to be tested, respectively. An integrated approach by uniting the Grey relational analysis, backpropagation neural network, and bat algorithm was presented to search the optimal technology parameters for composite tape winding process. Then, the composite tape winding process model was provided by backpropagation neural network utilizing the results of Grey relational analysis. According to the bat algorithm, the optimal parameter combination was heating temperature with 73.8 °C, tape tension with 291.2 N, roller pressure with 1804.1 N, and winding velocity with 9.1 rpm. The value of tensile strength increased from 1215.31 to 1329.62 MPa. Meanwhile, the value of void content decreased from 0.15 to 0.137%. At last, the developed method was verified to be useful for optimizing the composite tape winding process.
Graphical Abstract
Background
Advanced composites have made great achievements in the field of military, aerospace, industry, and civil application for the advantages of high specific intensity and specific rigidity. As a significant way to manufacture rotary composite parts, the composite prepreg tape winding technology is widely used to fabricate the aerospace products [1,2,3,4], such as ablation resistance parts, rocket motor nozzle, some hightemperature resistance components, and rocket launch tube. Therefore, composite winding products play an important role in the development of national defense and aerospace industry. In the composite tape winding process, four technological parameters including tape tension, heating temperature, roller pressure, and winding velocity have major impact on the composite winding products [4,5,6,7]. However, as a representative form of product defect, an excess of voids will markedly reduce the compactness and strength of final winding products. Meanwhile, for the composite manufacturing process, product strength is an important item which needs to be considered. Therefore, to research the composite winding process more comprehensively, not only physical performance but also mechanical properties of winding products should be given a good attention at the same time.
Recent years, composite prepreg tape winding technology has made a huge contribution for the aerospace industry. In the manufacturing field of highstrength rotational composite, especially for rocket motor nozzles, the tape winding process shows huge advantages and vitalities, such as high efficiency and high reliability. Currently, a large number of scholars in the world have carried out a lot of research about the composite tape winding process. Firstly, modeling the composite tape winding process is beneficial for researchers to comprehend the entire technological process from a macro level. The thermodynamic modeling of composite tape winding process proposed by Tannous et al. [8] showed that composite tape winding process could be carried out with a small tape tension in the event that the high frictional contact existed between the tape and compaction roller. However, during the filament winding process, the fiber bundle, more or less, will suffer damage on different degrees due to the tension and extrusion stresses. According to Akkus and Garip’s research [9], the damage of carbon fiber increases with the increasing of pretension force on the carbon fiber during the tape winding process. Therefore, to obtain the better performance of composite, the defects and strength of composite winding products should be lucubrated. Cui et al. [10] studied the influence rule of the winding tension on the appearance and performance of bearing composites using the T300/epoxy prepreg tape. Similarly, Okuya et al. [11] enhanced the bonding strength of winding products by cocuring the carbon fiberreinforced plastics strand with end tabs. Then, the modified method was employed to two kinds of carbon fiberreinforced plastics strands and generated the responsible tensile strength. Last but not least, the performances of composite winding products are intensively subjected to the four process parameters. A preferable winding parameters combination will improve both physical and mechanical performance for the composite winding products. As in Nayani Kishore Nath’s [12] article, the optimum set of composite tape winding technological parameter were found and used to improve the performances of throat back up liners based on robust design method. Besides that, Yu et al. [13] provided a composite prepreg tape winding technology theoretical model which could be applied to selecting optimal parameters and prominently enhance the interlaminar shear strength of winding products.
In summary, a good deal of the literatures concentrated on the theoretical simulation, process control and technological optimizing on the composite prepreg tape winding technology. We can see that modeling and optimizing of the composite tape winding process has attracted many scholars to study. Nevertheless, for optimizing of the composite tape winding process, the current researches are often about optimizing for one target or multiple targets of the same type. In other words, the evaluation standard for the performances of composite tape winding products should be more comprehensive. Researches show that a relative effective process parameter combination will have a great contribution to the composite tape winding manufacturing. Therefore, in this optimizing process of the composite tape winding technology, both physical and mechanical performance of winding products should be considered simultaneously instead of just only one of them. In view of this, void content was selected to measure the physical performance of winding products in this study process. At the same time, tensile strength was chosen as the test index for the mechanical properties of winding products. In the paper, an integrated methodology combining Grey relational analysis (GRA), backpropagation neural network (BPNN), and bat algorithm (BA) would be established to search the optimal technology parameters of composite tape winding process. The authors wish the study will be beneficial for the composite prepreg tape winding manufacturing technology and provide a better performance for the composite winding products.
Experiment Procedure and Results
The composite prepreg tape winding technology can be summarized as the hoop winding process prepreg tapes aiming at fabricating the revolving body composite. At the beginning, the prepreg tapes need to be heated to an appropriate temperature by the electric heating device which is located inside of the compaction roller. Meanwhile, magnetic powder brakes are utilized to guarantee that the prepreg tape keeps a certain constant tension. Simultaneously, the compaction roller pressure provided by the air cylinder is applied to the winding tape. Subsequently, the mandrel, following the spindle’s turning, rotates at an invariable speed. Then, the unwinding tapes are continuously winded to the outer layers of the mandrel. Figure 1 shows a threedimensional diagram of the composites prepreg tape winding process. From the picture, we can see a tension measuring mechanism has been applied to ensure the correct tape tension. In order to reduce the product defects, a highprecision partial adjust mechanism is utilized to keep the proper winding trajectory. In the winding process, the heating temperature is conducive to bring down the resin viscosity and improve the interlaminar contact degree. In addition, the positive force produced by compaction roller will be applied on the prepreg tape. As the roller pressure squeezes out the bubbles among the interlaminar contact interfaces, the prepreg tape and laminated layers will not only contact intimately but also has a lower void content. Then, a suitable tape tension can greatly enhance the tensile strength for winding products. Last but not least, the mandrel velocity will have a major impact on the properties of winding products, for example, compactibility and uniformity. Therefore, both the mechanical and physical performances of winding products are deeply affected by the above four process parameters.
Experiment Design and Sample Preparation
During the experiments, four critical process parameters of the composite tape winding technology including heating temperature, tape tension, roller pressure, and winding velocity were chosen as the design variables. At the same time, two key performances characterizations for tape winding products, tensile strength and void content, were selected as the evaluation indexes. And, more remarkably, the interval of each process parameter was designed on the basis of actual processing requirements. Therewith, the experiment was designed according to a fourfactor and threelevel Box–Behnken design (BBD) based on response surface theory. The experimental level of four key process parameters can be seen in Table 1.
In the experimental process, the composite prepreg tape, fabricated by Gloway Composite Materials Co., Ltd., was composed of carbon fiber and epoxy resin. The carbon fiber was T300 provided by Toray Industries, Inc., and the epoxy resin matrix was YH69 coming from Wuxi Resin Factory of Bluestar New Chemical Materials Co., Ltd. Furthermore, the fiber volume content of the composite prepreg tape was near 55 ± 2%. The width and thickness of the prepreg tape were 80 mm and 0.25 mm, respectively. The structure of composite prepreg tape was plain weave with the braided angles of 0°/90°. All the experiments were carried out on the Automate Tape Winding KUKA Robot (XGD1200). This proprietary CNC equipment was designed and manufactured by Northwestern Polytechnical University, China, as shown in Fig. 2. Meanwhile, the XGD1200 can be also applied to the composite prepreg tape placement process. The machine body is a horizontal structure with a full closedloop control system. The size of the machinable parts (including the core mold) is less than 1500 mm in length and 50~ 1000 mm in rotary diameter. In addition, the winding mechanism uses the sixaxis robot KR 180 R2500 extra fabricated by KUKA Aktiengesellschaft, Germany. The robot has a repeat accuracy of ± 0.06 mm and a working radius of 2500 mm. Furthermore, the technical parameters of tape winding process including winding temperature, roller pressure, and tape tension are controlled by SIMATIC S71200 PLC.
The winding specimens were manufactured with a manner of hoop winding. The ambient temperature and relative humidity of these experiments were 20 ± 2 °C and 25 ± 2%, respectively. The size of the compaction roller was 160 mm in external diameter and 150 mm in width with a material of 45 steel. The winding mandrel was a 45 steel cylinder which was 150 mm in external diameter and 1200 mm in length. A highprecision online rectifying deflection system was employed to ensure proper winding trajectory for decreasing the product defects. Ultimately, the winding products produced by multilayer prepreg tape were cured by autoclave provided by TEDA Industrial Equipment Co., Ltd. (Tianjin, China). During the cured process, the heating rate was kept at 2.5 °C/min. It is worth noting that the curing temperature needs to be kept for 150 min when the temperature rose from room temperature to 150 °C. Meanwhile, the curing pressure stayed around 0.15 MPa.
Measurement Method
Tensile Strength
The tensile strength measurement for winding specimens was proceeded based on the GB/T 14582008 standard [14]. At first, the standard testing ring, as shown in Fig. 3a, was obtained by mechanically cutting the cures winding specimen along the tape winding direction. Then, the STRs having a dimension of 150 ± 0.2 mm in inner diameter, 6 ± 0.2 mm in width, and 3 ± 0.1 mm in thickness would be utilized to test the strength. At last, the tensile strength tests were carried out with the help of electronic universal testing machine DDL100 (Fig. 3b) produced by Changchun Research Institute for Mechanical Science Co., Ltd. Meanwhile, the forcedisplacement tensile curve was provided in Fig. 3c. Then, the computational formula for the tensile strength of the fiberreinforced composite can be described as
where σ_{t} denotes the tensile strength T_{S}, F_{b} means the maximum load, and b and h are the width and thickness of specimens for tests, respectively.
Void Content
Figure 4 gives the simplified schematic of how the test samples were obtained from a multilayered cured winding product. The void content measurement for winding specimens was processed based on the GB/T 33652008 standard [15]. The dimension of the test sample was 20 mm in length, 10 mm in width, and thickness of ring component in height. Three samples were cut out from three cubical equidistant locations along the toroidal direction of winding component (Fig. 4). Whereafter, rough polishing for winding samples was carried out on the surface grinding machine in horizontal HZ800/2CK produced by Hangzhou Hangji Machine Tool Co., Ltd. Then, corresponding polishing paste and cloth were employed to fine shine the experimental samples. For fiber reinforcement composite, micrography is a significant method to measure the void content of composite winding products [16]. Finally, the scanning electron microscope HITACHI S3400 provided by Hitachi HighTechnologies (Shanghai) Co., Ltd. was used to take photographs from the direction of A (red italics in Fig. 4). Then, postprocessing including graying and binarizing for the micrographs was implemented in MATLAB version R2017a. Then, the computational formula for the void content of fiberreinforced composite can be described as the ratio of all the voids acreage to the entire crosssectional area, i.e.,
where V_{C} denotes the void content of winding samples, and A_{viod} and A_{total} are the area of all voids and total crosssectional acreage of the testing sample, respectively.
Experiment Results
The testing data results including tensile strength and void content are pulled together as shown in Table 2. In the table, T denotes the heating temperature, F denotes the tape tension, P denotes the roller pressure, and V denotes the winding velocity. For tensile strength, the maximum and minimum values are 1215.31 and 783.26, respectively. For void content, the maximum and minimum values are 2.19 and 0.13, respectively.
Multiobjective Optimization Method
The composite prepreg tape winding technology is a multifactor and multiobject process. In order to optimize the parameters of composite tape winding process, this paper provided an innovative solution which combined three optimization technologies including the Grey relational analysis (GRA), backpropagation neural network (BPNN), and bat algorithm (BA). First of all, the GRA is widely employed to obtain the approximation ratio among the data series in virtue of Grey relational grade (GRG). Meanwhile, the discrete sequences produced by GRA will be used to carry out the correlation analysis such as multiple factors, processing indetermination, and discrete data. At the same time, the backpropagation neural network (BPNN) is an artificial learning algorithm for multilayer neural networks and has a strong retrieval ability for functions. Due to the advantage of strong nonlinear interpolation ability, BPNN has been effectively used to find the interrelation between the process parameters and two performance characterizations of winding products in this study. At last, the bat algorithm, a patent evolutionary algorithm inspired by microbats’ echolocation behavior, can be usefully utilized to find the best process parameters combination quickly and reliably. Compared with other algorithms, bat algorithm has more superior accuracy and efficiency and does not have the need to adjust many parameters of the algorithm.
In the paper, Grey relational analysis, backpropagation neural network, and bat algorithm are integrated as a GRABPNNBA method to model and optimize the complex multiobjective composite tape winding process. In order to improve efficiency and simplify the counting process, we choose to compute the signaltonoise ratio (S/N) ratio of data sequence in the first place. The S/N ratio is defined as the ratio of signal power to the noise power, often expressed in decibels. In the composite tape winding process, a large value of tensile strength is expected, while the lower value of void content, the preferable performance of the winding product. Thus, the S/N ratio of the tensile strength and void content can be given as
where T_{Si} and V_{Ci} represent the values of tensile strength and void content for the ith result in N tests, respectively; η_{TS} and η_{VC} are the corresponding S/N ratio value of the tensile strength and void content, respectively.
The results of S/N ratio are displayed in Table 2. For tensile strength, the maximum and minimum S/N ratio values are 61.6937 and 57.8781, respectively. For void content, the maximum and minimum S/N ratio values are 17.7211 and − 6.8089, respectively. At the beginning, the experiments for tensile strength and void content of winding products were carried out respectively. The experimental data should be carefully recorded and conformed to the corresponding test group. Thereafter, the GRA method was employed to describe the influence degree of technological parameters on the tensile strength or void content of winding products. Then, the BPNN method was applied to build the nonlinear mapping relations between technological parameters and GRG generated by the GRA. Finally, the BA method would be used to provide the optimal solution after a finite number of iterations. To verify the accuracy of the optimizing method, some validation tests were necessary to be carried out at the last step.
Optimization Process and Discussion
Grey Relational Analysis
The idea of the Grey theory is produced by the combination of multiintelligence theory such as system theory, space theory, and control theory. Grey systems method can be applied to cope with numerous ambiguities caused by imprecise human decisionmaking. Even though the number of data is small or the variability of factors is great, the Grey system theory also can produce the satisfactory results [17, 18]. Through proper processing and regularization of data aggregation, Grey relational analysis can reveal the uncertain relationship between one major factor and all other factors in the system [19, 20]. When the expectancy characteristic is the larger the better or the smaller the better, the normalized value of Grey relation can be described as formula (5) and (6), respectively:
where \( {x}_i^{\ast }(k) \) denotes the ith value’s normalized value from the kth data series, \( {x}_i^0(k) \) represents the ith value of initial result from the kth data series, m signifies the quantity of element from the data series, and n denotes the quantity of data series.
Grey relational coefficient for the data series expresses the connection between the perfect and practical data arrays. The Grey relational coefficient is defined as:
here
where \( {x}_0^{\ast }(k) \) is the reference series and \( {x}_i^{\ast }(k) \) is the comparability series; ξ is the distinguishing coefficient, ξ ∈ [0, 1], usually ξ = 0.5; furthermore, \( {\Delta}_{\mathrm{min}}=\underset{\forall i}{\min}\underset{\forall k}{\min }{\Delta}_{0i}(k) \), \( {\Delta}_{\mathrm{max}}=\underset{\forall i}{\max}\underset{\forall k}{\max }{\Delta}_{0i}(k) \).
The Grey relational grade reveals the degree of interrelation between the reference sequences and comparability series. Therefore, a greater value of GRG tends to show the relevant parameter combination is nearer to the optimal parameters set. In fact, GRG is the weight sum of the Grey relational coefficients. Then, the GRG can be calculated as:
where \( \gamma \left({x}_0^{\ast },{x}_i^{\ast}\right) \) denotes the GRG; β_{k} is the weight value of the kth response variable which can be obtained from the principal component analysis.
Grey relational grade is a significant way to reduce two optimal objectives to one. In addition, the GRG indicates the degree of influence of parameter levels on the quality characteristics. In the multiobjective optimization process, the experiment and measurement results in Table 3 were normalized at first. Subsequently, the deviation sequence ∆_{0i} were calculated with the help of formula (8). And then, the Grey relational coefficient was obtained by means of formula (7). The results of deviation sequence and Grey relational coefficient are shown in Table 3. According to the principal component analysis, β_{1} = 87.306% and β_{2} = 12.694%; here, β_{1} and β_{2} are the weight value of the tensile strength and void content, respectively. So, the tensile strength is the first principal component, followed by void content. Then, the results of GRG were calculated on the basis of formula (11) as shown in Table 3. From the table, we can see the maximum and minimum values of the GRG are 0.9686 and 0.3337, respectively. It means that the combination with the heating temperature of 75 °C, tape tension of 300 N, roller pressure of 1500 N, and winding velocity of 10 rpm are the best parameters combination for the composite winding process. Meanwhile, the heating temperature of 50 °C, tape tension of 300 N, roller pressure of 1500 N, and winding velocity of 15 rpm are the worst parameters combination.
Modeling of Backpropagation Neural Network
The backpropagation neural network generally includes three layer constructions which are input layer, hidden layer, and output layer. In order to obtain better results, a supervised learning algorithm needs to be employed to train the neural networks. Later on, the object minimizing the summation of the mean square error for all output layers is used to regulate the weights and thresholds of before and after layer [21, 22]. Particularly, during the training process, the neural network’s weights and thresholds are amended in a manner of repeated iteration until the trained network shows good agreement with the training sets [23]. Meanwhile, the final configuration of backpropagation neural network will be concluded by the input series and output sequences. In this study, the tape winding process contains four process parameters, namely heating temperature, tape tension, roller pressure, and winding velocity. Hence, the variable of input layer including four parameters is set to 4. The output layer has only one neuron that is the calculated GRG. Meanwhile, the hidden layer of BPNN has a major impact on the network model’s robustness. In the paper, the quantity of hidden layer is set to 6. Finally, the training process of BPNN can be described as follows:
Step 1
Count outputs of nodes in the hidden layer. According to the calculation principle of the neural network, the hidden layer and the output layer can be respectively described as:
where x_{i} denotes the ith input variable in the input layer, y_{j} denotes the jth neuron’s output from the hidden layer, and z_{k} denotes the kth neuron’s output from the output layer; w_{ij} denotes the connection weighs between neuron i in the input layer and neuron j in the hidden layer; θ_{i} is the threshold value of neuron j in the hidden layer; v_{jk} denotes the connection weighs between neuron j in the hidden layer and the neuron k in the output layer; and η_{k} is the threshold value of neuron k in the output layer. In addition, f(x) denotes the transfer function between input and hidden layer; here, we choose the Sigmoid function, and g(x) is the transfer function between the hidden layer and output layer; here, we select the Purelin function just as shown in formula (14).
where α, a, and b are all the coefficient of the model. For simplicity, we can use α = a = b = 1.
Step 2
Count the output data of BPNN. Let z denote the final output of the model, then the backpropagation neural network model can be described as follow:
Step 3
Minimize the mean square error. To improve and refine the accuracy of the BPNN model, the mean square error function between the actual and trained outputs should be defined, that is,
where E is the mean square error; R_{k} denotes the desired output.
Since we had obtained the GRG, the BPNN was applied to establish the nonlinear mapping relationship between process parameters and the GRG. In this step, the BPNN was composed of threelayer networks including one input layer with four neurons, one hidden layer with six neurons, and one output layer with one neuron. For the composite tape winding process, the foremost parameters heating temperature T, tape tension F, roller pressure P, and winding velocity V were selected as the input neurons. The GRG was the only one output neuron and also the ultimate optimal goal of the neural network model.
The modeling process for BPNN was carried out via the MATLAB version R2017a. The sample data coming from Table 4 were applied to train the neural network model. When the expected error precision was achieved, the training process stopped. Figure 5 shows the training process and results of backpropagation neural network. According to Fig. 5a and b, we can see the best training performance is 0.00099518 at the 98th training times. In Fig. 5c, the points fall on the reference line which means the two data sets come from the normal distribution. Meanwhile, the prediction value is closely matched with the measured results as shown in Fig. 5d. However, to further verify the prediction accuracy of the model, some additional validation experiments should be put into effect. Three tests were selected randomly from the process parameters interval of tape winding manufacturing. As can be seen in Table 4, the error between the experimental value and simulated value is less than 6.5%. In a word, the validation test shows a high fitting accuracy for the trained model.
In order to describe the GRG changing with the process parameters more intuitively, the response contour for the GRG with respect to process parameters based on the BP neural network model is drawn in Fig. 6. Each slice in 3D view consists of different color values which express the corresponding Grey relational grade value. The corresponding color bar on the right side of each thumbnail in Fig. 7 shows the congruent relationship between color and GRG value. According to the slice planes, it is quite clear that the GRGs have no evident changes with the roller pressure increasing or decreasing in most situations. The GRG increases with the increase of the roller pressure only at the high winding velocity and heating temperature. The reason could be that the roller pressure has a great impact on the void content of winding products in the composite tape winding process. However, the void content has a lower proportion in the GRG according to the principal component analysis. When the heating temperature is low, the GRG decreases as the tape tension rises. Meanwhile, in the higher tension range, the decreasing trend of GRG as the increasing of tape tension is more obvious than the other parameter range. At high temperature, the GRG increase at the early stage and then decrease with the increasing of tape tension. In the composite tape winding process, winding velocity has an obvious influence on the performances of winding products. The GRG has a higher value at the lower winding velocity. Looking at the slice planes as a whole, the high peak values of GRG are located in the condition of medium temperature, low velocity, and high tension. In general, void content is more likely to be affected by roller pressure, and tensile strength is more likely to be influenced by tape tension.
Optimal Grey Relational Grade via Bat Algorithm
The bat algorithm is a patent evolutionary algorithm inspired by microbats’ echolocation behavior when looking for preys or avoiding barriers in a condition of complete darkness [24]. Actually, the microbat transmits the quite loud acoustic pulses and concurrently listens to the echoes bouncing off the ambient objects, so that the microbats can be able to develop the hunting strategy for prey taking full advantage of the sound pulses properties [25]. Figure 7a describes the hunting process of microbats. From the picture, we can see each bat has an individual location and emits a sound pulse which has a steady loudness and frequency domain so as to amend the location and velocity in real time.
At first, the microbat has a position x_{i} and velocity v_{i} in the multidimensional predatory searching space. Then, the updated position \( {x}_i^t \) and velocity \( {v}_i^t \) with a time step t can be provided by
where β ∈ [0, 1] denotes a random vector extracted from the uniform distribution; x_{∗} represents the latest global optimal position selecting from all the n bats’ solutions; f_{i} is the frequency of bat i and λ_{i} is the wavelength of bat i; f_{i} (or λ_{i}) is usually applied to modify the velocity changing while fixing the other factor λ_{i} (or f_{i}). In general, we use f_{min} = 0 and f_{max} = 100. Originally, each bat has a random frequency extracted from [f_{min}, f_{max}]. When a solution has been produced from the latest optimal solutions, a new resolve project for each bat will be produced as follow:
where ε ∈ [0, 1] denotes a random number; \( {A}^t=<{A}_i^t> \) denotes the average loudness of all the bats at time step t.
With iterations going on, the loudness A_{i} and pulse emission rate r_{i} will be renewed synchronously. Naturally, once a bat has found the prey, the sound loudness will generally decrease. At the same time, the pulse emission rate will increase, then the loudness can be set as any random value. For simplicity’s sake, we choose A_{0} = 1 and A_{min} = 0, and assuming A_{min} = 0 means that a bat sends no sound provisionally as the reason for finding a prey. Then, we can get
where σ and γ both are constants. In practice, σ is analogous to the cooling factor of the simulated annealing. For simplicity, we can also use σ = γ = 0.9 in the simulation.
Based on the Grey relational analysis, BP neural networks model for the tape winding process had been established subsequently. Then, the bat algorithm was applied to search the optimal parameters combination for the GRG. Compared to other algorithms, bat algorithm has more advantages such as high seeking velocity and efficaciousness. The formulation of the process optimization problem for producing maximum allowable GRG can be expressed as follows:
where T is the heating temperature, °C; F is the tape tension, N; P is the roller force, N; and V is winding speed, rpm.
The optimization process is performed on the MATLAB version R2017a software platform. Figure 7b shows the iteration process of batinspired optimization algorithm. It is obvious that the convergence was achieved within 20 iterations. According to the optimization results, the optimal parameter combination is heating temperature with 73.8 °C, tape tension with 291.2 N, roller pressure with 1804.1 N, and winding velocity with 9.1 rpm. And the highest GRG is 0.9829. The corresponding desirability value is 0.9504 which demonstrates the high agreement between the target data and the objective value. Moreover, the optimal parameter combination conforms to the optimized process parameter intervals based on the sensitivity analysis which is published on the authors’ another article [7]. From that paper, the optimized intervals of the process parameters are as follows: heating temperature within 62.5 and 75 °C, tape tension within 200 and 300 N, roller pressure within 1500 and 2000 N, and winding velocity within 5 and 10 rpm. Therefore, this paper testifies the necessity and availability of “the optimal parameter interval for composite tape winding process” on the other side.
Verification
To validate the optimal parameter combination, a confirmation experiment was carried out. Firstly, the highest GRG value 0.9686 in the 17th experiment, namely heating temperature of 75 °C, tape tension of 300 N, roller pressure of 1500 N, and winding velocity of 10 rpm, was selected as the initial process condition setting. Then, the comparison between the initial experiment and optimal settings was accomplished as shown in Table 5. The corresponding desirability value is 0.9796 which demonstrates the high agreement between the target data and the objective value. The value of tensile strength increased from 1215.31 to 1329.62 MPa. Meanwhile, the value of void content decreased from 0.15 to 0.137%. It is observed that the changing of the void content had a minor impact on the GRG of the research model. Nevertheless, it is undeniable that the void has a nonnegligible effect on the properties of the winding product. The results make it clear that the proposed method in this paper can be utilized to guide the composite tape winding manufacturing process. The optimal parameter settings can improve the tensile strength and reduce the void content for the composite tape winding products. And the performance of winding products can be improved to a certain degree.
Conclusions
In this paper, an integrated methodology combining Grey relational analysis, BP neural network, and bat algorithm was established to obtain the optimal technology parameters of composite tape winding process. In the composite tape winding process, processing parameters including heating temperature, tape tension, roller pressure, and winding velocity play a crucial role. A satisfied composite tape winding technological parameter combination aiming at two different objectives, including physical performance, mechanical property, or others, would actively guide tape winding process. Therefore, preferable winding parameters combination will improve both physical and mechanical performance for the composite winding productions. In this paper, void content and tension strength were selected as the two performance indexes for winding products. At first, the Grey relational analysis successfully transformed the multiresponse problem into a singleobjective optimization problem. According to the principal component analysis, the weight value of the tensile strength was much larger than the void content which means the tensile strength occupies a more important proportion in the GRG. BP neural networks were applied to establish the nonlinear mapping relations between the process parameters and GRG. Due to the high seeking velocity and efficaciousness, bat algorithm was applied to search the optimal parameters combination for the GRG in the last step.
According to the optimization results, the optimal parameter combination is heating temperature with 73.8 °C, tape tension with 291.2 N, roller pressure with 1804.1 N, and winding velocity with 9.1 rpm. And the corresponding tensile strength increased by 15.69 MPa and void content decreased by 0.013%. It is observed that the changing of the void content had a minor impact on the GRG of the research model. Nevertheless, it is undeniable that the void has a nonnegligible effect on the properties of the winding product. The verification test validated that the optimized intervals of the process parameters were reliable and stable for winding products manufacturing. The optimal parameter settings can improve the tensile strength and reduce the void content for the composite tape winding products. And the performance of winding products can be improved to a certain degree. At last, the developed method GRABPNNBA was verified to be useful for the multiobjective optimization problem in the manufacturing industry.
Availability of Data and Materials
The datasets supporting the conclusions of this article are included within the article.
Abbreviations
 BA:

Bat algorithm
 BBD:

Box–Behnken design
 BPNN:

Backpropagation neural network
 GRA:

Grey relational analysis
 GRG:

Grey relational grade
References
Grünewald J, Parlevliet P, Altstädt V (2016) Definition of process parameters for manufacturing of thermoplastic composite sandwiches–part a: modelling. J Thermoplast Compos Mater 31(6):745–766
Misri S, Ishak MR, Sapuan SM, Leman Z (2015) Filament winding process for Kenaf fibre reinforced polymer composites. In: Salit M, Jawaid M, Yusoff N, Hoque M. (eds) Manufacturing of Natural Fibre Reinforced Polymer Composites. Springer, Cham, pp 369–383
Kumar LM, Usha K, Anandapadmanabhan E, Chakravarthy P (2015) Development of a novel ablative composite tape layup technology for solid rocket motor nozzle and liquid engine liners. Mater Sci Forum, Trans Tech Publ 830:417–420
Deng B, Shi Y (2017) Modeling and simulation of voids in composite tape winding process based on domain superposition technique. Appl Compos Mater 25(5):1219–1236
StokesGriffin C, Compston P (2015) A combined opticalthermal model for nearinfrared laser heating of thermoplastic composites in an automated tape placement process. Compos A: Appl Sci Manuf 75:104–115
McGregor O, Duhovic M, Somashekar A, Bhattacharyya D (2017) Preimpregnated natural fibrethermoplastic composite tape manufacture using a novel process. Compos A: Appl Sci Manuf 101:59–71
Deng B, Shi Y, Yu T, Kang C, Zhao P (2018) Multiresponse parameter interval sensitivity and optimization for the composite tape winding process. Materials 11(2). https://doi.org/10.3390/ma11020220
Tannous M, Barasinski A, Binetruy C, Courtemanche B (2016) Contribution of thermomechanical parameters and friction to the bonding of thermoplastic tapes in the tape winding process. J Mater Process Technol 229:587–595
Akkus N, Garip G (2017) Influence of pretension on mechanical properties of carbon fiber in the filament winding process. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 91(9–12):3583–3589
Cui YQ, Yin ZW, Li HL (2017) Influence of tension in T300/epoxy prepreg winding process on the performance of the bearing composites. J Reinf Plast Compos 36(15):1099–1115
Okuya T, Nakada M, Miyano Y (2013) Reliable test method for tensile strength in longitudinal direction of unidirectional carbon fiberreinforced plastics. J Reinf Plast Compos 32(21):1579–1585
Nath NK (2017) Optimization of tape winding process parameters to enhance the performance of solid rocket nozzle throat back up liners using Taguchi’s robust design methodology. J Inst Eng (India): Series C 98(4):479–484
Yu T, Shi YY, He XD, Kang C, Deng B (2017) Modeling and optimization of interlaminar bond strength for composite tape winding process. J Reinf Plast Compos 36(8):579–592
G.T. 14582008, Test method for mechanical properties of ring of filamentwinding reinforced plastics, National Standards of the People's Republic of China (2008)
G.T. 33652008, Carbon fiber reinforced plasticsdetermination of void content and fiber volume content, National Standards of the People's Republic of China (2008)
Paciornik S, d'Almeida J (2010) Digital microscopy and image analysis applied to composite materials characterization. Matéria (Rio de Janeiro) 15(2):172–181
Manikandan N, Kumanan S, Sathiyanarayanan C (2016) Multiple performance optimization of electrochemical drilling of Inconel 625 using Taguchi based Grey relational analysis. Eng Sci Technol Int J 20(2):662–671
Rajesh R, Ravi V (2015) Supplier selection in resilient supply chains: a grey relational analysis approach. J Clean Prod 86:343–359
Rajyalakshmi G, Ramaiah PV (2013) Multiple process parameter optimization of wire electrical discharge machining on Inconel 825 using Taguchi grey relational analysis. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 69(5–8):1249–1262
Sarikaya M, Gullu A (2015) Multiresponse optimization of minimum quantity lubrication parameters using Taguchibased grey relational analysis in turning of difficulttocut alloy Haynes 25. J Clean Prod 91:347–357
Yin F, Mao HJ, Hua L (2011) A hybrid of back propagation neural network and genetic algorithm for optimization of injection molding process parameters. Mater Des 32(6):3457–3464
Zhang YD, Wu LN (2009) Stock market prediction of S&P 500 via combination of improved BCO approach and BP neural network. Expert Syst Appl 36(5):8849–8854
Ren C, An N, Wang JZ, Li L, Hu B, Shang D (2014) Optimal parameters selection for BP neural network based on particle swarm optimization: a case study of wind speed forecasting. KnowlBased Syst 56:226–239
Yang XS (2010) A new metaheuristic batinspired algorithm. Nat inspired Coop Strateg Optim (NICSO 2010) 284:65–74
AlBetar MA, Awadallah MA, Faris H, Yang XS, Khader AT, Alomari OA (2018) Batinspired algorithms with natural selection mechanisms for global optimization. Neurocomputing 273:448–465
Acknowledgements
The authors firstly acknowledge the National Natural Science Foundation of China. In addition, we would like to thank all the editors and anonymous reviewers who have helped to improve the paper.
Funding
Support for this study is provided by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Number: 51475377).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Contributions
BD presented the concept of this article and collected the corresponding data. He carried out the experimental work, finished the study design, the analysis, and interpretation of data, and drafted the manuscript. YS reviewed this article and put forward some constructive suggestions for the paper. All the authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Competing Interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
About this article
Cite this article
Deng, B., Shi, Y. Modeling and Optimizing the Composite Prepreg Tape Winding Process Based on Grey Relational Analysis Coupled with BP Neural Network and Bat Algorithm. Nanoscale Res Lett 14, 296 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1186/s1167101931184
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s1167101931184
Keywords
 Composite tape winding process
 Tensile strength
 Void content
 Backpropagation neural network
 Bat algorithm