 Nano Express
 Open Access
 Published:
Multifunctional graphene metasurface to generate and steer vortex waves
Nanoscale Research Letters volume 14, Article number: 343 (2019)
Abstract
Graphene, an innovated 2D material with atomic thickness, is a very promising candidate and has drawn great attentions in various applications. Graphene metasurface enables dynamic control of various wavefronts, achieving distinguished functionalities. The flexibility of graphene metasurface makes it possible to implement multifunctional devices with ease. In this work, a novel design of multifunctional graphene metasurface, which can combine the functionalities of generating and steering vortex waves, has been proposed. The multifunctional graphene metasurface consists of a large array of graphene reflective unit cells. Each unit cell is controlled independently by its size and external static gate voltage. By scrutinizing the reflective property of the graphene cell, the graphene metasurface is designed to realize multifunctionalities. Simulation results show that vortex wave can be generated and steered. This work can establish a methodology to design multifunctional graphene metasurfaces, and the tunability of graphene opens the gate to the design and fabrication of reconfigurable graphene devices.
Introduction
Graphene, an innovated 2D innovated material with atomic thickness, is drawing more and more attention in biology, optoelectronics, terahertz communication, etc [1]. In terahertz regime, graphene has better performance than conventional noble metal due to the support of surface plasmon polaritons (SPPs) propagation [2], which makes it a very promising candidate in terahertz technology. Therefore, in recent years, there emerged a great number of graphenebased devices in terahertz and midinfrared regimes, such as modulators [3–6], detectors [7], absorbers [8, 9], and lasers [10, 11].
It is of great importance to design and fabricate reconfigurable metamaterials to control the behaviour of electromagnetic waves [12, 13]. Therefore, many tuning mechanisms have been realized in various different frequency ranges [14], such as electricallyreconfigurable metamaterials [15], mechanically reconfigurable metamaterials [16], nonlinear materials [17], liquid crystals [18], microfluids [19], semiconductor structures [20], and graphene [21]. Graphene, as an innovated material, is a distinguished candidate among them, mainly due to its electric/magnetic controlled conductivity, which enables the design and fabrication of miniaturized controllable devices [14, 22]. Therefore, it has great potential to design reconfigurable metasurface, and many application based on its tunability have been proposed in [23] and [24]. By applying generalized Snell’s law [25, 26], anomalous reflection can be tuned and realized by graphene metasurfaces [27]. These works can pave the way of design and fabrication of tunable terahertz devices.
In telecommunication, orbital angular momentum (OAM) is important to enhance the channel capacity since it can provide infinite state[28, 29]. Threedimensional metamaterial can be used to generate OAM wave [30]. Metasurface, which can be considered as two dimensional metamaterial, can bring outstanding performance in subwavelength thickness. In microwave regime, metasurface have been widely used to design and fabricate devices of subwavelength sizes to generate waves with various polarization and gain properties [31–34]. In terahertz regime, a reflective graphene metasurface has been reported to generate vortex waves with tunability [35]. Graphene metasurface has the flexibility to control the wavefront [36]; therefore, a feasible design, which combines the functionalities of vortex wave generation and anomalous reflection, can be expected to tune the directivity of vortex waves with high precisions.
In this work, based on our previous research on metasurface in micronano optics [37–41], we study the mechanism to combine the functionalities of two metasurfaces. A graphene cell is analysed to obtain the relationship between the reflection coefficient and its chemical potential along with its patch size. A full 360 ^{∘} reflection phase range is calibrated as reference to design a graphene metasurface to combine the functionalities of vortex wave generation and anomalous reflection. The combined metasurface is realized by large array of reflective graphene cells. The simulated results show that vortex waves can be generated and steered by a certain angle of reflection.
Methods
The conductivity of graphene consists of interband and intraband transition. The intraband transition dominates the terahertz and infrared regime, while the interband transition dominates visible optical regime. In terahertz and infrared region, the conductivity can be modelled by Drude model [24],
where k_{B} is Boltzmann constant, T is the temperature, τ is the relaxation time, and E_{f} is Fermi energy.
In this work, the device operates in the terahertz regime, where E_{f}≫k_{B}T; hence, the equation can be simplified as
assuming the typical value of room temperature T=300K, and the relaxation time of graphene τ=1 ps. In this work, the Fermi energy E_{f} is controlled by external static gate voltage. In the simulation, graphene is not modelled as 3D metamaterial blocks but 2D surface conductive conditions due to the atomic thickness.
Graphene metasurface is composed of large array of graphene cells, which results in collective plasmonic behaviour excited on the surface, realizing extraordinary electromagnetic properties. The frequency is 1.3 THz; thus, due to the slowwave propagation associated with the plasmonic mode, the resonance can occur at very small sizes, i. e., below λ/10 [23, 42]. In order to design the metasurface of graphene cells, a calibration graph of the reflective behaviour of a graphene cell is extracted to study the detailed influence of each parameter in a single graphene cell.
A typical unit graphene cell, as shown in Fig. 1, is composed of multilayer structure with graphene patch of atomic thickness mounted on the top. The graphene patch with size of w_{x}×w_{y} is mounted at the center on top of a stack of layered square substrates with side lengths p of 14 µm. A quartz substrate (ε_{r}=3.75,tanδ=0.0184) of 25µm thickness is placed on top of the metallic ground layer at the bottom. An external biasing DC voltage is applied between the graphene patch and a polycrystalline silicon layer of 50nm thickness. A 10nmthick Al_{2}O_{3} (Alumina, \(\epsilon _{r}=8.9, \tan \delta =0.01\)) layer is inserted in between as spacer. The chemical potential can be adjusted from 0.01 to 1.0 eV, by controlling the by external biasing DC voltage from 0 to 14.7 V [23, 35]. It should be mentioned that the polycrystalline silicon layer and the Alumina spacer is not modelled in the simulation in this paper and the reasons are as follows. Firstly, a separate 2D simulation, which is much less expensive, is carried out to show that, since the thickness of the polycrystalline silicon layer and the Alumina spacer is much less than the quartz substrate, their influence on the reflective behaviour can be neglected. On the other hand, in the finite element simulations, an extreme amount of elements is required when dealing with adjacent objects with huge difference in sizes. As a result, 3D simulations modelling these two layers will be extremely expensive.
In order to study the reflective properties influenced by μ_{c} and w_{x}, periodic conditions are assigned in both x and y directions. The wave impinges normally from top with parallel polarization, i.e., electric field polarized in xdirection. Since graphene is equivalent as complex surface conductance condition, only w_{x} can affect conductance in xdirection significantly, while w_{y} has negligible influence and is fixed as 4 µm in all the simulations in this paper.
To scrutinize the influences of patch size and chemical potential, we sweep w_{x} from 0.2 to 13.8 µm by step of 0.2 µm, and sweep μ_{c} from 0.01 to 1.00 eV by step of 0.01 eV, and the frequency is fixed at 1.3 THz. The phase and magnitude of S_{11} are plotted in Fig. 2, which are called the calibration graphs since the value of w_{x} and μ_{c} can be calibrated from them. In order to guarantee the efficiency of the metasurface, the magnitude of the reflection coefficient should be lager that 0.7; thus the unqualified regions are dug out as blank. In the calibration graph, one obtains a full coverage of 360^{∘} which is sufficient to construct graphene metasurfaces.
The phase diagram should be smooth enough to control the phase precisely. In order to design the parameters of graphene cells to achieve full phase coverage from 0^{∘} to 360^{∘}, seven combinations of w_{x} and μ_{c} are selected, as shown in Fig. 3.
Results and discussions
To realize various functions, it would be very useful to combine the functionalities of two metasurfaces, or add new functions into another. This methodology will provide versatile way to design new metasurfaces. We combine the functionalities of vortex wave generation and wave deflection by anomalous reflection in this paper.
A generalized methodology is proposed in the following to combine two metasurfaces MS_{1} and MS_{2} into one multifunctional metasurface MS_{t}. To realize the combination, we start with the generalized law of reflection [25]. As illustrated in Fig. 4, consider a planewave with freespace wavelength λ impinges with incident angle θ_{i}, the following equation describes the generalized law of reflection,
where θ_{r} is the angle of reflection, n_{i} is the the refractive index in upper space, and ϕ(x) describes the phase discontinuity along the interface.
Consider the simplified case that the wave impinges normally, and the upper space is freespace (n_{i}=1), as shown in Fig. 5, for the first two metasurfaces MS_{1} and MS_{2}, Eq. 1 can be further simplified as
To obtain ϕ_{t} of MS_{t}, we choose a segment D_{x} along the interface, and the problem becomes the following: assume in x∈D_{x}, holds −π/2<θ_{r1}(x)+θ_{r2}(x)<π/2, find ϕ_{t}, s. t. for ∀x∈D_{x}, that
It can be derived from Eqs. 2 and 3 that
which leads to
where the integration term calculates the contribution of the variance of θ_{ri}(x) and can mostly be calculated numerically. Equation 5 plays a vital role to combine the functionalities of two metasurfaces.
Furthermore, if the steering angle is constant, the integration term in Eq. 6 vanishes. Equation 5 can be significantly simplified as
This is the governing equation to combine metasurfaces, and the phase distribution can be calculated to combine vortex wave generation and anomalous reflection.
In this paper, MS_{1} is the metasurface that generates vortex waves, while MS_{2} is the metasurface that steers the waves.
As illustrated in [35], vortex waves with mode l can be generated by a plate of N sectors with successive increment of phase shift. The phase shift of the nth sector ϕ_{n} can be calculated as ϕ_{n}=ϕ_{0}+2πnl/N, where ϕ_{0} is the phase shift of the initial sector. Moreover, in order to generate vortex wave, it should be satisfied that −N/2<l<N/2. Therefore, N=4 is sufficient to generate modes l=0, ±1.
To generate vortex wave with l=1, the plate is subdivided into four sectors as shown in Fig. 6a. The phase condition ϕ_{1}(x,y) is a piecewise constant function that decreases by 90^{∘} through sectors, counterclockwisely.
When xpolarized wave is impinging normally from above, vortex wave with l=1 will be reflected. It should be noted that the wave is reflected vertically; therefore, the deflection angle is 0^{∘}, i.e., θ_{r1}(x)=0^{∘}.
To generate anomalous reflection with deflection angle θ_{r}, Eq. 1 is applied. As illustrated in Fig. 4, when wave is impinging normally in freespace, i.e., θ_{i}=0^{∘} and n_{i}=1, Eq. 1 is reduced to
In this work, the deflection angle is set as θ_{r}=30^{∘}. From the equation above, by knowing that the period of unit cell is 14 µm, the difference of phase shift between adjacent patches is calculated as 10.9^{∘}. The phase distribution is shown in Fig. 6b.
To combine MS_{1} and MS_{2}, we take θ_{r1}(x)=0^{∘} and θ_{r2}(x)=30^{∘} into Eq. 6 and obtain the design formula of MS_{t},
From this formula, one can calculate the phase distribution, which is shown in Fig. 6c. According to Fig. 3, by choosing the chemical potentials μ_{c} and the patch size w_{x} of each cell, a 32×32 graphene metasurface is configured. Figure 1a shows the top view of the placement of the graphene cells on the metasurface. One can see that each sector is a 16 ×16 subdomain, consisting 16 columns vertically. And each column consists of 16 identical graphene patches, where a certain combination of w_{x} and μ_{c} is assigned.
The plate is excited by an xpolarized wave impinging from top. The electric field of the incident wave is normalized, i.e., \( \vec {\mathrm {E}}_{\text {inc}}=\vec {x}\). The simulation was carried out using commercial finite element solver COMSOL Multiphysics 5.2. Graphene has atomic thickness; however, the thickness of the substrates is in micrometre scale. Therefore, computational effort would be tremendous if threedimensional meshing is applied to graphene patches. Therefore, the thickness of the graphene patches is ignored, and an equivalent two dimensional surface conductivity condition is applied as transition boundary conditions in COMSOL Multiphysics. There are 32×32 patches on the plate, which is subdivided into four sectors. On each sector, there are 16×16 patches controlled independently by their sizes and chemical potentials. The simulation consumed 7.1 million degrees of freedom, which was carried out on a server of 40 ×2.1 GHz threads and 256 GB memory.
Figure 7b shows the magnitude of the electric field of the reflected wave normalized by the incident wave. The graphene metasurface generates vortex wave with l=1 and deflects by 30 ^{∘} towards xaxis.
Conclusions
In summary, we have studied the design principle of multifunctional graphene metasurfaces. The methodology of combining two metasurfaces is proposed. As an example, a graphene metasurface is designed to combine the functionality of generating vortex wave and steering the waves. Graphene is a twodimensional atomic thick material, which can dynamically tune the phase condition by applying external gate voltages. Its parameters are scrutinized to calibrate the reflective behaviour of a single graphene cell and obtain coverage of 360^{∘} phase shift. A graphene metasurface consisting of 32×32 unit cells is designed to realize anomalous reflection and generate vortex THz wave simultaneously. Simulation results show that a vortex wave with l=1 is generated and steered. Graphene exhibits many extraordinary behaviour in terahertz regime, such as supporting SPP, high efficiency, and tunability; therefore, it is a promising candidate in terahertz technology. This research investigate the approach to combine the functionalities of different metasurfaces implemented by graphene, which opens the gate of dynamically controlled multifunctional metasurfaces in terahertz regime.
Availability of Data and Materials
The datasets generated during and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding authors on reasonable request.
Abbreviations
 OAM:

Orbital angular momentum
 SPP:

Surface plasmon polariton
References
 1
Geim AK, Novoselov KS (2007) The rise of graphene. Nat Mater 6(3):183–191.
 2
Tamagnone M, GomezDiaz J, Mosig JR, PerruisseauCarrier J (2012) Reconfigurable terahertz plasmonic antenna concept using a graphene stack. Appl Phys Lett 101(21):214102.
 3
SensaleRodriguez B, Fang T, Yan R, Kelly MM, Jena D, Liu L, Xing H (2011) Unique prospects for graphenebased terahertz modulators. Appl Phys Lett 99(11):113104.
 4
SensaleRodriguez B, Yan R, Kelly MM, Fang T, Tahy K, Hwang WS, Jena D, Liu L, Xing HG (2012) Broadband graphene terahertz modulators enabled by intraband transitions. Nature Commun 3:780.
 5
Degl’Innocenti R, Jessop DS, Shah YD, Sibik J, Zeitler JA, Kidambi PR, Hofmann S, Beere HE, Ritchie DA (2014) Lowbias terahertz amplitude modulator based on splitring resonators and graphene. ACS Nano 8(3):2548–2554.
 6
Zeng B, Huang Z, Singh A, Yao Y, Azad AK, Mohite AD, Taylor AJ, Smith DR, Chen HT (2018) Hybrid graphene metasurfaces for highspeed midinfrared light modulation and singlepixel imaging. Light: Sci & Appl 7(1):51.
 7
Spirito D, Coquillat D, De Bonis SL, Lombardo A, Bruna M, Ferrari AC, Pellegrini V, Tredicucci A, Knap W, Vitiello MS (2014) High performance bilayergraphene terahertz detectors. Appl Phys Lett 104(6):061111.
 8
Xing R, Dong C, Zhu B, Gao Y, Jian S (2016) Numerical analysis on ribbonarraysheet coupled graphene terahertz absorber. IEEE Photon Technol Lett 28(20):2207–2210.
 9
Sang T, Gao J, Yin X, Qi H, Wang L, Jiao H (2019) Angleinsensitive broadband absorption enhancement of graphene using a multigrooved metasurface. Nanoscale Res Lett 14(1):105.
 10
Otsuji T, Tombet SB, Satou A, Ryzhii M, Ryzhii V (2013) Terahertzwave generation using graphene: toward new types of terahertz lasers. IEEE J Sel Top Quantum Electron 19(1):8400209–8400209.
 11
Tong J, Muthee M, Chen SY, Yngvesson SK, Yan J (2015) Antenna enhanced graphene thz emitter and detector. Nano Lett 15(8):5295–5301.
 12
Walia S, Shah CM, Gutruf P, Nili H, Chowdhury DR, Withayachumnankul W, Bhaskaran M, Sriram S (2015) Flexible metasurfaces and metamaterials: a review of materials and fabrication processes at microand nanoscales. Appl Phys Rev 2(1):011303.
 13
Yu P, Besteiro LV, Huang Y, Wu J, Fu L, Tan HH, Jagadish C, Wiederrecht GP, Govorov AO, Wang Z (2019) Broadband metamaterial absorbers. Adv Opt Mater 7(3):1800995.
 14
Oliveri G, Werner DH, Massa A (2015) Reconfigurable electromagnetics through metamaterialsa review. Proc IEEE 103(7):1034–1056.
 15
Gil I, Bonache J, GarciaGarcia J, Martin F (2006) Tunable metamaterial transmission lines based on varactorloaded splitring resonators. IEEE Trans Microwave Theory Tech 54(6):2665–2674.
 16
Naqui J, Martín F (2014) Mechanically reconfigurable microstrip lines loaded with stepped impedance resonators and potential applications. Int J Antenn Propag 2014.
 17
Goldflam M, Driscoll T, Chapler B, Khatib O, Marie Jokerst N, Palit S, Smith D, Kim BJ, Seo G, Kim HT, et al (2011) Reconfigurable gradient index using vo2 memory metamaterials. Appl Phys Lett 99(4):044103.
 18
Zhao Q, Kang L, Du B, Li B, Zhou J, Tang H, Liang X, Zhang B (2007) Electrically tunable negative permeability metamaterials based on nematic liquid crystals. Appl Phys Lett 90(1):011112.
 19
Holloway CL, Kuester EF, Gordon JA, O’Hara J, Booth J, Smith DR (2012) An overview of the theory and applications of metasurfaces: the twodimensional equivalents of metamaterials. IEEE Antenn Propag Mag 54(2):10–35.
 20
Kafesaki M, Shen N, Tzortzakis S, Soukoulis C (2012) Optically switchable and tunable terahertz metamaterials through photoconductivity. J Opt 14(11):114008.
 21
SensaleRodriguez B, Yan R, Liu L, Jena D, Xing HG (2013) Graphene for reconfigurable terahertz optoelectronics. Proc IEEE 101(7):1705–1716.
 22
Hanson GW (2008) Dyadic Green’s functions and guided surface waves for a surface conductivity model of graphene. J Appl Phys 103(6):064302.
 23
Carrasco E, Tamagnone M, PerruisseauCarrier J (2013) Tunable graphene reflective cells for thz reflectarrays and generalized law of reflection. Appl Phys Lett 102(10):104103.
 24
Li Z, Yao K, Xia F, Shen S, Tian J, Liu Y (2015) Graphene plasmonic metasurfaces to steer infrared light. Sci Rep 5:12423.
 25
Yu N, Genevet P, Kats MA, Aieta F, Tetienne JP, Capasso F, Gaburro Z (2011) Light propagation with phase discontinuities:generalized laws of reflection and refraction. Science 334(6054):333–337.
 26
Yu N, Capasso F (2014) Flat optics with designer metasurfaces. Nature Materials 13(2):139.
 27
Carrasco E, PerruisseauCarrier J (2013) Reflectarray antenna at terahertz using graphene. IEEE Antenn Wirel Propag Lett 12:253–256.
 28
Wang J, Yang J. Y., Fazal IM, Ahmed N, Yan Y, Huang H, Ren Y, Yue Y, Dolinar S, Tur M, et al (2012) Terabit freespace data transmission employing orbital angular momentum multiplexing. Nature Photo 6(7):488.
 29
Mohammadi SM, Daldorff LK, Bergman JE, Karlsson RL, Thidé B, Forozesh K, Carozzi TD, Isham B (2010) Orbital angular momentum in radioa system study. IEEE Trans Antenn Propag 58(2):565–572.
 30
Zhang C, Deng L, Hong WJ, Jiang WX, Zhu JF, Zhou M, Wang L, Li SF, Peng B (2016) Threedimensional simultaneous arbitraryway orbital angular momentum generator based on transformation optics. Sci Rep 6:38667.
 31
Chung KL, Chaimool S, Zhang C (2015) Wideband subwavelengthprofile circularly polarised array antenna using anisotropic metasurface. Electron Lett 51(18):1403–1405.
 32
Chung KL, Kharkovsky S (2013) Metasurfaceloaded circularlypolarised slot antenna with high fronttoback ratio. Electron Lett 49(16):979–981.
 33
Chung KL (2013) Highperformance circularly polarized antenna array using metamaterialline based feed network. IEEE Trans Antenn Propag 61(12):6233–6237.
 34
Chung KL, Chaimool S (2012) Broadside gain and bandwidth enhancement of microstrip patch antenna using a mnzmetasurface. Microwave Opt Technol Lett 54(2):529–532.
 35
Chang Z, You B, Wu LS, Tang M, Zhang YP, Mao JF (2016) A reconfigurable graphene reflectarray for generation of vortex thz waves. IEEE Antenn Wirel Propag Lett 15:1537–1540.
 36
Lu F, Liu B, Shen S (2014) Infrared wavefront control based on graphene metasurfaces. Adv Opt Materials 2(8):794–799.
 37
Xu P, Huang Y, Zhang X, Huang J, Li B, Ye E, Duan S, Su Z (2013) Integrated microoptical light guide plate. Opt Express 21(17):20159–20170.
 38
Xu P, Hong C, Cheng G, Zhou L, Sun Z (2015) Planar optical correlators integrated with binary optical lens. Optics Express 23(5):6773–6779.
 39
Xu P, Huang Y, Su Z, Zhang X, Luo T, Peng W (2015) Research of microprism distribution on the bottom surface of the smallsize integrated light guide plate. Opt Express 23(4):4887–4896.
 40
Huang H, Ruan S, Yang T, Xu P (2015) Novel even beam splitters based on subwavelength binary simple periodic rectangular structure. NanoMicro Lett 7(2):177–182.
 41
Xu P, Yuan X, Huang H, Yang T, Huang Y, Zhu T, Tang S, Peng W (2016) Research on design of tricolor shift device. Nanoscale Res Lett 11(1):485.
 42
Christensen J, Manjavacas A, Thongrattanasiri S, Koppens FH, García de Abajo FJ (2011) Graphene plasmon waveguiding and hybridization in individual and paired nanoribbons. ACS nano 6(1):431–440.
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge the support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 61275167 and 61601040) and the Fundamental Research Foundation of Shenzhen (Grant No. JCYJ20170817102315892 and JCYJ20160308100236349).
Funding
National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 61275167 and 61601040)and Fundamental Research Foundation of Shenzhen (Grant No. JCYJ20170817102315892 and JCYJ20160308100236349).
Author information
Affiliations
Contributions
MW designed the configuration, performed the simulations, and wrote the manuscript. QZ, BF, and LD provided support of theoretical analysis and simulations. PX provided many critical suggestions for this paper. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Correspondence to Botao Feng.
Ethics declarations
Competing Interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
About this article
Cite this article
Wang, M., Zeng, Q., Deng, L. et al. Multifunctional graphene metasurface to generate and steer vortex waves. Nanoscale Res Lett 14, 343 (2019) doi:10.1186/s1167101931892
Received
Accepted
Published
DOI
Keywords
 Graphene
 Metasruface of multifunctions
 Vortex wave