On the Enhanced Antibacterial Activity of Antibiotics Mixed with Gold Nanoparticles

The bacterial action of gentamicin and that of a mixture of gentamicin and 15-nm colloidal-gold particles onEscherichia coliK12 was examined by the agar-well-diffusion method, enumeration of colony-forming units, and turbidimetry. Addition of gentamicin to colloidal gold changed the gold color and extinction spectrum. Within the experimental errors, there were no significant differences in antibacterial activity between pure gentamicin and its mixture with gold nanoparticles (NPs). Atomic absorption spectroscopy showed that upon application of the gentamicin-particle mixture, there were no gold NPs in the zone of bacterial-growth suppression in agar. Yet, free NPs diffused into the agar. These facts are in conflict with the earlier findings indicating an enhancement of the bacterial activity of similar gentamicin–gold nanoparticle mixtures. The possible causes for these discrepancies are discussed, and the suggestion is made that a necessary condition for enhancement of antibacterial activity is the preparation of stable conjugates of NPs coated with the antibiotic molecules.

Conjugates of gold NPs with antibiotics and antibodies also have been used for selective photothermal killing of protozoa and bacteria [36][37][38]. In regard to antibacterial activity, Williams et al. [39] showed that gold NPs themselves do not affect bacterial growth or functional activity, whereas conjugates of vancomycin to gold NPs decrease the number of growing bacterial cells [37]. Gu et al. [40] synthesized stable gold NPs covered with vancomycin and showed significant enhancement of antibacterial activity for this conjugate, in comparison with the activity of the free antibiotic. A similar result was reported for ciprofloxacin conjugated with Au/SiO 2 core/shell NPs [41].
In contrast to gold NPs, silver NPs may exhibit antibacterial activity [42]. Furthermore, silver NPs were shown to enhance the antibacterial activity of penicillin G, amoxicillin, erythromycin, clindamycin, and vancomycin against Staphylococcus aureus and Escherichia coli [43]. Similar conclusions were reported on the antibacterial activity of silver and gold NPs stabilized with hyperbranched poly(amidoamine), containing terminal dimethylamine groups [44].
It should be emphasized that in the above-cited studies [37,40,41], the authors used NPs functionalized with antibiotics by physical or chemical adsorption. Compared with bare NPs, stable conjugates exhibited small changes in the absorption spectra. For the naked eye, the conjugated sols retained their red color, typical of colloidal-gold sols.
In 2007, four papers have been published [45][46][47][48], reporting the use of blue aggregated mixtures of drugs and GNPs, rather than of stable red conjugates. Such a color change and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images unambiguously indicated NP aggregation [49]. The drugs used were aminoglycoside antibiotics (streptomycin, gentamicin, kanamycin, and neomycin), quinolones (ciprofloxacin, gatifloxacin, and norfloxacin), ampicillin (a penicillin antibiotic), and 5-fluorouracil (an antimetabolite of nucleic metabolism). The preparations obtained by the authors were tested for antibacterial activity toward gram-positive (S. aureus, Micrococcus luteus) and gram-negative (E. coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa) microorganisms, and they also were examined for antifungal activity toward Aspergillus fumigatus and Aspergillus niger. The basic experimental tests for the determination of antibacterial activity were the disk diffusion method [45,46,48] and the agar-well-diffusion method [47]. Depending on the antibiotic used, increase in the activity of the antibiotic-colloidal-gold mixture ranged from 12 to 40%, as compared with the activities of the native drugs. From those data, the authors concluded that the antibacterial activities of the antibiotics were enhanced through the use of gold NPs [45][46][47][48].
However, as noted by the authors themselves [43][44][45][46][47][48], the question of the mechanisms governing possible enhancement of the antibacterial action of drugs or polymers remains unanswered. Whereas several hypotheses have been raised for aggregatively stable NP-antibiotic conjugates [40], the enhancement mechanism for aggregated NP-antibiotic mixtures-if it exists at all-is absolutely incomprehensible, at least when the activity of preparations is assessed by the agar-well-diffusion method. First, no gold NPs have been shown to be present in the agar zone of bacterial-growth inhibition. Antibiotic addition to an NP suspension leads to NP aggregation, readily detectable with extinction spectra and with TEM images. The question now arises, can particle aggregates diffuse into agar at all? Let us suggest for a moment that diffusion is impossible. In that case, the question of enhancement of antibacterial action loses its meaning altogether. Here, therefore, we decided to examine the antibacterial activity of an NP-antibiotic mixture and to simultaneously investigate the penetration of particles into agar.
We explored the antibacterial activity of a mixture of gentamicin and colloidal-gold particles (average diameter, 15 nm) toward E. coli R12, by using the agar-well-diffusion method, enumeration of colony-forming units (CFUs), and turbidimetry. Gentamicin was chosen on the basis of the following reasons. First, as an aminoglycoside antibiotic, gentamicin is of unquestionable practical interest. Being a mixture of gentamicins C1, C2, and C1a, it is bacteriostatic to many gram-positive and gram-negative microorganisms, including E. coli, Proteus, Salmonella, and penicillin-resistant Staphylococcus strains. The mechanism of gentamicin action is linked to disruption of ribosomal synthesis of protein, and microbial resistance to gentamicin develops fairly slowly. Gentamicin is a major agent used to treat severe purulent infection, especially that caused by a resistant gram-negative flora. As a broadspectrum antibiotic, gentamicin is often prescribed for patients with mixed infection and also when the infecting agent has not been identified. Sometimes gentamicin is effective when other antibiotics display insufficient activity [50].
Second, gentamicin was chosen because, as found previously [45], a mixture of gentamicin and gold NPs has the most enhanced activity toward E. coli. It is this result, along with the need to study particle penetration into agar, that prompted this research.

Preparation of Gold NPs
Gold NPs were prepared by the reduction of tetrachloroauric acid with sodium citrate [51]. A 242.5-mL portion of 0.01% aqueous tetrachloroauric acid (Aldrich, USA) was heated on an MR 3001 magnetic stirrer (Heidolph, Germany) in an Erlenmeyer flask fitted with a water-cooled reflux tube. This was followed by the addition of 7.5 mL of 1% aqueous sodium citrate (Fluka, Switzerland) to the flask. The mean particle diameter (16 nm) was controlled by spectrophotometric calibration [52].

Preparation of a Gentamicin-NP Mixture
We used an aqueous stock solution of gentamicin sulfate (Fluka, Switzerland; activity, 636 U mg -1 ; concentration, 4.5 mg mg -1 ). Immediately before being added to the culture medium or to the gel wells, the antibiotic solution was mixed 1:1 either with 2 mM K 2 CO 3 or with gold NPs in the same solution. In agar-well-diffusion experiments, we also made a series of twofold dilutions of the freegentamicin solution and of the gentamicin-NP mixture.
The formation of Au-Gm complex can be easily monitored by UV-Vis spectra (S-300 spectrophotometer, Analytik Jena, Germany). The initial 16-nm gold colloid exhibits well-known plasmon resonance near 520 nm. Immediately after addition of Gm, we observed drastic change in the colloid color from wine red to purple blue. To follow such kinetics in detail, we decreased the concentration of Gm 20 times (up to 0.05 lg mL -1 ) as compared to the average concentration used in microbial assay ( Table 1). The time-dependent UV-Vis spectra were recorded after mixing (1:1 v/v) Au colloid with Gm at timed interval 30 s (step, 1 s). A portion of spectra is shown in Fig. 1. The appearance of a new red-shifted peak near 650-670 nm is a typical signature of a fast NPs aggregation. Indeed, such a phenomenon has been described in numerous reports; for details, the readers are referred to review Ref. [53].

Bacterial Strain and Growth Conditions
E. coli R12 obtained from this institute's collection was used for this study. The strain was grown in Luria-Bertani (LB) medium at 37°C. All inoculation experiments used an overnight accumulation culture grown to stationary phase in advance. The initial culture absorbance A 600 was 0.04. Bacterial growth was assessed by using the timedependent absorbance curve. The cell concentration was estimated by the turbidity-spectra method [54].

CFU Enumeration
A bacterial suspension was mixed 1:1 with either a freegentamicin solution or a gentamicin-NP mixture and was incubated at 37°C for 1 h. For each treatment, six 10-fold serial dilutions were made. A 200-lL volume of the resultant suspension was uniformly spread onto overnightdried solid LB medium with a sterile spatula. After cultivation at 37°C for 24 h, all the colonies grown were enumerated, and the mean values and maximal scatter in CFUs were determined.

Microbial Assay
Antibacterial activity was studied by the agar-well-diffusion method, wherein a bacterial suspension was added to sterile nutrient agar at 45°C and the mixture was solidified on a Petri dish. A 20-mL volume of the medium was poured into a Petri dish (diameter, 90 mm) on a horizontally leveled surface. After the medium had solidified, 4-mm-diameter wells were made in the agar (at six wells per dish) that were equidistant from one another and from the dish edge. The wells received either 20 lL of the freeantibiotic solution or 20 lL of the antibiotic-NP mixture. The Petri dishes were incubated in a thermostat at 37°C for 24 h. After incubation, the diameter of the zone of bacterial-growth inhibition was measured with an accuracy of ±0.1 mm. The mean inhibition-zone diameter and the maximal data scatter also were determined. All experiments were repeated thrice.

Determination of the Minimum Inhibitory and Maximum Tolerant Concentrations
In experiments to determine the minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) and the maximum tolerant concentration  (MTC, equivalent to the ''no observed effect concentration''), culturing was done in microtitration-plate wells for 3 h. The initial culture absorbance A 600 was 0.04. The MIC was taken to be the gentamicin concentration at which the A 600 of the bacterial suspension after incubation was almost the same as the initial A 600 , and the MTC was numerically equal to the gentamicin concentration at which the parameters of culture growth were close to those for the control culture (without the antibiotic).

Atomic Absorption Spectroscopy
Ashing of samples was done with the addition of sulfuric acid at 600-630°C. The ash was then dissolved in a mixture of concentrated hydrochloric and nitric acids. The solution was evaporated to dryness, a necessary amount of 0.5 N hydrochloric acid was added, and the sample thus prepared was analyzed for gold on an AAS-3 atomic absorption spectrometer (Carl Zeiss, Germany). The resonance line was 242.8 nm, and the spectral slit width was 0.35 nm. Under such conditions, the limit of detection is 0.02 lg mL -1 and the linear working region is up to 20 lg mL -1 .

Results and Discussion
Effect of the Antibiotic Concentration Figure 2a is a photo of a Petri dish showing the zones of inhibition of E. coli growth upon addition of free-gentamicin and a gentamicin-NP mixture to the wells. The antibiotic concentration in the wells was decreased by twofold dilutions from 2.25 to 0.56 mg mL -1 . It can be seen that the gentamicin-NP mixture retarded bacterial growth to a degree comparable to that demonstrated by the free antibiotic. When the free antibiotic and its mixture with NPs were diluted twofold, the diameter of the zone of culture-growth inhibition was reduced to the same extent in both cases. To obtain reliable statistical data, we ran five independent experiments, with three replicates per experiment. Figure 2b and Table 1 give averaged data indicating that the antibacterial action of gentamicin did not differ significantly from that of the gentamicin-NP mixture.

Effect of the Residual Particles and Supernatant Liquids
We next answered the question whether the mixture NPs freed from unbound antibiotic in the solution showed antibacterial action. Because gold particles on their own did not have antibacterial activity (Fig. 3), our experiment allowed us to assess (to an extent) the degree of antibiotic binding to the particles and the possible enhancement of antibacterial activity through the agency of the particles. For this purpose, the gentamicin-NP mixture was centrifuged at 30009g, and the sediment was stirred in the same volume of water and was applied to the wells. We found (Fig. 3, wells 3 and 4) that the sediment NPs did not cause the formation of a zone of culture-growth inhibition at all. Yet, the supernatant liquids resulting from centrifugation had the same degree of activity toward bacterial growth as did the initial gentamicin-NP mixture (Fig. 3, wells 7 and 8). We emphasize once again that in our control experiments, neither colloidal gold itself nor solvent (2 mM K 2 CO 3 ) inhibited bacterial growth (Fig. 3, wells 5 and 6).

Effect of the NP Concentration
The absence of enhancement of the antibacterial action of the antibiotic-NP conjugates may have been due to the low concentration of particles themselves. Therefore, we examined the effect of the gold NP concentration on the antibacterial action of the conjugates. solutions in 2 mM K 2 CO 3 before being added to the wells. Note that the gold concentration of as prepared 16-nm particles was about 0.3 mM. Accordingly, the mass/volume concentration is about 57 lg mL -1 or, equivalently, the particle-number concentration is about 1.4 9 10 12 mL -1 .
After the preparation of a concentrated stock solution, the above concentrations (0.1-1 mM) were obtained by corresponding dilutions. The results (Fig. 4) show that the antibacterial activity of the preparations decreased slightly with increasing particle concentration, but from a statistical analysis of the data, it follows that this effect is within the error and is not significant.

Diffusion of Free Gentamicin and Its Complexes with NPs into Agar
As said above, addition of the antibiotic to the NP sol led to aggregation, confirmed by changes in the colloid color and extinction spectrum and also by direct TEM images. Consequently, the absence of enhancement of the antibacterial action of the conjugates and particles sedimented from the antibiotic-NP mixtures could be explained by an inability of aggregated particles to penetrate into agar gel. To test this hypothesis, we poured 1.5% agar gel (in water) into 40-mm-diameter Petri dishes, made a well in the center of each dish, and applied an NP solution and a gentamicin-NP mixture to the wells. A day later, a red colloidal-gold halo was clearly seen around the well in the case of the NP solution, whereas a blue precipitate at the well bottom in the case of the mixture (Fig. 5).
In order to independently estimate the content of gold in the diffusion zones, we used AAS. A ring-shaped piece of gel with an outside diameter of 15 mm and an inside diameter of 5 mm (the well diameter was 4 mm) was cut from the samples (Fig. 5) for AAS analysis of the gold content in the gel. The same procedure was used for the gels (Fig. 2) (for wells 2 and 6, which received the antibiotic-NP mixture and free NPs). Analysis showed that gold was totally absent in the agar gels around the mixture- Fig. 3 a Antibacterial effect of gentamicin (1), gentamicin ? gold NPs (2), redissolved sediments (3,4), the solvent (2 mM K 2 CO 3 ) (5), a solution of gold NPs (6), and the supernatant liquids from both preparations (7,8) on the growth of E. coli K12. b A diagram showing the coincidence of the average inhibition-zone diameters for free gentamicin (1), its mixture with NPs (2), and the supernatant liquids from these preparation (7,8), respectively containing wells but was present around the wells containing an NP solution ( Table 2).

Experiments with Bacterial Suspensions
Our study with bacteria grown on a solid nutrient medium has shown the absence of NPs in the inhibition zone. It follows that the question of enhancement of or decrease in the antibacterial activity of gentamicin is meaningless in this context. Therefore, we decided to investigate the antibacterial activity of an antibiotic-NP mixture in liquid culture, in which NPs or aggregates have a chance of coming into contact with bacterial cells because of Brownian motion. The antibacterial activity of the preparations was assessed by the MIC and MTC of gentamicin and a gentamicin-NP mixture for E. coli K12. From spectroturbidimetric data [54], the initial cell density was 5 9 10 7 cells mL -1 . Figure 6 shows that the absorbance of the control culture in an NP-containing medium did not differ within the limits of error from that in an NP-free medium. The main result of this experiment is that curves 3 and 4 for bacterial cells grown with free gentamicin and with a gentamicin-NP mixture do not differ from each other. Consequently, the antibacterial activity of the gentamicin-NP mixture does not exceed that of the native antibiotic not only on a solid nutrient medium, but also in a liquid medium. Quantitatively, this conclusion is shown in Table 3, which gives data on the MIC and MTC of the free antibiotic and its mixture with gold NPs.

Comparison of the Bactericidal Effects of Gentamicin and a Gentamicin-NP Mixture
In the final set of experiments, we compared the bacterial effects of the original antibiotic and a gentamicin-NP Table 2 Analysis of gold content in the gel samples cut out around the wells at 24 h after the application of an NP solution and a gentamicin-NP mixture

Sample
Fraction of the total Au mass in the sample (%) Au in 1.5% agar gel 9.3 9 10 -4 Gm ? Au in 1.5% agar gel 0 Au in solid LB medium 3.2 9 10 -4 Gm ? Au in solid LB medium 0  mixture. For this purpose, the cells were plated on gentamicin-free solid LB medium from the 10 -6 dilution of cultures incubated for 3 h with different preparations. For incubation, we used free gentamicin, a gentamicin-NP mixture, and colloidal NPs (control). The antibiotic concentrations were lowered by twofold dilutions from 240 to 3.7 lg mL -1 . The CFU data for the minimal and maximal values are given in Table 4. Table 4 shows that gentamicin at 240 lg mL -1 was bactericidal to 50 9 10 6 bacterial cells mL -1 both in a free state and in complex with NPs. The NPs decreased the CFU value, as compared with the control, but these differences were not significant. At a gentamicin concentration of 3.7 lg mL -1 , the difference between the CFU values for free gentamicin and for the mixture was almost twofold, with the addition of NPs decreasing, not increasing, the bactericidal action of the antibiotic. However, because the CFU method is usually in error by an order of magnitude, this difference between the CFU values for gentamicin and for its mixture with NPs is not significant.

Conclusions
By using several methods, we have studied the effect of 16-nm gold NPs on the antibacterial activity of gentamicin. Within the limits of experimental error, no differences have been found between the antibacterial activity of gentamicin and that of a gentamicin-gold NP mixture at various gentamicin and particle concentrations. Sedimented gold NPs from the conjugates had no antibacterial activity, whereas the supernatant liquids from gentamicin-NP mixtures and free gentamicin demonstrated the same activity. Electron microscopy and the changes in the extinction spectra showed the presence of NP aggregates, which, on evidence derived by AAS, could not penetrate into gel. This explains the absence of growth inhibition upon addition of NP sediment to the wells. Furthermore, the same degree of activity of free gentamicin and the mixtures indicates that the amount of antibiotic that could bind to the particles is small. By the CFU method, we have found that the bactericidal action of a gentamicin-NP mixture does not differ from that of free gentamicin within the limits of error. Finally, the parameters of growth inhibition in a liquid bacterial culture (MIC and MTC) also were the same for gentamicin and for the gentamicin-NP mixture. In all our experiments, therefore, we have found no significant differences in antibacterial activity between the free antibiotic and the mixture either on a solid or in a liquid nutrient medium. Comparison of these data with the findings in the literature [37,40,41], showing enhancement of antibacterial activity in the presence of NPs, suggests that two conditions at minimum are necessary (but insufficient) for such effects to be observed. First, antibiotic-NP conjugates should be stabilized, and their spectrum and color should correspond to those of single-particle nonaggregated colloids. Second, the amount of the antibiotic covering the particle surface should be large enough to ensure an increase in the local antibiotic concentration at the site of bacterium-particle contact. Thus, although gold NPs themselves do not have any antimicrobial activity, they may act as drug curriers. In other words, because of the presence of gold NPs, the surface area increases and hence it carries a lot of drug on its surface. Obviously, when the amount of drug in proximity of a bacterium is more, the antibacterial property may be enhanced. For other possible explanations, the readers are referred to Ref. [40]. In our opinion, the mechanism(s) of possible enhancement of the antibacterial activity of conjugates is still an open question and needs further study. 4.6 ± 0.5 9 10 9 NPs 3.6 ± 0.9 9 10 9 2.8 ± 0.6 9 10 9 Gm 0 1.8 ± 0.5 9 10 9 Gm ? NPs 0 0.96 ± 0.5 9 10 9