- Nano Express
- Open Access
High-Speed and Direction-Controlled Formation of Silicon Nanowire Arrays Assisted by Electric Field
Nanoscale Research Letters volume 15, Article number: 25 (2020)
Metal-assisted chemical etching (MaCE), a low-cost and versatile method was considered a promising technique for preparing silicon nanowires (SiNWs), yet the lack of well controlling the injected holes within Si might reduce the etching rate, create the unwanted sidewall etching, and degrade the structural uniformity. Herein, in this study, the bias-modulated MaCE process was performed, showing the etching rates more than four times of magnitude than that of typical bias-free MaCE with large-area uniformity. It was found that the field-mediated hole rectification overwhelmed the effect of retarded diffusivity from reactive ions, and thus the dynamics of distributed etching were therefore transferred to the directional etching behaviors. In addition, the etching orientation could be also manipulated with the external bias. The results demonstrated that the etching direction was switched toward the slanted features by varying the electric polarization, creating the special slanted/vertical NW arrays, which possessed the superior antireflection characteristics than the conventional vertically aligned features.
Low-dimensional silicon (Si) nanostructures displayed remarkable electronic, mechanical, and optoelectronic properties that could act as building elements of functional devices and applications [1,2,3], such as field-effect transistors, biosensors, and photovoltaic cells [4,5,6,7,8,9]. To form the regular arrays of Si nanostructures, metal-assisted chemical etching has been considered the prevailing strategy that even enabled to form Si nanowire (SiNW) arrays on planar substrates [10, 11], powders [12, 13], and pyramidal structures . In the etching process, the hole injections across metal catalysts toward Si underneath and subsequently the dissolution of oxidized Si were continuously occurred, thus resulting in the long etching pores. However, the generated holes could diffuse within Si matrix rather than always moved vertically with respect to the substrate plane; it usually caused the formation of numerous Si nanopores near the primary etching sites, leaving the uncontrollable etching profiles behind . This feature turned out to be particularly obvious while the solutions owned high viscosity.
The lack of well controlling the injected holes within Si might hinder the practical applications of Si nanostructures for practical use.
To overcome this demanding issue, the employment of the external field seemed to be promising. Liyi Li et al., demonstrated that the high aspect ratio (> 10:1) regular hole or strip arrays could be realized by using electric bias-attenuated MaCE, but the feature dimensions were in microscale . Inspired by this work, in this study, we attempted to explore the feasibility of fabricating SiNW arrays by means of applying bias during MaCE process. Both positive and negative bias were investigated to understand the field-dependent etching kinetics. In addition to the etching rate, we found that the etching orientation was able to be modulated, where the dual-segment SiNWs in the form of slanted/vertical features were realized by tuning the bias direction. The underlying etching mechanism and etching kinetics in the presence of electric field were explored, and the superior antireflection characteristics of unique slanted/vertical SiNW arrays were presented in both experimental and simulated analysis.
The single crystalline (100), single-side polished Si substrates with a thickness of 525 μm were used as starting materials. The Si substrates were ultrasonically cleaned in isopropyl alcohol, acetone, and deionized water for several cycles, and then were further cleaned in SC-1 solution (1 part of NH4OH, 1 part of H2O2, and 5 part of deionized water) for 30 min to clean the surfaces and resulted in the hydrophilic surfaces.
In order to fabricate the highly ordered aligned nanostructures, nanosphere lithography (NSL) was conducted. Basically, polystyrene nanospheres (PSs) with diameters of 300 nm are slowly dispersed and assembled in the hexagonal close-packed features at the air/water interfaces in the Petri dish, and then directly transferred onto the Si substrates. The size shrinkage of large-scale and uniform PSs was achieved by employing oxygen plasma with a power of 100 W under a process pressure of 200 mTorr. The etching time was set to be 120 s and the oxygen flow was maintained at 12 sccm. Subsequently, 30 nm silver film was deposited using an electron beam evaporator at a rate of 0.3 Å/s under the vacuum condition of 7.0 × 10−6 Torr. Afterward, the remaining PSs were completely removed by sonication for 2 h in the toluene, which resulted in the formation of patterned silver mesh on Si substrates.
Fabrication of Si Nanowires
The as-cleaned Si substrates were pasted with copper tapes as the electrodes as top and rear side and connected with power supply for applying the electric field. The applied voltages were adjusted within 40 V to 40 V. The Si substrates with the loadings of either Ag nanoparticles or patterned Ag layers were formed when immersing them in an etching mixture consisting of HF (49%), H2O2 (30%), and DI water with the concentrations of 4 M and 0.28 M, respectively [17,18,19,20]. After conducting the etching process, the residual Ag layers were removed with the concentrated HNO3 (65%)
Morphologies of as-formed nanowires were characterized by field emission scanning electron microscopy (SEM, LEO 1530). Contact angle analysis was obtained using a Theta Lite (TL101). Luminescent behaviors of SiNWs were characterized through a photoluminescent (PL) system equipped with a light-emitting diode lamp (output power: 780 mW) and the wavelength of the light source was 365 nm. UV/Vis reflectance spectra were recorded by a UV-vis-NIR spectrophotometer (Varian, Cary 5000, Australia). The optical reflectance was simulated with finite-difference time-domain (FDTD), where the perfectly matched boundary was selected along the illumination directions.
Results and Discussion
Comparisons of typical MaCE and bias-assisted MaCE employed on the Ag-loaded Si substrates were presented in Fig. 1a. It could be found that the H2O2 oxidants provided the holes diffusing toward Si assisted by the existed Ag catalysts. The injection of holes, nevertheless, was not always forwarded in unidirectional orientation, which instead were spread out owing from the fact that the uneven facets of AgNPs in contact with Si, as shown in Fig. 1a. These features explicitly caused the loss of holes that were incapable of contributing to the directional dissolution of Si for NW formation but instead being distributed and might readily lead to the formation of porous structures. By contrast, the employment of forward bias (+ 10 V) in vertical arrangement with respect to the substrate planes could dramatically modify the etching kinetics. The correlated design of field-applied MaCE was schematically presented in Additional file 1: Figure S1. In fact, the involved polarization potential enforced all the holes diffusing along the orientation of applied field that responded to the enhanced etching rates (260 nm/min) (Fig. 1c) compared with typical MaCE process (220 nm/min) (Fig. 1b). The variation of positive bias applied within MaCE process could therefore resulted in the change of etching rates, as demonstrated in Additional file 1: Figure S2, where it clearly evidenced the hole rectification of MaCE as the positive bias was involved.
Such field-assisted effect, on the other hand, was also valid while the MaCE process was subjected to the negative bias. Figure 2a indicated the opposite rectification of hole diffusion with respect to the hole injection path, which inhibited the effective dissolution of Si by constraining the holes within Ag microscopic electrodes and gave rise to the reduced etching rate (180 nm/min). In addition, the overall range of applied bias on the etching rate of MaCE reactions was demonstrated in Fig. 2b. It indicated the transition of etching kinetics with respect to the polarization of involved bias. The negative bias unambiguously caused the reduction of etching rate, whereas the positive bias at + 10 V facilitated the effective etching of Si directionally through hole rectification effect and reflected the gradual increase of etching rate. With larger bias, in addition to the hole rectification, it potentially introduced the newly generated holes involving in the directional etching of Si, which was correlated with anodization effect [21, 22]. Such effect predominately controlled the etching kinetics, thus dramatically enhanced the etching rates more than four times of magnitude than that of typical bias-free MaCE. We therefore could conclude that the combined effects of hole rectification and anodization took place on Si that could modulate the etching kinetics and correlated behaviors.
To further unveil the bias-modulated kinetics in MaCE reaction, the comparably high viscous solutions were utilized. This was accomplished by mixing etching regents in 90% of IPA solvents. The relationship between the diffusion coefficient and the viscosity could be expressed as below ,
in which D is the diffusion coefficient, A is the empirical constant, T the temperature, η is the viscosity of solvent, and p the viscosity exponent. Accordingly, the viscosity of IPA solvent is 2.1 mPa s at 25 °C, which is more than 2.3 times larger than that of water (viscosity = 0.9 mPa s). Therefore, one can expect the ion diffusivities of both H2O2 and F− ions in IPA medium were much lower than those in water condition. As indicated in Fig. 3a, the thin porous structures with a thickness of 170.3 nm were created under a 5-min etching when no bias was employed. This was contributed by the fact that the involved IPA solvents possessing a large viscosity that intended to spread out the holes in a random orientation, and thus the porous features rather than one-dimensional structures were formed. To facilitate the charge accumulation for initiating vertical etching of Si, the various positive biases were introduced, as shown in Fig. 3b–d. It should be noted that at low involved bias including + 20 V and + 30 V, the film thickness of porous structures was clearly increased, leading to the enhanced etching rates from 34.0 nm/min (0 V), 62.2 nm/min (+ 20 V) toward 92.1 nm/min (+ 30 V).
These results validated the effect of bias that essentially dominates the etching kinetics, where most of the separated holes were assumed to be collected and accumulated just beneath sites of Ag catalysts, thus initiating the deeper etching morphologies. When the applied bias was increased to + 40 V, the field-mediated hole rectification turned out to overwhelm the influences on retarded diffusivity of reactive ions, the dynamics of random and distributed etching were therefore transferred to the directional etching behaviors; the vertically aligned SiNW arrays were realized, showing the highest etching rates up to 137.8 nm/min among these four testes conditions, as presented in Fig. 3d. The distinct formation mechanism with respect to the applied bias could be understood from Fig. 3e. It indicated that the isotropic diffusion pathways of hole led to the formation of the thin porous film when no bias was introduced. By contrast, the relatively anisotropic hole transport was found under the involvement of modest bias, where the generated pores eventually moved along the bias orientation and established the features of multiple pores. At high bias condition, the injected holes were enforced to accumulate at catalyst/Si interfaces and synergistically move into Si following the polarization field, thus creating the vertically etched profiles.
In addition, the surface wettability of prepared Si textures was examined, where all the samples were measured by six times at different positions, as presented in Fig. 4. It has been reported that the measured contact angle was correlated with the roughness of nanostructures according to the equation shown below [24, 25],
in which θ and θe are the contact angle of rough and flat Si surfaces, respectively, and R represents the roughness factor. In addition, f is the area fraction of the air/water surfaces. It could be found that the average contact angles from four different samples were 109.80 ± 10.80 in the case of etching without bias, 108.40 ± 9.20 with + 20 V of bias, 105.40 ± 7.60 with + 30 V of bias and 103.60 ± 1.60 with + 40 V of bias, as shown in Fig. 4. The greatly reduced deviation at measured contact angle from the employment of + 40 V could be attributed to the relatively uniform topography on etched surfaces, which indicated that the utilization of bias in MaCE not only enabled to enhance the etching rate, but could further sustain the sound etching uniformity that was essential for the practical applications.
In addition to the modulation of etching rates, the etching orientation could be also manipulated with the external bias, as shown in Fig. 5a. In this test, the combination of MaCE with nanosphere lithography was conducted for defining the Ag patterns through self-assembled polystyrene nanospheres . By applying the vertical bias relative to the substrate planes during MaCE process, the directional etching along the bias orientation was created, where the vertically regulated SiNW arrays were formed, as presented in Fig. 5b. Switching the etching direction from the vertical feature toward a slanted profile was realized by varying the electric polarization at 60° with respect to the in-plane direction. While the bias was modulated, it overall resulted in the formation of two-segment slanted/vertical SiNW arrays, as presented in Fig. 5c.
Unlike the typical way to vary the NW orientation through the diffusion-controlled local change of etchant concentrations in the etching condition [27, 28], here both the concentrations of oxidants and etchants remained consistent and thus, the variation of etching direction was mainly contributed from the external bias. This might give rise to the feasibility for the realization of three-dimensional processing capability. Finally, the visible reflectance was examined from both vertical and two-segment based SiNW arrays, as demonstrated in Fig. 6. The measured reflection results clearly verified that the slanted/vertical SiNW arrays with average reflectance of 2.8% possessed the comparably lower light-reflection capability than that of sole vertical SiNW arrays (average reflectance = 5.4%) covering the visible bands. To further confirm the experimental investigation, the simulated reflection results were also compared, as shown in Fig. 6. It could be found that the simulated findings corresponded well to the measured results, indicating the superior antireflection characteristics of slanted/vertical nanostructures.
Electric-field assisted MaCE method for the formation of orientation-controlled SiNW arrays with improved etching rate was presented. The underlying mechanism was elucidated by the combined effects of hole rectification and anodization that could modulate the etching morphologies and kinetics. Furthermore, the surface wettability was examined, indicating that the large-area uniformity was created while the bias was + 40 V. By manipulating the polarization of applied electric field, the transition of the etching direction from the vertical feature toward slanted profile was realized. Such two-segment SiNWs in the form of slanted/vertical features possessed the greatly improved antireflection properties, which might be potentially useful for optoelectronic devices, photonic crystals, and other multifunctional applications.
Availability of Data and Materials
The datasets supporting the conclusions of this article are included within the article.
Metal-assisted chemical etching
Scanning electron microscope
Schmidt V, Wittemann JV, Senz S, Gósele U (2009) Silicon nanowires: a review on aspects of their growth and their electrical properties. Adv Mat 21(25-26):2681–2702
Yu JY, Chung SW, Heath JR (2000) Silicon nanowires: preparation, device fabrication, and transport properties. J Phys Chem B 104(50):11864–11870
Ghosh R, Giri PK (2016) Silicon nanowire heterostructures for advanced energy and environmental applications: a review. Nanotechnology 28(1):012001
Zafar S, D’Emic C, Jagtiani A, Kratschmer E, Miao X, Zhu Y, Mo R, Sosa N, Hamann H, Shahidi G, Riel H (2018) Silicon nanowire field effect transistor sensors with minimal sensor-to-sensor variations and enhanced sensing characteristics. ACS Nano 12(7):6577–6587
Lee BH, Hur J, Kang MH, Bang T, Ahn DC, Lee D, Kim KH, Choi YK (2016) A vertically integrated junctionless nanowire transistor. Nano Lett 16(3):1840–1847
Ibarlucea B, Römhildt L, Zörgiebel F, Pregl S, Vahdatzadeh M, Weber WM, Mikolajick T, Opitz J, Baraban L, Cuniberti G (2018) Gating hysteresis as an indicator for silicon nanowire FET biosensors. Appl Sci 8(6):950
Shehada N, Cancilla JC, Torrecilla JS, Pariente ES, Brönstrup G, Christiansen S, Johnson DW, Leja M, Davies MPA, Liran O, Peled N, Haick H (2016) Silicon nanowire sensors enable diagnosis of patients via exhaled breath. ACS Nano 10(7):7047–7057
Savin H, Repo P, VonGastrow G, Ortega P, Calle E, Garín M, Alcubilla R (2015) Black silicon solar cells with interdigitated back-contacts achieve 22.1% efficiency. Nature nanotechnology 10(7): 624.
Chen CY, Wei TC, Hsiao PH, Hung CH (2019) Vanadium oxide as transparent carrier-selective layer in silicon hybrid solar cells promoting photovoltaic performances. ACS Appl Energy Mat 2(7):4873–4881
Peng KQ, Yan YJ, Gao SP, Zhu J (2002) Synthesis of large-area silicon nanowire arrays via self-assembling nanoelectrochemistry. Adv Mat 14(16):1164–1167
Zhang ML, Peng KQ, Fan X, Jie JS, Zhang RQ, Lee ST, Wong NB (2008) Preparation of large-area uniform silicon nanowires arrays through metal-assisted chemical etching. J Phys Chem C 112(12):4444–4450
Ouertani R, Hamdi A, Amri C, Khalifa M, Ezzaouia H (2014) Formation of silicon nanowire packed films from metallurgical-grade silicon powder using a two-step metal-assisted chemical etching method. Nanoscale Res Lett 9(1):574
Kolasinski KW, Unger BA, Ernst AT, Aindow M (2018) Crystallographically Determined Etching and Its Relevance to the Metal-Assisted Catalytic Etching (MACE) of Silicon Powders. Front Chem 6:651
Putra IR, Li JY, Chen CY (2019) 18.78% hierarchical black silicon solar cells achieved with the balance of light-trapping and interfacial contact. Appl Surface Sci 478:725–732
Chen CY, Wong CP (2013) Morphological transition of Si surfaces from solid nanowires to porous nanobelts at room temperature. Chem Commun 49(66):7295–7297
Li L, Zhao X, Wong CP (2014) Deep etching of single-and polycrystalline silicon with high speed, high aspect ratio, high uniformity, and 3D complexity by electric bias-attenuated metal-assisted chemical etching (EMaCE). ACS Appl Mat Interfaces 6(19):16782–16791
Huang Z, Fang H, Zhu J (2007) Fabrication of silicon nanowire arrays with controlled diameter, length, and density. Adv Mat 19(5):744–748
Elnathan R, Delalat B, Brodoceanu D, Alhmoud H, Harding FJ, Buehler K, Nelson A, Isa L, Kraus T, Voelcker NH (2015) Maximizing transfection efficiency of vertically aligned silicon nanowire arrays. Adv Functional Mat 25(46):7215–7225
Tang CH, Chen KY, Chen CY (2018) Solution-processed ZnO/Si based heterostructures with enhanced photocatalytic performance. N J Chem 42(16):13797–13802
Mirzaei A, Kang SY, Choi SW, Kwon YJ, Choi MS, Bang JH, Kim SS, Kim HW (2018) Fabrication and gas sensing properties of vertically aligned Si nanowires. Appl Surface Sci 427:215–226
Liang J, Liu K, Wang D, Li H, Li P, Li S, Su S, Xu S, Luo Y (2015) Facile fabrication of superhydrophilic/superhydrophobic surface on titanium substrate by single-step anodization and fluorination. Appl Surface Sci 338:126–136
Prakasam HE, Shankar K, Paulose M, Varghese OK, Grimes CA (2007) A new benchmark for TiO2 nanotube array growth by anodization. J Phys Chem C 111(20):7235–7241
Hasinoff BB, Chishti SB (1983) Viscosity dependence of the kinetics of the diffusion-controlled reaction of carbon monoxide with the separated. alpha. and. beta. chains of hemoglobin. Biochemistry 22(1):58–61
Cassie ABD, Baxter S (1944) Wettability of porous surfaces. Trans Faraday Soc 40:546–551
Hsiao M, Chen KY, Chen CY (2019) Tailoring the robust superhydrophobic silicon textures with stable photodetection properties. Sci Rep 9(1):1579
Yeom J, Ratchford D, Field CR, Brintlinger TH, Pehrsson PE (2014) Decoupling diameter and pitch in Silicon nanowire arrays made by metal-Assisted Chemical Etching. Adv Functional Mat 24(1):106–116
Kim J, Kim YH, Choi SH, Lee W (2011) Curved silicon nanowires with ribbon-like cross sections by metal-assisted chemical etching. Acs Nano 5(6):5242–5248
Chien PJ, Zhou Y, Tsai KH, Duong HP, Chen CY (2019) Self-formed silver nanoparticles on freestanding silicon nanowire arrays featuring SERS performances. RSC Adv 9(45):26037–26042
The authors greatly thank Center for Micro/Nano Science and Technology, National Cheng Kung University, with the facilities provided for conducting material characterizations.
This work was supported by Ministry of Science and Technology of Taiwan (MOST 107-2221-E-006-013-MY3), and Hierarchical Green-Energy Materials (Hi-GEM) Research Center, from The Featured Areas Research Center Program within the framework of the Higher Education Sprout Project by the Ministry of Education (MOE) and the Ministry of Science and Technology (MOST 107-3017-F-006-003) in Taiwan.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Schematic illustrations for conducting bias-assisted MaCE process. Figure S2. Cross-sectional SEM images of SiNW arrays made by various bias-assisted MaCE process. The Ref represented the case without applying bias.
About this article
Cite this article
Chien, PJ., Wei, TC. & Chen, CY. High-Speed and Direction-Controlled Formation of Silicon Nanowire Arrays Assisted by Electric Field. Nanoscale Res Lett 15, 25 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s11671-020-3259-5
- Etching of Si
- Formation mechanism
- Surface wettability