 Nano Express
 Open Access
 Published:
Observation of Landau LevelDependent AharonovBohmLike Oscillations in a Topological Insulator
Nanoscale Research Letters volume 15, Article number: 171 (2020)
Abstract
We study the quantum oscillations in the BiSbTe_{3} topological insulator. In addition to the Shubnikovde Haas (SdH) oscillation, the AharonovBohmlike (ABL) oscillations are also observed. The ABL oscillation period is constant at each Landau level (LL) which is determined from the SdH oscillation. The shorter ABL oscillation periods are observed at lower LLs. The oscillation period is proportional to the square root of the LL at temperatures. The ratio of the ABL oscillation period to the effective mass is weak LL dependence. The LLdependent ABL oscillation might originate from the LLdependent effective mass.
Introduction
AharonovBohm (AB) interference originates from the carrier wavefunction interference in a loop which might be patterned ring [1, 2], material geometric structure [3–6, 8–11], or carrier transport trajectory [12]. The magnetic field, B, through the loop will induce carrier wavefunction phase shift that leads to periodic wavefunction interference oscillations. This oscillation period is sensitive to the carrier transport characteristics, such as carrier coherence length and mobility [3, 12]. The quantum interference is an excellent tool to detect material transport characteristics and understand intrinsic mechanisms. Due to the short carrier coherence length and the small flux quantum, the quantum interference is mainly reported at high mobility nanowires or patterned nanorings at low B [3–6, 8–11]. Reports on a macroscopic system at high B are rare. The works on AB quantum interference at high B are less investigated, and the related mechanism is less understood.
In this work, quantum oscillations were performed in a BiSbTe_{3} topological insulator macroflake at high B. In addition to the Shubnikovde Haas (SdH) oscillation, the AharonovBohmlike (ABL) oscillation was observed. The ABL oscillation period is Bdependent and is different from the traditional AB oscillation, which the oscillation period is independent of B. The observed ABL oscillation period is constant at each Landau level (LL), which is determined from the SdH oscillation. The shorter oscillation periods are observed at lower LLs. The oscillation period is proportional to the square root of the LL at temperatures. The ratio of the ABL oscillation period to the effective mass is weak LL dependence. The LLdependent ABL oscillation might originate from the LLdependent effective mass.
Experimental Method
The growth condition of the BiSbTe_{3} single crystal is the same as our previous work on the topological insulators [13–16]. Our previous work demonstrated that TI with extremely high uniformity can be obtained using the RHFZ method [13–16]. Raman, EDS, and XPS spectrum proved that the crystal is BiSbTe_{3}. The BiSbTe_{3} single crystal flakes were obtained using the Scotchtape method. The cleaved flake geometry is roughly 3 mm in length, 2 mm in width, and 170 μm in thickness. Magnetotransport measurements were performed using the standard sixprobe technique in a commercial apparatus (Quantum Design PPMS) with a B of up to 14 T. The B was applied perpendicular to the large cleaved surface. The data points are taken per 100 Gauss at magnetic field region between 6 and 14 T in the steady magnetic field mode, instead of the sweeping magnetic field mode.
Results and Discussion
Figure 1 shows the magnetoresistances (MRs) as a function of B. The R(14T)/R(0T) reaches 10 and is higher than most reported values in Bi _{x}Sb_{2−x}Te_{y}Se_{3−y} topological insulators [17–23, 23–33]. Both theoretical and experimental investigations support that the MR ratio is proportional to the carrier mobility [34], The measured high MR ratio supports the high quality of our BiSbTe_{3} sample. The topleft inset reveals the dR/dB as a function of 1/B. It reveals that periodic oscillations and oscillation peaks and dips are at the same B at 2 and 8 K. This is known as SdH oscillation that originates from a twodimensional system. The SdH oscillation period corresponds to the Fermi momentum vector, k_{f}. The bottomright inset shows the fast Fourier transform (FFT) of the SdH oscillation. A sharp peak at 48 T is observed for both 2 and 8 K. Following the Onsager relation, one could estimate k_{f} through \(F=\frac {\hbar k_{f}^{2}}{2e}\), where F is the SdH oscillation frequency. The F=48 T leads to the k_{f}=3.8Å^{−1}, which is consistent with the observed value from ARPES from a different batch of the same crystal and from reported values in literature [35]. That supports the high quality and uniformity of our BiSbTe_{3} crystal. As well as the SdH oscillation, the topleft inset reveals oscillations with a short period. To suppress the influence of the SdH oscillation and extract oscillation characteristics, the d^{2}R/dB^{2} is performed.
Figure 2 exhibits the dR/dB and d^{2}R/dB^{2} as a function of B at 2 and 8 K. Dot lines label oscillation peaks in d^{2}R/dB^{2}, and long dash lines correspond to B of LLs that are determined from the extracted SdH oscillation frequency. The periodic oscillations is similar to the AB oscillation. The AB oscillation period is expressed as \(\Delta B =\frac {\Phi }{A}\). Φ is the flux quantum, where \(\frac {h}{e}\), and A is the geometry area looped by clockcount and anticlockcount carrier trajectories in a confined structure. Due to the small flux quantum, the AB oscillation is mainly observed in confinement by artificial nanostructures [1, 2], such as nanorings and nanowires [3–11]. Recently, it is reported that carrier elastic scattering trajectory might form a series of connected closed loops in a macroscopic system. A B flux through these loops would induce carrier wavefunction phase shift and lead to periodic ABL oscillations [12]. The extracted elastic scattering length is roughly 150 nm which corresponds to the oscillation period with 0.02 T and is consistent with our experimental observation.
Following the dot lines in Fig. 2, one could note that the oscillation period is constant at each LL and the oscillation period is shorter at lower LLs. This behavior is different from the traditional AB oscillation. To extract and determine these oscillation periods, FFT is performed at different LLs. Figure 3 shows the FFT at different LLs at 2 and 8 K, and it clearly reveals the higher oscillation frequency at lower LLs at 2 and 8 K.
A similar LLdependent ABL oscillation is reported at the integer quantum Hall regime in semiconductor twodimensional electron gas [36, 37]. It has been interpreted either as constructive interference of onedimensional electron traveling along edge channels or as quantum wave interference of edge electrons. The carrier transport path in different edge channels leads to different effective areas in a confined pattern and eventually to different ABL oscillation periods in edge channels at different LLs [38–40]. Further studies on electric FabryPerot interferometers in integer and fractional quantum Hall regime reveal that the ABL oscillation period is related to the flux period by \(\frac {\Phi }{f}\), where f is the fully occupied LL in the constrictions. The oscillation period is expected to be \(\frac {\Phi }{A f}\), where A is the geometry area of the confined shape [41, 42].
Table 1 lists the extracted oscillation periods from the FFT at different LLs and temperatures. The analysis reveals that the ratio of the oscillation period to the square root of LL is constant at each temperature. This is different from the behavior of FabryPerot interferometer in which the oscillation is inversely proportional to LLs [41, 42]. On the other hand, the electric FabryPerot interference originates from carrier trajectory coupling between different LLs from inside and outside a confined pattern [37]. The oscillation is strongly related to the patterned geometry. There are no artificial patterns on the surface of our samples, and there should be no suitable coupling channels between different LLs. Furthermore, the geometry sizes of our samples are in the millimeter scale and the related AB oscillation period would be too small to be detected. Despite these differences from existing works, we think that aside from the geometric area and carrier coherence length, the intrinsic carrier characteristic might play a critical role on the LLdependent ABL oscillation [3, 43].
Following the LifshitzKosevich (LK) theory, one can extract characteristic parameters of the transport carriers in the surface state of the topological insulator, and the temperature dependence of the amplitude of the SdH oscillation is expressed as
where \(\lambda (T/B) = (2\pi ^{2}k_{B}Tm_{cyc})/(\hbar eB)\). Figure 4 shows the extracted normalized SdH oscillation amplitude as a function of temperature at different LLs. It agrees well with the LK theory and reveals different tendencies at different LLs. The fitting results support that the m_{cyc}=0.152m_{0},0.170m_{0},0.185m_{0}, and 0.191m_{0}, where m_{0} is the free electron mass, for N=4, 5, 6 and 7, respectively. These values are consistent with the reported effective masses in topological insulators [21, 22]. This Landau leveldependent effective mass is recently observed in the 3D Dirac semimetal ZrTe_{5} [44]. However, the origin of the magnetic fielddependent effective mass is not clear yet. It needs further study to clarify the intrinsic mechanism. The different effective mass would directly deviate the intrinsic carrier transport characteristic at Fermi surface, such as Fermi velocity, which is directly related to the carrier phase coherence length. The higher effective mass would lead to lower coherence length that corresponds to the longer ABlike oscillation period. This is qualitatively consistent with our experimental observation. As shown in Table 1, the ratio of the ABlike oscillation period to the effective mass shows weak LL dependence. The Landau leveldependent effective mass might be one of the intrinsic effects that leads to the LLdependent oscillation period.
LL is a transport characteristic of a twodimensional system. It indicates that the LLdependent oscillation might have originated from the surface state carrier in TIs. Berry phase is a characteristic of transport carriers. Extracting the Berry phase might help identify the source of these LLdependent periodic AB oscillations. We define the AB oscillation index number by dividing the corresponding B of oscillation peaks in dB/dB by the related oscillation period in the LL. It reveals that the index number of oscillation peaks in dB/dB corresponds to N+0.25, where N is integer, for all oscillations in different LLs and temperatures. This further supports that the AB oscillation period is related to LLs. Figure 5 shows that AB oscillation index numbers are proportional to B at different LLs and temperatures. The intercept is 0.25 which indicates a 0.5 phase shift in the plot of the AB oscillation. This supports the Berry phase is π and the observed AB oscillations might be the carrier transport characteristic of the surface state in our BiSbTe_{3} topological insulator [45].
Conclusion
We have reported the quantum oscillations in a BiSbTe_{3} topological insulator macroflake. In addition to the Shubnikovde Haas (SdH) oscillation, it reveals AharonovBohmlike (ABL) oscillation. The ABL oscillation period is Bdependent. The ABL oscillation period is constant at each Landau level (LL). The shorter oscillation periods were observed at lower LLs, which was determined through the SdH oscillation. The oscillation period is proportional to the square root of the LL at different temperatures. The ratio of the ABL oscillation period to the effective mass is weak LL dependence. The LLdependent ABL oscillation might originate from the LLdependent effective mass.
Availability of Data and Materials
The datasets generated during and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding authors on reasonable request.
Abbreviations
 EDS:

Energydispersive Xray spectroscopy
 XPS:

Xray photoelectron spectroscopy
 ARPES:

Angle resolved photoemission spectroscopy
 SdH:

Shubnikovde Haas
References
 1
Webb RA, Washburn S, Umbach CP, Laibowitz RB (1985) Observation of \(\frac {h}{e}\) AharonovBohm Oscillations in NormalMetal Rings. Phys Rev Lett 54:2696–2699.
 2
Tonomura Akira, Osakabe Nobuyuki, Matsuda Tsuyoshi, Kawasaki Takeshi, Endo Junji, Yano Shinichiro, Yamada Hiroji (1986) Evidence for AharonovBohm effect with magnetic field completely shielded from electron wave. Phys Rev Lett 56:792–795.
 3
Dauber Jan, Oellers Martin, Venn Florian, Epping Alexander, Watanabe Kenji, Taniguchi Takashi, Hassler Fabian, Stampfer Christoph (2017) AharonovBohm oscillations and magnetic focusing in ballistic graphene rings. Phys Rev B 96:205407–1–20540713.
 4
Wang LX, Li CZ, Yu DP, Liao ZM (2016) Aharonov–Bohm oscillations in Dirac semimetal Cd3As2 nanowires. Nat Commun 7:10769–1107697.
 5
Cho Sungjae, Dellabetta Brian, Zhong Ruidan, Schneeloch John, Liu Tiansheng, Gu Genda, Gilbert MatthewJ, Mason Nadya (2015) Aharonov–Bohm oscillations in a quasiballistic threedimensional topological insulator nanowire. Nat Commun 6:7634–176345.
 6
Xiu Faxian, He Liang, Wang Yong, Cheng Lina, Chang LiTe, Lang Murong, Huang Guan, Kou Xufeng, Zhou Yi, Jiang Xiaowei, Chen Zhigang, Zou Jin, Shailos Alexandros, Wang KangL (2011) Manipulating surface states in topological insulator nanoribbons. Nat Nanotechnol 6:216–221.
 7
Peng H, et al. (2010) Aharonov–Bohm interference in topological insulator nanoribbons. Nat Mater 9:225–229.
 8
Hamdou B, Gooth J, Dorn A, Pippel E, Nielsch K (2013) AharonovBohm oscillations and weak antilocalization in topological insulator Sb2Te3 nanowires. Appl Phys Lett 102:223110–12231105.
 9
Jauregui LA, Pettes MT, Rokhinson LP, Shi L, Chen YP (2016) Magnetic fieldinduced helical mode and topological transitions in a topological insulator nanoribbon. Nat Nanotechnol 11:345–351.
 10
Bachtold Adrian, Strunk Christoph, Salvetat JeanPaul, Bonard JeanMarc, Forro Laszlo, Nussbaumer Thomas, Schonenberger Christian (1999) Aharonov–Bohm oscillations in carbon nanotubes. Nature 397:673–675.
 11
Hansen AE, Kristensen A, Pedersen S, Sorensen CB, Lindelof PE (2011) Mesoscopic decoherence in AharonovBohm rings. Phys Rev B 64:0453271–0453275.
 12
Huang SM, Wang PinChun, Lin Chien, You ShengYu, Lin WeiCheng, Lin LinJie, Yan YouJhih, Yu ShihHsun, Chou MC (2018) The AharonovBohm oscillation in the BiSbTe3 topological insulator macroflake. Appl Phys Lett 112:203103–1–12031034.
 13
Huang ShiuMing, Huang ShihJhe, Yan YouJhih, Yu ShihHsun, Chou Mitch, Yang HungWei, Chang YuShin, Chen RueiSan (2017) Extremely highperformance visible light photodetector in the Sb2SeTe2 nanoflake. Sci Rep 7:45413–1–454137.
 14
Huang SM, Yan YJ, Yu SH, Chou M (2017) Thicknessdependent conductance in Sb2SeTe2 topological insulator nanosheets. Sci Rep 7:1896–1–18967.
 15
Huang ShiuMing, Huang ShihJhe, Hsu Ching, Wadekar ParitoshV., Yan YouJhih, Yu ShihHsun, Chou Mitch (2017) Enhancement of carrier transport characteristic in the Sb2Se2Te topological insulator nanosheets by N2 adsorption. Sci Rep 7:5133–1–51338.
 16
Huang ShiuMing, Huang ShihJhe, Yan YouJhih, Yu ShihHsun, Chou Mitch, Yang HungWei, Chang YuShin, Chen RueiSan (2017) Highly responsive photoconductance in a Sb2SeTe2 topological insulator nanosheet at room temperature. RSC Adv 7:39057–39062.
 17
Zhang SX, McDonald RD, Shekhter A, Bi ZX, Li Y, Jia QX, Picraux ST (2012) Magnetoresistance up to 60 Tesla in topological insulator Bi2Te3 thin films. Appl Phys Lett 101:202403–1–2024035.
 18
Wang Z, Yang L, Zhao XT, Zhang ZD, Gao XuanPA (2015) Linear magnetoresistance versus weak antilocalization effects in Bi_{2}Te_{3}. Nano Research 8:2963–2969.
 19
Wang X, Du Y, Dou S, Zhang C (2012) Room Temperature Giant and Linear Magnetoresistance in Topological Insulator Bi_{2}Te_{3} Nanosheets. Phys Rev Lett 108:266806–1–2668065.
 20
Wang ZH, Yang L, Li XJ, Zhao XT, Wang HL, Zhang ZD, Gao XuanPA (2014) Granularity Controlled Nonsaturating Linear Magnetoresistance in Topological Insulator Bi_{2}Te_{3} Films. Nano Lett 14:6510–6514.
 21
Barua S, Rajeev KP, Gupta AK (2015) Evidence for topological surface states in metallic single crystals of Bi_{2}Te_{3}. J Phys Condens Matter 27:015601–1–01560110.
 22
Qu DX, Hor YS, Xiong Jun, RJ Cava, Ong NP (2010) Quantum oscillations and hall anomaly of surface states in the topological insulator Bi_{2}Te_{3}. Science 329:821–824.
 23
Assaf BA, Cardinal T, Wei P, Katmis F, Moodera JS, Heiman D (2013) Linear magnetoresistance in topological insulator thin films: Quantum phase coherence effects at high temperatures. Appl Phys Lett 102:012102–1–0121024.
 24
Tang H, Liang D, Qiu RL, Gao XP (2011) TwoDimensional TransportInduced Linear MagnetoResistance in Topological Insulator Bi2Se3 Nanoribbons. ACS Nano 5:7510–7516.
 25
Yan Y, Wang LX, Yu DP, Liao ZM (2013) Large magnetoresistance in high mobility topological insulator Bi_{2}Te_{3}. Appl Phys Lett 103:033106–1–0331064.
 26
He HT, Liu HC, Li BK, Guo X, Xu ZJ, Xie MH, Wang JN (2013) Disorderinduced linear magnetoresistance in (221) topological insulator Bi_{2}Te_{3} films. Appl Phys Lett 103:031606–1–0316064.
 27
He H, Li B, Liu H, Guo X, Wang Z, Xie M, Jiannong W (2012) Highfield linear magnetoresistance in topological insulator Bi_{2}Te_{3} thin films. Appl Phys Lett 100:032105–1–0321053. He H, Li B, Liu H, Guo X, Wang Z, Xie M, Jiannong W
 28
Hsiung TC, Mou CY, Lee TK, Chen YY (2015) Surfacedominated transport and enhanced thermoelectric figure of merit in topological insulator Bi1.5Sb0.5Te1.7Se1.3. Nanoscale 7:518–523.
 29
He X, Guan T, Wang X, Feng B, Cheng P, Chen L, Li Y, Kehui W (2012) Highly tunable electron transport in epitaxial topological insulator (Bi1xSbx)2Te3 thin films. Appl Phys Lett 101:123111–1–1231115.
 30
Leea PC, Huanga YC, Chiena CH, Chiu FY, Chen YY, Harutyunyan SR (2015) A comparative study of sizedependent magnetoresistance and Hall resistance of Sb2Te3 nanoflakes. Physica B 459:12–15.
 31
Wang K, Draf D, Petrovic C (2014) Large magnetothermopower and Fermi surface reconstruction in Sb2Te2Se. Phys Rev B 89:125202–1–1252026.
 32
Huang SM, Yu SH, Chou M (2016) The linear magnetoresistance from surface state of the Sb2SeTe2 topological insulator. J Appl Phys 119:245110–1–2451105.
 33
Huang SM, Yu SH, Chou M (2016) The large linear magnetoresistance in Sb2Se2Te single crystal with extremely low mobility. Mater Res Express 3:126101–1–1261015.
 34
Parish MM, Littlewood PB (2003) Nonsaturating magnetoresistance in heavily disordered semiconductors, (London).
 35
Xiang FX, Wang XL, Dou SXTransport evidence for the coexistence of the topological surface state and a twodimensional electron gas in BiSbTe3 topological insulator. Arxiv.org/pdf/1404.7572.
 36
Camino FE, Zhou W, Goldman VJ (2005) AharonovBohm electron interferometer in the integer quantum Hall regime. Phys Rev B 72:155313–1–1553136.
 37
van Wees BJ, Kouwenhoven LP, Harmans CJPM, Williamson JG, Timmering CE, Broekaart MEI, Foxon CT, Harris JJ (1989) Observation of zerodimensional states in a onedimensional electron interferometer. Phys Rev Lett 62:2523–2526.
 38
Goldman VJ, Karakurt I, Liu J, Zaslavsky A (2001) Invariance of charge of Laughlin quasiparticles. Phys Rev B 64:085319–1–0853195.
 39
Camino FE, Zhou W, Goldman VJ (2005) AharonovBohm Superperiod in a Laughlin Quasiparticle Interferometer. Phys Rev Lett 95:246802–1–2468024.
 40
Goldman VJ, Su B (1995) Resonant Tunneling in the Quantum Hall Regime: Measurement of Fractional Charge. Science 267:1010–1012.
 41
Zhang Yiming, McClure DT, LevensonFalk EM, Marcus CM, Pfeiffer LN, WestK W (2009) Distinct signatures for Coulomb blockade and AharonovBohm interference in electronic FabryPerot interferometers. Phys Rev B 79:241304–1–2413044.
 42
Choi H, Jiang P, Godfrey MD, Kang W, Simon SH, Pfeiffer LN, West KW, Baldwin KW (2011) Aharonov–Bohmlike oscillations in Fabry–Perot interferometers. New J Phys 13:055007–1–0550079.
 43
Choi HK, Sivan I, Rosenblatt A, Heiblum M, Umansky V, Mahalu D (2015) Robust electron pairing in the integer quantum hall effect regime. Nat Communi 6:7435–1–74357.
 44
Yu W, Jiang Y, Yang J, Dun ZL, Zhou HD, Jiang Z, Lu P, Pan W (2016) Quantum Oscillations at Integer and Fractional Landau Level Indices in SingleCrystalline ZrTe5. Sci Rep 6:35357–1–353577.
 45
Qin LaiXiang, Pan XinChen, Song FengQi, Zhang Liang, Sun ZhangHao, Li MingQiang, Peng Gao, Lin BenChuan, HuangShiuMing, Zhu Rui, Xu Jun, Lin Fang, Lu HaiZhou, Yu Dapeng, Liao ZhiMin (2018) Confinedpath interference suppressed quantum correction on weak antilocalization effect in a BiSbTeSe2 topological insulator. Appl Phys Lett 112:032102–10321025.
Funding
The work was supported by the Taiwan National Science Council through Grant Nos. MOST 1062112M110002 and MOST 1072112M110011MY2, and Center of Crystal Research at National Sun YatSen University. SMH thanks the support of the shortterm overseas research for scientist and technician from the Taiwan National Science Council.
Author information
Affiliations
Contributions
SMH conceived the idea, analyzed these experimental results, and prepared the paper. CL, SYY, PCC, JLH, and JFW performed the experiments. YJY, SHY, and M.M.C.C. grow the highquality crystal. The author(s) read and approved the final manuscript.
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate
All authors agreed on the ethics approval and consent to participate.
Competing Interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Additional information
Publisher’s Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
About this article
Cite this article
Huang, SM., Lin, C., You, SY. et al. Observation of Landau LevelDependent AharonovBohmLike Oscillations in a Topological Insulator. Nanoscale Res Lett 15, 171 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s11671020033898
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Keywords
 AharonovBohmlike oscillations
 Shubnikovde Haas oscillation
 Landau level